Quality breakfast place. We had delivery from here and it was spot on. The yogurt with fruit and granola was great. It was one big bowl of yogurt with fruit and granola underneath. The bagels were chewy and tasty. You could tell they made these bagels with care and attention. The assortment of fruit was also fresh. Overall great experience. read more

See all

This is the bagel place where everyone in Commack goes to on a Saturday/Sunday morning. The line is often long but moves quickly. The staff is friendly and funny. If you go during rush hour, it might be tough to get a table. The bagels and cream cheeses are very good, my particular favorite being the lox spread. The bagels and cream cheese here are quite expensive for a Long Island bagel shop which is a drawback, but they are of good quality. read more

Bagel Chalet - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

My favorite bagel spot! The bagels and all their sandwich creations are delicious here! Everyone that works here is super friendly and takes the time to get to know the regular customers by name! It's a popular spot so the lines can get long! Call ahead if you are in a rush. read more

went thereon 6/15. a premade salad with chicken( $9.99) and strawberries in cup container (5.99) came to $17.00+..i kicked back the strawberries.. over- over priced. plus the now have added a surcharge and call it cash discount. a cash discount policy- is when you post 4%higher prices- for credit card transactions. you have to post the higher retail amounts. then give the 4% discount on a cash purchase. its not a cash discount if all you discount is the fee!! read more

Fall from grace...I have been frequenting the Chalet for 35 years and today was the last time. After waiting 25 minutes just to place my order, and watching grub hub orders fly out the door, I was disappointed with my meal. I have always loved their walnut chicken salad, Today it was terrible. Made with dark meat and hardly any walnuts or craisins as promised. Had it on a multigrain bagel that was hard. My husband had the plain chicken salad on a roll that was stale and the salad was over salted. Sad to see the decline but my frequenting days are over. read more

Ordered bagels on DoorDash, an hour later they still hadn't started my order. I'm sure they're busy but if you can't handle tending to online orders with the same importance as walk in customers, don't take the orders. read more

Went here for breakfast a couple times while visiting family on Long Island. Went on a weekday around 9am and it wasn't too busy thankfully. They have a large selection of breakfast items and bagels/spreads. We got some bacon, egg and cheese sandwiches one morning and the other we got a couple different bagels with cream cheese and lox. Everything was fantastic and the service was quick, efficient and Friendly. I also liked their iced coffees. Would definitely recommend you check it out if you're in the area. read more

Once again, I go to pick up an egg sandwich for someone. The store wasn't busy. All u asked for was 1 egg scrambled, with cheese and extra bacon.. i was charged a small fortune for this becausr they make sure to get their money, not only is there no extra bacon but there is none. They put a disgusting looking egg on a roll and wrapped it. Whi the hell checks their order for an egg sandwich. $16 for a large ice tea and they egg sandwich, believe me the guy told the girl at the register 3x to charge me for extra bacon. The sandwich is inedible but so, so happy BAGEL CHALET charged me for nothing. Shame in them Think twice before going read more

Have always been a bagel chalet Stan. Whether you need to bring in work breakfast, hangover cure or want to grab bagels with friends, this place does it all. Delicious bagels and my personal favorite- flagels! Can't go wrong here read more

Bagel Chalet is kind of the bagel rock star of the local community. Expect a line no matter what time you get in, but their service never suffers for it which is commendable. Prices are reasonable and there is lots of seating, entire store is kept clean so kudos for that. One negative thing is that they sometimes have tofu cream cheese and sometimes not, and when they do it's just the plain one. I would think a busy shop like this might offer more to vegans / lactose intolerant / dietary or religious preferences influencing diet but nah. I got a cinnnamon raisin bagel with peanut butter and avocado, which I admit sounds disgusting but it's friggin' amazing. Try it. Tryyyyyy ittttttttttt. read more

One of the best breakfast spots around. The line is usually long but they work through it very quickly. Their bacon, egg and cheese is the perfect hangover cure. read more

Found this spot the day before looking for a cup of coffee that was NOT sbucks. Found this gem and decided to come back for breakfast. Place is extremely clean, staff friendly...and food is excellent! Its not just "bagels" as name implys, but much more. Sipping a nice hot cup of black coffee, everything bagel, and watching the hustle of locals starting the here. You should try breakfast, lunch, or tailgate sandwiches here! read more

Bagel Chalet - A nice cup of steaming hot coffee while I wait for my ham, egg, & cheese on an everything bagel. Place is already bustling...love this gem! - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

I've ordered from here several times for lunch at work and only had a problem once with my salad but it was a big deal. My bagels have always come toasted with butter as requested. Today they just gave me a bagel. Not toasted and no butter. Literally just a bagel. When I called about this I spoke to nick the manager and he said he would either give me a bagel the next time I come or something of equal value but would not be able to deliver me a bagel. I work a full time job. I am not able to just go to this place to pick up a bagel for their mistake. This is horrible customer service and what is next weeks bagel going to do for my stomach now?? Thanks a lot for nothing nick. read more

I'm giving 5 stars solely because the salads are so good! I haven't really gotten much else aside from bagels and bagel chips. It's reasonable priced and pretty fast service considering it's always busy and the staff is making custom chopped salads. There are so many options, you can get exactly what you want. Bagel Chalet has casual seating but I personally wouldn't feel comfortable sitting at this point because of COVID. It doesn't seem like there's much ventilation and everyone eating has their masks off. There doesn't seem to be many precautions put in place to help stop the spread. For example, I didn't see any tables closed to separate patrons, there didn't seem to be a limit for how many people could be inside, and no one stands 6 feet apart. Not a safe place for at-risk people but good for take out. read more

