Today i stopped off here after a hike, I got a coconut Milk Ice Cream with chocolate chips and a Chocolate Egg Cream. Menu: They have a TON of different flavors, from what I heard they make their own. Alot of them sound really good, they offer shakes, sundays, ice cream, ice cream sodas, egg creams. Coconut Milk with Chocolate Chips Ice cream: The coconut milk ice cream had really good coconut flavor and good texture, the combo with the chocolate chips reminded me of an almond joy. Really good dish! Chocolate egg cream: It had a little too much chocolate, it wasn't the best i ever had, but wasn't the worst. Service: The staff is super friendly and nice and helpful and the prices are good. Overall: Definitely worth checking out if you are in the area. Great choices with good prices and good flavors make it a good spot. read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Coconut Milk with Chocolate Chip ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

4:00pm good time for some ice cream and Weir's is the right place.. no long lines yet so wifey and I sashayed right up to the window and she order today special choco taco, I always get the Kahlua Brownie. Ice cream is always refreshing and delicious. So on your hot summer days ride over to Weir's located in Salisbury mills on Route 94 you're be glad you did. read more

See all

Absolutely amazing !! We tried " Honey Bazaar & chocolate Pb & pralines & cream!! So good!!! And the young lady served us with a huge smile!! Love the sitting area also!!!! We will definitely be back! read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

Delicious ice cream, the best house made frozen deliciousness in the whole region. Worth the drive! read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Classic ice cream summer day - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

Pretty good ice cream. Ample parking. Benches to sit and enjoy outside. Young kids working. They served us a waffle cone without a napkin or glove and then they handled money so that was a bit unsanitary, but other than that, no complaints. Definitely will go again and I recommend this little shop. read more

(From my 8yr old reviewer) Weirs is a really awesome ice cream place.my dad has been going here since he was a little kid.my dog got his first pup cup and he devoured it all in 5 seconds.my brother got a big banana split it was so big he did not finish it. I got an ice cream sundae with gummy bear and gummy worms. I didn't eat all mine and it wasn't very big same as my mom and she got the same thing as my me. read more

See all

This is a nice hidden gem in the area. There are so many different flavors choices and uniquely enough, dairy free options. It has private parking and the price was on point. The staff is friendly and the actual ice cream is delicious. read more

I have been stuck on the Praline & Cream hard ice cream & make sure to add the nut crunch topping...YUMMY!! My partner tried something different this time... the banana split. You can get the banana split with 2 or 3 scoops of ice cream & of course, the toppings. The line can be long in the evening but the staff keeps the line moving quickly as possible & give great friendly service. read more

See all

Stopped by Weirs for a sweet treat on this nice summer day! The place had lots of open parking space, as well as seats and tables. The establishment is decorated very colorfully with their different ice cream flavors/creations and cute puns all over the ice cream stand. The place itself looked cleaned and well maintained. Ambience rate 10/10. The staff is friendly and helpful. The worker that helped me gave me generous portions of ice cream and toppings which I really appreciated. The wait time wasn't long considering I went at 5:30pm before peak hours. A long line started to form maybe 5 minutes into me ordering, so I'd definitely recommend going before 6pm if you want to avoid the line. However, they started to open up more ordering windows as they saw more people coming, so that could help speed up the wait. Service rate 9/10. My boyfriend and I both ordered the make your own sundaes. 1. A medium sundae w/ a scoop of wizard tracks and a scoop of chocolate chip cookie dough. 2. A large sundae w/ a scoop of wizard tracks and Vanilla Cake Batter. The portion sizes were a good amount that left me satisfied. The wizard tracks ice cream was incredibly delicious. I enjoyed the mini pb cups imbedded inside the ice cream. Wizard Tracks Rate 10/10. The chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream was okay, I couldn't taste much of the cookie dough. Cookie dough Ice cream rate 7/10. However, their cookie dough topping was very yummy and so soft. Topping Rate 10/10. The vanilla cake batter was good, but it tasted like your average cake batter ice cream. Rate 7/10. Most importantly, the ice cream didn't melt fast at all which I liked because some ice cream places I've been to, the ice cream melts really fast and it turns into a milkshake. But not at Weirs! The prices for these sundaes were a little on the pricier end, however the yummy taste and great amount they give justifies it. Medium Sundae: $8.00 and Large Sundae: $9.00 (for hard ice cream). One recommendation is I wish they didn't make the menu hard to see by putting it on a large digital screen. With the glare of the sunlight, it makes it difficult to see from a distance, so you really have to get close to the monitor. Plastering it on a printed paper copy would be much better. Nevertheless, I would definitely go back to this cute mom and pops ice cream stand to indulge in some scrumptious ice cream. read more

See all

Best ice cream shop in the area. The Earl Grey BlackBerry had a strong tea flavor and Spice Hot Chocolate really had a chili pepper kick. Lavender lemon was very refreshing read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Labor Day weekend lines but moves quick - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

