I always thought that if you get to the bakery when they first open you would get the freshest donuts.....NOT I arrived this morning at 4:10 and began selecting donuts. As I made my choices, the employee walked down to the far left and grabbed the similar donuts that I selected from the other display. I ask if those were fresh and made "this morning" and she replied "yes". Once I paid, left and began driving home I had two of the donuts from the box. Both of the donuts were hard, crunchy and cold. I spent $16 for a dozen donuts that I was under the impression were the best......I won't go back read more

Have been going here since I've been a kid and it hasn't changed one bit. Still fantastic baked goods. We have used Boydens for many occasions. Sunday mornings on the way to church we would stop for some donuts and I would have to say my favorite is the baby gator(small braided dough with white icing and nuts on top). We have used them for birthday cakes and they have been great. Every Christmas we order their gingerbread men and it just isn't Christmas without the taste of them. Also their dinner rolls are to die for. A great all around bakery that I would definitely go out of my way to get to. read more

Very upset with the Graduation cake that I ordered. I took a picture in to show how and what I wanted...pretty simple design but it covered the majority of the cake which is how I expected mine to turn out. I was encouraged to purchase a full sheet to make it easier for the decorator and I did. Paid $100 and was told might be more but I was ok as long as I got what I ordered. Picked it up and the design was very small and the majority of the cake was plain white icing! Very upset because this was a surprise and the center of our party. I could have done it myself and wanted to get another cake! The small design looked like it was missing something. Very very disappointed in this bakery. They had done well in the past but obviously did not listen to my order! read more

I went a couple months ago to get my wife some danishes after she had our first child to brighten her day a little. The selection they offered was very good. I got a couple of each and some donuts which were good also. They are a hidden gem in the side of a gas station, but definitely deserve the love. A must try for sure. read more

Their yeast and jelly filled donuts are delicious. They always have a full selection and they're fresh no matter what time of day. The staff is very personable and friendly. We love Long's and these are comparable and an even switch for us. read more

My wife and I have been sneaking over to this guilty-pleasure filled spot for a little while. I can't fathom why it has taken so long to review it! It's nothing to look at; it's a part of a strip mall connected to a gas station. However, the baked goods they're churning out inside are to die for. This is where I go when I want a sweet treat to bust my diet. They have doughnuts, cookies, danishes, cinnamon rolls, and other sweet treats. The doughnuts are huge, luscious, and decadently topped. My favorite is a cinnamon roll doughnut covered in caramel icing and chopped peanuts: yum! Everything I have ever had here has been decadently delicious. There usually is a line, always a good sign! Make your way over to the southside and check it out! read more

I love this bakery. Their cakes, cookies, donuts, alligators are all so delicious!!!!!!!

I happened along this place last year and return about every 4-6 weeks just to pick up chocolate eclairs and cream puffs. I live over half an hour away but it's well worth the drive. My daughter really enjoys their Cannonball cookies. I haven't had their donuts or cookies but their alligator pastries are quite good. If you don't see the eclairs or puffs in the case, it's because they're in the cooler by the door, just order and they will happily get them for you. read more

The worlds best honey bars! Trust me if you haven't tried them you are missing out! Cake donuts and a fresh strong cup of coffee make this little bakery one of our absolute favorites! read more

This by far my favorite bakery in Indy. I grew up going to the bakery with my mom, it was right around the corner from us. Now that I live further away I still make sure to find a way for this gem to be on my way to work. The blueberry cake donuts are my favorite! Make sure to get there early because your favorite may not be there, couldn't love this bakery more! The staff is always so friendly! read more

Would receive 5 stars for food but -2 for hygiene. I witnessed servers not wearing gloves and touching money and the walls just handling the food products bare handed and it made me walk out not a good practice. read more

I hope this place still exists. It's in a run down little strip mall and you might find it a bit depressing, but, if you go, try the molasses sugar cookies with jam in the middle. They are incredibly delicious. read more

Always friendly, always helpful. Great donuts. Outdated look, but who cares? I've come in multiple times in the middle of the day and they're always hoppin'. The food is what counts and its delish! I asked today and they've been there since the 1930s...awesome to find a gem like that in our fast paced world - who cares what the decor is! read more

