We stopped for a quick brunch. I ordered a bagel, with an egg, and a side of fresh fruit…read more Let me tell you, the freshly made, warm, "everything" bagel was so tender! The cream cheese spread easily and the scrambled egg was perfectly cooked. The fresh fruit salad was so delicious. The combination of pineapple, cantaloupe, melon and sliced oranges were so fresh. Free parking just outside the door.

I love that this bagel shop is in my neighborhood! My favorite to order is a bagel sandwich with…read morehalf egg salad and half tuna salad. I love this with an onion bagel or wheat bagel, but other flavors would be good too. Comes with a pickle spear and is a wonderful lunch! I always look at the pastry/sweets case while waiting, but I've yet to try them. Maybe next time!

While visiting from out of state, I stopped by The Bagelry and had a fantastic experience! The…read moreowner and staff were incredibly friendly, welcoming, and courteous. I ordered the Garden bagel sandwich, and it was fresh, perfectly made, and absolutely delicious. It was one of the highlights of my visit, and if I'm ever back in Cincinnati, I'll definitely stop in again!

Their bagel sandwhiches are great. I enjoy the ability to customize sandwhich and smears. I have…read morenever encountered them selling out of bagels however I have only visited only earlier in the morning. They have parking behind the building.

Ordered online for family of 4. Trying to support small business…read more Got there, didn't see my order and had to wait 20 min. Guy was working alone which I get, but no eye or customer service. Also, bagels didn't have the bacon on two of the sandwiches

Updating my review. Haven't been here in over a year and a half. Bagels are different (it's just…read morebread), their flavored cream cheeses are not flavored, bacon not cooked, and I got half an egg. Super disappointed.

The workers are so helpful and always have a smile on their face. The bagels are awsome and I love…read moretrying new thing!

Although I've been to the location in Eastgate, I prefer going to the smaller location in Fairfax…read moreas it's on my way to work. I love the selection of bagels there. They also have great seasonal coffee flavors and drinks. I like this location as they have a drive thru. The bagel chips are always tasty and you can buy day old bagels there too. Friendly service. One of my favorite breakfast spots.

Hot Heidi. Ready on time. Great staff. Always delicious…read more Make sure to order online it can get a little busy. Some outdoor seating, typically pretty busy, but to be expected when your food is this good.

I have heard so much about this place recently and I love a good sandwich so I know that I had to…read morestop in ASAP. I stopped by for a quick lunch during the week and wanted an easy to-go sandwich. They have a medium sized menu but a lot of different options which makes it a bit hard to pick haha! I decided on a reuben sandwich with all of the fixens inside. I was surprised that I was the only one in there because of the amount of rave reviews. It was a small quaint little place. The employees were suppperrrr nice and gave me a lot of time to think about my order. The vibes in there were very cool with fun music and just overall a good time. Now onto the Reuben. Holy cow! It was juicy and very flavorful, with the perfect amount of sauerkraut. The bread was toasty and the sandwich was nice and warm but not too hot. I think this will be a new spot for me for lunch!

This place was so banger. Didn't expect much but I was really surprised at how good it was. Wish I…read moreworked in the building so I could go everyday.

I love bagel stop! Every time I'm downtown I always get the same thing…read more A turkey zinger on a plain bagel and it's oh so good! I'm there maybe once every 2 months and the ladies shocked me by knowing my order. I enjoy getting I speak with them when I come in.

This place has all the low quality amenities and downtrodden appearance of a hidden gem but the…read morefood tastes exactly how the place looks: bad. Bagel sandwich was dry, overcooked and something I would expect a college freshman to make in their dorm room with a toaster oven and frozen meat. I should have taken the Open sign being off as a warning to potential customers to avoid this place. The bathroom is one of the worst I've used in a public setting including the third world. Hungover? Hungry? Try your luck elsewhere.

Great prices on some very good bagels and very good servings given the cost of the sandwich…read more Service is quick and friendly, and they have a pretty good selection of different options every day. Probably my favorite thing is you can get a day old donut for 60 cents, that's the kind of quality transparency we need in this world. I got a pair of omelet sandwiches on some delicious breads and left out for under 10 bucks, very tough to beat

What a gem! I stopped into this cute coffee shop as it has rave reviews and it certainly lived up…read moreto the hype! I tried the Brown Bear latte with almond milk which was sooo delicious along with the everything bagel croissant with chive cream cheese. My God on today it was absolutely amazing! It was flaky on the outside and soft on the inside just how I like it. The staff was super sweet and gave great recommendations. Literally can't wait to get back and try more of the pastries! The place overall is fairly small but there's a few tables to dine in. There is metered street parking downtown and they get really busy on the weekends and sell out very quickly so I would recommend trying them during the week when it's more calm.

Pleasantly surprised with their coffee! Definitely worth adding to your pastry order. Cinnamon roll…read morewas solid, orange zest on it was unique but not really my thing. Definitely going to come back to try another pastry sometime! Service is excellent, they have great recommendations based on what you like. Cozy place to sit & eat if you can nab a table in time.