So I guess this is my own fault for ordering a sub from a place called "BrickFire Pizza" where clearly pizza is the main focus... I was in the area for work and was not about to order a whole pizza for myself for lunch. So I opted for a "house made" tuna sub and let me tell you, they should start out-sourcing it asap!! I hate to say this but it was probably one of the worst subs I've had in a while; watery, flavorless tuna that was slopped together with lettuce, tomatoes and pickles. It didn't even look appetizing! I took a few bites and threw it away. I can't comment on the pizza but I would stay away from the subs at this place :( read more

See all

" Great pizza " Pizza here is good or great , lol. The prices are great as well. The pizza tastes great , fresh and just plain delicious. The vibe is welcoming and friendly. They have a parking lot , so no worries on parking. read more

BrickFire Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

Fantastic pizza. NY slices perfection. Cheesesteaks are a must. As good as Philly's best. Keep up the good cooking here. Great spot! read more

What a dish!!! I would have to say that this was one the best dishes I've tried recently that was filling and delicious and the garlic bread that came with it was good as well but a bit soggy which was okay but back to the main dish the chicken soft and crispy and well cook which good flavor and the spaghetti was made just right plus the sauce along with it seem good but could have had more flavor put into it but nothing crazy needs to be done just an extra hfmmm could do for the price it was a bit high but a good portion that will fill you up or leave some for leftovers but please try for yourself and tell me what you think 4/5 :) read more

BrickFire Pizza - Chicken parmigiana, mozzarella cheese - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

BrickFire Pizza Co is located on the corner of Oak St and Chestnut St, sharing a small plaza with Allstar Liquors. They offer counter service and an airy space for those who dine in at one of five 4 tops and a 2 top on the left, and a 10 seat communal high top on the right by the soda case. Their menu is well posted on screens above the counter, displaying both description and prices clearly. BrickFire's pizza is thin crust, made with their own pizza dough and signature red sauce. We opted for the 12 inch Caprese (signature red sauce, fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, basil, balsamic glaze $16.50) with the glaze on the side, and were told it would be 20 min. I made good time, and the pizza was boxed and ready for me. Unfortunately it was no longer even warm by the time I got it back - no surprise since it was a very thin crust. A run through the toaster oven however did its magic. With a normal firing, the crust was golden in color and crispy chewy, the sauce sweet savory, and there was both tomatoes and mozzarella on each slice, and a nice sprinkling of sliced basil. The balsamic glaze was on the side as requested - a generous pour in a little condiment container of a satisfyingly thick dark glaze. Crispy might have resulted in some burnt spots on the pizza pie, so I'm glad I didn't make that special request, as we are an anti-charcoal consuming household. Five years ago, I bought a certificate for BrickFire on LocalFlavor, which is similar to Groupon, but not as popular. It still exists online (I googled it), but the promotional value ($20) expired after a year, while the paid value ($10) expires this year (5 years) according to the fine print on the second page. For my 2023 visit, I called ahead to check about how to redeem the paid value and asked to speak with the manager. He's worked there 4 years and had never heard of LocalFlavor. He could not honor the certificate but was willing to give me $10 in free food. I appreciated that but told him I would bring in the certificate anyhow so he could see that I was being honest. My suggestion would be to dine in on site when possible for the best experience of their food. Consumed cold, their pizza would have been 3 stars - okay. However, based on my experience of their service and the pizza once warmed back up, 4 stars - worthy of a return visit. read more

The guy that works here "Jeff" doesnt know how to toast sandwiches. Just look out for Jeff yall

Chose delivery during a college football game watch at home. It was efficient and fast. The pizza was good but my order was incorrect - ordered pepperoni and got a cheese pizza. Called the restaurant and they apologized and removed the charge for pepperoni. It was too far away and not worth trying to make the order right- but they did offer it. Enjoyed the pizza and will try again- next time in person. read more

BrickFire Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

Absolutely love Brick House Pizza! The food was amazing, service was top-tier, and Belal made the experience even better with his great energy and attentiveness. Definitely coming back! read more

I have driven by so many times, and always thought "I really need to try it sometime"; that day finally happened yesterday because it was 5pm and I hadn't eaten all day. I ordered a slice from the nice guy (maybe 17/18?) and a few minutes later a giant slice of deliciousness was presented to me. The crust was crispy, but not at all burned; I have friends who love burnt crusts, but I like to taste mine. The slice was delicious, my next stop in will be for 2 slices, or maybe a whole pizza! read more

