Black Sheep Bagels

Great sandwiches for beach days. Lovely staff who makes amazing sweet treats. Old school seaside…read moredeli makes for a cool local vibe. Love this place.

21.75$ for a small coffee and eggs turkey on a hero. Next to no turkey on it either. the most I've…read moreever paid for this same egg sandwich. Avoid this place wasn't even good.

Inside

Sandwich menu

See all

Bacon, egg and cheese on a poppy bagel

Goldbergs Famous Bagels

3.4(71 reviews)

3.7 mi

Does everyone know that besides being the best bagel shop on the North Fork, GOLDBERGS actively…read moresupports the local community? YES THEY DO! GOLDBERGS continues to support the Southold Historical Museum each year for their annual "History In the Making" pickleball tournament, which takes place next Saturday, May 30. 2026, at Tasker Park in Peconic. There are still some spots left! So next weekend, as you're rushing out the door for the 9 am tournament start time, know that GOLDBERGS will have free bagels waiting for you!!! Thank you GOLDBERGS for the great food and generous support. You are invaluable to this community.

Food was good but expensive and some of the staff members were kind of rude. The menu could have…read morealso been more clear with regards to when breakfast food sales start / end.

Goldberg bagel with the lightest amount of Lox Spread. Some of the bagel doesn't have any spread!

Eggs with spinach and cheddar on a whole wheat sunflower seed flagel

See all

Goldberg bagel with lox spread ... no really there is lox spread --- enlarge the picture!!!!!

Signature Bagels Deli & Catering

3.5(99 reviews)

4.2 mi

Great food and good people working there. Prices are reasonable, you get alot of food for your…read moremoney. Tremendous menu there is something for everyone.

I order the meatless panini but what I got was not a panini - it had all the ingredients described…read morebut it was not fried/pressed as one would expect a panini to be. I ordered online so I didn't see them make the food so I didn't realize the issue until I returned where I was staying to eat the food. My wife had a reuben which she enjoyed and the sides we got were both very good. The non-panini was tasty as well but not what I was expecting.

More menus

Whole Wheat Everything Bagel with olive cream

See all

Menu Selection October 2025

Black Sheep Bagles - Cutchogue

3.9(26 reviews)

7.4 mi

As someone who has been gluten free for 6 years - this is the best gluten free bagel I have ever…read morehad. So fluffy and moist - I would have been nervous it wasn't gluten free had I ordered this without 2 of my friends getting gluten full bagels & seeing what theirs looked like - THATS how good it was

Great little coffee, bagel, and lunch spot in North Fork-specifically, Cutchogue…read more My friends are North Fork residences and hosted us for a long and lovely weekend; Black Sheep is their prefered bagel spot in the area, so we ordered breakfast pickup for five of us. The order included a handful of the *must-try* breakfast bagels, tofu bagel, and a gluten-free bagel for moi. Topped it off with OJ and iced coffee.

Bagels

Table by the window

See all

Inside

Bagel Lovers

3.8(31 reviews)

4.8 mi

I love this place. The people were great! Bagles are really nice. I love this place!!read more

Great little breakfast spot. Friendly service and a comfortable atmosphere. Menu has all the…read moreclassics. Bagel sandwiches are excellent. Fair prices as well.

Rib Hero

See all

Goldbergs Famous Bagels

2.7(71 reviews)

4.3 mi

I discovered Goldberg's while serving jury duty, and I'm so glad I did! I ordered the Greek Chicken…read moreWrap, and it was absolutely delicious. The chicken was flavorful and tender, the veggies were fresh, and the creamy sauce tied everything together perfectly. It's a great portion, super satisfying, and wrapped up just right for a quick but tasty lunch. It comes with chips and pickles. The staff were friendly, and the service was quick. I'll definitely be coming back even after jury duty is over.

Visited NY and had high hopes for bagel places. This place fell flat. They ran out of many bagels…read moreearly, which is a surprise for a breakfast place.

See all

Love Lane Kitchen

4.1(715 reviews)

4.1 mi

Locally owned & operated

Casual dining

We were searching for a lobster roll and this spot popped up on our radar while we were out east…read more What a great experience through and through! First of all it's a cute interior setting with a decent amount of seating. We came today, on a Sunday around 2 pm and were put on the waitlist with an estimated 25 minute wait time but we ended up being seated earlier. Our server Ryan was amazing- he was very attentive throughout the visit. He was very informative when it came to the menu and any of our questions and seemed very passionate as he spoke about this restaurant and its food. What we had: - Lobster Roll: what a WINNER. I looooove lobster rolls, hot and cold, and the best one I had to date was in Boston MA (which is a given). I had not found a solid lobster roll yet on Long Island and this place definitely took the cake!!! First of all it was PACKED with lobster (like I couldn't even close the roll) and the lobster salad mix was so delicious and fresh (mixed with celery and the lobster itself was so tender) The bun was nice and toasted too. It was just so SOLID. Whenever I think about lobster rolls here on LI- this place will literally be the only place I think about. So happy to know we have such a solid spot here on LI!! - Fish and Chips: my brother enjoyed this! The fish was nice and crispy although needed more salt. It was paired beautifully with garlic fries which helps with carrying through the flavors. BEST LOBSTER ROLL and great service! 10/10 recommend!!

