Food: They have daily combo specials. I got the grilled striped bass filet with veggies and can of soda for $20. We wanted some carb, so we got a side dish of roasted potatoes for $8. We also got a lobster roll $25, combo ($5 extra for French fries and can of soda). Both dishes taste good, but the grilled sea bass is definitely the winner! Service: we were greeted right away when we entered the store. They have seating inside but they also have some seating outside in the back. The guy at the register is super friendly, explained to us what they have as special and made recommendations. We ordered, paid and another server brought our food to the table when it was done. That server was also super friendly. We will definitely come back! read more

Bay Ridge Fish Bar - Lobster roll combo $30, roasted potatoes $8, grilled sea bass with veggies ($20, includes drink) - Fish & Chips Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Got 3 orders of fish and chips on Uber Eats. All the fish was spoiled and smelled so strongly of ammonia that it burned your nose and we couldn't eat it. Thankfully uber gave us a refund but this place is going to get people sick. read more

I drove over an hour in traffic to come here. The people are very friendly and helpful in ordering your food. The place is small inside so we decided to sit outside because it was a beautiful day. We had to tell them it wasn't a good look to have large garbage cans and a motor bike where we have to eat. They removed the garbage cans. We had the grilled octopus and it was perfectly seasoned and tender. The grilled Bronzini was a nice size and it was really good but I had to ask if they would grill the other side. The fried snapper needed more seasoning for my taste but overall the food was good. read more

See all

I finally took the plunge and decided to try them. I remember speaking with the previous owner when the first opened. I did not know they had a new owner. I can tell that the owner is trying to make this place work. What we ordered was good, o would not call it great. We had the salmon burger and fries priced around twenty dollars. Also the tuna poke bowl around the same price. You have to order at the counter and then if you are staying, they will bring the food to your table. One issue I ran into is that when you order your food, it brought out to you as they are ready. If you are eating with someone else they may get their food before yours. Then you are waiting 5 minutes or more for your food. It's a little uncomfortable as most people would like to eat together. They can definitely do better job in this area. There are some challenges as there is not really enough seating to accommodate customers during colder months. Right now there are two small tables on the street and three small tables inside. The garden area can seat more and probably is only good for about four or five months if the weather is dry. I would tend to recommend them more for take out and not sit down unless you are ok with the things I mentioned. read more

See all

Have ordered from Bay Ridge Fish Bar a few times. The best dish I have had is the Mussels. They serve them in this intensely garlicky and flavorful sauce that you can literally drink! Ask for extra bread for dipping. When they had the buy 1 get 1 special on it I saved one order and it was incredible over pasta the next day. Other dishes I have tried are the build your own poke which was very fresh but the dressing and rice weren't as flavorful as a sushi spot, the fish and chips was really good with nicely battered fresh fish and plenty of fries, the salt and vinegar fries really didn't have much vinegar flavor and weren't worth the upcharge and the crab cake sandwich was good with a large well seasoned crab cake. I like that they have specials and the delivery is always fast. The actual menu is much larger than the menus on GH and UE so it may be best to check those out and order direct. read more

Bay Ridge Fish Bar - Amazing mussels in garlicky marinara - Fish & Chips Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Place has a new owner, the older place was better but not by much. The chef is good but the old owners chef was better, staff is nice, the seafood is fresh but poor quality for the price, portions are ok, store layout sucks, not a place run by someone who knows how to run a restaurant, more like Someone who's washing money and doesn't care if they lose or make Money. Not family owned. I wouldn't waste my time. I found port Said much much better and 7 blocks away read more

This place felt super homey and everyone was so nice. Sat in the patio in the back. Pot of mussels for 20$ makes it worth it in itself. It was a Monday and they seem to do lobster roll specials on Mondays. Fried calamari was also very good. Shrimp tacos were great as well. Fish and chips were alright - wish they were more crispy. All in all, will come back to try their seafood pasta and other things! Their menu is pretty extensive, so excited to come back again read more

See all

They used to only take cash but now accept card. The owner and staff are very friendly but the wait time can be quite long so I would order ahead or come here for a slow lunch. The calamari with red sauce, chowder, and pasta were all delicious and I would definitely come back! read more