BrickFire Pizza - This is one slice, imagine of I had ordered 2 or 3? This was delicious!!! - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

I just keep coming back!! Pizza is so yummy and the service is great, if you're looking for a classic pizza and a great vibe this is the place to go! a bit on the expensive side, but regardless it's a nice treat read more

Brick fire pizza is great! The individual slices are massive and have great toppings. It's cheap for two slices and a drink, which is more than enough for a meal. Calzones are great too. Good atmosphere, clean restaurant. One of my favorite places to get a bite to eat after work! read more

The best buffalo chicken wrap I've had in a long time! I requested the blue cheese on the side and my order was ready when I got to the store. Very generous portions! read more

BrickFire Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

Used to love this place. I work right around the corner and go 2-3 times a week and get the same exact thing 99% of the time, a chicken ceaser wrap on wheat. Lately I go in and theres always something wrong, they didnt put my order in, I go to pick it up and they say its not ready meanwhile its sitting on the shelf behind them, its always service related with the same guy working the counter. Today I went in 10mins after I had called in my wrap and I was the only customer there and I was there for another 10-15mins before they even started on my order. The guy behind the counter was staring at his phone and the cooks were joking around half working. I asked a few times if it was ready and the final time when I said "I got to go can i just grab a slice of pizza" the guy behind the counter shrugged and pointed to raw chicken that was placed on the grill and said "we're working on it now" like I was the one who was in the wrong and made no move to get me a slice of pizza or help the situation. I was mad and I had to go so I left empty handed even though i had paid. I have never written a bad review for a place in my life. But i hope the owner sees this and realizes theres a guy working his counter with a bad attitude that doesnt give a damn thats messing with his business, because they just lost a 2-3x a week customer and if the guy cares that little about his job im sure im not the only angry customer. For a place where the food is excellent to be losing business over a guys thats working the counter is absurd. **the kid with long hair that also works the counter and is good must have been on break*** read more

Food is good and very fresh , and very very delicious, . Trust me , i am eat Pizza around New England.

Pizza is great staff is very nice!!! Will be back soon! My friends and I highly enjoyed the ambiance.

20 bucks for a 12" pizza is too high . I do see buying a pizza there . 16 " maybe, but their 16" are 24-26!bucks? A bit rich for me as a neighborhood pizza spot 1.07 on line web charge ? To order on line ? read more

Great pies, the crust is especially good. Go with a crowd, plenty of seating and good ambience. read more

BrickFire Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

Fast delivery which was a treat since it was pouring outside. Love the pizza dough and ingredients were tasty and fresh. Mediterranean on the garlicky side so if you not trying to keep vampires away just be alert to this. Probably not a first date choice (laughing emoji) Overall both very delicious and I would order again. read more

BrickFire Pizza - Mediterranean - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

See all

Brickfire is the best!!! The food is awesome and the slice of pizza is massive!! You can't go wrong with this place!!!!

The new owners have raised prices multiple times & the food is not as good as it use to be. The pizza is still good but everything else is not as good as it use to be. They are also robbing customers by charging 15.49 for mozzarella sticks, greed is going to kill this business. Me & my family will no longer be giving them a penny of our money. read more

Great subs, friendly staff, and always a solid pie for those who enjoy a cheesier pizza with tangy sauce.

Second update. It has since improved since the last one. The food is consistent. The folks are regularly friendly and it's a decent spot again. Still no bathrooms. read more

Phenomenal Brick oven pizza! I absolutely love the portions and the taste is rare to find in Massachusetts! 10/10 recommend.

Excellent service and good pizza crust. I love their Greek salad portion size . Many toppings to choose from

Bought 7 pies and 36 knots for my nieces birthday party, and they were super helpful and everything was amazing! Couldn't recommend more!

They're terrible. They always get my order wrong. I ask for a sub a certain way and they never get it right.

