First time here and the bagels were amazing! Soft, fresh, and chewy. I had the whole wheat everything bagel, and was pleasantly suprised. The Iced coffee was refreshing and on point. I would return. read more

I asked for fresh squeezed oj. I paid for fresh squeezed oj. I got tropicana in a cup.

Working at a construction site first day at the site a food truck comes in and everyone goes to get sandwiches except me I had yelped bagels and saw bagel smith and was looking forward to eating a good bacon egg and cheese on a bagel so I skipped on the sandwiches at the food truck (which looked good btw) I walk 5 blocks in 15 degree weather thinking it'll be so worth it I get there staff isn't bad wait time either price was 5 something I gladly paid it thinking it's gonna be soooo good grabbed my bagel walked back to the site opened my bag and realized wow I get more bagel than bacon egg or cheese took a bite and realized I wasted my time I should've gotten from the food truck because this was far from my expectations felt like I was eating bacon egg and cheese from Dunkin donuts and I can't stand Dunkin donuts bacon seemed microwaved and very little bacon at that bagel was OK.... I love bagels so I was looking forward to this being amazing but nope just bleh next time I'll stick to the food truck unless I find another bagel place close by read more

Bagelsmith - Cheap with the cheap bacon - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious bagels and coffee. Came here before hopping on the L train (subway is right next to it) and it brought back my bagel addiction. The bagels are fresh and the cream cheese is beyond delicious. read more

Employees don't use gloves properly to handle food. Watched several different employees either touch money with gloves on and then not change gloves and prepare food. OR simply touching their face/mouth with bare hands and then prepare food. Pretty sure this is a health violation. read more

The lady at the front was the only nice person, the guy with the glasses who took my order was attempting to be nice but came off so rude and obnoxious, & my bacon and cheese on a roll has literally 3 slices of bacon and 1 slice of cheese that wasn't even melted. Will not be coming back. It was my second attempt at trying them out. Don't bother. read more

this place is the first decent bagel i ever had. they're really good. even had an old one at 5pm once (toasted) and it was still good.

I was only in NY for a week, and we went here just about every morning. I dream of the veggie tofu spread on a whole-wheat everything bagel. Seriously. I have yet to find anything like it back in CA, boo :( read more

mediocre at best. The only draw of this place is that you can put $4 on a credit card. Bagels are decent, but nothing to write home about. I've ordered a toasted bagel and when i get to work 4 blocks away, the bagel is ice cold... barely toasted. Also, it would be nice if they could put my order in a bag with napkins instead of ignoring me as soon as they ring me up. This is apparently a chore... Whateves...like I said, the only draw of this place is the convenience. read more

Bagel Smith. I Love you. After my Zumba class, i was in despite need of their delicious chocolate chip cookies. I only ordered two. (LOL) Anyhoo, while leaving the store and coming home i must have dropped my phone. I was frantic. Checking my bag and coat pockets to no avail. Out of the blue, my dad calls and says did you text me. I'm like, no Daddy, u don't know how to text. But, it was my favorite bagel store, trying to locate the owner of the phone. Texting my dad was a great choice. I quickly called bagelsmith, and my phone was there waiting for me. Thank you bagel smith, for being tasty and great. read more

I love bagels. So I love this place. And I love that they're open late.

Best bagel place in Williamsburg. Great bacon, egg and cheese.

I have eaten here several times and it has been perfect both times. I love it and I recommend you to not listen to the negative comments as I am sure they are over exaggerating. Service is quick, easy and kind, no complaints here. 5 stars no questions asked. read more

Great place to stop for a quick and cheap bacon egg & cheese, and even perch to read while sipping on some good coffee. My go-to bagel place to duck into after hopping off the L. read more

Yelpers be warned! The most mediocre bagel I've ever had. I ordered a garlic bagel with vegetable cream cheese and it was awful. Bagel had like 3 crumbs of garlic on it. The vegetable watery cream cheese had 3 thinly sliced carrots in it...cool. So why charge so much for an average bagel. I could have gone to dunkin for way less. I don't mind spending a little more on a bagel but at least make it fresh and worth it. I guess eating a bagel at brooklyn bagel co made me high maintenance lol Do yourself a favor and go else where. Not worth coming here. LOL at their long line read more

I should also add that on the off chance there is something wrong with my order, everyone is more than willing to help fix it!

Got there at 5:10am this morning and wanted a bacon egg and cheese bagel and a coffee. Was told the grill wasn't on and coffee isn't ready.

The bagels here were good, not the best and not the worst. But the staff was so rude, I won't be going back. It's definitely not good enough to put up with bad attitudes. read more

Small, cramped, extremely hot. Got order completely wrong. Will not go back. Threw out the food and wasted $20.

After throwing my cookies last night while trying to recover from a respiratory infection, I decided to revisit my usual craving- a toasted cinnamon raisin bagel with lowfat cream cheese from Bagel Smith! Not only was the bagel super delicious- the bagel is thick, soft on the inside and crispy on the outside and the cream cheese is tasty and creamy, but the staff there is also walys so nice. They deliver the bagel in a bag with an old fashioned "Thank you. Have a good day" with a sincere smile and firm look in the eyes. All this great service and food, despite the fact that there is often a line of people outside waiting for their delicious bagels as well. read more

I can't see how they could be doing anything better. The food is great and the service is friendly, quick, and attentive.

Solid Bagels. Quick Service.