We visited this past Sunday and our experience was lackluster at best…read more We were a party of 7 and we were seated in the porch area which was dark and gloomy. If the food was good then it wouldn't have been so bad. Dogs were in there with their owners so I guess it's good to know if you'd want to sit there with your dogs. But the food wasn't good. The service wasn't good either. Many things were missing from the order and when we asked for them they came out late. Coffee is self serve. The inside of the restaurant is very cute. We used the bathroom before leaving and there's only 1 bathroom with 1 stall. The toilet paper was empty so I had to refill it myself. There were no paper towels either. I don't know. It just altogether wasn't worth it.

Inside of the restaurant

Blackened chicken sandwich

See all

CJ's American Grill

4.3(164 reviews)

3.8 mi

What a great place. Food was excellent and came out fast. We had 5 kids with us and the server was…read moreso kind to them, gave them crayons to use and ring pops (at the end of the meal). Wonderful service and yummy food. We had the French dip, lobster roll, kids had pasta and chicken fingers/fries. All delicious. Will definitely be back!

The service is always fabulous, the atmosphere is like a small home town "cheers" type of vibe …read more This evening they had a special that was wild caught Chilean Seabass with capers, mashed potatoes and seasonal vegetables. It was outstanding!! Kudos to the Chef. Hubby ordered one of my usual favorites, which is the filet mignon with a peppercorn sauce. It is always beautifully prepared. I have to say we enjoyed our meal this evening. We will be back soon. Thank you.

Birthday dessert board filled with scrumptious after dinner treats!

Stuffed flounder with crab meat stuffing , mashed potatoes and asparagus

See all

Prime rib with mashed potatoes and asparagus

The Meetinghouse Deli

3.6(11 reviews)

1.7 mi

Today I got my throwback lunch, pastrami & swiss with mustard on a roll. A side salad & pickle are…read moreincluded. A Large iced tea & a bag of Jax completed my order. One of the few good delis left on the the north fork. They haven't changed much since I was a teenager & that's a good thing so for all you weekend warriors & pumpkin pickers give this place a look if you are in the mood for a sandwich, enjoy!

North fork native. Don't treat me like a tourist. I called. You took my order. It wasn't there when…read moreI arrived, and couldn't be found by anyone. Didn't bother to fix the situation. No one bothered to fix the fact that they lost my order. I checked the number in my call history. It was your shithole deli. Place is in need of a complete attitude adjustment. You're just as bad as North Fork Bagel in Southold. If you hate your jobs that much, quit.

The Meetinghouse Deli - Delicious chicken salad on a fresh Kaiser roll and yes old school deli they give you a pickle on the side what a great sandwich

Delicious chicken salad on a fresh Kaiser roll and yes old school deli they give you a pickle on the side what a great sandwich

Chicken cutlet with honey mustard and melted cheese. Amazing

See all

Pastrami

Cafe and Juice Bar

5.0(1 review)

3.5 mi

Delicious, fresh, organic, and local meals made right in a small kitchen on a farm. The cafe juice…read morebar is located inside the garden of Eve organic marketplace. I was looking at the menu and knew right away that I was in for a treat! I ordered the grass fed Kobe burger with a salad for my niece and grilled cheese on brioche for the second one. The chef was very accompanying to meeting the needs of my niece being allergic to many ingredients and condiments. They accidentally gave me one with mayo which she could not eat once we noticed it and I brought it back. He immediately apologized and cooked up another one. Great customer service and so polite! He then offered the burger that had the mayo on the house since he made a mistake which I graciously appreciated. The grilled cheese on the brioche was creamy, buttery and with just the right amount of crunch! I must say the salad was unbelievable! It must've grown right in their back yard which they drizzled a bit of olive oil and sunflower seeds with shredded carrots. The prices are worth it for the quality of amazing local organic food. Trust me your body will be thanking you!!!

The front

Homemade potatoes

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Mary L.

