The food is incredible, All the workers here are always happy to help you out! The vibe of the area is always calm even when's it's packed it's still nice and calm environment read more

Great little breakfast spot. Friendly service and a comfortable atmosphere. Menu has all the classics. Bagel sandwiches are excellent. Fair prices as well. read more

Bagles are great always fresh and always great service here wouldn't go anywhere else so glad they open here In riverhead read more

Bagels are good. BE @ C are very good. Service is also good. Place is clean and tidy. Will return soon.

Food tastes excellent! Service was great! Ambiance was great! We love eating here! Love meeting friends and family to enjoy breakfast! read more

Bagel Lovers - Rib Hero - Bagels Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

The food is delicious, the staff is friendly and the cost is acceptable. I have ordered breakfast and lunch from here on several occasions and have never been disappointed. read more

food is delicious! some places dont cook the bacon very well unless requested. however bacon here was fully cooked and didnt have to ask! service is excellent and place seems cozy too. nothing is better than fully cooked bacon with eggs sitting by the fireplace. i will be back. very nice place and staff read more

Walked in looked at the board started with the number one breakfast bagel. It was a winner! Turned out to be a great place for a rainy day. Breakfast would highly recommend this place. Food was great, service was with a local flare, and a locals atmosphere. read more

Great breakfast, I will definitely return here if I'm around this part of the island again. Service was great, they brought our food out to us all at the same time (7 of us workers). Very spacious in the place and it was pretty convenient where we sat because after I was done, I reached the garbage from my seat. Convenient and delicious. Conven-egg. Great baceggminyegg. Price was reasonable too. read more

Garbage. Woman with the tidy hair has ZERO personality. A lot of loud bizarre chatter from kitchen area. Boring atmosphere. Definitely NOT NY bagels. So many better places in town. Rude service...won't be back. read more

I've been to the Riverhead location a few times.. The first time, I ordered toasted a plain bagel with cream cheese and got maybe like half of an ounce of cream cheese spread on the entire bagel. This morning I ordered a toasted bagel with cream cheese. when i opened the bag after I left, the bagel was not toasted at all. I will not be spending my money at the Riverhead location anymore I gave 3 stars because the employees were friendly. read more

Ummmmmm NO!!!! I do have my go to bagel place but was on my was to my favorite coffee house and saw this cute place and wanted to give it a try. Looked at the reviews and decided to give it a go. Well........I walk in standee on line for 30 seconds when I get this stare behind the counter like I was bothering her. Mind you hard to hear over the glass counter I gave her my order and I thought she said say it again when I guess she said anything else???? Because when I gave my order a again she gave me this look like I was an idiot! Bagel was ok and cream cheese was good but seriously people WTF???? Reviews say customer service is great and beloved it for a split second. Maybe she was having a bad day and I get that but holy crap!!!! Never again. Sorry for all the ones who wrote great reviews on here but I had the total opposite experience! read more

I got a sundries tomato bagel and it was delicious! I wish I had gotten jr with cream cheese on the side, it was too much for my likings...but the cream cheese is good too! I saw they had potato salad, I love potatoes salad, so I got a small order...I wish I had gotten a larger order. So good! The the whole staff was super nice and friendly! read more

It's a great bagel place. I used to come here all the time when I was still in high school, and my memory of it being great was spot on. Spending about 5 bucks on a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich is relatively cheap, and it tastes really good as well. If you get one, make sure to ask about getting a free small coffee or juice. I missed coming here often, so I'll be sure to visit as much as I can. read more

The bagels are great here!!! I love their homemade flavored cream cheese especially the vegetable flavor one. The home fries are delicious. I'm obsessed with their whole wheat wrap with bacon egg and cheese. The pancakes with bacon is great too. Great place the only down side organization on taking the orders could be better. read more

Bagel Lovers - a bagel and grapes on a plate - Bagels Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Absolutely horrible. I waited over ten minutes for an order and had to ask if my order was ready. I asked them if they toasted the bagel and they said no, she did not write that. The woman was extremely rude and said we are busy, it's Sunday. I said I have had many jobs working on weekends and that was never the answer I gave nor with a horrible attitude. There was a man there who was very nice. The bagel was doughy and disgusting. Bad coffee. I asked for a refund it was that bad. Another place gone down hill from COVID and horrible staff. Cheap food and it shows. read more

