The restaurant was bright as one side had windows the full length from floor to ceiling. There is an outdoor seating area. Indoor seating is limited to a counter along the window. There were high ceiling with flower boxes up highs. Oath has mainly pizza and salads. I would call it flat bread. There were a few sandwiches that use the same bread as the pizza, precooked similar to a large pita bread. it is like a pizza with no cheese. They make it the same way but they fold it in half to make a sandwich. The sandwich had chicken, cheese and mushrooms. It was delicious. There is just counter service I had to wait my turn. The pricing on the sandwich was reasonable. I would return if in the area. read more

See all

I wanted to like this pizza (Muffled Trushroom) -- really I did, as I'm a total truffles fan -- but it just didn't WOW me like I'd hoped. There just wasn't enough truffle sauce to taste 'truffley' and definitely not enough mushroom topping! There were so few, in fact, that one or two slices (out of eight) didn't have any! As this was my first time patronizing the restaurant, I'd like to think that perhaps it was a one off? I don't know. And while there are two other pizzas there that I'd like to try, I dunno if they're really worth the $28 price point apiece (more like $30ish when you include tax)! Oath Pizza prove me wrong! That said, the service there was very warm and friendly and the place looked clean. I just wish my pizza had been better! read more

just had Oath Pizza At JJ Foleys Backyard in Dennisport. First time at JJFoleys. Was a beautiful day, they have about 5-6 food Trucks to serve customers. Oath Pizza was the only one open (due to Labor Day) inly 3 choices, plain, pepperoni, and sausage. took about 20 minutes to cook. I asked for red pepper flakes, they had no condiments ! Was the worst looking and tasting pizza I ever had. looked like a child made it! had about 1.5"s of unflavored hard crust around perimeter then about 1.5"s of tomato sauce with no cheese on it inside crust. Then the cheese in the center of pizza with minimal sausage. overall would say only 55-60% of pizza had cheese on it! not sure how they stay in busines! read more

I would say overall, I'd give it a 3.5 rating. This spot was good, quick, and the pizza was better than average but nothing spectacular. But the service was great. I would say it's worth a try! read more

Oath Pizza Wellesley - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

These charming young adults work so hard and are personable and efficient and friendly The restaurant is meticulously clean. There's a handbook the team refers to in order to be sure the order is exactly what you had hoped for or better. Some high school kids hang out there -- there's a nice book with football games playing and a steady stream of pick up orders streaming in and out. I always loved Oath on Straight Wharf but Oath Wellesley is a home run. We will be regulars. Oh. And of course the pizza is delicious. read more

Oath Pizza Wellesley - Oath "sandwich" to go!! - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

If you prefer a real pizza made in a pizza oven, then you might want to skip this place. The crust is pre-made and looks like focaccia bread versus a real pizza crust that is crispy and fresh. read more

Keep an eye on the employees (all boys) with all the young girls hanging out there to distract them food is not being made on time!

Came here for their vegan cheese & the pictures of their pizzas. We got delivery, one vegan cheese pizza showed up as a plain regular cheese. Also, the crusts were not cooked properly and the toppings were extremely, extremely lacking. Not going back. read more

Oath Pizza Wellesley - Tuscan Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

See all

Oath Pizza is now open at Linden Square in Wellesley. They serve up small thin crust and large slightly thicker crust craft or build your own pizzas, salads, cookies, brownies, and cold Pepsi fountain drinks and bottled drinks. The pizzas are made behind the glass counter with prebaked pizza shells, and a variety of toppings behind being baked quickly in the small belt pizza oven. I placed an order online back at my home, then headed down to Wellesley. I got the Large 14" Muffled Trushroom (online $28 plus tax) and they were just making my pizza as I arrived about 4 minutes early from my pickup time. My pizza was ready and boxed within 7 minutes. The owner thanked me for stopping by. The light and soft crisp pizza crust was topped with their house-made truffle sauce, mozzarella blend, fresh mushrooms, ricotta, and grana padano cheese. This pizza had good flavors and I enjoyed a few slices back at the vehicle with my large Bubly water. I decided to order a small dessert and placed another online order for a Chocolate Chunk Cookie Pizza ($9 plus tax-same price in-store). I watched the staff make my 7" dessert pizza, hot and fresh out of the oven. This was a bit messy and very sweet to eat which had fluffy mini crust topped with chocolate chunk cookie dough, ricotta, chocolate drizzle and powdered sugar. A scoop of Trulys coffee ice cream went very well with this hot treat. read more