2 years ago

First I want to say the ladies at the counter are always very nice and the bagels are great. You can eat-in if you'd like. The place is clean and the decor fits in with the North Fork. My only complaint is they need to put more cream cheese on the bagel. I have never had a bagel from any other bagel shop where they literally put a light smear of cream cheese on the bagel. Other shops put an exceptional amount of cream cheese on the bagel to the point where you bite into it and the cream cheese oozes out the sides. I never had this problem. If customers want a smear they know they have to aak for that because the usual is a full cream cheese bagel. I have never had to ask for extra cream cheese until now. The first time I got a bagel here I thought ok this was probably done in a rush. The second time the same thing! A smear that didn't even cover the entire bagel and was only on one half of the bagel. The third time I asked for extra cream cheese and I got it, perfect bagel. Now I know to ask. The next time my husband went to get breakfast and I told him you have to ask for extra cream cheese for my bagel. He does not eat cream cheese or bagels. Did I get the extra cream cheese? NO! I DID NOT! I am so frustrated because I love their bagels and cream cheese and don't want to have to beg for extra cream cheese especially for what it cost. I know everything is expensive now but $8+ for a simple plain bagel and drink seems a bit much but I don't mind paying for something if it's worth it. Please have a staff meeting and give the customers what they want. Thank you! read more

John R.

8 years ago

Always a great choice when you're craving a good bagel! They are always busy on the weekends, so a line will form out the door, but just gets you to want to order even more! We make this a regular weekend starter and the kids enjoy going and checking out all of the selections. They are always friendly to the kids, even during their rush, which makes you really appreciate an establishment that connects with their customers. read more

K C.

8 years ago

We love Goldberg's. Bagels are top notch. Would love a true rye bagel though. Highly recommend.

Monique L.

3 years ago

Too expensive ! its just an ok bagel

Black Sheep Bagels - bagels - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Jamesport, New York Restaurants near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Coffee near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Breakfast near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Parking near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Desserts near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Cocktail Bars near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Pizza near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Things to Do near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Shopping near Black Sheep Bagels

BEST of Jamesport, New York Thrift Stores near Black Sheep Bagels

Best of Jamesport

Things to do in Jamesport

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Black Sheep Bagels also viewed

Goldberg's Famous Bagels

3.6

(128 reviews)

Good selection of bagels. Got the "Hobo" breakfast sandwich on Egg Bagel. Fantastic…read more Would definitely recommend / return Nice prompt service even on a busy morning. 5/5

Moments after I placed my order, I noticed the flat bagel sandwiches and started second-guessing my…read morechoice. When I heard another customer order one, that sealed it--I decided to change mine. I asked the woman who took my order if I could switch; she hesitated, likely because my bagel was already toasted, but then quickly agreed and handled it. It felt a bit awkward for a moment, but customer-service-wise it was the right move. This is a legendary bagel shop and worth a stop if you're nearby. The bacon, egg, and cheese I ordered was a bit dry--being toasted without a smear made it come off a little crusty. Next time I'd definitely get a smear, or maybe not have it toasted at all. The highlight, surprisingly, was the heavy-duty sweatshirt I bought as a souvenir--honestly felt even heavier than Carhartt. Tip: Go for the flat bagel version and don't skip the smear.

Goldberg's Famous Bagels

3.9

(8 reviews)

Wow, lots of choices! Quite a place. Can only imagine the crowds in season. Not much activity this…read moremorning. Very good bagel sandwich but not the best I've had. Good spot along the highway. Lots of parking and inside/outside dining.

My husband's breakfast sandwich was cold, so we had to ask them to reheat it. Since it was a…read moremorning rush, we told them to just stick it in the microwave to not cause trouble. But why would a breakfast sandwich be cold anyways? Like you can see the cold cheese unmelted in it. My husband surmised that since it was a holiday weekend and they expected crowds they precooked everything (precooked egg, precooked sausage) and threw it together. Then to top it all off, we found a piece of plastic in his sandwich. Easy enough to pick it out, so it was fine, but again - why? 3 stars because mine was good. Would give them another try on a non-holiday weekend. They might have just been busy.

Country Corner Cafe

4.1

(96 reviews)

My family and I always going to the Country Corner Cafe whenever we travel out east. The food is…read morealways amazing and our favorite thing to get/take home is the Macaroni and Cheese! The cafe looks like it was once someone's home and I have often wondered if it was due to its cozy atmosphere. Every time we've eaten there the service has been attentive, they can't help or feed you enough. We will be returning soon!

Country Corner Cafe is a neighborhood spot filled with all the locals. We dined there for an early…read moreSunday dinner before leaving town, and it was nice to see their staff so acquainted with the patrons. Pancakes, omelettes, eggs bennie, burgers, soups and other cafe (or diner) classics round out their menu. And ice cream! Ice cream seems to be a big deal there; my beau even ordered a malt shake at 9am.