Love this bakery. Found it by chance driving from Greenwood back to the City and was happily surprised. The outside did not look too great but the pastries were delicious. We ordered the cream puffs and they were huge, full of cream and yummy. It is out of the way for me but I will go back. The cream puffs were that good. read more

Tried cheese danish and a brownie. both are good, not overall sweet (the biggest problems of desserts here in the midwest). I wish it could be even less sweet, but it's good enough. The ladies have an interesting way of counting changes, cute. I like it and will go back. read more

Great bakery. When I get a donut craving this is where I go. Little local spot at Hanna and 31. Any U of I students and professors should really be getting these on a regular basis if they don't already. They have a good selection of both cake and yeast donuts, both of which are awesome. Their French Cruller is especially fantastic. I think they are cash only, but I'm not 100% on that. They also had some breads and cakes, so I'm sure if you're looking for something special they can help you out. read more

I recently changed my route of travel to work and now pass Boyden's Bakery. After noticing their sign and seeing the amount of traffic in the parking lot, I decided to stop to buy a dozen donuts to bring into work. Boyden's has charm only seen from family owned bakeries with long term roots. As other reviewers stated, it is on par with Long's Bakery as far as quality however it is a much smaller footprint. Smaller is not necessarily a disadvantage however almost every donut aficionado has heard of Long's. Outside of the old Indy Southside, Boyden's just doesn't have the name recognition. It is quite possible that after a few more trips this may become my "go to" place for a donut fix. read more

Love the smiley face cookies! Tasty!

Boyden's is a treasure trove of sugary goodness! This may be considered a crime, but I don't particularly care for doughnuts. However, Boyden's is my exception. Their simple glazed yeast doughnut is heavenly! It's fluffy and never greasy, only yeasty. They have tasty seasonal iced sugar cookies as well which are delightful aesthetically. I always pick-up a box before I go see my nieces and co. They also have a crazy cookie called the "Cannon Ball." One can obtain this delightful object with chocolate or white icing. Personally, I have never strayed from the chocolate icing. It's kind of like an 'everything but the kitchen sink' type of cookie with an oatmeal cookie/oatmeal cream pie flavor profile going for it. I know that might sound strange - but TRY IT! You won't regret it! read more

Excellent Danish, best in Indy! A little pricey but so delicious. The pineapple is the go to. Try this place you will be satisfied. Baby gators are awesome. A++++ read more

We just had the best cake we ever had. It was strawberry for our daughters birthday. Ordered one day. Picked up the next. Always have great service and have the best cake donuts. Will go there again. read more

I really wish I could give it 5 stars. I do! But alas, I cannot. :( I've had cake from here several times as my mother-in-law loves it and orders from there for birthdays, showers, etc. I've always liked it. So, when it came time to order a cake for my son's 1st birthday party, I decided to go with Boyden's. Stopped by on a Sunday morning after church about a month before I needed it to get my order for the two cakes (one for him to smash into) initiated. They were friendly enough and talked with me about what I had in mind but advised that the owner would be the one to discuss the finer details with me and tell me exactly how they could decorate it to go along with the party's Noah's Ark theme. So I left my contact info with them and waited on her to contact me. I also emailed her a picture of the invitation for the party to give an idea of the theme. I never heard from her, so I called them back. She wasn't available to speak with so I left a message indicating that I'd like to talk with her about the cake and I got a. Still never heard from her. I also sent a separate email to the girl I spoke with on the phone. Never had a response to that either. I eventually gave up and cancelled the order and procured my cakes elsewhere. Won't be returning here. :( read more

They used to have amazing Red velvet cake donuts that they are no longer selling for whatever reason.They are always friendly but for some reason always out of everything,Loved this place. read more

Agree with all the positive comments...great variety and quality of baked goods, vintage shop, and wonderful staff. The amazing thing is that no one has mentioned the BEST eclairs I have ever tasted. I have tried some other highly acclaimed bakeries throughout central Indiana and not a one can compare. One came close with the custard filling, but the combination of the pastry, filling, and chocolate icing are all 5-star quality. It is wonderful to see them still serving high-quality baked items, when so many small family-owned businesses have closed their doors. Definitely stop in for an éclair and an assortment of cookies, donuts, cakes, or whatever. It's all so good. read more