See all

I didn't think that it was possible to ruin pizza. Oath has succeeded. Seriously unattractive and tasteless. Go somewhere else. Anywhere else. Dreadful! read more

Oath Pizza Wellesley - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

I've been to two other Oath Pizza locations, so I pretty much knew what to expect, great pizza and friendly service. Well, yes, that's exactly what I got. Great staff, prompt service and the pizza was, as always, delicious. T?he location is great, right on the corner of the building, was comfortable seating. read more

Ordered take out. The ingredients were ok, but they were too sparse. I mostly got tomato sauce. My pizza was cheese, mushrooms and roma tomatoes. They put about one mushroom on per slice at best. Some tomatoes here or there. I ordered fresh mozzarella and got one coin sized dollop on each slice. The rest was just the sauce. A tomato sauce pizza with a topping sitting here or there like an island in the sea. Really? It needed a lot of assistance before it would be enjoyable. I had to add some of my own mushrooms and a bunch of cheese and put back in my oven. This was my second and last try at this place. read more

I ordered a gluten free pizza. The crust was not very good. it was thick and hard. All of their crusts are made in advance and sit out on the counter in a pile until you order. The toppings were very skimpy including the sauce and cheese. Unfortunately, I will not be returning. The service was ok, the girl was not very friendly. read more

I rarely leave reviews, but when I do they are to give credit where credit is due. Oath pizza in Wellesley is great. I've been wanting to try this place out and came in for lunch. The owner, Bill is a super nice guy. He told me about the healthy option chic pea crust, which was amazing. This was my first time here. Great location, great menu. The spicy chicken pizza was great and I'm looking forward to coming back. read more

This pizza is fresh with fresh ingredients. The price is ok for the quality . The staff is friendly . The ambiance is good . I would recommend this place . read more

The crust on the personal thin crust pizzas is amazing. I also LOVE their chocolate chunk cookie dessert pizza. It is so good! The pizzas I like best are the spicy mother clucker, the Bella and the Tucson sausage! read more

Oath is the most amazing pizza in town! My friends and I always order pizzas from here! The service is great, and all of the employees are so kind! I highly recommend ordering here for your next meal! The store feels so friendly with its bright lights and warm atmosphere! read more

The BEST pizza and I'm not even joking. The pizza is a little expensive but i think its worth every penny. read more

Oath Pizza Wellesley - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

Not what I expected. Nice high school customer service. 1 large pizza was not worth the $31.00. Did Take out, so can't review the eat in. A little disappointed. Flavor was fresh, a bit too much cheese. Would not go back. read more

Be New lots of staff, a little disorganized, pizza good but mine could have used more toppings. Second night think they were overwhelmed. read more

The pizza is delicious. I was amazed that you can create your own toppings. The pizza crust is excellent. The owner takes pride in helping his customers. The place has a home style feel. read more

Addy and Jacob are so kind and helped me out picking out a pizza. Food was DELICIOUS atmosphere was awesome

This place is so good. There was this worker Hudson and he was so nice and made the best pizza.

First time trying this place! It was excellent. We had a delicious Greek salad that was fresh and crisp. The dressing was very good. The pizza we ate was hot and crispy on the bottom which I like. Will definitely be going back. read more

At first, I didn't think this place would stand the test of pizza time. Now I love this place for its great tasting pizza and sides to go with it. Sinxe this was my first visit here , The man at the pizza booth was very inviting and offered me a few choices of their best pizzas, but I had to go with cheese and a side of their cheesy breadsticks and it all tasted glorious. That along with great service and a nice quiet atmosphere makes it the second best pizza spot in Wellesley right behind Deluxe and Old Schools. Now that is how you do Pizza, The Wellesley way! I salute you Oath for I shall make an Oath to come here again real soon! For that is the Pizza Promise! read more

The pizza here was great and had some of the best in Wellesley but also they had the best service and appropriation and patients for their customers. Also the food was very fast read more

This tastes like pizza made on a grocery store pre-made crust. It's fine but nothing more than that.

The crust is terrible. No idea what the hoopla is over this pizza, and it is way overpriced.

