Ordered a huge spread of catering from Bartoli's. I placed the I order in store for a future date. Was nice to do this in person and talk to a human who understands what I needed for the event. Delivery was very easy and the driver was very helpful. The meal was great. Everyone loved the combo of deep dish options + thin crust. Wings are very good for a pizza place. Salads were great sizes and tasty. The Italian salad came with a very nice amount of spruced up toppings on top. Bartoli's is a great option for catering for any event. Thank you Bartoli's crew! read more

See all

Sure! Here's a funny, casual Yelp-style version that fits your vibe -- like something you'd write after the marathon and still running on endorphins: Maybe it's the post-Chicago Marathon delirium talking, but this might be the best pizza-and-salad combo I've ever had. Was it the carbs? The exhaustion? The fact that it was the first place near my Airbnb that didn't require me to run another mile? Who knows. Either way, this place hit the spot. The pizza was perfect, the salad made me feel slightly healthier about my life choices, and the vibes were exactly what my tired legs needed. Highly recommend for anyone who just ran 26.2 miles--or just wants to feel like I did read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Pizza was actually pretty damn decent. For some odd reason a couple of the end pieces had a sour aspect to the dough. Sauce was either authentic or somebody else it some tlc into making it taste special. I agree with a blogger than they were generous with the cheese. I'd run it back if in the area & my top 3 or 4 places weren't available. Maybe read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Cheese pie with half garlic - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I wish I could give Bartolis another 5 stars, not only is their pizza delicious (and the rest of their food too) but they give out treats for neighborhood pups. My dog knows the route to walk here and some of the staff even know him by name. Thank you for spoiling my pup, Bartolis definitely has my business for every pizza order going forward! read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Half lb Badger-Style Fried Cheese Balls - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Stop by this place to grab some food to head to watch movie. Been seeing this place many times, decided to give this place a try. We got couple slices of pizza and a charbroiled chicken sandwich with curly fries. The flavor of the chicken came out pretty good. I added pickles and onion. The chicken is juicy, just wish it be a different bread instead of French. The sauce on the pizza very flavorful. Would come back to try other food in the menu. Street parking. read more

We got a pizza delivered, it was incredible! My husband said today he wishes he could get it delivered to our home- 2 states away.

I ordered the Italian beef combo, but I was disappointed when I opened it. They usually be on point not this time very disappointing and also my pizza was not cooked properly. and you cannot mess up pizza I guess you can. read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - I ordered the Italian beef combo, but I was disappointed. - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Very yummy deep dish pizza with a crispy crust and good cheese, to sauce to topping ratio! Quick and easy ordering online and pick up service. read more

The pizza is great, service is fast, but why not just label the pizza small, medium and large?! Who orders a large pizza then ends up getting their medium size pizza? Very odd, beware when ordering by size. read more

Bartoli's was a stop on the Chicago Pizza Tour. The deep dish slices are enormous and delicious! Our guide said they sell pizza by the slice, making it a great lunch option if you're in the area. read more

See all

I've seen this place for a while and never went in but boy is it good! I got two slices, the deep dish was ok but the thin crust was excellent! The prices were great too, Ive noticed that a lot of pizza by the slice places will give you a mediocre slice that's way too big and charge like 9 for it, this place has all the slices for 4,75 and they're a good size and very high quality read more

Very clean. The gentleman at the counter was so kind and welcoming. Very helpful and attentive to every single person who walked in. The food was good and very quickly served. Great little grab and go! read more

See all

The best deep dish pizza in town, I like to get it delivered however when I have dined it the experience was a good one. The entire staff provided excellent service! read more

10/10! We came from Minnesota to eat here! Chris at the register was amazing and very friendly!! Definitely coming again if I am in Chicago! Very clean and awesome decor! Follow on TikTok! Plus side we got to see one of the many puppy visitors when leaving!!! read more

Bartoli's pizza thin crust is so good! It's my favorite thin crust pizza with sausage and the sauce is delicious but wait till pizza cools off it's super hot out of the oven fresh! I like to eat inside so I order my pizza on phone before so when I come in it's ready and no waiting! I also tried the minestrone soup and another winner! Bartolis I'm hooked ! read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - At Bartolis Pizza Bartoli's Chicago Classic Thin Crust Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Their southside breaded steak is amazing. The only problem is that they're north of Madison so technically they're Northside! The regular as is with the bit of provolone is more than enough for most people I would think. Hit the bigger sandwich and you can split it with someone. Also, great they have good slices and well cater to your little pup friends as well as you come by read more

This pizza just ain't it. Tastes like premade dough and little flavor. Only positive was the sauce was good.

