I ordered Loaded Fries and a Vanilla milkshake with peanut butter, while visiting from out of town. The delivery didn't include my milkshake, so I called the restaurant. After they confirmed my info, they PERSONALLY delivered the milkshake! The milkshake is so good and the loaded fries are amazing. I attached pics - sorry everything is half gone! I'm already making plans to go in person tomorrow! read more

Black Iron Burger - Half an order of Loaded Fries - soooo good - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Delicious food, fast and friendly service. Music is a bit loud so don't expect to be able to talk with your friends/family at this restaurant. Decent date spot if you don't mind speaking loudly. Overall my new favorite burger spot, love it here! read more

Black Iron Burger - Smokey Blue Bacon Crunch Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Iberian Ham burger- 4 stars The ham was falling out everywhere. But it was interesting and I've never had or heard of that type of burger before. Fries normally cooked with fish but not that day. Yay!! Service was 5 stars. It was a bar. read more

Great burgers. Nice place for an after show dinner. Came here cause we were craving a burger after a show. Super close to the theaters and time square. The location is long and narrow with a bar area and probably 15 tables. The place was pretty busy due to the world cup games but we managed to get a table for 4 after about a 15 min wait. On issue we had was that the TV coverage wasn't great. We sat at a table and only half of us could see a TV. Ordered burgers, shake, onion rings. The truffle mushroom burger hit the spot for me. Perfectly done meat with a nice taste from the truffle mayo. The bacon bits on the burger were probably overkill though. The onion rings were not soggy and paired well with the ranch. Others at the table enjoyed the basic black iron burger. The shakes were a bit disappointing. They were basically liquid with no thickness to their consistency. Overall, a good place for food before or after a show. If you want to go watch sports YMMV. read more

See all

We had a great experience here and Felix was excellent! We had alot of their wings which are fried to perfection and i love that their sauces are served on the side. Their classic burger with a sunny side up egg was my order and it was delicious ! Perfectly cooked and fresh toppings. Their house burgers was great as are the truffle fries and a must order is their house made onion rings! Great craft cocktails! Fun vibes with great music and too notch friendly service! read more

See all

The food was so amazing, I didn't even take pictures I got the masterpiece and it was cooked to perfection wow. I would go back just for a good burger. Our server was Maria and she was so sweet and helpful. Her recommendations were great. We also got the Peruvian wings and they were so yummy. Ambiance was good. Low music read more

Black Iron Burger - We devour the food - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

We stopped by for a quick bite before a Friday night Broadway show at 6pm. The restaurant was pretty packed with diners so we were seated all the way in the back. Waters came quickly and we were able to order the Black Iron and Mushroom Truffle Burgers. For the $17 price tag, we were expecting a much larger burger or for it to come with a small side. Unfortunately there wasn't such a combo and fries had to be ordered on the side for an extra $5.50-9.50 depending on the type. Thankfully the burgers came out quickly and we were able to enjoy them before our show. The mushroom truffle burger could have used more mushrooms but the burger was seasoned and cooked well. The black iron burger had two beef patties so it was a bit more substantial. The patties were also cooked well but was underwhelming Overall, we were satisfied with our bugers but there was something lacking with the burgers here. There are tons of other burger joints that can also serve a great burger with sides included for the price. read more

Black Iron Burger - Mushroom Truffle Burger (5 oz) - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Had delicious food here while visiting New York. The burger was very tasty and so were the sweet potato fries! The service was good.

Excellent burger and great prices at lunch time with the fries combo. Food quantity is good and probs worth more bang for buck than shake shack. Liked all of the sports and the support for NY sports! read more

Nice dinner, loved our burgers. Rings and fries were excellent. Chips and salsa appetizer was sad and came out after our burgers. Could have skipped those. Service was quick friendly and good. Auto charged us a "large party gratuity" even though we were just a table of four. Their auto gratuity of 18% is less than we normally tip, so her loss. But heads up to other small parties to check before tipping. read more

