Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bennets Pizza

    4.4 (8 reviews)
    Closed • 1:00 pm - 2:00 am (Next day)

    Order Bennets Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Bennets Pizza Photos

    BENNETS PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bennets Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Jinx K.

    Friday night my husband decided to order a late night pizza at 11:15 PM. We were gonna go with our usual favorite, but then I went on to Yelp and I found a new place which I've never heard of called Bennet's on 6th. So I thought we would give them a tray. Delivery time was pretty decent. It took about 40 minutes. The pizza came relatively warm and our first bite. It was OK. The pizza itself in my opinion reminded me of a Domino's Pizza chain. So if you like spending over $40 for pizza which a bonus for some they do deliver till 3 AM, then this might be your place. Personally I don't know if we'll be ordering from them again.

    Loaded fries include bacon, cheese sauce and sour cream. Very good!
    Jessica G.

    I've ordered delivery from Bennet's twice in the last few weeks. It's definitely not bad but truthfully, I'm ordering from them because they're open late at night and they deliver. Dare I say, they're kind of like a Southside Pizza Shuttle or Zayna's. Ya know, delicious only late at night. The pizza was good. It's a nice diversion from the standard Milwaukee cracker crust. I'm not sure if it was the sauce, the pepperoni or both but the pizza had a nice little kick of spicy that I enjoyed. The orange dip in the photo was supposed to be a garlic butter but I wondered if that was correct since it was orange and neither garlic nor butter are orange. Dunno. The loaded fries come with cheese whiz, sour cream and some fresh, real bacon. And, they were so good! The fettuccine Alfredo can be made with sausage, chicken or meatball. It was tasty but very rich. I was a bit disappointed with the value of the pasta dish as it came in a very small serving with little pasta. I'll definitely be ordering from Bennet's again. Perhaps I'll skip the pasta in the future. Delivery has always been without a problem.

    Spinach Salad
    Adam P.

    Amazing in town for a baseball tournament and need some meals late at night they delivered to the hotel room and everything tasted great you can to wrong!

    Bone in wing breadsticks and pizza with shrimp and sausage with Alfredo Chicken sauce

    See all

    2 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Adam P.
    23
    10
    7

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Bennets Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 9,187 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Zaffiro's Pizza - Cheese @ Sausage Pizza

    Zaffiro's Pizza

    3.8(449 reviews)
    3.5 mi•Lower East Side
    •$$

    Yummy pizza! The crust is super thin, thinner than NY style pizza - that being said, I would…read moreheavily recommend dining in instead of taking out. If you take out, I'd imagine the crust gets soggy quickly. I split this pizza with my brother and it was more than enough for us, we ended up having a little bit of leftover. The service was friendly! Our server was attentive and warm. Interior has an old charm vibe - apparently they still use the same decorations from when it first opened. In the end there was a bit of a billing hiccup and it took about 3 calls over the span of 3 weeks to get it fixed. That was a little bit of a nuisance since I had to keep calling and asking them to fix it, and they ultimately did. Free street parking in the area. From my understanding, do not park in the gravel lot near it - it is not for Zaffiro's

    Ok my first mistake when moving to the Milwaukee area and knowing nothing about this place was…read moregetting a beef sandwich. Knowing more about this restaurant today I ordered a small sausage pizza. The place it self is dated and divy so it's not a good date place. It's small with a small bar as you walk in and a dinner room on the other side. I called in a small sausage pizza and I was told 30 minutes while I was parked in front of the place with no visible traffic which I thought was a long time. 25 minutes later I go and get it. I ate it one minute after walking out and you could tell it was sitting around for awhile because the cheese had no pull and it was solidifying. It did look good with that thin cracker crust and reminded me of when I lived in Chicago we would order this style of pizza to the bar. The pizza had a nice thin cracker crust. The sauce was on the sweet side. The Italian sausage was the star because it was the quintessential perfect pizza sausage and seasoned nicely like a good Italian sausage. The pizza was still good and delicious but fresh out of the oven would the way to go. Overall if the pizza was fresh out of the oven and you sat in the restaurant is the way to go in my opinion.