My favorite ice cream spot since I was a small child. So many flavor choices, many dairy free options. I've never had bad service there and it's a great place for families. read more

Weir's ice cream is refreshing, delicious, and it comes in a wide variety of flavors!! The long lines show how much locals like Weir's rich ice cream flavors. Their customer service is fast, efficient and always friendly. They are adjacent to a park with clean ample benches to sit. People can bring their dogs and walk them while enjoying mouthwatering ice cream. read more

Wow weirs has the best ice cream in the 845 very friendly staff especially jess!!! Worth the drive and you won't regret it

This place is delicious and very affordable. Thank you jessica for serving me with respect and kindness. Coming here is a great environment where I can sit outside and enjoy my icecream! read more

Lick, slurp, swallow (repeat). We stumbled across this place and I'm glad we did. I was in desperate need of a soft vanilla cone with chocolate sprinkles. I know, I know, boring but going back to tradition before ALL these weird crazy other flavors came into play. Yes, I enjoy them immensely, but sometimes you just need good old reliable. So....we pull up and there is this plastic chainlink trail line (kinda like a waiting for a ride at Great Adventure- hmmm just really aged myself) Oops! Anyway, I figure hey this place must get busy so the ice cream must be good. So under I go because I'm not going round and round and round. Get a medium cone (which is HUGE) lick, slurp swallow. Oh my enjoy, ya can't go wrong here. They even have a place with benches that you can sit and relax. read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Medium soft vanilla cone. Minus all the chocolate sprinkles I licked off - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

This place is open from April to October and the cold winter wait is absolutely worth it. They have a wide variety of treats (sheet cakes, hard ice cream, soft serve, and all manner of floats, shakes, and even egg creams) and a ton of their flavors are custom made in house. Their Raspberry Linzer Tart (pictured) is absolutely delightful and their brownie batter ice cream is top notch. Service is always incredibly friendly (family owned since the 50s) and even on a cold April evening the line easily had over 60 people in it. read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Raspberry Linzer Tart hard ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

See all

This ice cream is soo good and they have so lovely garden to sit and enjoy the ice cream! read more

Weir's Ice Cream - a hand holding a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

Weir's is a family favorite. Best place to get ice cream. Prices are good and service is quick and friendly! There are benches outside to sit and enjoy your treats. Love bringing my kids here when we have an ice cream craving ! read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Soft serve vanilla with rainbow sprinkles - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

The line waiting outside the windows doesn't lie. The soft serve is smooth, creamy and natural tasting. read more

Weir's Ice Cream - the front of the store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

Classic old time ice cream stand. Weir's was used for a scene in the movie "The Irishman". We go there all summer. It's open now for the season. read more

Love this place! Even when the line is long, it goes quick enough. There's so many places to sit and enjoy your ice cream on a nice day and the staff here is very friendly. So many ice cream options to choose from! read more

I passed on stopping at another ice cream stand on route 32 in Highland Mills thinking I would go to Weirs which is local to me and I've had good experiences there in the past. However, this time I asked to see the difference between cup sizes of medium and large soft serve. I chose the medium thinking that was big enough. Unfortunately they barely filled it to the top. Not only was it not filled to the top but they only filled 1/2 the side of the cup. I'm going to include pics so you can see. This hasn't happened there before so maybe this is how they're making up for inflationary hits. Not a good way to treat customers during these inflationary times! That is not cool. read more

See all

All homemade ice cream but not a fan of the taste. However, great atmosphere and most people love it!

Cute place, but it's 2022 up your non dairy options. Super nice people, lines are beyond long... pretty much standing in line with the local high school. its a place for the kids to gather, hang out and check out the scene. ice cream is just meh... would i go back nah.. should you try it to try it.. if you like a huge ice cream menu then yes! just gotta love the cows milk for it. Who would've thought there is such a thing as too many sprinkles.... read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Yes that is a little heavy on the sprinklers i couldn't even taste the lame "ice cream" - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

I love weir's ice cream! Classic ice cream stand with many choices! Their ice cream cakes are great too !

