Wow what a disappointment! We have always loved Blue Collar in the past, it had been a while since we last went and we were so excited to come back. Since our last trip they have moved across the street to a larger location (they were always packed with sometimes quite a wait-and for good reason-the food was outstanding). This new venue just isn't it. The vibe is completely different, it no longer has the homey comforting atmosphere, in fact you'd probably never know it was blue collar if you didn't see the menu. While I miss the old cozy place, it's definitely not a deal breaker for me so long as the food is good
Service-NOT GOOD. Our waiter was very nice, but 75% of the time he was either nowhere in sight when we needed him or he was talking in a corner with other staff. We had to call him over to put in our order, he never checked on us after getting our entrees, didn't get refills of drinks until after we finished our entrees and the table wasn't bussed. Plates from the apps were left on the table when the entrees came and entree plates left when the dessert arrived (which was delivered by a different waiter). The manager was walking by so I had to ask him to clear the entree plates and let me say-he was not the friendliest person. No warm smile, no apology for this. Several times the waiters were all congregating together while diners sat there looking confused and annoyed. I went inside to use the restroom, unsure of which hall to turn down, I tried to get the attention of a group of waiters huddled together laughing about something and none of them either heard or noticed me asking where the restroom was.
I found the restroom myself and immediately was put off by the dingy floors, dirty mirror and a sticky bathroom door I had to literally shove to get it to open.
Food-very mediocre and small portions. We ordered the latkes for an app. They were fine, a bit greasy (yes I know latkes are oily) and really bland.
My father in law (it was his birthday we were celebrating) got the oxtail. This was the toughest oxtails I've ever seen and so small. My FIL would've told the waiter and had them take it back, but our waiter never came back until he asked if we wanted dessert. My FIL was hungry (and at this point if we finally found the waiter we all would've been finished by the time he got a new order) so he gnawed what he could and ate the mashed potatoes
Snapper was fine, not great and not bad. Salmon with tomato salad and asparagus were fine, but the sides were very small. Jambalaya was weird and NOT good. The rice was cooked separately (I've never had jambalaya that the rice and proteins were separated) , and in this case it was undercooked basmati rice. The "sauce" was chicken and shrimp in a tasteless brown sauce poured over.
So far very very underwhelming, but we had high hopes about dessert. We've always loved their desserts in the past, but again what a let down. The chocolate cake tasted like it came out of a box mix and topped with Duncan Hines frosting. The heath bar bread pudding didn't have a hint of heath bar and it was so dense, super gummy and dry. You know the dessert is bad when even my toddler didn't eat either one. We used to come just for the amazing side dishes alone and even the sides were small and disappointing. Bland and unappealing.
Price-we had one Diet Coke, one beer, two waters
One appetizer, 4 entrees, an $8 side and one dessert (one was comp'd for my FIL's birthday) came out to $204
This was definitely not worth it and such a bummer. I can understand now why on a Saturday night it was hardly full. read more