I have been ordering pizza from BrickFire for years and have always loved it! If I were reviewing just the pizza, there would be 5 stars. Today, for the first time, I ordered a salad with extra dressing, no peppers or onions. I also ordered the two cookies for $1.50. I picked up the order and when I got back to my office, the salad had peppers and onions, there was no extra dressing, and no cookies. Mind you they charge extra for extra dressing so I paid for that and the cookies, waste of money. The salad was pretty terrible, the tomatoes were refrigerated and tasteless and rock hard. A couple of my coworkers also ordered salads and they agreed, never again. If I were reviewing just the salad, 0 stars. read more

A favorite pre-pandemic. Since we moved had not been here in a while. Good, fresh pizza. The staff is very nice. Only negative - the place was freezing! read more

The staff working were a great team of people! I've never had this pizza and it was amazing! Thx to all! read more

BrickFire Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

I like this place alot ...Today there was a misunderstanding regarding Sub Rolls...Lol I ordered a small italian Sub.......I got an Italian although it was not a Sub....It was a Sandwich on a Knot Roll....Unfortunately my wife is not a fan of a Knot Roll......I called them and explained what had happened, meaning we didn't get what we thought we were getting.....Anyways to make a short story long....I spoke with Damien and he was very appologetic and offered to remake the "Sub" right away.....we chose to take a credit for when we return .....Now that is Good Service!!! read more

Pizza was tasty and delivered promptly. We also ordered garlic knots, which somehow slid off the table and onto the floor (I say somehow because we didn't touch the basket). They noticed that the garlic knots fell, and brought us a replacement basket on the house - which they really didn't need to do. That's totally unexpected nowadays. read more

The food was great. The price was just right and the staff was super friendly! Would definitely recommend. Thank you for your hospitality! read more

BrickFire Pizza - 12'' pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

BrickFire Pizza Co. ROCKS!!! I called from Nashville and ordered a surprise pizza delivery for my sister's birthday ( y'all went above and beyond...) The staff was AWESOME on the phone and upon delivery! So friendly and helpful. And the food was perfect! Not only were the pizza and wings delicious, but delivered hot and on time! They even wrote her a Birthday note on the inside of the box top! I highly recommend all my Boston friends (or if you are visiting the area) try out BrickFire Pizza Co.!!!! read more

BrickFire Pizza - Anchovies, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Basil, Ricotta (side of olives). SPECTACULAR!!! - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

BrickFire has been our go-to pizza place for a year or 2 now. It's further than our previous place, and definitely pricier, but SO worth it. The pizza is just so good. Great quality & flavor. We usually get cheese or pepperoni pizza, so I can't speak to many other menu items. We didn't love the meatball topping when we got it, but that's personal preference. read more

This has change TREMENDOUSLY! I've purchased from BrickFire for the 3 years I've lived here and was never disappointed. The BBQ chicken pizza was drowning in BBQ sauce. Tried wiping some off but it's just I edible. Food costs too much to have to accept this horrible product. read more

BrickFire Pizza - BBQ Chicken pizza DROWNING in BBQ sauce. Inedible. - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

The dressing used on the Greek salad is to die for. This in auspicious place is on my must visit list when the Boston area. I try & try to pry the recipe from the owner who is wise enough to keep it secret. Traveling back to Florida I'm sneaking a small portion home. Hoping TSA doesn't catch it. read more

Greek salad was not what I accepted, : couple small pieces of chicken, a lot of tomatoes, most of the lettuce , no onions, few olives. very empty salad, I was so dissatisfied , I will never get salad from that place again. Very pricey that place all about making money. read more

Was craving Mac and Cheese pizza and this was the only one in the Watertown / Newton area I could find it. The mac and cheese pizza was excellent. We also got the meat lovers which was good as well. The crust was fantastic so I imagine all the pizza would be wonderful. Service was also exceptional. Would highly recommend this place and will be returning. read more

BrickFire Pizza - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newton, Massachusetts

See all

I visited BrickFire for the first time on Thursday May 1st and am glad I did! I wasn't too hungry, so I ordered something light. On the menu was a Ham & Cheese sandwich, so that's what I told the young man who took my order. I know it's hard to get excited about a Ham & Cheese sandwich. Right? But the fact that I am leaving a review speaks volumes about the quality of the food. First, the bun was unbelievable! The bread was warm, substantive, and actually tasted good! Not like those boring buns you buy at the deli counter at a grocery store. The ham had a nice, smoked flavor. I've had Ham & Cheese sandwiches at some sub shops that had absolutely NO flavor. To top it all off was the American cheese. My only "complaint" would be that I wish BrickFire offered other options, like Swiss Cheese for example. That's about it. Oh yeah, the person who took my order was very cordial and brought the sandwich to me at my table when it was ready. I will most definitely visit this place again! read more

I live in the area, and order often. The fact that the last 5 times I've ordered, they mess up the order. I don't know if it's the person answering the phone, or the cooks. But constantly they mess some type of my order up. I'm at the point where I'm not calling to complain, but it's a little bit crazy how this continuously happens. The food is great, when you get what you want read more