Bartoli's is one of my favorite deep dishes in Chicago in my opinion! I will say my preferences for deep dish include a lot of sauce, not an overwhelming layer of cheese, and good toppings within the sauce. Bartoli's hit every spot! The sauce was exactly what I love: chunky tomato with a little bit more acid rather than sweet and had a great taste. The cheese wasn't overwhelming & had a great proportion to the pizza. I had it delivered and the delivery guy was extremely nice & the pizza arrived hot!! I will def be taking all my out-of-towner visitors here! read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

We did not get the pizza we ordered, which felt odd because we were the only customers who ordered a full pie. Our bad for not saying something once we realized, though we had each eaten half a slice at that point, so hard to do much truly. It was pretty clear to me that the staff realized their mistake at a point but also said nothing, make of it what you will. We ended up with a deep dish sausage, which was decent, but nothing special either. Probably would've been much better if we'd gotten the pizza we ordered. read more

Bartoli's deep dish may well be the best in Chicago. The sauce is perfection; with an amazing tang and only a hint of sweetness. It's like a rich, bold, 'Sunday Gravy' that the best Italian grandmas make, LOL. We got a simple sausage and pepperoni, and it had a perfect amount of meat. Sausage also had a nice spice blend going. The crust? Killer. Baked to perfection; with a buttery texture and slight flakiness. Crust on the bottom? Thick enough to withstand the onslaught of sauce, cheese, and toppings without getting too soggy. Finally, and this is important, let's talk about juice. The biggest challenge with deep dish is getting as little juice as possible at the end of the bake. This is where Bartoli's knocks it out the park. Juice is minimal; which, if I had to guess, is mostly the result of that sauce. Instead of the watery, diced tomato sweet mess you find at other places, the sauce is thick. As everything bakes away in the oven, there's not much initial liquid going on... GENIUS! We also got the thin crust alfredo with chicken, roasted peppers, and artichoke hearts. Incredible. The toppings, sauce, and cheese is not something they skimp on...this is very nearly a pan style pizza. Delicious. This is a place that deserves some serious patronage. Bravo, Bartoli's. read more

The fettucine Alfredo with grilled chicken was SO GOOD. I didn't expect to receive so much food. You definitely get what you pay for and then some. If you're craving some Italian or classic Chicago pizza, this is a great place. You'll be in and out quickly and feel full and happy. read more

Great flavorful authentic thin crust chicago neighborhood pizza . It is now my go to spot read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Medium pepperoni & mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Decent deep dish pizza at Bartoli's. First of all this location is more of a delivery pick up type place - though they do have a bit of seating. I was there later in the afternoon in a Monday, so it wasn't too busy. You'd see a few pick up orders coming through and another table or two being occupied. In terms of the deep dish pizza itself, this was my first time trying Bartoli's, so my mind immediately tries to compare it to other Chicago deep dishes. It's kind of hard to compare places, but I'd say it's kind of it's own hybrid style between deep dish and stuffed. The crust was kind of like Gino's, but more crunchy, rather than the bready crust Gino's has. The sauce on top is more like a stuffed pizza like a Giordano's rather than the chunks of tomatoes at an Uno's or Lou's. The cheese was nice and super melty. Overall it was good. Glad to have tried something new. read more

normally I do web pick ups, i work across the street at the city of Chicago. This past Friday night I was working late, and decided to come in. Upon coming in both front girls are laughing and giggling and not paying attention to anyone coming in. I seen another woman come out of no where walk past everyone not say anything to anyone and walk to the back. I'm assuming she's a manager maybe? I'm still standing in line and still nothing from anyone. Then I see the girl in back come up to the front and it's just break time here. Laughing and playing and just whatever they had in mind. I wanted another 2 mins still nothing I decided tonight's just not the night. I commonly come in during the day, I'm greeted in and out the door in mins when I call an order in for pick up. There's 2 girls that work always pleasant and they seem to be much more busy and still made a second to acknowledge me. I came in for silverware. That's it that's all. I'll still going to come as a customer but it's just not the way I'm used to being treated here. I did call and spoke to I think Tracey and I didn't want to leave a name or get anyone in trouble so I did tell her I would email the owner. I love your pizza and food day service is so much better compared to night staff its like they don't care read more

Only the second time visiting since they opened a year ago and glad I did. Some places are "slice places" and while Bartoli's isn't a bad slice by any stretch, they are a bright shining star when it comes to a full pie. First time was a slice of something I can't recall and was sort of forgettable. But I did put in my mind that for future visits for a full pizza, they would probably excel. And they did! Ordered a Medium cheese only with extra sauce and crispy/well done. They knocked it out of the park w the execution....perfectly cooked with golden-brown bubbly cheese and just the right amount of cheese to sauce ratio! It is also a place that just MAKES you want to support local business and come back again. It was near closing time and while I waited the few minutes for it to be cooked to the ordered doneness, the owner was cleaning up and asked if I wanted a slice of Deep Dish that was in the window. He hates to throw food away but it's the (unfortunate) nature of the pizza/food industry. It is disheartening to know this is a common practice without much an owner can do about it:/ That slice of Deep Dish (sausage) was the first slice of Deep Dish pizza i've had in at least three years...i've lived in Chicago over 20 years and can count on two hands how many times I eat the stuff....very rarely. I much prefer Tavern Style, NY Style and well, Pequad's.lol (Pan;) but this slice was dynamite! [X] Go --- and order appropriately as it will not disappoint. read more

See all

So good. We got pizza delivered to a brewery nearby that we were hanging out at. Perfectly cooked, crispy crust, browned cheese, amazing sauce, arrived piping hot. Not much more you could ask for in a pizza delivery, honestly. Also, they were quick. This is very VERY good Chicago tavern style pizza. My go-to. Will continue to frequent Bartoli's - love it!!! read more

My family and I came here after seeing this restaurant was listed as a go to for authentic Chicago-style pizza. I ordered the classic deep dish and it was very good! I loved how the sauce was fresh and the ingredients were also. I especially loved the onions and bell peppers in every bite. I would highly recommend this place to anyone read more

See all

This pizza is great, it is my new favorite. Bartoli's has a fast delivery time. The staff is always helpful and friendly.