"Holy Whipped Cream Batman!" As my little girl and I rolled up in the Batmobile we noticed tons of people lined up to get some of the yummy goodness Weir's was selling. I thought to myself, "Holy Gorydamn Batman the ice cream here can't be that good!" But the crowds and reputation of this place speak for itself because the ice cream was really good. I mean really how good can "ice cream" really be? Isn't ice cream just ice cream? Probably but what we got served here was pretty darn yummy! I'll certainly be stopping by again to try something else other than the ice cream. Maybe I'll try a milk shake ("My milk shake brings all the boys to the yard. And they're like, it's better than yours. Damn right it's better than yours..."). read more

Of course I recommend Weir's Ice Cream the different flavors of ice cream is the best! The amount of people that are willing to stand on the very long lines to get their ice cream from Weir's says it all!!!! The only thing that I don't like is that once Labor Day comes around Weir's shuts down until they open back up for the Summer the wait is so long. Ice Cream Ice Cream I Scream for Ice Cream! read more

I have been on a kick to seek out these local frozen confection's stores all around and this one was well hidden from me. After a long drive we arrived to this place and it was an open space with nice park type setting to sit down and enjoy your frozen treats. The selection of ice cream is basic not really lots to pick from in terms of flavors but the menu looked SO BIG for my first time. The thing that stood out was sizes ranged from Child - Jumbo! They meant jumbo it is a huge bucket they call a cup lol. I got a tropical breeze blended treat with banana (fresh) pineapples (fresh) and toasted coconut mixed with vanilla soft serve. Cheese got a m&m blended with chocolate soft serve in a medium. We went and sat on the park benches and did some fun people watching while devouring. Nearing the half way of my cup i realized the error of my ways thinking getting a jumbo would be funny. I felt drunk on Soft Serve so unless you are in that mood AVOID the Jumbo lol. But if you are do enjoy because its GREAT! Well until you stand up and with every step you feel it all sloshing around in your tummy. Delicious pay it a visit! read more

drive by this place often and never got to try because of huge lines I see at it, so in the afternoon I saw no line and finally got to try. so took me a while to decide since they have a lot of choices to choose from and I settled on the maple walnut sundae, so not even a second after thanking me for ordering it and asking if I wanted whipped cream on top or anything else, they made it and give it to me, am like wow they so fast, am like I ordered less then 30 seconds ago, got to say I love the quick service. so, the vanilla ice cream soft serve was velvety and rich, walnuts were crunchy and maple sweet was very sweet, but not too aggressive. whip cream was yummy. honestly i really loved the sundae and for a medium only $4 that's a steal, other stands would want like 6-7$ for that size. so glad i stopped by for a treat after my lunch. this place completely destroys my local ice cream in my area in taste and customer service. read more

Weir's Ice Cream - maple walnut sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

A most go to in the summer. The best ice cream in the area. We try to go every day while open every year.

Top notch ice cream and simply the best ice cream place in the area. It is kid friendly and the prices are great.

Our in-laws took us to this place when we recently were there. They told us it is one of their favorite places and I can certainly understand why. Pistachio ice cream was the one I got and it did not disappoint. We will want to go there for ice cream the next time we are in the area. oh, and did I mention it is a cute place with lots of outdoor seating? Sorry I didn't take any pics...to busy eating :-p read more

"All The Chocolate" is now a full time flavor, no longer seasonal!!!!!!!!!! Weirs ice cream is gourmet and my favorite place around. During the off season I slum it with other brands but it all goes in the garbage when Weirs reopens. read more

This is a very popular local ice cream parlor. I almost never asked for a sample. However, I didn't want to risk trying the coconut milk ice cream. But, he said they don't give samples, which was a bit disappointing. Otherwise, the ice cream was average, and I'm not really sure what all the hype is about. read more

Our favorite ice cream place!! We will buy multiple pints at a time to stock up. The drive through makes me nostalgic of my childhood. We love the creative flavors here, but the natural/balanced taste of the ice creams. Personal favorite is anything with cherry and chocolate, the Kahlua brownie, choco taco, coffee. We had peach one and strawberry, and it was very natural/light for a creamy ice cream. The ice cream sandwiches are great too. The only negative things (which a few are really positives...) Be ready for a line... because everyone loves this place Be ready to gain weight... because it's really good I'm bummed the place closes around Labor Day... because I wish I can buy it all year Oh.. don't get the watermelon. That one does not taste so natural and is super sweet. read more

Great spot for a delicious scoop of ice cream! They have a large selection of hard and soft serve, toppings, and specials (like the Turtles delight). While the menu can be a bit overwhelming and the prices a tad high, it's well worth it. Lines move fast, staff is friendly, outdoor seating only, large parking lot, and cash only! read more

Weir's Ice Cream - Rocky road (small) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury Mills, New York

Yum. Great soft serve (what I ordered).. large vanilla with chocolate sprinkles - my go to. Really good cone and extremely generous. Kids at the window were respectful and delivered my cone with a smile. ice cream was creamy and delicious. Only complaint is that I wish I lived closer to this shop. ;) read more

Always great! We wait for months for Weirs to open and it never disappoints!! Best soft serve in the planet.

Weirs is a staple to the small community. Ice Creams always hitting the spot. It's a little pricey but what isn't these days. Long lines if you go after 6 but worth the wait. read more

There's not much that makes me happier than seeing the spring clean up crew parked behind Weir's. It means they're opening soon, summer is coming and so are our ice cream shakes and cakes! read more