See all

Black Iron Burger on a weekday afternoon met the moment on many levels. Located not far from Columbus Circle, this burger joint is quite spacious and inviting. Upon arrival, I was greeted by a kind gentleman who welcomed me and seated me in my preferred area. My seating was quickly followed by another waiter/bartender who took my order and checked back frequently to ensure my satisfaction with the food and service. Seeing as I was passing through and did a quick Google search for the best and closest burger joints in my area, I didn't spend too much time laboring over the extensive options. I went with what I knew, which was a classic American burger, which didn't disappoint. That said, perhaps the best part of my meal was the loaded sweet potato fries; Epic! All in all, I would recommend the Black Iron Burger. My long-standing ritual is to have a burger only once a month, and Black Iron Burger is now one of my go-to options. read more

See all

The food is excellent and would rate a five for the burger and loaded fries. The service from Kimberly was not very good. One item we ordered we did not get, one item a shake came very late in our meal and we had to ask where it was. The initial drink service was slow, one drink came out fast the others were way behind. The burgers were excellent, we had build your own and the caramelized onions are very good and the taste of the beef hamburger was worth the price. The loaded fries were very good and served hot. The inside is a sports bar atmosphere with many tv's. Top shelf burgers in a very casual setting. read more

See all

Quick but poor service - maybe since we were seated in the back? Bathrooms were very subpar and unclean with heavy smells. For a best burger and zagat rated joint - was very disappointing. Maybe since we didn't venture to the more exciting or decorative burgers but shouldn't their classic burgers be just as good or decent? The best thing there was the strawberry milkshake and fries (not saying much). BIB Chicken Wings 7/10 Truffle Cheese Fries 7/10 Classic Burger with jalapeños 6/10 Classic burger with onion rings and bbq 7/10 Malted milkshakes - strawberry 8/10, vanilla 7/10 read more

See all

A very average burger, not bad, not great, but a little on the pricey and small side. Came backvhere after nearly a decade after my first time trying this place, the first time i came I thought the burgers were magical, this time not so much. Cant tell if its because the quality of this place has taken a dip or if my palete has changed, but either way a very average burger read more

Black Iron Burger - Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Black Iron burger is the best! Their meat is so tender and juicy, I've been dreaming about it at night. Great service, but I would've liked more breading on their onion rings. Anyways, I totally recommend Black Iron Burger if you are craving a classic burger and fries. NOTHING BEATS THEIR MEAT! read more

I was staying in the hotel basically next door. I thought it would rude not to sample a burger as I was so close location wise. I had the Black iron Burger. I really enjoyed the marmalade onions. The patties were very juicy. Service was Swift and fast. read more

See all

IWas surprised how easy it was to get a reservation on New Years Eve and got a table for 6. We all really enjoyed our burgers. U got the Midnight Espresso Burger which was delicious, I wish they gave more sauce either on the burger or on the side (they charge extra for that). Nothing like dipping a burger in BBQ sauce . The staff was very friendly and welcoming and the place was lively with music and TVs all around to watch the games. Enjoy! read more

Black Iron Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

I went in Jan really rather ravenous and it hit the spot. I got the mushroom truffle burger if I remember right, quite tasty. The onion rings are different than I've had elsewhere--very thin & crispy but I enjoyed them (you definitely have to eat them hot & fresh though, don't think it would keep well). Washed it all down with a milkshake, which was decent. The service was friendly and they were helpful when I asked for suggestions. Casual bar-like atmosphere. I would go again if I was nearby & craving a burger. read more

Black Iron Burger - Mushroom Truffle Burger Onion Rings Milkshake - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Was craving a solid burger and knew Black Iron Burger would hit the spot! I had ordered the truffle mushroom burger and it was cooked and seasoned to perfection! Cajun fries were well seasoned, but the onion rings for me didn't quite hit the spot. Not sure if it was the breading or what, but they're alright. Definitely a sports bar kind of vibe for a burger joint with quite a few TVs. Overall, it's a good place if you want a decent burger in the city read more

Black Iron Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Yummy burger. Love the juciness of the patties and the sunny side egg. Only thing is I asked for medium and it was a bit medium rare but still a solid thicc burger. read more