It was sub par, I'm from Chicago born and raised and I am very picky with pizza joints. It's all about the dough, pizza sauce ratio and then the toppings. Never been here before, but heard great reviews. Went in one night to get my Chitown fix, took almost an hour to get our pizzas, nothing fancy just regular pizza pies. Drive almost an hour home and opened the box, just to realize they gave us the wrong pizza. I paid for a sausage and pepperoni with bell pepper pizza and they gave us some day old cheese pizza instead. I will never eat there again. I would never recommend this place. Employees didn't even verify my pizza before handing it to us. Most places show the pizza inside the box to confirm. Pretty sure the owner was also there and no quality control was done. 2 girls at the front counter too busy chatting instead of making sure we got the right order I was hoping it would be great since I heard good things about this place, unfortunately I could not agree read more

The most delicious pizza I've tried in Chicago! Nice service and really friendly staff. Recommend to try! read more

The place seemed pretty clean but the cross contamination turned me off to the place. I order cheese pizza because it needs to be kosher and so I don't want the sausage or pepperoni grease on my pizza. The girl taking orders seemed nice but not understanding cross contamination can get people sick. read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Sign in front of the building - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I really enjoyed the deep dish pepperoni pizza and the thin sausage pizza. The crust had a nice crunch and I loved how the deep dish pizza sauce had fresh tomato pieces in the sauce. Small spot but a gem. read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Amazing pizza... we ordered an 18" thin with Italian beef and garlic. The pizza was excellent! For those interested they have what looked like a pan or stuffed pizza as well, we're looking forward to trying it next time. read more

My first time (I know, it's a sin) eating Chicago style pizza. My friend and I came here for lunch and we both got the deep dish cheese, as well as sharing some fries and and each getting a cannoli. Everything was fantastic!! The tomato sauce on the pizza is spicy and garlicky but not too overpowering, and it's very cheesy. The fries and ranch sauce were amazing too. Glad I went here to pop my Chi Pie cherry! read more

See all

He Said: We've been craving some pizza and this one came up on several searches. Sure, we were staying in Chinatown, but good pizza is good pizza, so off we went! The kids ordered the ready-made deep dish cheese from the display while She and I ordered a margherita. The sauce here was much deeper and savory than my usual and it was very very good. The small tomatoes were really nice and the basil, as She notes, was excellent. The cheese was not the usual rounds I'd see on other margheritas, but I really liked it. I ate 4 of the slices of a 12" and was stuffed. An unassuming local spot that does it well. She Said: I tasted the deep dish that we had at the table, and was really impressed. Chicago-style pizza isn't usually my thing, but I would have absolutely eaten a whole piece and been happy about it. The crust was crispy and thick without being a hunk of bread, and the sauce was terrific. I thought the thin-crust pizza He and I shared was great. The cheese wasn't overwhelming but was definitely present, the tomatoes were pleasantly sweet, and the fresh basil was the perfect amount to finish it all off. It was a really well balanced pizza. And the young man working the register was very nice and attentive. I wish I'd gotten his name so I could give him a more personal shout-out. Potty Points: No trip to the potty for me today! read more

Great pizza and delivery. I love the thin crust sausage. Sausage isn't too spicy for me either. Loved it, thanks!

I was really craving some fettuccine pizza and their pizza completely exceeded my expectations. The pizza was amazing although I do think the cheese balls could use an improvement read more

Terrific neighborhood pizza and terrific staff! They have a few tables for dining in but they rely on delivery. Great prices too. My go to pizza place when I am visiting Wicker Park read more

Good pizza but terrible service. It took us a long time to get greeted or served. There was zero air conditioning, not even a fan and it was over 90 degrees when we went there. The woman at the front seemed annoyed that we were there. Although the pizza was good the atmosphere and service was subpar and sadly I cannot recommend this place. read more

I got one slice of their deep dish sausage pizza and was disappointed by the flavors. This might be because they didn't heat the pizza up enough and it was still quite cold when I ate it, but the flavors were bland and the pizza was harder than I'm used to. The crust was also very thick and doughy, not crispy and buttery like how I prefer my deep dish crust. There was something off about the flavor of the sausage as well, as if it was old or had gone bad. Overall, not the best Chicago deep dish you can get but if you are desperate it'll fill you up. read more

Bartoli’s Pizzeria - Deep dish sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all