First time eating at BIG Bills NY Pizza and I knew it would be good the second we walked in the door. Full house with folks waiting for tables and the smell was incredible! Chatting with 30 year customers while we awaited our table and was served by a 29 year employee very soon after! Laura was so kind and respectful and all around exactly what youre looking for when dining out. She found out it our first time visiting and made time to chat, bring us samples and all with a big NY smile. - Even with how bust this place was, she showed zero signs of pressure. And if this wasn't already enough reason for my 5-stars, out came the pizza! NY Combo with extra cheese steaming and beautiful. I mean this thing was a piture perfect pie! The crust was thin and crispy through ever bite. Even with all those toppings (and it was a heavy pie) the slice held true and straight without any floppiness. - Big Bill knows crust!!! I am a pizza LOVER, my favorite food group....and I can say this, Big Bills is my new favorite spot to grab a pie. Bravo Big Bill and your amazing crew! Bravo read more

It was packed house , everything smells amazing ! Had calzone , meatballs , pizza and cannolis! All was amazing ! Best cheese that stretches a mile ! They are the real deal ! Reasonable prices also ! Won't regret read more

The pizza was amazing. Nice crust and the sauce was delicious. We had the Chop Salad which was great. The salad dressings were fresh. It was a great meal and a wonderful place for the family to enjoy good food in a relaxed atmosphere. And we had to get a box of Yodels to take home. The service was excellent read more

See all

Big Bill's is an authentic New York style pizza joint that has great service and super affordable prices. The crust is perfect and crispy on the pizzas and the chopped dinner salad is not something you want to pass up! The staff makes you feel right at home without breaking the bank for high quality food. Definitely a go to in this area for pizza! read more

See all

After 25 years, this is still my favorite pizza in the Denver Metro area! Excelent service and the atmosphere feels like the local pizza place I went to as a child in NJ. read more

We stopped by here in between games for our hockey tournament next door, and we are so glad we did! The calzones were crispy on the outside and filled with ricotta and mozzarella cheese and came with a full bowl of marinara sauce for dipping. My partner ordered the lasagna and said it was a little too salty, and it was cold and not cooked through the middle. They did take it and add it back to the oven to make it right. The pizza looked good, but it was a little greasy. My daughter also enjoyed her spaghetti. Overall, I think the calzones are five stars! The other dishes need a little work to be at that level. I would definitely go back again for the calzone! read more

Big Bill's NY Pizza - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

See all

After many years of coming to Big Bills, during lunch and also dinner hours, the best time to dine is either lunch or early dinner hours. If you are coming in during prime dinner hours, expect to wait. Also the parking can be a problem due to several very popular restaurants nearby sharing the parking lot. Looks like they have a nee menu but price seems to be still very reasonable. I have dined at the similar pizza restaurants and Big Bill still serves quality food at very reasonable price. . My go-to choice is the canzone, heros and of course pizzas. Service is always good, drinks are priced very reasonably and they keep the restaurant very clean. read more

See all

Still the best NY pizza at the cheapest prices I've found in Colorado. My daughter and I came in on a Saturday night and were greeted with a 30-45 minute wait. They flip tables fast, and people ahead of us were seated quickly. We were called and seated right at the 30-min mark. The only downer of the meal were the garlic knots. While they came out quick, they appeared to be undercooked. Dense, and a little raw tasting, and yet, not overly hot. Good flavor, however. Maybe we try something else next time or just skip the app altogether. Slices stand up to any I've had before at other places. I got one pepperoni and one sausage, while my daughter had one cheese and one pepperoni and sausage. Great flavor, great grease to cheese ratio, and great foldability. What more could you want? Service may have seemed a bit slower than usual, but we were still in and out in just over 30 mins after being seated, and they were busy, so the waitstaff was busting their butts throughout. They were as attentive as they could've been. I always look forward to coming here. $28 before tip. How could anything be wrong with that?!? read more

See all

I'm looking at other reviews and thinking my meal today must have been atypical. The pizza looks better in other photos! Servers were welcoming and friendly, but the food was disappointing. We got sticks and stones (breadsticks and garlic knots), a chopped dinner salad, and slices of pizza. It was all okay, but not great. I didn't enjoy my veggie NY-style slice very much. The chopped salad would have been better with a higher concentration of the ingredients that aren't lettuce. I did think the garlic knots were pretty good. read more

See all

Great food, great staff and great prices. What more could you ask for? The menu has a huge variety from salads to pizza, entrees and sandwiches. Even the kids menu has good variety. And there is so much memorabilia on the walls that it would take longer than your meal to look at everything! read more

See all

Great pizza from New York City!! The food is top quality and the service is great. It used to be a Skipper's Seafood and Chowder House place and I worked there. Great location read more

Tried several times to phone in a pizza order, kept getting a message that call could not be completed. I guess they sell so much that they don't need to take phone orders. read more