This is my doughnut place. Love the small family charm, and pastries are amazing! I love their yeast doughnuts! They are light and fluffy with a hint of cinnamon in the glaze. The glaze is thin and gives the right amount of sweetness to the dough without overpowering it like some places. Their noodles are great for making chicken & noodles or other comfort food type dishes. Great Amish style, so a nice sturdy noodle, without being so thick as what Reams or other supermarket brands are. Service has always been friendly! Been a customer and fan for 8 years now, and counting! The space next to them has rotated through many restaurants, I sometimes think it would make a nice place for them to expand and have a cafe.. read more

Delicious cake and very happy with their decorating abilities. Ordered a super bowl cake and there was not a piece or even a sliver of icing left. Was a huge hit at the party. Thank you Boyden's!! You are officially my go to for all future events!!! read more

Good for a treat but very overpriced. Never seen cookies for over $1 at a small bakery before. Brownies are 1.29. Good but not that good. I won't come back, it added up fast. Long's has cheaper and better donuts, and the Mexican bakeries nearby have good pastries for very cheap read more

I am a long time customer and should have written a review before now. I absolutely love the butter cream cinnamon coffee cake. It is amazing every single time. Just the right amount of sweetness and cinnamon with wonderful flakiness of the pastry. I have ordered cakes and also had the donuts but the coffee cake brings me back time and time again. read more

I visited the bakery for the first time in hopes of ordering a cake and asked if I could see a book of what they can do. They opened a book of pictures that were old, faded and looked like they were made 20+years ago. They offered for me to speak with the baker. When she came out I showed her a couple pictures I had on my phone of ideas. Before I could even swipe to the second picture she just kept repeating, "No. No. No." She said those were fondant and it would raise the price. I told her that would be fine. She then said, "No one will like it. No." At that point I left the bakery. I can accept the fact they can't or won't do what I want but to be so rude as to immediately yell, no, over and over at me when I'm simply asking was unprofessional. Needless to say my first visit will also be my last visit to Boydens. If I could give 0 stars I would have. read more

Visited again this morning and Boydens didn't disappoint! We LOVE the bismarks.. Long johns and today tried the yeast which were also awesome!!! BEST donuts in Indy hands down! read more

we just moved here from georgia and was lucky enough to find this place it truley is the best pastries we have ever had!!!! the eclairs are the best and the alligator coffee cake is the bomb i could set and eat the whole thing alone!! dont pass this place up it's well worth the drive!!! enjoy!!!!! read more

I have eaten a lot of Apple Fritters from a lot of different bakeries here in Indy,,,, and in other Midwestern cities,,these Folks sell the very best I have ever eaten,,,Longs holds the title on Yeast,,But No One can beat em on them Fritters read more

Always delighted with their goodies! The peanut butter cookies are a favorite along with their "CANNONBALLS"- a cookie you could survive on during a 3-day hike! Great local bakery. read more

My daughters formal wedding was yesterday, in the statehouse downtown was so beautiful until the cake arrived. The cake was so ugly the guest were shocked !!!! I cried for her, what an embarrassment..The cake I ordered and even provided a picture of was not the cake that was delivered ..The cake delivered looked as if a 10 year old made it. I paid $400.00 for this God awful thing ..IT"S A WEDDING !!! One of the most important part's of the celebration is the CAKE!!!! Shame on you !!!! This was a day that will one happen once.. . If that wasn't bad enough the cake leaned forwarded and almost fall to the floor we had to do the cake before we wanted to because we were afraid the whole cake was going to fall over. There were 150 guest ..None will ever use Boydens bakery for a wedding or Special event. What also gets me is 5 years ago Boyden's messed up my our other daughters wedding cake no one would eat the large bottom layer they put the wrong filling in the cake and it tasted nasty. But I thought okay mistake lets try again I like to give to small business..Now I know exactly why after so many years in business you have stayed as small as you are. You had a chance yesterday to gain more customers. A few of the guest at the wedding are with Indy event planning..They said, they will never use Boyden's they felt so sorry for my daughter. Bless her heart she didn't even want to stand by the cake let alone have a picture taken, She was a trooper and did the whole cut the cake thing fast so the caterer could cut the HIDEOUS thing up, so she didn't have to look at it ever again. read more