    Photos
    Zaffiro's Pizza - Restaurant seating

    Restaurant seating

    Zaffiro's Pizza - Small sausage pizza

    Small sausage pizza

    Zaffiro's Pizza - This is the bar near the entry - very comfortable

    See all

    This is the bar near the entry - very comfortable

    Tauro Cocina - Guajillo Risoto

    Tauro Cocina

    4.6(202 reviews)
    3.4 mi•Lower East Side
    •$$

    What a fabulous meal and experience atTaurp Cocina! 3 of us…read morewent last Sunday, Aug 23rd, to celebrate a birthday. Actually 2 of the 3 of us had a birthday in the last 4 weeks. 1 of us had been to Tauro Cocina before. The food was excellent! We shared a house salad which was very good. The 3 entries ordered were: Linguine al Poblano, (house-made linguine tossed in our specialty poblano pesto with grilled chicken) Cilantro Risotto (cilantro cream risotto, served with spicy grilled shrimp, topped with shaved parmesan) And Grilled Salmon (served with your choice of risotto & sauteed seasonal. Each one was unique, so flavorful & freshly prepared. Excellent! The service was top notch. I had called earlier to see if they did anything for birthdays. The reply was yes. When arriving the host asked if we were celebrating any special event, confirming my call. Through the entire meal service was attentive without being obtrusive. When our plates were cleaned (with leftovers for each of us) the server brought out plates for both birthday friends. The plates had 3 churros, a small dish of warm chocolate sauce, were decorated with Happy Birthday & a candle. All with finesse. An overall great meal and great experience. Definitely worth visiting & I will be returning.

    Our first visit to Tauro Cocona (and my first visit to the building since it housed Tracadero) but…read morewill not be our last. Great ambience. The menu offers enough options without being too big; we were intrigued by the italian/mexican fusion. Everything we ordered was delicious. The calamari was a great starter with a spicy red sauce. The pastas were fantastic. Finally the birthday churros the waiter delivered changed my stance on churros. They were fresh out of the fryer, hot and crispy. Gone in no time. The only complaint i can offer is that our server was not as attentive as you'd want. It wasn't bad service; just not as prompt as you'd expect (i.e. asked how our food was as we were halfway through the dish, we finished our cocktails and were never asked if we wanted another, empty plates sat on the table a bit longer than they should). None of which will keep us from coming back. Will chalk it up to a busy Saturday first seating.

    Photos
    Tauro Cocina - Back room and bar

    Back room and bar

    Tauro Cocina - Mejillones

    Mejillones

    Tauro Cocina - Ilegal en Milwaukee

    See all

    Ilegal en Milwaukee

    San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

    San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

    4.5(373 reviews)
    2.4 mi•Downtown, Westown
    •$$

    I loved my experience eating at San Giorgio, I ordered the Margherita DOC and the Genevieve and the…read morewaiter was super nice. The crust had that nicely charred flavor to it, and even though they were super busy, there was no wait at all. The vibes were very chill but lively, with lots of families and friends dining together. It's also located near two lots, so parking was very easily accessible. Overall, would recommend!

    This is a must try if you're in Milwaukee!…read more Watching the pizzas being made right in front of you is an experience in itself. The open kitchen lets you see the craftsmanship that goes into every order, and the team is friendly, welcoming, and happy to interact with guests. Their passion for what they do really stands out. I definitely ordered more than I could finish, but it was worth it! I recommend enjoying the pizza at the restaurant since it's best fresh from the oven. Since this is an authentic Italian restaurant, they don't serve ranch with their pizza, which I completely understand. I personally love a good ranch with my pizza, but that's just my preference. The Caprese salad was fresh and flavorful, and the pasta ball appetizer was delicious. Between the quality of the food, the welcoming atmosphere, and getting to watch everything come together, this was one of my favorite dining experiences in Milwaukee. I will definitely be back.

    Photos
    San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana - The wine display

    The wine display

    San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana - Cannoli

    Cannoli

    San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana - Cannoli

    See all

    Cannoli

    Bennets Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...