Black Iron Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Honestly, feels like a major tourist trap. I tried to order a set burger on the menu (The American Burger), and was told that this was the same option as the customizable one. I tried to clarify I wanted one that doesn't require customization, and was still told that was not an option. I was also asked to move after seated, whereby I was told that my beer would be on the house. The bill would say otherwise. I was still charged $11 for it!!! The staff are nice, but this experience in its entirety was extremely frustrating. The patty was also very thin and overcooked. 1/5 would not recommend. read more

BIB is right next to the Studio 54 Theatre, which was the main reason my friend and I got an early bite before a show there. I appreciated the convenience but thought the food was just adequate. My friend ordered a burger and I had the fried cod sandwich. Her food was okay, but nothing special. The cod was also fair, but could have done at least with pickles and putting the mayo on both buns. I thought charging $18+ and not including fries with, was pretty obnoxious. The kitchen and management could make more of an effort. Good, friendly service and the place was doing very brisk business on a cold night so other people seem to like it well enough, FWIW. read more

I'd ordered lunch from here a few months back. The burger tasted great. All was well until I came across a short, straight black hair (not that texture matters. I just prefer my food hairless) in the burger. Still get the icks from the experience. read more

Walked in off the street after a Sunday afternoon show at Studio 54. Starved and boarding in hangry. Seated quickly. Ordered and within ten minutes we had food. They specialize in burgers, some pre-programmed to make it easy on you or you can build your own with a burger or chicken or turkey etc. Fries were hot and crunchy. Mexican arugula salad was a meal In itself. Grilled cheese with Iberia ham had sautéed onions and it was amazing. The burgers come with all the fixings as well as a myriad of upsell options. Delivered fresh and hot in record time. The bar tender took our order by memory and honestly I expected him to mess it up but it came out spot on. Full bar, lots of tv's and plenty of seating from 2 to 10. They have happy hour specials that seem pretty affordable as well. I'd definitely come here again. read more

See all

Food was great, but our server Maria was almost nonexistent and we had to keep getting the busboy to bring us what we'd ordered, and he was great. Really surprised that we got an 18% large party charge for our group of four. read more

Our server wasn't in a great mood, but the speed of service and the quality of the food - I had a MYO double burger and my wife ordered the chicken sandwich 1 more than made up for it. Great place with lots of TVs, an old bar vibe, and convenient to the theatre district. read more

Good service, attentive staff. American bar set up, good to stop for a bite or a beer, decent burger, laid back vibe. Stopped here for a bite before a show, convenient location. Chips were very salty, did not like tomatoes in fries. read more

Black Iron Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A True NYC Burger Legend: Perfection on a Bun! Black Iron Burger absolutely delivered on its reputation. This was, without a doubt, one of the best burgers I have ever had. I went straight for their namesake, the Black Iron Burger (two patties), cooked to a beautiful medium well. The beef was incredibly flavorful and juicy, perfectly complemented by the savory, sweet caramelized onions. Every bite was rich and satisfying. On the side, the onion rings were the ideal companion. They had a light, crispy crust and were cooked to absolute perfection--no greasy sogginess here! To wash it all down, the fresh strawberry lemonade was tart, sweet, and genuinely refreshing. The entire experience was seamless, with service to match the outstanding food quality. If you're looking for a top-tier burger experience in NYC, stop searching and start eating here! read more

See all

Unfortunately, our experience was extremely disappointing. We ordered five burgers, and every single one arrived cold. One of the burgers was also missing an additional topping that we specifically ordered. For an order of five meals to all come to the table cold is unacceptable and makes you wonder how long the food was sitting before it was served. When you're paying to dine out in NYC, you expect your food to at least arrive hot, fresh, and prepared correctly. Overall, the food quality and attention to our order fell far below expectations. Definitely not the dining experience we anticipated, and based on this visit, I would not recommend it. read more