Tried this place while visiting Denver, I'm a Pizza snob and have to say this is some of the best Pizza I have ever had. When you enter you will find lots of decorated nostalgia with a nice Mom and Pop feel. Excellent service from the minute you walk in, everyone working together to make sure you are taken care of. The Pizza dough is amazing, fresh flour, light and airy, nice crisp on the under carriage, nice and thin NY style with a good chewy crust, the sauce has a great flavor along with fresh mozzarella and tasty pepperoni. If you live in the area and haven't tried this place you're missing out!!! read more

See all

Food was very good when we finally got it. Had to wait around 10 min to get a table but wasn't unpleasant. They have many young people taking your drink orders and picking up empty plates. My only complaint is that they had one person to take your order at your table. She also ran food and paid attention to all of the other tables with checks, etc. Needless to say, our order wasn't taken based on when we were seated. Only when she realized we hadn't ordered, she finally came over. Didn't take that long to get our food. Expect a bit of a wait if you order a pizza or two. Doubt I eat there again due to the order issues. Probably would have been better to order take out and pick it up. Reason I gave it a 3. Ambiance was ok as it is a local pizza/General Italian plate restaurant. read more

Great atmosphere ... a story in pictures of Bill Finke's life, loves, and passions. A true home owned hole in the wall treasure worth the trip form the "big city" We didn't have to wait to be seated and got our food in a flash. Great place to meet up with old friends or for family supper. Some people really like the crust, but that was the only thing I wasn't in love with. They offer more than just pizza. Do yourself a favor and come in for a good meal in a true treasure; a little piece of Manhattan in the mountains. read more

See all

The food was SO GOOD. We ordered the Sicilian crust not knowing it came in only one size which is MASSIVE but it was SO good. Leftovers were just as enjoyable. The ambiance was cute and the staff was so nice. We will definitely be back!! read more

I usually Love Big Bill's Food, but last night I went to get a couple slices of Cheese Pizza to go. I didn't bother opening the box until I got to me car to eat. One of my slices looked like it had been sitting for a while and they just re-heated it It was not hot and I couldn't eat much of it. I was extremely disappointed. I had spent $8.50. Come on Big Bill's, you can do better than that. read more

On a Friday night we got through the phones to place a pick up order. The wait was only 20 mins. When we went to pick it up it was clean, fast, easy and a delicious pizza and knots. We overheard a walk in person having to wait an hour for a to go order - popular, amazing place with delicious food so plan accordingly. read more

I have been to Big Bills many times and love it every time. We usually get pizza, we have had the thin and thick crust. The party pizza is serious! We took it on a road trip and it lasted us days. We have also had the chicken parmigiana and other entrees. All so good. The service there is wonderful. A great atmosphere of a local shop. And a great value, everything is reasonably priced. I have only good things to say. My first visit was 5 years ago and most recent today. Always wonderful! read more

Big Bill's NY Pizza - Sausage and pineapple pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Pleasant surprise to hear about true NY slices. The cheese only definitely tasted like a NY slice. The supreme equivalent was good and hefty but crust and pie tasted not as NY style. Still would come again if ever in the area. Service very friendly and progressional. Inside does remind me of the old pizza joints back in NY/NJ area. read more

This is some of the best pizza we've had not only in Denver, but anywhere. The price isn't too expensive and the portions are nice. We have been here several times but always order to go. They always have our order ready within a few minutes. Our food has always been hot and fresh, and they always get our order correct. I always have to park across the parking lot then walk over but it's not too bad or far. Don't skip the garlic knots! read more

The food was great. We started with the garlic knots and the sauce. They were really well made. We then had the anti-pasto salad for two. We then ordered the pizza and my daughter ordered the Mac and cheese. She loved the Mac and cheese. Our pizza was great as well. The service was great and very prompt. If your drinks were empty they would be on it. The ambience is definitely neighborhood sports bar complete with photos of sports stars from Denver and New York. read more

See all

The calzones are really good a the cost to eat out here is fabulous! It's always crowded too!

A Centennial classic, we try to go a few times a year. The pizza and subs are always solid, and it's good to see so many kids working here still after all these years. Outside of them closing too early, there is nothing to complain about as the food and atmosphere is always good. read more

Best NY style pizza in the Southern burbs. Very family friendly and a great place to visit family and friends. You can catch the man himself, Big Bill, there on a regular basis. He always offers a friendly wave and smile. read more

See all

Great pizza and institution in the neighborhood. Bill is a hero in the the community always good service to go with the tasty food

Best pizza I had in decades! Highly recommend!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The food is great, both eat in and take out. Service is very good, especially Connor Gilchrist. Big Bill's is a great family oriented Italian restaurant. read more

The food is good - the pizza is far better than the pasta, skip the salad. The tables are cramped and small. We barely had room for our party of 6, which included two young children, all of us with elbows tight to our bodies and leaning over our food because there was no room to eat otherwise. The restaurant is also extremely loud and a little chaotic, so conversation, even with the person right next to you, is challenging. I'd say this spot is better for to-go than dine-in. read more

