Ok time to update my review! Ordered on a Saturday and it was ready within 45mins which is typical for Broadway pizza and it was definitely worth the wait. I placed my order by calling it in and the guy taking the order was very pleasant. When I arrived ( same guy....i think) was just as pleasant when asking for my name and checking to see if it was ready. It wasn't crowded yet but the day was still young and I'm pretty sure it will be busy later as usual. I only wish they'd invest in getting a parking lot that can accommodate their customer base. The current lot is too small. Pizza was delicious and just as I ordered it. read more

See all

My daughter,grandson and I went to Broadway Pizza for the first time and we actually enjoyed everything I got the Southern Fried Catfish it was cooked perfectly like I wanted, my daughter enjoyed her burger and grandson enjoyed is personal Pizza. Customer Service was Suberb, it was nice and clean and comfortable. We will go back again. Deserts were off the wall. read more

Broadway Pizza - Cheeseburger and fries - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

See all

First off when I called to order I was put on hold for almost 10 minutes. I hung up called back ,the line was busy. I called back and was able to order a turkey pizza.I got the pizza and it looked good on top. The dough at the bottom wasn't fully cooked,the turkey texture was not right The taste was unseasoned very blan. It was HORRIBLE a waste of my $27.I've never had any issues with Broadway Pizza,but with the younger people working not giving a damn.Customer service sucks., I'll never eat here again read more

I hadn't been here in quite some time but that pizza was on my mind heavy. First the people here are very friendly including the customers. I always get my order to go and if you don't order ahead of time then you will have to wait for them to cook it. The pizzas are hearty, not Chicago deep dish but good! I got the sausage and mushroom pizza. They have beautiful cakes and brownies too. The Banana Pudding Cake is very popular. I could see myself hanging out here one evening having a drink at the bar, very cool neighborhood vibes! read more

See all

Food was good. Didn't really care for the chicken on my pizza but the price was cool so it worked. read more

Broadway Pizza - Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

One of the best pizza places I've encountered yet. Absolutely amazing service and the restaurant speaks for itself. I love both locations. read more

Broadway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

This was an impromptu decision and it was well worth it. I ordered a Chef salad and it was amazingly fresh and delicious. The entire service was great. The server was professional and friendly. Our salad and cheese sticks were delicious as well as the pizza we took as carryout. The restaurant was clean, bright amd quiet because I got there as soon as they opened. My overall experience was delightful. read more

See all

Visited Broadway pizza today at 2:30 pm and it was an enjoyable visit. Dan was polite and very helpful on what to order and he was like this to everyone who came in. We ordered the cheese pizza and around the world sausage. Pizzas were HOT and delicious had loads of toppings and cheese pizza was very cheesy. Whole family thoroughly enjoyed them. Will be back in future to try their desserts read more

See all

Absolutely awful experience here. The beer was soured, and one pizza was raw and so greasy the toppings literally slid off in a clump. The cooked pizza wasn't great... the crust and toppings were very plain, and again- SO greasy. The service wasn't good either, and we were told there was nothing that could be done about the food except for "don't order pre-cooked meats" (what does that even mean??). Even when we showed that the dough was wet and spongy. We will never be coming here again. read more

Great pizza! It was so flavorful and so good. Service was really slow and they charge you a 15% gratuity fee for dining in. Parking is also extremely limited. Otherwise, it was a great lowkey pizza place with awesome food! read more

Ratings here are way too low. Crust, cheese, toppings are excellent. Sauce is on the tangy & citrus side, but tasty.

I ordered my vegetarian pizza through Uber Eats, and requested a side of garlic butter. It took an hour to receive my pizza (I live in the Evergreen area), I had to recut the slices because they did not cut through the crust, and I got an unwanted cup of green olives and banana peppers, but no garlic butter. The taste was not bad, but I was not impressed. read more

If you like box pizza... you will love Broadway. I've tried it twice. The fist time, I thought it was mediocre at best. The second time confirmed it was mediocre at best. I tried both locations and was disappointed both times. The service was definitely better than the pizza. read more

Me and my friend decided tried this Broadway Pizza location on November 11, 2023.The staff was good and our server Robert made sure we got our foods fast. I decided to get the pink lemonade, fried cheesesticks, All Pig Pizza, and Strawberry Shortcake. The fried cheese sticks was the only thing I really like. The fried Cheesesticks was really fresh and have really good flavor. The marinara sauce that came with the fried Cheesesticks was very generic and not that good. The All Pig Pizza was really disappointing to me. All the toppings on the pizza keep sliding off the crust. The sausage on the All Pig Pizza needed more seasoning. I was hoping the Strawberry Shortcake would make everything worth it, but it didn't. It was good the first bite, but when I keep biting on the cake it just didn't taste right anymore. read more

See all

I've been eating broadway since I was 4 and I'm 45 now and never had my pizza done like it was yesterday! it was door dashed and when I got it the pizza box was dirty and my pizza was old, cold and dry! I'm so disappointed!! very pissed off! read more