Beach Bakery

3.7

(230 reviews)

I would give this 3.5 stars if I could, because I love the charm of this place and do think there's…read morea lot they get right here. This place has been here for so many decades, it almost feels like stepping back in time with the big wooden booths and pastry counter. It's giving old school diner. When you walk in you'll notice the bakery portion of the store to your right, where you can order any freshly baked breads, pastries, cookies and the like. Straight back is where you go to place food and coffee orders. You place your order on a kiosk. Options include a variety of egg dishes, omelets and frittatas, as well as waffles, pancakes and avocado toast. There's a full coffee bar as well with iced coffees, lattes and other espresso drinks to choose from. We went with a bunch of iced coffees, a "build your own" omelet, breakfast burrito and mushroom omelet. Despite the crazy line here on a Saturday afternoon our food came out very quickly. Coffees took another 20 minutes or so until we were able to ask someone about it (we felt bad, they were so busy), and they handed them over to us. The food here was good and fresh, but also very no frills and portions are small. The prices here are so high though that when we were walking by Donahue's on our way out we realized we could've had a fancy brunch there for just about the same price as we paid for a few small dishes.

I got the apple turnover and a hot chocolate on an early morning and it was so nice. The service…read morewas very delightful and quick. I savored every bite of apple crispness as it melted in my mouth. The powder in the outside of the turnover was a little messy but it made it a fun eating experience. The hot chocolate was perfect for an early June morning alongside my turnover, I loved it. With whipped cream it made my day. I loved this place I highly recommend, underrated spot!

Wildcat Bagel Deli

3.4

(16 reviews)

Came here for lunch with a colleague…read more My sandwich was huge and very filling. For just under $12 I had a huge sandwich and a bag of chips (or salad). Everything tasted fresh and it was clean inside. Employees were friendly too! I would definitely stop in again for either breakfast or lunch.

Everything bagel toasted veggie cream cheese and a medium coffee were on point: order was quick and…read morecorrect, staff was friendly, and everything tasted fine. Wasn't overly busy at 8 am on a weekday which was nice -- plus the place is very clean with ample seating. Lastly - the place appears to be a big supporter of the community, which I love. Great work.

Toasted Bagel

3.3

(27 reviews)

Ok, I see you Toasted Bagel…read more I had to stop at the Staples here and was starving, so I popped in. The staff member behind the counter who helped me was super sweet. She got a kick out of how funny I found the Labubu chocolate. Also, they have Dubai chocolate in their fridge. To me that means they know what's up. On to the bagel and ice tea. The deli ice tea is like what I had in high school. The everything flagged wasn't as flat as I've had, but I ain't mad about it. The cream cheese was on point. The place was clean, and they had a nice offering of paninis and sandwiches with Boar's Head. I would come back here again for sure to try some of their other stuff.

The bagels fresh I ordered everything with butter and jelly. I kind of spaced out on which jelly so…read moreI was just hoping I'd get great, but I don't mind strawberry. But what I paid for and what I asked for and what I got are three different things. Jelly is not that expensive that it should be almost nonexistent on my bagel. My bagel also was supposed to be toasted. The name of the place is the toasted bagel. Bummer. I wish I would've looked before. I left the restaurant and took it home. Now 1 miles away and it's not worth going back.

Main Road Biscuit

4.0

(360 reviews)

Everything I have ever eaten is delicious, homemade and fresh. I love Main Street Biscuit. Even the…read moreambiance is relaxed and cute.

Came here for Sunday breakfast. Gave 2 stars because the food was good but service affects how you…read moreenjoy a meal and leaves you wondering if you'd like to come back. Everyone who works there is dry and unfriendly. Our server took our order, served us food and we never saw her again. It was not insanely busy to excuse the fact that she never came back to see how we were doing. I had to go to the counter to ask for our bill and was looked at like I had two heads. At this point we were annoyed and disappointed because the food was good! We won't be coming back though, we'd rather spend our money where servers will at least smile at you , greet you nicely and not disappear. Very unfortunate, especially considering we were with our baby. Fyi* their patio seating is a sauna. They have mini fans blowing that provide a hot breeze.

Goldberg's

3.6

(169 reviews)

Goldberg great breakfast place, foods good and fast but the problem is it takes so long. There is…read morealways a line out the door, but overall it's fine. Good ambiance.

I like Goldberg's but the lines are unbearable. Call ahead always. The young man who works the…read morecashier at the East Hampton location is the best. Overall good food but not worth the wait if you don't call ahead.

Strathmore Bagels

3.0

(45 reviews)

This is how bagels and egg sandwiches are supposed to be done! There are some decent bagel places…read morein NC but they just can't compare to the meaty bagels on LI. I also have to get an egg sandwich when I visit where I grew up because they don't do it on a Kaiser roll anywhere else I've been. Why not? I don't have an answer for that.

All the employee's are very nice. The past couple times…read moreI've been my egg sandwich was cold.

Krieg's Bakery

4.2

(101 reviews)