Always a good meal and experience at our local watering hole. Check out their daily specials and their small plates.

The steak meal was great. Will be back again. Potatoes were very good. Dessert creme brulee excellent. Our waitress Katie G. Was very friendly and informative of all details on menu. She was very attentive to our needs. Excellent waitress. read more

Our server, Eli, was wonderful and made our experience even better! We really enjoyed the lively weekday dinner rush atmosphere. We weren't quite sure about the calamari--the breading wasn't our personal preference--but it was still good. Our main courses were fantastic, and the soup special was absolutely delicious. We'll definitely be back! read more

See all

My wife and I enjoyed lunch here on Wednesday. Once again, the restaurant experience was great. The food, the service and the atmosphere were all very good. My wife had the pepper salad, which is one of her favorites here. I enjoyed the French dip with au jus, and a cup of coleslaw. The French Dip was stacked with nice slices of roasted beef. Delicious! read more

See all

Didn't eat here but sat at the bar for a drink. The bar is super cool. TVs on the wall to watch the game. The bartender served us quickly and was friendly. read more

We had a large party and we were quickly accommodated with no fuss. The menu had so many great options that it was hard to choose a favorite. The food was promptly served and everyone was satisfied. This was a good place for our family. I didn't order from the bar, but the drinks looked good! read more

This restaurant is a must go-to on Thursdays. $10 pasta dinners, with a side salad. Thank me later after you tell me it was totally worth it. Atmosphere is super cozy an level the upper level booths. Awesome staff thats very energetic. I put blue wolf on my calander every week. read more

We came here after watching the One Lap of America event at nearby Quaker City Motorsports Park and very much enjoyed it! Everything we had was terrific and the portion sizes made for leftovers for us! We will be back! read more

The food was good as well as the service. The restaurant was very quiet and very clean. I recommend it to anyone. Also in the past I have ordered food to go and it was as good as eating in the restaurant. read more

Excellent good tonight!!! Very nice ambiance! Very nice wait staff. A great experience tonight!

Truth in Advertising Ordered Tuesday special half rack of ribs. Never have seen a 4 bone half rack before. Maybe a third.. Charge me more and give me half the half or change advertising to third of rack Food was great. Fries, coleslaw and the few ribs I had Ken read more

Food excellent, good service, ambience okay. Everyone friendly including patrons. We are a couple of color. We felt very welcomed by everyone. We will be returning. read more

The Blue Wolf has an amazing selection of appetizers and entrees. Beef, Pork, even seafood! I had some grilled and sautéed scallops decorated with creamy mashed potatoes. Our service was attentive and polite! They had a full out last evening but managed to service the entire restaurant without issue. Favorite part of dining was getting to sit next to a statue of the Blue Wolf... a truely majestic beast! read more

Presentation of food poor. Taste of food horrible. Calamari awful. Seafood couldn't eat it. Tasted like two day old fish. Caesar salad was terrible way too much mustard no anchovies too much dressing. No one was at the restaurant and I can see why. read more

Came here after a recent weekend round of golf in the area...we sat at the horseshoe bar area to enjoy some sports on the telly and a shared meal. Was not super-hungry, so I ordered the tavern sampler appetizer platter. It was decent in size and quality...crispy onion rings, boneless chicken wings with a mild buffalo sauce (your choice) and Thai chili rubbed ribs that were boiled then flash fried. Not usually a fan of boiled ribs, but this preparation method worked reasonably well. Service was great and the space was set-up nicely, although it lacked social distancing. read more

Blue Wolf Tavern - Tavern appetizer sampler platter - Italian Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

Wife loved the blackened salmon. Not pink inside, but it was hot, so good for her palate. But check out my prime rib. Big fat nope. Ordered it rare. Said "spit cooked? It will be rare" assured it would be. But the prep cook who cut it off the grainy textured pre cooked log of prime rib could not have given me a more medium well done cut. Giving a 3 because staff is nice, but so disappointed. An eighth grader can cook prime rib. And browned? Check the picture. Just so sad...(I should have read my previous prime rib review, they obviously didn't) is funny tho, this time I'll remember NOT to come back. They took the meal off my check. BFD. I wanted a nice dinner! read more

Blue Wolf Tavern - The prime rib. Total ****. Tough, cooked like a steak, not sliced off of a roast. terrible cut cooked horribly. And I LIKE this place. - Italian Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

See all

Food was great. Nice selection. Atmosphere was nice too. My only complaint was that I paid in cash and they still charged me the 3.5% Credit Card Surcharge. Most places take that charge off when you pay in cash. read more

My daughter raves about the Spinach Artichoke dip. They have a Very Amazing menu and the staff makes it a wonderful dining experience. I have visited this Restaurant for over 20 years never a complaint. read more

Food is still good but the restaurant is now charging an egg inflation fee of $2 for ordering chicken francaise which is ridiculous. They also started charging $1 per roll if you want more than the 1 per person they bring to the table to start read more