NY style pie. Always good and cooked Well. They do a 9/11 fundraiser that is cool for helping the Susan b komen foundation. Take the family and have a pitcher of beer and a monster of a pizza!! Not fancy, just good! read more

We were looking for a great local pizza place for Valentine's Day take out. We of course looked to Yelp to help us find a non chain restaurant. This place had dozens of great reviews so we'd thought we'd give them a call. A guy with a New York accent answered the phone...super promising... and quickly took our order. The place wasn't hard to find, but with it being snowing and all parking was super limited! So I hopped out of the car and went inside to pick up the pizza while my boyfriend waited outside. Immediate smell of italian food goodness! Oh my. Think marinara sauce and garlic knots. Mmmmmmm. The restaurant was at a limited capacity I think cause there was a whole section without tables and chairs. And the whole place sure was busy. There was about 4 people ahead of me picking up orders too. Expected especially during the "holidays". If you tip, the head guy tells all the young pizza makers to thank you by name. It was really like a mom and pop feel even if the restaurant wasn't screaming mom and pop if that makes sense. Pizza was huge for the price. Cheaper than any large specialty pizza at less than $30 WITH TIP ADDED TOO. We got the combo which came with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and olives. Literally all of these as add ons would have been way more than this combo. The pizza was hot, cheesy, and smelled soooo good! I think because it was take out and the heat went through the box for about a 15 minute home drive, the pizza did get soggy. There were so many toppings it couldn't contain itself! Definitely a good pizza and the sausage was super flavorful. But probably would have been better dining in. read more

See all

This is one of the best pizza places in my area. The establishment is ALWAYS busy which is good. The service is pretty smooth and spot on. The pizza is amazing. It's hard to find good pizza so I'm glad we gave this place a shot. We've been here twice in a month so we have found a winner. I didn't take any pictures unfortunately but I will next time. Would definitely recommend. read more

Place is always busy so that is a good sign. We have only ever done take out and by the time home it is still hot and has good cheese pull. Staff is friendly and it looks like they sell the desert snacks that I remember hearing about while watching King of Queens. Definitely one of the best pizza places in Highlands Ranch. read more

See all

Classic east coast style pizza! Tossed dough, excellent sauce, toppings include my fave capicolla. Yum! Bonus - Tastycakes (like Hostess, but better. To my taste anyway. Classic vibe - tile floors, red and white tablecloths, pizza heaven! read more

As a former New Yorker, this spot is like back home. The sauce, the cheese, the crust, the pepperoni so good.

Not horrible for pizza in CO but like NY no that would be a stretch. Place was busy and I noticed many people trying to walk in after 8 when they close. Who closes a pizza place at 8pm? Thats DEFINITELY nothing like NY. Husband did not like the pizza said it was dry and tasteless except for the unexpected spicy sausage which was supposed to be regular. Honestly I'd stay away from trying to order pizza in Denver suburbs. read more

Always great New York style pizza and calzones! Lovely salads too. Great service, family atmosphere read more

See all

Big Bill's is a favorite local pizza spot for NY style pizza in the burbs. It's more Joe's than it is Grimaldi's or Roberta's, and it's solid overall. While Blue Pan and Redeemer get all the attention and accolades in Denver, BB's is beloved in the burbs. This is a super comfortable place to eat with other families in a casual dining room, which is harder and harder to find with pizza places these days. The service is always friendly, and the thin crust pizza has good texture and flavor that our 2-year-old son loves. When people say this is better than NY pizza, they're wrong. When they say it's pretty good when you're craving NY pizza and a good place to eat with your family, they're absolutely right. read more

Big Bill's NY Pizza - New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centennial, Colorado

Don't know why Big Bill's NY pizza has been off my radar for a while. It is definitely back on the roster. I like to go in, order a pizza and a "forgettaboutit" draft and by the time I am done with the beer my pizza is up. Usually have to drink it quickly cause the pizza comes when I am only 1/2 done with the beer. Today ordered 2 dinner salads and a large pizza. It can easily feed 4. But I do love pizza leftovers. Next time I will just order one dinner salad. It was plenty for 2. http://www.bigbillsnypizza.com/ read more

We had to make a stop here on the way back to Denver from Castle Rock. Why? It was the anniversary of 911 and every year the owner does an amazing donation event here. All proceeds from the day go to help sick and injured FDNY first responders from that terrible day. We saw a report on the morning news and had to come in for some pizza. The place was packed which speaks to how much the community comes together to help in this way. We ordered two large cheese pizzas and an eggplant parm dinner. Pizza was good, don't get me wrong, but the crust was kinda tough and chewy. Maybe this is authentic NY style pizza...? It wasn't really foldable like they said. It was thicker than NY pizza I've had in the past. The eggplant was done very well. All in all if we are in the area, we'd give them another try. read more