My wife and I enjoyed our anniversary dinner here at Brindille. We chose this because it looked like a throwback to our favorite restaurants of the past, with great ingredients well prepared without a lot of flash. We are not fans of "hot" restaurants in general, as the sizzle hides the lack of substance that most of them have (see Paris Club and RPM). The Chicago Tribune review of Brindille was enticing so we made a reservation.
There were not many customers on a Sunday night, so we were given a nice table in the window. Other than the clear view of the frog on the top of Rainforest Cafe, it was very comfortable. My wife noted that the tables are awfully close together, so had the restaurant been full, we might not have enjoyed it as well. A class in absinthe was being taught at the bar, and while it was a little off-putting at first, we were able to move it to the background.
We brought our own wine. It was subject to a $50 corkage fee that was waived when we bought a bottle from the list. Our waiter was excellent, having a full command of the menu and the wine list. He steered us to a delicious French white that we would not have found on our own. He indicated that they are working on a half-bottle list, and it would be useful. More on the wines in the summary at the end.
Our appetizers were stunning. I had the fois gras and my wife had the sweetbread and rabbit combo. The flavor combinations were amazing and everything I expect at this price point. The same was true for the entrees where I had the saddle of lamb and she had the Lobster Brindelle. So often, restaurants oversalt their entrees in the name of being "French", but the seasoning was absolutely spot on. The cut of lamb was perfectly cooked and tender.
Although the portions are not exceptionally large, the food is so rich and flavorful that I could easily have skipped the dessert course, but in the spirit of the evening, we went ahead. In the whole scheme of things, this is a small point, but it was a little disappointing. I had the cheese plate. It was lovely to look at, and the cheeses were tasty, but it was not a good value at the price point. The accompaniments were a little spartan and each cheese appeared to be less than a 1 inch square. I would have been pleased if this had been at the same price point as the rest of the desserts. My wife had their single chocolate offering, which was sold as almost an ode to dark chocolate. Again, it was visually impressive, arriving in a lovely transparent spun sugar shell, looking like a light bulb. But, the cream dominated the dish, hiding the chocolate from view and when she found it, it was simply good, not great. Post dinner we were given a chocolate candy that was so much better. If we were to return, we would ask for a plate of those if we chose to have dessert.
So, in summary, we found this to be an excellent restaurant with respect to the main events, but the value proposition needs just a little work on the side. We did a little research prior to arriving and found that the wine markup was substantially higher than most other places. That was what prompted us to bring our own wine more than anything. We found several bottles that were 3x retail. We wanted to have a better than average bottle of wine with this meal, but their prices made that difficult. A little work on the dessert menu and perhaps a curtain on the front window and this has the potential to become a 4 star Chicago destination. I'd also suggest a side room for things like the absinthe tasting. It is a little odd to go out for a fine dining experience and to hear a lecture in the same room. All of these suggestions are meant to be constructive criticism for a fine restaurant. read more