The website is so unclear about what you are ordering. For the second time we got a pizza that was not what we ordered. Very disappointed. And when you call the store, you get a kid who doesn't care or know what they are talking about. It's too bad because if you get what you want, the pizza can be good. read more

My family and I went in there last night and found the pizza rather tasteless..I don't like to see my pizza made from premade crust either that just sits on the counter in different sizes..is it fresh? who knows! It all just sits there out in the open and then they take it and make your pizza from there. All in all my pizza was ready in like 5 minutes..they put it in that oven and it comes out on the other side like a waffle maker. It doesn't stay hot very long either! I always see a different employee there..one that looks kind of raggedy with long hair..You used to see the Owner there every night now I haven't seen him in ages. No thank you..I like a pizza that is freshly made including the crust nice and hot with flavorful toppings that aren't skimpy! read more

Great service. Made up for any mistake very quickly and nicely. Very friendly people. Pepperoni is great. As are the mushrooms.

I have been looking forward to Oath Pizza opening but after the long awaited event I don't think I could have been more disappointed. To start off the order was completed over 45 minutes after it was promised. The store was a chaotic mess. We ordered the Bella, it sounded and looked fantastic on the menu but sorely disappointed, it was sparsely covered with toppings, feeling more like garlic bread than pizza. I ordered a large Caesar salad but received two small half full containers of Roman lettuce two croutons and some shredded cheese. The final disappointment was a burnt and broken cookie that I had to remind them that I had ordered. My overall impression is that Oath Pizza in Wellesley is not ready for prime time. I think they are simply overwhelmed and the food is overpriced for the quality of their product. read more

Oath Pizza Wellesley - The Bella - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

Food yummy. This place is a treat. My family enjoy eating here when we are in Wellesley. A little pricey but the food tastes great. Easy to place your order online and it is always ready when we arrive. read more

Bummer. Had high hopes. It was "almost" good. I got the sausage and mushroom pizza because I like mushrooms. 1) I love cheese - this pizza had TOO MUCH cheese. 2) No mushrooms - at first I thought oh they must have forgotten the mushroorms but there were random mushrooms. Maybe 1 little button mushroom - honestly if that- on the pizza; 3) It appears that the ingrediants are frozen? Pizza was $28 3) got the full size ceasar salad - OY- in a pre made plastic container for 12 bucks Shame on me if I ever order from here again. So, unless you are in a bind I would go elsewhere. Bummer. read more

VEGAN PERFECTION! The pizza was just exceptional. i'm a vegan and have a tough time finding great pizza. Oath nailed it! look at this gorgeous pizza with vegan cheese, beyond crumbles cheese olives, garlic as. cherry tomatoes. it tasted better than it looks! Welcome to Wellesley, Oath!!!! read more

Oath Pizza Wellesley - Vegan Classic Cheese (Half Personal) - Pizza Near Me - Wellesley, Massachusetts

The hype way exceeds reality...the pizzas are expensive for their size...kinda tasty, but there are probably 000's of places out there that would totally eclipse this place read more

My first time here. Menu seemed great. Tried The Works pizza. Open the box - lots of fresh ingredients, looks great. And then you bite into it. Ugh. What cheese blend they use is disgusting. It's not that wonderful mozzarella feel, taste, and pull. Their cheese turns into a horrible liquid sauce that tastes like some mixture of Velvetta, mayonnaise, dirty sweat socks, and hot garbage. You're thinking - no it can't be that bad. You push your way through a slice and get to the second, but you have to stop. You have to admit to yourself that you just laid $15 for something you're going to throw away. Wtf is wrong with people? Are they not trying these things themselves? Maybe the other types of pizza here don't use the same revolting cheese blend. Idk. And I'm not going back to find out. Grrrr-rosss. read more

The workers were really nice. The crust was thin and so good! I got a half personal pizza. Lots of open tables and calm ambiance. Please go here! read more

Oath pizza is decent fast food. I was looking forward to this opening for awhile. The pizza itself is ok. The location is super convenient so I'm sure I'll be back. The pizza crusts are premade shells and they quickly throw the toppings on and cook for a few minutes. Nothing amazing, it's the Chipotle of pizza. read more

A good pizza is not easy to find however you can certainly find it at Oath. Mushroom Truffle and Roni pizza were very good. will be back