Good bagels. If you get yours with lox like I do, they'll be skimpy on the lox, but who in this town isn't? Really stellar chocolate rugelach and a friendly manager who's loved in Williamsburg his whole life. Happily told me about the old days in a crusty old-Brooklyn kinda way. read more

Long line and the food had no taste. Bagel was OK, but poor for sandwiches.

The bagels here are great. The staff is friendly. On weekend mornings there is a bit of a line, but they try to get you through as fast as possible. read more

I have ordered from Bagelsmith for the past 4 years because I enjoy the bagels/bagel sandwiches that they make. I order the same sandwich pretty much every time using Seamless and I can confidently say, after having ordered this sandwich anywhere between 50-75 times, it almost arrives incorrectly prepared (probably 95% of the time). Condiments are left off even when written in all caps on the order fifteen times in a row. I was driven to write a review today out of frustration because I requested cheddar cheese and got muenster for some reason - even though the post-it note they use to communicate the order to the preparer says "Dar" (indicating cheddar cheese). Sometimes, I even go to Bagelsmith in person to place the order and either have to correct the sandwich maker in the process of making the sandwich after watching them leave condiments off (when I JUST told them how I'd like the sandwich prepared). I've even left the store after purchasing the sandwich only to arrive at home and find out it was not made correctly. In my humble opinion, sandwich preparation is not rocket science, but some folks seem to be asleep at the wheel. The level of hassle involved in calling the restaurant to request a new sandwich or to request forgotten condiments has overwhelmed my desire either for the sandwich or to remain a paying customer, so I will not be ordering from here again. read more

Wow the thought the bagel store was kind'ov bad this place is very small and expensive if u dont have a good budget or do dont go......bagel store best bagels in williamsburg..these bagels taste like plastic..THE BAGEL STORE IS VERY BIG compared to this hell hole read more

Thought I'd get a bagel after a night out. Fortunately, I was not drinking that much. Ended up getting a few cents change from a ten. They fixed that quickly, but I would not trust them to count change... Going to Brooklyn Gourmet Deli next time. The egg and cheese is way better. read more

Their EVERYTHING BAGELS are a-mazing; I go here 4+ times a week. Love Bagelsmith!!!!!!! (not sure how I feel about their new signs though)

I too, like many, discovered the delights of Bagelsmith at 3am. Whilst not the best bagels in NYC or Brooklyn, Bagelsmith has a wide variety of fillings, very tasty freshly baked bagels and perfectly good coffee (as Ian Y mentions, it's damn hot). The staff are friendly and suggestive too - overall, a very enjoyable bagel dining experience! read more

Awesome bagels, especially the lox plate. Baked goods are delicious as well. Prices are on the high end, but that goes with the neighborhood of course. read more

Huge selection of vegan cream cheeses (as well as normal), fast service, amazing bagel quality. Kinda awful coffee, but it's hard to care, because bagelsmith has saved me. Friend visiting NY and wants a bagel for lunch? Bagelsmith. Woke up too early and want a decent breakfast before work? Bagelsmith. And most importantly: Drunk at 3 a.m. and need a bite with your date? Bagelsmith. read more

This place is a JOKE!!! I ordered a ham and cheese omelette with a bagel and cream cheese, the omelette came out, and after 8 minutes he started toasting the bagel , I told him not to bother, my eggs were getting cold, I got home to a Western omelette?!?! I HATE BELL PEPPERS!!!!! They have a TEA party sign about how the government is inconveniencing you by charging taxes behind the register.....they should stop with politics and focus on service and guest satisfaction instead. Too bad, so convenient, but so incompetent, they lost a great potential costumer. read more

Small place but they are part of my routine. Pretty good bagels a mind blowing selection of cream cheeses (vegan and non). Good selection of drinks. Not the best bagels you can find but it is leaps and bounds better than anything you can find in the area. read more

Toasted bagel barely toasted. I scraped all the cream cheese off to put on 1/8th of the bagel, because there was only about a teaspoon of cream cheese on the whole thing. Threw the rest of the dry bread away. A line out the door means you can afford to put more than a tic tac of cream cheese on a bagel. read more

Good reviews on here and very crowded on a Sunday Brunch time. We both had expensive egg and cheese bagels. The egg was disgustingly runny and the cheese flavorless and very very buttery. A small orange juice was $4. Avoid this place! There are lots of lovely other (cheaper) bagel places in the area. Left a nasty taste in my mouth. read more

Just what I needed with a suitable hangover when I was being so indecisive as to what food I could actually stomach. Went with a friend who opted for the cream cheese and avocado while I picked the cream cheese and lox salmon. Absolutely divine! My sure if it was my lack of appetite or their portion sizes but I could've probably just shared one with my friend as they are pretty decent in size. Great value for money and v filling! read more

The selection and quality of bagels merits the name Bagelsmith. I was especially impressed by their tofu spreads. However, breakfast rushes are real and delivery takes hours even outside of breakfast time. Visit for the food, but be prepared to wait for it. read more

The only bad thing I can say about the Bagelsmith is their seating area leaves a lot to be desired (its basically non-existent). Otherwise, this place rules. Easily in my top 5 of best bagel places in the world. The cream cheese selection is full of variety and extremely tasty. Try their yogurt as well, sooooo good. A must if you're ever in the Burg looking for breakfast. read more

Plain toasted bagel with munster cheese and butter, yummy! coffee is good to.