See all

Came here with my husband and my 3 year old. The backyard patio is really cute, and a great spot on a warm, sunny day. We had mac n cheese (huge hit with my toddler) and Lobster Bisque soup, along with fish n chips. The bisque was really yummy, but my only complaint is that there was barely any lobster in it! Just one small piece and another even smaller piece. The previous owner would give a more generous portion of lobster when serving the soup. The service was super friendly, but they do take long. Not necessarily a bad thing, but good to know if you're in a rush. All in all, it was enjoyable and I'd def be back! read more

Food was delicious and service was great! Ambience is very cozy and chill. There is outdoor seating available or AC seating on the inside. Staff is very friendly and helpful. I had trouble deciding what to get but gave a general idea of what I wanted and they were able to provide some lovely options. Loved my meal and will be taking my family and friends here next time read more

4 stars for the customer service. I've been having this place on my list from seeing it from IG. Let me start off by saying parking in this area is horrid, you'll circle around but will find something eventually. It's a real fish market where you order the fresh fish off the cold display and they cook it to order. There was so many varieties of crustaceans and fish you don't know what to choose from. I went during mother's days weekend and it had a special surf and turf which was lobster and steak. The steak was amazing and cooked well . The lobster was cooked perfect but the butter sauce was average. It needed more seasoning. I also had the lobster linguine that was really oily. The baked clams were really good as well. read more

See all

Amazing food! Fresh and delicious- easy to order and very quick! The lobster roll I couldn't take a pic of but it was out of this world delicious! My fish was seasoned to perfection. I didn't even know the person behind the register whom was also bringing the food out was the owner himself! The service was quick and will deff be back soon for a seafood boil! The table next to us had a seafood boil and it looked amazing as well! Loved every bite of my food! read more

See all

- haven't had a bad meal yet - I love the garlic linguine Shrimp, scallop, lobster, you name it - I love the crab cakes - I loved the shrimp tacos - I love all the soups - the menu is quite expansive - free coffee is a plus - I loved the fries, although I haven't had the vinegar - very friendly service read more

I dined with a friend for lunch. You can take out or eat in. The ambiance is simple with cafe style tables, and backyard dining which is delightful. I had shrimp and fries and my friend had seafood tacos. You can choose the fish you like for the tacos. Both were tastefully seasoned and more than adequate in size portions. The pricing was also adequate, at approximately $15-16.00. per meal. The service was excellent! Mohammed was eager to please you with any type of fish you decided on and would prepare it any way you liked. The young lady that waited the table was very pleasant and also eager to please you. I will definitely be eating there again and would take out if I'm on the go. In Bay Ridge I highly recommend this seafood eating experience. read more

i've been coming to this place for a while now and it never disappoints. every time i go, the vibe is the same super welcoming, chill, and just a really good spot to sit down and enjoy some amazing seafood. it's one of those places you can keep going back to and it still hits every single time. the seafood boil 4 is always my go-to and it's consistently so good. it comes out hot, loaded with flavor, and perfectly seasoned every time. the seafood is always fresh, and the sauce is honestly addictive. they don't skimp on portions either, which is a big plus. i also get the fried calamari pretty often and it never misses. it's crispy, light, and not rubbery at all. you can tell they actually know what they're doing in the kitchen because everything is cooked just right. the service is a big reason i keep coming back too. the staff is always friendly, quick, and make you feel taken care of. the owner is super nice and always checking in, which makes the whole place feel more personal and welcoming. overall, this is easily one of my favorite spots. i come here all the time and i'm definitely not stopping anytime soon read more

This is my second review of this restaurant because it's that good! Just had the grilled shrimp tacos and they were delicious and very fresh. The pico de galo and mango salsa were excellent. The cole slaw although a little too creamy is very tasty. I've also had their linguini with white clam sauce and that was excellent as well. Best place in Bayridge for consistently good seafood. read more

Bay Ridge Fish market was an awesome experience clean place to eat fresh food home made everything made in house . Muhammad. Always treats you like your at home and staff is awesome I come there every chance I get it's better than city island the seafood. read more

We ordered a large order for my office today and it was a hit! The seafood is fresh and delicious. It was a pretty large order but everything was in order and perfectly packaged. The lobster bisque was BOMB with huge clumps of lobster meat in it. Delivery was smooth and the delivery guy was very nice! Only one small suggestion I would make is to add two tortillas to the tacos because with one it became a little soggy causing the tacos to fall apart - all good though we used a spoon and scooped up the DELICIOUS fish inside! read more