Excellent food and service. They take pride in their pizzas. My children loved this place. This pizza shop is just as good as the original. read more

Originally from Chicago and have been here almost 20 years. The best pizza in Memphis. The crust is a little thicker for thin crust but it can really hold up to the great sausage used on my pizza today. The owner recommended that they can do a thinner "hand tossed" crust but it would get wet if you had sausage on it. So if you got a cheese I would try it. The pizza was overflowing with sausage, grn pepper and onions. I got the 12 inch and ate 3 PCs. Also it was cut in squares. I will be back. read more

I went to this location around 10pm on a Friday night hoping the kitchen was still open and it WAS; still poppin' and lively! There are a lot of young people (18-25) working at this location but you can tell they like being there so they were helpful, kind and attentive to us. At 10pm on a Friday, I didn't expect it to be spotless so I did see a couple of tables that needed to be cleaned off but the bathrooms were clean (very important to me). - All Around the World (beef) 9" could've had a little more seasoning on the beef but it was topped and layers super well. I couldn't finish it all! - Long Island was A+ and the bar was FULLY stocked! *Masks weren't a requirement; there was ample space to socially distance. You can find more business reviews and experience reviews on my social media Camille Unlimited. read more

Broadway Pizza - At the bar :) - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

See all

Amazing food, not just pizza, amazing server, Lacey, and an amazing mgr Dan! Fried green tomatoes, side salad, country fried steak.! read more

Broadway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

decided to give it another shot and wish I didn't. Can't even get a thin pepperoni decent. For the absolute BS price I thought ok this is nothing special and it's gonna be good, just forget about the price is what I told myself. This was by far disappointing . I am not one to take the time to write a review but this kinda struck a nerve after I heard the price and once I got home to taste it!!! I have had Hunt Brothers pizza from gas stations that were 10 xs the pizza this was. Hate to bash anyone but this place needs to hang it up and let someone else start a restaurant that's worth eating at. and just heads up my first disappointing experience was at different location from the one tonight on Mendenhall. read more

Toppings do not stick to the crust. Crust is too thick. Ordered online but they didn't check it. Only paid attention to phone orders. Had to wait an extra 15 minutes. Just in time for the thunderstorm to catch up to me. read more

Today's visits was a quick meal after school with my boys. The restaurant wasn't crowded at all. However , two people running the restaurant from my POV. The server was kind but busy running the front. We had to wait on refills for our drinks and the my margarita to be made. The chicken wings were served HOT!!! The pizza was filling and savory!!! read more

See all

Dirty tables. Slow service. Couldn't get waiter for drink refil till we got the check which took awhile. When we ordered our pizza, we asked if we could substitute mushrooms for the bell peppers and the waiter said sure. When we got the bill, he charged us $2.50 for extra mushrooms. We pointed out that we had asked about doing this and he should have said there was a charge if there was one. He said it was their policy and I said they should have told us when we asked. Will never go back. Also, suggested we order a 12 inch pizza for two people. We couldn't even eat half of it. Apparently, he was aware as he also brought us a to go box right after he delivered the pizza. read more

Great Memphis Pizza never disappoints Me. Been eating here since a Kid. They have two locations and neither is a miss. I always get the Broadway special no mushrooms. read more

The pizza is good but the service is horrible! Manager was the Rudest person ever. Waited 1 hour for our pizza with 3 tables seated. They blamed it on a shift change with the server trying over compensate for the manager. He acted like he didn't even want to hear my complaint. So the server did at first. If I ever buy pizza for my team. It will NOT be here. I doubt I will ever be back. The ambiance is not that great. If you come do carry out. ONLY. I will NEVER be back. read more

Broadway Pizza - Seating - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

Pizza looked ok on the top but when I got home the sauce was still cold and meat also. I believe someone did something nasty to the pizza too. It was a white creamy taste under the big blog of cheese on top. The worst pitiful pizza I've ever tried to eat. I was so hungry after eating one piece my stomach soured. It was near closing time so I couldn't return rest I just put in fridge tried to eat a second piece next morning still bad just threw the rest in trash . I want my dern 15 dollars back...should not have to waste money trying to patronize businesses like Broadway pizza...management has definitely changed read more

Broadway Pizza is the best. I used to go to Exliners but they started getting greedy with the meat and cheese. Broadway is a little more expensive but they will do the pizza right. I ordered the All Pig pizza and the bbq is great. I will get this again when I return. read more

We stopped in for a quick lunch since they are always busy it seems after 4 or 5. We got there right when they opened and they already had at least 4 customers ahead of us! We sat down right away and the server brought us our menus within 5 minutes. We got the lunch special ( I thought they only had pizza!!!) and my husband got a 12" pepperoni pizza. He loves pizza and couldn't finish his! I also had to get a to go box for my lunch special. Which was great btw. read more