The wings were great. The service was quick and the staff was very accommodating. I got the food to go but the Mexican corn was really great

This used to be the place to go!!!! I even had them cater my wedding!!!!! ( not cheap ) but I wanted what I loved. My wedding food was fab!!!. But in the past year and a half. Food is crap.!!! All our fam snd fam from out of town we always ate there. First choice!!! Now the carbonaro had no peas. Is watery. No taste. The fish is soggy. I'm so disappointed this was my fav place read more

Recently there Saturday night 3/29/24 with friends. Usually visit 3/4 times a year for special occasions but starting last year things have gone down hill and Saturday was the worst !! My turn to pick the the location and I picked Blue Wolf .Big Mistake !!!!!! Beer $8 House Wine $8 Out of fish special ok Prime rib 2nd choice WRONG ,Terrible !! Ordered med well and was still bleeding !! Our guest upset because food was cold and out of sides they ordered . My husband ordered a power bowl was supposed to have rice NOPE .What the hell happened to this one time great restaurant?? Don't expect owner to respond they apparently don't care read more

Great appetizers! Emily was a fantastic server. We ordered the seasonal bruschetta and goat cheese salad. Great service and the Bellagio martini was delicious! read more

I really wanted to like this place. I wanted to eat the food here. I liked the options on the menu. I liked the variety. Every place I plan to go to I check out online ahead of time. People seem to like this place based on reviews. I'm a foodie. I was excited. Backstory. I was here once four years ago. The poor service and timing miffed my husband enough that we didn't come back. He's a bit of a diva about good service. It wasn't a great dining experience the first time. Long wait, poor timing, empty drinks, meh. I was willing to give it a second shot but he never wanted to. Well, today we had a day date planned and he surprised me by pulling up to BWT. He was willing to try again for me! We walk in, and it's a busy lunch at around 1pm. Tables abound and the people in front of us are being told that all that's available are high tops in the bar. Must have been short staffed, sure I get that. About 3-4 mins go by and we haven't been greeted yet. We've been told by the hostess that she'll be back. She comes back and answers the phone. Ok ok ok. All that's available are high tops. That's fine. Sitting down at our table, we read the menu for a while. This takes about five minutes or so. We decide on our choices and start to look up, around, and chat. The server for the area makes her way around, walks by a few times, and a few times more. No one has greeted us. We wait. Another five minutes go by. Nobody says a thing. I get if you're busy, I get if you need to catch up, but you walk by my table five times while this happens. Say hello, say I'll be right with you, anything. Well here we are having the same experience again. We didn't have lunch, unfortunately. We left before anyone came. Sad. read more

We had to send our black and blue Burger back three times. Our waiter was the worst. We finally left because they couldn't get my friend's burger right. I was done eating by the time they brought hers out the third time and it was still raw. The deal was to buy a burger with the purchase of a drink and your burger was half off. They took her Burger off but still made her pay for her drinks which we usually drink water when we go out. They ruined our whole lunch experience because they couldn't get it right and I had to eat my meal and now my friend is still hungry. Booo! Raw! Bad experience! read more

Mediocre food. Below average service. It's frustrating that you have to wait to be seated. Sitting at the bar is alright, but the dining room is like being at Cheesecake Factory. Crowded and noisy. I go there because my son and daughter in-law like the wings. If not for that I wouldn't eat there. read more

Don't judge a book by it's cover or name. By the looks and sound we thought it was more of a bar atmosphere. We were pleasantly surprised with lovely family restaurant. The menu was quite extensive from seafood, pasta and steaks. We had the spicy stuffed peppers and shrimp special appetizer, both delicious. My husband ordered the Thai salmon and I had the lobster ravioli that served with cajun alfredo and portobello cap. It was very popular on a Saturday evening both in restaurant and bar area. I just wish our server told or offered us dessert option since I didn't see that on menu. read more

Love love love their wing night. Came with some family and the kids and we each got almost every flavor wing for a good price! Will be coming back. read more

Avoid this place! With all the good spots to choose from in Boardman I'm sorry we went here! They did a bait and switch on us with the menu items we went for. They didn't list the fine print on the website so what we went in for that was listed on the web, was not available in house! I figured we would try it anyway. I ordered the fish and the piece I got was about half the size you would expect for $15! The fries were soggy like they were made earlier and then microwaved when I ordered them! We don't go to Boardman that often but I can assure you we will never go back to this place! read more

Forget their filets I have eaten three times there forget it. Not impressed at all. I will go for the wings only. Never reimbursed my money for the awful filet I got either. read more

Make a reservation but it is totally worth it! The staff is amazing! The food is fresh, tasty & so many choices! It will take extra time to decide. Ladies lunch on Saturday was fun! Sunday 2:00pm anniversary celebration meant so much! Our waiter was so helpful & patient with an honoree needing extra help. 8 different meals ordered and not a single problem! A very special place to celebrate or have a casual lunch! read more