Right as you walk in there's fresh seafood waiting for you. I was greeted immediately with a friendly face. Because I follow them on Instagram I ordered their special they highlighted for that Sunday: a shrimp burrito. Hubs got the lobster roll and we grabbed a seat outside in the back. We regretted the decision only because it was colder than we thought and my sweater was not doing its job. My guy kept us updated on our food and apologized for the wait but it was so understandable cuz there was a cute (birthday?) party and the kitchen was hustling to get their orders in. It's a small-ish space; party table in the back for about 6, table in front for 2, bar stools by the register for 4, and outdoor seating could be for about 10. But when we wanted to move, they made sure to clear the table and have it ready. Service is so attentive and kind that it felt rare. Okay, the FOOD: that lobster roll was at capacity and the fries were perfect. The shrimp burrito had shrimp in nearly every bite. The size was enough where I could finish but also feel stuffed but also could walk. We couldn't stop there. We had to take home some appetizers that they have prepared in the fridge. While their homemade hummus looked gorgeous, we opted for mac and cheese and the crab empanadas. I also had some pieces of salmon broiled. All this seafood and a couple of drinks came out to be under $100. I'll definitely be back! read more

Bay Ridge Fish Bar - Sunday Special: Shrimp Burrito - Fish & Chips Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Food and service was great can't wait to go back the wife went wild on the menu and everything was sooooo good 8 read more

Was hungry late one night and found this place thanks to social media.. lived up to the hype, food was good..... Friendly staff as well.. they had an outside seating as well.. read more

Disappointed by the hype. Ordered the boil 3, which was advertised as 2 lobster tails 1/2lb of dungeness crab, 1/2 snow crab (since the dungeness crap was not available, I was promised 1lb of snow crab) -- instead got 1 overcooked lobster tail (cut in half) and maybe half a pound of crab. The sauce was watery and bland. Tried the seafood linguine too --linguine was undercooked, and all the seafood (shrimp, clams, mussels, squid) was overcooked and chewy. Only highlight? The oysters -- fresh and well-prepared. For the price and buzz, I expected way better. Not rushing back. read more

Definitely a great spot for seafood lovers! The pricing is excellent, and there's a wide variety of options to choose from. I highly recommend the scallop linguine with white sauce--totally worth it in terms of both taste and value. You definitely won't find prices like this elsewhere in NYC. Note that the place is quite small, but there is outdoor seating available, making it suitable for larger groups. Overall, I highly recommend it! read more

Oh my gosh the shrimp rice balls and the lobster roll and the calamari were absolutely amazing. I could not stop raving about the shrimp rice balls. The texture and fresh flavor for everything you can possibly order here is perfection. The lobster rolls are filled- they absolutely do not skimp out on the lobster! The service was great and Mo was very kind. Will be back for the seafood pasta and the fish! read more

Bay Ridge Fish Bar - Fried Calamari - Fish & Chips Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This is place is amazing. The customer service is amazing. It's a small place with great potential. It's definitely a place I would return to often for date night. read more

See all

Flavor is fab.with fish cooked to order. It's a cute spot with a nice variety of seafood plus chowders and bisque. I sat in their lovely backyard and had a feast. I ordered mahi mahi and I think it was sautéed not grilled. They have a mufaletta sauce I put on top plus roasted broccoli with garlic & oil. Very delicious but missing some nice bread to sop it up. Total: $23.67 & would eat with bread when they have it. PS Plastic cups in 2023 are a no- no. read more

See all

Been wanting to try this spot since they opened up and Idk why it took me so long! The seafood was delish and customer service on par. We ordered the pot of mussels, calamari, French fries, and corn on the cob. The mussels was supposed to be cooked in a white sauce but accidentally came in a red sauce. I'm not picky so it was still delish! I can't wait to try the white sauce. The portion was good enough for me and I felt full. The mussels were meaty. The calamari was my son's favorite. Another good portion and the breading was seasoned nicely. The French fries were crisp and tasty and the corn had a nice char and delish summer bbq taste. We will def be back! I can't wait to try the rest on their menu as well as buy fresh fish from them. read more

