Delicious ice cream spot located inside the Hudson Valley Food Hall…read more I love seeing rotating vendors and this creamery pop up. They sell homemade ice cream and offer from scoops to milkshakes to pints to go. The cool thing is they have a selection of over 100 rotating flavors on the menu. Everything is homemade by the owner Dan, Five Pennies is a true local ice cream shop of a gem :)

Five Pennies Creamery is the first place you see when you walk into the Hudson Valley Food Hall…read more And the last. I walked into the Market for iced coffee. I had just eaten. I wasn't hungry. At all. But Five Pennie's' friendly owner warmly greeted me as I entered. Told me he makes his own ice cream. High quality ingredients. Small batch. It looked really good. He offered me a sample of Praline. It was delicious. I told him that I needed to get iced coffee but I would see him on the way out. After drinking my coffee, I wasn't hungry. I hoped I would find the strength to say no to ice cream as I exited. I did not. He offered me another sample. He asked if I like peanut butter. I said I do, but I didn't tell him I don't usually love peanut butter ice cream. He gave me a sample of Peanut Butter Oreo. It was amazing. So peanut buttery. I ultimately ended up splitting a scoop of Praline and a scoop of Peanut Butter Oreo with my wife, who by then had entered the Food Hall. I live in CT. I have been to most of the best ice cream spots in CT. These two Five Pennies flavors, were as good as the flavors at CT's best spots. Five enthusiastic Stars

Cute little ice cream stand. Ice cream was delicious and reasonably priced. They also had a full…read moreoff the grill menu, which we didn't try. It's nice to support a local business. Win win.

The ice creams were enjoyable, though they could be improved for a more memorable experience. The…read moreatmosphere was pleasant, and the service was prompt. I appreciated the option for outdoor seating, which added to the overall experience. Tried their vegan ice cream, which was good, strawberry cheesecake was yum, and pistachio ice cream you can miss.

What can you say, toppings and ice cream! Staff is amazing! Always serving with a smile and…read morefriendly. They get to know their customers and treat them with professionalism. Great shakes too! Flavors are great and always something new! Plus their milkshakes are some of the best around!

Several flavors to choose from including sugar free options. Place very clean and service prompt.read more

We made a random stop for milkshakes as we often do and this place checked all of our MUST. Good…read morethick straw - most do not. Delicious flavor and wasn't too milky. Great consistency. Good service and great prices too!

I've had ice cream nearly every day this summer, in a dozen states. This is the winner. It is the…read morebest ice cream of the summer.

Staff is friendly and helpful. Very patient with kids and their delays when making an order, super…read moreplus! Ice cream is great and with a park across the street it makes it a family establishment!

Haven't had great ice cream in a while but this is definitely one of the best ice cream shops I've…read morebeen to. Cotton candy ice cream and Coffee Cookies and Cream was 100/10!

Frank has been making the most flavorful ice cream anywhere! I have gotten all my ice cream cakes…read morefrom Frank for over 45 years! His cookie crunch is the best!

We stopped with three girls after a late gymnastics class. The older gentleman (looked like an…read moreowner) was not very friendly. He didn't smile and didn't say more than 5 words total. The place looked very outdated and gave me Soviet Union vibes. I didn't have ice cream but the girls loved it, so hopefully the products are worth it.

We absolutely love coming to Midnight Ferry! Whether we're taking an evening stroll along the…read moreNewburgh waterfront or simply craving something sweet, this is always one of our favorite stops. Everything we've tried has been amazing! Our favorites are the Warm Brownie Sundae, Banana Split, Strawberry Fields Sundae, and the incredibly creative specialty milkshakes. Their homemade crepes are delicious too, especially if you're sharing dessert. And if you're 21+, you have to try their boozy ice cream creations and frozen cocktails--they're such a fun and unique treat you won't find just anywhere. The portions are generous, everything is beautifully presented, and the atmosphere is always lively and welcoming. We love grabbing our desserts and walking along the Hudson River afterward--it's become one of our favorite family traditions. The only downside? They close during the winter! Every year we can't wait for them to reopen because they're truly one of our favorite dessert spots in the Hudson Valley. If you're looking for a unique place to satisfy your sweet tooth in Newburgh, Midnight Ferry is an absolute must-visit. Every visit feels like a little celebration, and we always leave happy--and already planning what we'll order next!

This place deserves so much more visibility. Their cocktails are exceptionally good…read more Kids are happy with milkshakes and icecream and parents can enjoy 5min of peace. I cant wait for the weather to get warmer so we can seat outside. I wish service was faster for the shakes and icecream, dis kids patience is close to zero. But the bartender is very efficient and makes great drinks. P.s. flimsy tiny tables inside always stress me, I cant shake the idea they will tip over eventually. Need sturdier base and larger surface.

In the post-Mr. Cone era Wally's is a stalwart for folks…read more Decent service, with a smile. They understand the ice cream lover's specific requests. It's a classic 20th century roadside ice cream stand. The ambience is the ice cream.

I've been to Wally's Ice Cream a few times now, and it always hits the spot…read more This time, I got the black raspberry and coconut swirl, and it was absolutely perfect. The flavors complemented each other so well, and it was the perfect treat on a warm day. As a bonus, it even matched my outfit, which made it that much more fun! If you're looking for fresh ice cream with great flavor combinations, Wally's is definitely worth a visit.