Broadway Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

Best pizza in town! The menu has a lot more than pizza!! I recommend the chicken Philly- you'll need a fork for this Philly!! Lots of bakery cakes to choose from! read more

Broadway Pizza - Chicken Philly - Pizza Near Me - Memphis, Tennessee

Legendary my ass. Got the large all meat. $48 for a pizza with soggy, grainy crust and zero flavor. Couldn't even see any sauce. It's like they forgot it. How the hell can a pizza have all that shit on it and not have any flavor? Maybe the original on Broad is better but I'm done with the one on Mendenhall. read more

I visited Broadway pizza and it was amazing ! I got the spaghetti and extra meat and it was great ! Servers were very kind and cooperating

I ordered a pizza without black olives and it was incorrectly prepared with black olives and upon arrival I asked that the pizza be prepared correctly and found that the cook with the dreads just picked through the pizza and pulled all the black olives out and they lied about remaking the pizza and I am currently in the urgent care for an allergic reaction to olives. They better have on camera remaking that pizza as they claim or expect Atty Chizzao to hold them liable read more

Pizza quality is typically hit or miss, no consistency. Then they add gratuity 18% for those who come in as a deterrent to be an order & go facility. read more

I have never had a Broadway Pizza that I didn't LOVE. The service; however, was the absolute worst!! We waited to be seated and when we weren't, we grabbed a table. After sitting there for at least 20 minutes and no one coming by to take our order, I figured we were supposed to order at the counter. After I went to the counter to order, one of the nine plus employees milling around behind the counter and in the back started handing out menus to the other people who had seated themselves. After our friends arrived, it took another 30 minutes after the waiter came by for them to get drinks. I'm not sure if it was just an off night for the staff and they couldn't get their crap together or what. Everyone was nice or I'd have given them two stars. Broadway won't lose my business, but I will be taking it back to Broad Street. read more

We ordered three different types and they were all disgusting. Their crust is very bland and gummy. The pizzas took 90 minutes and the service was awful. Honestly, not sure how this place has been going so long. read more

We went in for a late lunch on a Friday. We dined in. There were 2 other tables occupied at the time. We placed our order for 4 whole wings (comes with fries) and large BBQ pizza. In less than 10 minutes out comes the wings and fries! I commented "that was quick" and our server said she wanted to go ahead and get something out to us because it would be a long time on the pizza. WELL first of all, you should say that while we are ordering so we can decide what we want to do. 2ndly we had absolutely NO IDEA what "a long time" meant. It took 1 hour and 10 minutes to receive our pizza. I had finished my wings and fries AND dessert. I will admit their phone was ringing off the hook and they had a very steady stream of take out customers. My biggest issue is that we weren't told it would take that long until it was too late. All of the customers in the dining room were complaining about the service time. They have a dessert case that looks amazing!!!! I couldn't resist a piece of red velvet cake. I should have though. It wasn't fresh. Let me sum up our experience....we spent $50 on really good wings, mediocre fries, stale cake and a pizza that was so loaded with ingredients it just wasn't good. My son ate 2 pieces and didn't want anymore. I tried to eat 1 and couldn't. We ended up discarding the pizza. I always hear good things about Broadway. Maybe I will give them another chance later on in life. read more

See all

We ordered an "Around the world" pizza, garlic knots, and chocolate cake tonight for our first (and last) go at Broadway Pizza. First, we were quoted at a 45 minute wait time for our to-go order. No big deal since it's to-go, right? Wrong once you wait ANOTHER 20 minutes after getting there "on-time." What a waste of time to sit there. Now, to the food. Apparently the "around the world" pizza means they literally cover your entire pizza from edge to edge with whatever meat is listed. I say this because I don't want some poor other person thinking they are getting a reasonable amount of sausage only to find out they got a 16" sausage patty. My suggestion - double the sauce and other toppings and cut the sausage back by 4x... at least. The garlic knots were bland and oily. The marinara that comes with them is decent. The cake is actually pretty good. Not the best chocolate cake I've ever had but after the train wreck that was our pizza it's the redeeming part of our order. The search for great, locally owned Memphis pizza will continue on.... because this wasn't it. read more

Horrible first experience here. Got overcharged on my card by $20+. Then they took over an hour to give us a pizza after their mistake. Awful customer service. Won't be coming back. read more

The best cheese pizza, the best bbq pizza and best deserts ever! The customer service is wonderful! And the theme of the restaurant cute !

First off, the location of this place is awful!!! I called my order in 20 minutes prior & still had a 20 minute wait but it was ok! The service was pretty good! My food had a 30 minute drive home & was still fresh! Love broadway! The pizza was PACKED with so much meat it was crazy! Can't wait to go back, just HATE the location! Right off poplar. Also, the red velvet cake was TERRIBLE. I don't know if i caught it on a bad day or what? The fries that came with the wings were so good!! read more

See all