My friend asked if I'd eaten at Black Iron Burger. When I told her no, we decided to go. When we arrived, there was only seating at the bar--that was okay with us. I got the Black Iron burger, and my friend got the truffle burger. We also got an order of aioli fries. I was trying to decide which burger I wanted when the server suggested that we share the burgers. He said that he will have it cut in half. What a great idea. Both burgers were delicious. We also enjoyed the fries. The restaurant is large and can accommodate groups. I would come back. read more

Black Iron Burger - Half Black Iron Burger and half Mushroom Truffle Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My boyfriend said this is one of the best burgers in NYC so I decided to try it out. Barely made it for happy hour but was glad to still take advantage of the deal! We were seated immediately upon entering and in general, the service was very good and attentive. - Fries - I thought the fries were probably the best part of the meal as they were very crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. I like how they weren't overly salted and you honestly didn't need to have ketchup for this experience - Mushroom Truffle Burger - This was a pretty big disappointment to me as I had originally thought the mushroom flavor would be more evident. It sort of blended into the beef patty in a dulled-out flavor. I will say that I appreciate that the burger wasn't super greasy and that the patty itself was still very tender. - The Masterpiece - I liked this burger over the other one although I couldn't really taste the bacon as much. The fried egg really elevated the dish by making it have more dimensions with the runny egg yolk. I would say that this is a pretty standard higher quality burger place although probably pretty affordable by New York standards. read more

See all

Food was good service was quick. Found parking right outside on a Saturday night! We shared wings we were too hungry to take a pic of read more

See all

Friendly staff. Relaxing sports bar in the afternoons. Great drink specials and great choices on draft. The arugula salad is magnificent. read more

Fantastic burgers, friendly staff, and we didn't have to wait long despite things seeming quite busy!

Needed a place near Studio 54 for a show and walked in off the street. Great food and great service. Delicious burgers and sides, and finished off with a Nutella Brownie with ice cream for dessert. Definitely will come back! read more

Black Iron Burger - Bar and food pickup - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The veggie burger was a Garden Burger-style patty topped with avocado and the house aioli--simple, satisfying, and well-balanced. The garlic and herb fries came out hot and crispy, though the garlic was on the mild side. We're serious garlic fans, so others might find the flavor just right. The chicken sandwich stood out with its light, crispy coating and thick-cut bacon. Served on sourdough, the bread added a nice contrast to the richness of the filling. read more

See all

Interesting find in the Theater District with custom burgers and an arugula salad that stood out. We arrived early for lunch to a sparsely populated traditionally decorated and relaxing sports bar. We were wisked to a high table and quickly discovered that the place was popular with locals as midway through our meal the entire bar completely filled up with an eager lunch crowd. The ambiance was warm and inviting and service was professional, checking on our table periodically throughout the meal. The custom burger was exceptionally juicy with fresh ingredients albeit somewhat small. The arugula salad was fresh and my optional grilled chicken was generously portioned. I would only suggest serving the salad on a plate instead of a standard and seemingly smaller bowl for the sake of presentation and ease. The onion rings were a standout, nicely sliced and expertly prepared in a memorably light and flavorful coatng. Nice find! read more

Black Iron Burger - Burgers Near Me - New York, New York

Pleasant atmosphere. The service is okay. One of those situations where they would rather talk to each other than to patrons. The food is the star. We ordered The Masterpiece 5/5. Perhaps the best burger I have ever eaten. The bun is special soft, flavorful, and can contain the ingredients between. In addition, add the horseradish mayo 5/5. Onion Rings 4.5/5 (could have been crispier). Accompanied by ranch 5/5. BIB Chicken Club Sandwich 5/5. Nice draft beer selection. Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

After getting seated, we waited 20 mins before someone came back to our table. The person who seated us said there was a shift change but they definitely forgot about our table and the table next time to us. The restaurant wasn't even full. Then when it was time to pay, the waiter just left the payment terminal. We were splitting the checking so we, the customers, had to click through the payment terminal to figure out how to split the payment. read more

The food was good and the service was very good. The staff was very attentive and on the ball. Cleaned up a lot to keep the table neat. Friendly staff. Had a nice dinner after seeing a show at the theatre. read more

See all