This place is awesome...cute and homey (literally, it's an old home that they converted to a business). read more

Bagel Lovers - Free coffee while you wait!!!! - Bagels Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Best place for breakfast! People are great and so is the food! Seating is roomy and cozy at the same time! Miss the ole' fireplace, but gas fire will have to work. read more

I don't live in Riverhead anymore but I occasionally stop by for an egg sandwich when I'm out there because I enjoy their bagels. The only thing that really bothers me is I've been given the wrong change back twice! Once with a $50 bill where I received change for a $20 bill and today with a $20 bill I received change for a $10 bill. The first time I noticed right away but this second time I didn't realize until I was home which is about an hour away. Pretty frustrating because now it's my word against theirs if I really gave them that bill read more

I can't believe there are no reviews for this place. This place looks like a little whole in the wall and is not very inviting but they have the best bagels in town!! I have previously been a fan of bean & bagel but their bagels haven't been up to par recently and so was looking for a replacement. Anyway this place is closer and sooooo much better!!! I do wish they would offer more flagel choices though. read more

Good bagel place. Located close to the MVC. Says New York style. Being from NY I can say they were pretty good. Bagel sandwiches are Cali style. Cheddar cheese. Avacado. Etc. but a good place for breakfast!! read more

I was disgusted by the way they handle food, money and everything else in between- with the same gloves on. It doesn't matter if there is no law stating it's mandatory to change gloves if your employees touch money, management should make it mandatory in order to provide clean service for your customers. I was told by the employee as I complained about this that customers have to request for the gloves to be changed because money doesn't carry anything into the food LOL how sad is that. It may not transfer food borne illness but it sure does carry germs. I waited 10 minutes for the sandwiches and as I waited I watched as the employee handles money, stocked supplies, took gum from her mouth and threw it away, and scratched her nose all with the SAME gloves on as she causally helped another customer with bagels .. have some decent consideration for people's food if you are running a food business. Once again, DISGUSTING. Never going back. read more

Started going here for lunch as a junior in high school and it soon became one of the most popular spots for anyone in riverhead high great food great service a go to place in riverhead ! Your not a bona-fide junior or senior until you eat here read more

I tend to judge bagel places by what I call the Zip-Hoodie factor. If you see a place crammed with tradesmen, you know, the folks in jeans, boots and zip hoodies - construction, plumbing, electric, roofing, landscaping etc. - in to get their morning breakfast & coffee or their lunch, you know you have the real deal. Bagel Lovers is the real deal. They are insanely busy, so call ahead to avoid a wait. They cover all the basics; a nice selection of bagels, generous deli sandwiches and delicious breakfast. They even have healthy alternatives on the menu, and they don't suck. Cold weather means hearty soups. Yum. Now the good and the bad: Parking is hard to come by during rush. Not only is it scarce, you will occasionally get people driving against the flow to get out on Osborne. Tradesmen mean that sometimes you'll have to try to get around company trucks. Slow down and be aware. You'll have to be careful because you are in a school zone and students love to come here too. Students show up in waves during the lunch periods at the High School. If you come by and there are teenagers all over, you are going to have a wait. The only thing I would really change is to use the side window for pick up orders. It is a little tight and sometimes the pick up people get lost among those waiting in line. The staff at Bagel Lovers is superior. They are quick, friendly, and accommodating. The prices are reasonable and the food worth both the price and any wait you might have. read more

Good bagels-OK sandwiches. (Chicken cutlets are thick and rubbery) Very unfriendly staff and if they are busy you will wait on line, not acknowledged, for a while (as if you are inconveniencing them) Ladies behind the counter walk around very slow paced- call ahead. read more

I wouldn't call it a NY style bagel, it's more like Panera Bread style. They taste good and priced well but not my expectations of a NY Style Bagel. read more

Bagel Lovers provides awful customer service. Although the establishment is clean, and the food is decent, it all comes down to service. Grumpy, nasty old ladies work behind the counter, and it gives off a disgusting vibe. Not the place to go for a happy morning. Would never return. read more

Great bagels, traditional method, nice soft density and good overall texture. Seeding could be improved but overall a quality bagel with quality cream cheese and breakfast options. Parking is a little cramped but staff is friendly. Bagel Lovers gives Signature Bagels down the road a run for its money, although the latter still finishes first. read more