Bay Ridge Fish Bar - Pot of Mussels. Calamari, French Fries - Fish & Chips Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love this place! I've only been there twice. The first time I had the crab cake sandwich. It was fabulous! I read a lot of reviews. I can't wait to return and try something new. Very friendly service. Great fries too. My favorite place for fish (actually my only place) in Bay Ridge! read more

Incredible hot lobster roll!! Finally found a good one in Brooklyn. Just like the ones from New Smyrna Beach, but even MORE lobster- i devoured it. Great service too. Started off browsing the fresh seafood, but then the young lady read my mind and gave me a menu. Beautiful decor . A great new addition to 3rd Ave! read more

See all

I always get the salmon burger.Fresh and made to order. Great customer service as well.

Been to this place couples of times, food quality is consistently outstanding and exceeding my expectations every time. Friendly staffs and very accommodating. One of my favorite local spot. read more

Bay Ridge Fish Bar - Fish & Chips Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I had the seafood boil and it was meh.... Lobster was overcooked. The sauce is tasty but it is super watery! I have had seafood boils at other places and the sauce is not supposed to be watery. The sauce is supposed to coat the seafood. Usually, I would taste butter in seafood boils and that's not what it tastes like here. The sauce is supposed to be the key component to making a good seafood boil. read more

Immediately upon walking in I was greeted by the owner with the upmost respect and care. I had never been here and was curious as to what to get, the staff were more than accommodating in helping me choose, I felt part of the family soon enough. Being able to see the food being crafted in real time with the most beautiful and fresh looking ingredients was a real plus for me. The food itself was delicious, I ordered the crab empanadas and to my surprise it was REAL crab and not imitation. From the first bite to the last I was in love, especially with their in-house made sauces, I couldn't get enough. Definitely a weekly treat from now on! read more

Sooo I found this place on my social media handle (Tiktoj). Many great reviews on the food and family owned business so I decided to take a subway ride to Bay Ridge . I loved the family owned restaurant and the hospitality provided but if I just provide constructive criticism: This family owned restaurant needs to establish a structured system for holidays . My experience took place on Mother's Day . I noticed that there was struggle with managing " in person" customers, grub orders, and phone orders . Assistance of organization and setting boundaries caused a two hour wait on my food order and came to dine in . In person customers should be a priority . I was not the only person(s) that experienced a lengthy wait . To attempt to make up for it, I received several complimentary items such salad, bread and butter, and a shot of Hennessy . Although this was nice it didn't provide a greater experience . Once I received my main course, I ate two bites and asked for a to go box to eat for the next day . Pasta is better the next day anyway however I wanted to enjoy my main dish at the family restaurant . I don't think I will return to the establishment until this family restaurant gain structure for timely service . My food taste better the following day . read more

Discover the rich flavors of expertly selected and fresh seafood. The service is good. read more

See all

Really nice place and a welcome addition to Bay Ridge. I ordered the crab cakes to go and requested they cook them for me, which they did. I love me some crab cakes and I hardly ever see them anywhere. These did not disappoint. They were absolutely scrumptious and I will definitely order them again. The owner was very nice and the place was immaculate. Also to note they have a lovely garden for outdoor dining. Highly recommend! read more

This place is great! Stopped by on a Sunday afternoon & the owner was so friendly/helpful. My food was made to order & was extremely fresh. While there, I saw someone come in for fresh fish while I allowed them to cook my seafood for me. Menu was easily visible & just a great place to be. I will be back to try something grilled, as I was on my cheat day & ordered everything fried. The FRIES are a must get. Delicious food! read more

Very tasty juicy burger I liked it very much I advise I will go here again very beautiful

The seafood was incredibly fresh and full of flavor -- every bite was delicious. From the presentation to the taste, everything was top-notch. Can't wait to come back again! Service was very attentive and made us feel comfortable. read more

Very friendly service. The small dining area in the back is so cute and cozy. We ordered Fish and Chips, Salmon Burger, and Cole Slaw. The fish was very tender, the salmon burger was delicious, the fries were chunky, and the cole slaw was tasty. Overall, we really enjoyed the food and would like to keep revisiting until we have tried their whole menu. read more

Bay Ridge Fish Bar - Fish and Chips - Fish & Chips Near Me - Brooklyn, New York