Overall: It was good, not great, especially for the price.
We arrived just before 5PM (opening) on a Sunday afternoon. Very cool old house (1927) turned into a restaurant. We were pleased to find a higher-end dining establishment close to home (Rowlett), so we tried it out.
When we turned onto Olive street, we were struck by the delicious odor of wood smoke.
We were seated in what seemed to be the back, via a circuitous route past the bar and the staircase. It was actually the old living room just to the left of the front door. Tyler, our waiter, was excellent, welcoming us and giving a brief history of the house and the restaurant.
We started with a couple glasses of the Marietta Christo Lot 2 red blend, which was delicious. We had seen the Calamari & Anaheim Peppers on Yelp and ordered it. It was awesome. Some of the peppers were mild, others had a bite. The jalapeno cream sauce was very tasty.
For our entrees, we both gravitated to the Seafood Medley, so I ordered the Surf & Turf special instead so we could share some steak. Both dishes were on the small side.
The surf & turf consisted of a filet mignon (e.g. tenderloin) with toasted crab on top and a small side plate of 5 or 6 shrimp in a sauce. The tenderloin was cooked to order, but bland. It needed salt. The crab tasted okay, but was quite dry due to the toasting. I had to commit the faux pax of asking for salt for my steak.
The seafood medley consisted of a small piece of salmon, mussels and shrimp with kale. The plate was quite pretty. However, the food again was somewhat bland. The salmon was overcooked. It wasn't dry, but it wasn't rare either. The shrimp was the same as the Surf & Turf side. The mussels were the best part of the meal.
One of the dishes came with a side of roasted asparagus. The veggie was cooked well, but also could use some additional salt.
Now, you could assume that I'm just a salt fiend, but my wife is the opposite. When she says something needs salt, it REALLY needs salt. And that was the case here.
Finally, we had the creme brûlée for dessert. It was great! Most creme brûlées have a firm custard, but this one was soft like pudding which we loved. The caramelized gran marnier topping was glasslike and shattered into several nice, sweet shards.
I think this place could be really good. I am an engineer, not a chef, but one of my hobbies is cooking. So my litmus test is whether I could cook it better. And other than the mussels and the creme brulee, I could have done better at home. The filet needed salt and pepper. The salmon needed less time in/on the heat. The sauces needed a bit more salt.
For the appetizer, three glasses of wine, the seafood special and the surf & turf special and the creme brulee, the bill was a little over $150.
I'm thrilled that we are getting higher end restaurants in Rowlett/Rockwall. But I think the next time I am in the mood for "Texas" cuisine, I'll head back to Dale Wamstad's "Texas" restaurant in Richardson. read more