The receptionist hostess was friendly. The waitress was friendly. The food came quickly. One meal was under done, but those kinds of things happen. It's not the end of the world. The rest of the meal was good. The manager came by took it off my bill I would recommend going there and even try and order the same product. read more

The appetizers were served without any plates. It took more than 10 minutes to get plates, because the waitress did not come back until bringing another appetizer, and we had to requested plates. (If the second appetizer hadn't been ordered, we wondered if we would have ever gotten plates.) All of the meals did not come at the same time, my husband sat for 5-10 minutes waiting for his food, which was one of the specials. We thought they had forgotten his meal. When it did come, It came on a smaller plate than everyone else's and was very disappointing. Several people finished their drinks and water, but the waitress never returned to check for refills. She did not return after our entrees were served until she brought the checks after we were done eating. There were many empty tables in the dining room, so it was not busy. There are billing issues also. It seems that six people is considered a "Large Party", so they automatically add a 20% gratuity to the bill, so the waitress was guaranteed larger gratuity for doing as little as possible, and it was exactly what happened. There is also an automatic 3% fee on the bill for a credit card service fee, and it it not removed when you pay cash. They also do not bring back exact change for your bill. You get a "rounded" amount as your change. Overall, I could not recommend this place to others, and I would not return. read more

This place has good food. I got the Blackened Chickened Cajun Alfredo. It's was really good. Also tried their Yankee cocktail and that was super good. This place turns into a club basically after dinner. So if you're into dancing and music, it's pretty fun. read more

We have been going to Blue Wolf Tavern since we moved from Texas, about a year ago. we found this place on accident, because we went to another near-by restaurant who's staff didn't know what gluten-free meant; so we tried BWT. I am so glad we did, the staff and the food are fantastic. A couple of things to keep in mind: 1. Make a reservation ALL the TIME, they get very busy; which is good. 2. They do charge 3.5% if you pay by credit or debit card (which a lot of places are doing these days), but if you pay by Cash or Gift Card and tell the server before your check arrives, they will remove it--no problem. 3. Always check their website (thebluewolftavern.com) before you dine, they put a specials menu on the site daily for lunch and dinner. They will give you a copy at the restaurant upon arrival as well, but I always like to see what they offer that day before we get there. Lunch specials are posted around 10:00am with Dinner specials posted around 3:00pm daily, give or take a little bit. 4. Prices are very reasonable for the quality of food, amount you receive, speed of service and staff friendliness. These are my thoughts, we love to dine out and this place is at the top of my list. I hope you enjoy dining at BWT as much as we do!!! Bill read more

This restaurant is amazing! I've never had a bad experience in the 10 plus years I've eaten here. The food is fresh. Salads are cold & entrees are ho as they should be. The service is good & the menu has a nice selection to choose from. In fact, it's my favorite restaurant in the area! And having personally inspected every inch of the place as a pest control specialist, I can honestly say that Blue Wolf's kitchen alone is so clean that I would consider eating off of the floor - but only if I had to! LOL. The entire establishment was extremely clean and I couldn't find a single gnat which is common in most places. The prices went up a bit but I know their food & quality is well worth the price. read more

I've been to the Blue Wolf a lot before I got sick with the Long-covid and always enjoyed the great food and atmosphere. Thursdays were, by there own advertising, half price pasta days. So we split the meal last night as neither of us was that hungry. AFTER we ate and went to pay the bill we were told the half price doesn't apply if you split the meal! I won't be back!! read more

Unsatisfactory food: Ordered Christmas Chicken special ($23), the meal wasn't delivered with the other meals, more than a few minutes late, as if forgotten. Dreadfully plated on a cold saucer making the meal cold. Saucer was too small to cut the chicken breast, without making a mess of the table. Poor plating choices and flavorless chicken made the meal unsatisfactory. Below average service: Appetizers served without appetizer plates. We didn't see the waitress after the main course meal was served. Table head count of 6 is considered a Large Party/Auto Gratuity 20%, so the waitress was guaranteed a positive service gratuity for minimal effort, and it showed. Finally the credit card service fee of 3% is still being applied (12/16/2023). Would not positively suggest Blue Wolf in the future. read more

Absolutely phenomenal food and superb service. Don't listen to the bad reviews. A place can't be judged immediately post Covid. One of the best restaurants in Youngstown/Boardman, I promise you that! Five stars for this area, hands down. read more

was coming here often after a bike ride at Mill Creek Park. Menu is above average in terms of choices, and enjoyed several different items this summer. However - had one of those GOTCHA experiences this time. Seems ownership has decided you must pay a 3.5% surcharge on everything if you pay with a credit card ???!!!! Really ??? Not disclosed. Not right. Will never return here. Not so much the $ amount - but the audacity to just throw that on. Hoping people wont notice. A very bad business decision. read more