I have been a Bagel Chalet, COMMACK NY customer for over 30 years (both owners.) I support local business and have enjoyed Bagel Chalet's service and food for a very long time. But I need to share what happened to me last week so you can make safe choices for yourself during and after this pandemic. I am a 66-year-old woman and was on the line social distancing last week and wearing my mask. The area can be tight while waiting in line, but everyone ahead of me was keeping their distance. As I was waiting, a group of young people got in line behind me. One of the couples (clearly under the influence of a substance) were being very inappropriate and kept bumping into me. I moved ahead a little, and they moved as well; I realized what was happening, so I asked if they could keep their distance and showed them the markers on the floor to indicate where everyone should be standing. In the loudest tone, the guy looked at me, then called me a vulgar word several times, and then took off his mask and coughed directly on me. The store went silent. All of the counter clerks stopped and watched, including the owner Nick. I stood up for myself and told him to quit it and back up. He proceeded to repeat the vulgar words without a mask. A male customer stepped in and told him to stop that language and be respectful while another male customer went up to Nick to tell him what was going on, but Nick watched the whole scene and did absolutely nothing. He never told the young man to put his mask back on; he didn't tell him to calm down or make him leave the premises. He just stood behind the front counter in full view and did nothing to protect his customers. After I placed my order, I walked to the counter to pay, Nick just looked at me and never said a word...no sorry, no I will speak to this fool once he sits down; he did not even ask if I was okay after being verbally assaulted at his establishment while he watched. So after 30 years of frequenting this establishment, the Bagel Chalet and I will part ways...Nick and his staff should be ashamed of themselves for not supporting a customer that has walked through those doors multiple times a week for three decades. The almighty dollar was too much for Nick to think clearly and do the right thing! Be safe out there... read more

Among the best bagels around. House coffee is great My favorite: Hungary mans sandwich on a roll! read more

These guys make some pretty good bagels. As a non-New Yorker, I may not be the most qualified reviewer but when I get a bagel from here and eat it the same day, the taste difference is huge! They also have a great selection of sandwich and salad options. Occasionally, the line and the wait can get long though and appear a little chaotic. read more

The bagels are good!,,now the reason for the two stars. This bagel establishment is the most expensive I have visited, including Manhattan. The prices do not reflect the quality,service or cleanliness of this place. If you want to spend 100.00 on breakfast for four people than this should be your go to ..... Lol. Do yourself a favor, stear clear. ! Lastly I wanted to convey my discontent with the additude of the people serving you. If your not ready or take a bit to order be prepared for the service to diminish quickly. Sadly this was a good bagel jaunt that has now become overpriced,understaffed and quality of food is suffering... read more

Gross burned bacon. Burnt bacon is carcinogen. Brown avocado. Constantly screw up order. Gluten free bagels not gluten free. I hate spending hard earned money on food I can make at all 100 times better. read more

The bagels used to be fabulous here , not sure what happened since COVID ??? The bagels are no where near the same anymore ... it's a local business we love we hope they can recover . read more

I give the food 3/5 stars but I had to take off a one star for how overpriced this place is. Sausage egg and cheese and two bagels with CC and bacon cost $17. Which is about $6 more than it costs at my local bagel place. Hell thats more expensive than you would pay in Manhattan. read more

wowza. bagel chalet use to be THE deli to go to. Their food is superb but the quality of how the food is made has gone done significantly. Literally EVERYTIME i get something they screw up my order. I just got a bagel lightly toasted with cream cheese and when i was driving home i looked at my bagel it was literally put on the panini press.... lmao what is going on with the service here???? also the price of everything has literally doubled. I shouldn't keep coming back but the food is so delicious. just because the food is good doesn't mean the lack of service should have taken such a fall. woof. read more

The people that work here are the best. Always so friendly, fast, and efficient. The bagels are also really good and there's tons of cream cheese options. Give the workers a raise - they are the real reason people will come back read more

Bagel Chalet - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Taking off stars because I think this place is completely over priced and has wayyyyyyyy too many people inside without a mask during a global pandemic BUT you can't beat a fresh chopped salad. read more

They charged me 16 dollars for a SMALL chicken salad that had a few avocados in it. Biggest rip off on Long Island!!! Next I paid 6.99 for micro sandwich and with two seltzers my tiny meal cost us 26 dollars. Never go here unless you want to be ripped off. Ask to see how big your order will be and you will walk out after hearing the price. Huge mistake wasting my money here... read more

Bagel Chalet - Here is the tiny meal you get for 26 dollars. - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Honestly never ordered from here before but it's looks really good . The only thing is that there system sucks. Employee made a big deal that I came in through the FRONT ENTRANCE instead of the back in the building. No signs no where. They make us do a line and when order comes out they don't call it out. And they get upset when we are looking through the orders they are putting out. It waist time out of the delivery drivers. Really upset and would like to know what's the big deal. read more

I haven't been to this place in years. And I use to be a steady customer buying bagels for my family The past week I decided to stop in since I was in the neighborhood and get a dozen The bagels looked thin almost the size and thickness is DD donuts My order consisted of everything cinnamon n raisin and plain. I got them home and they were hard and chewy. Almost like they where not proofed long enough or very little yeast The store is clean and staff friendly but the staple product was the worst that I ever bought. read more

These guys make the best BLT ever! So much bacon I was afraid for my arteries...but definitely going back for more!! read more

First, let me say the rating is about service not food. Bagel Chalet is our go to bagel store for take out, brunch, and Jewish Holidays. So I pre paid on Mother's Day and for curbside pickup. I called numerous times, but the line was either busy or not answered. Forced to enter the store, I was APPALLED by the total disregard for New York State Social Distancing Requirements. The store was packed inside and it was business as usual. It is very disappointing that a local merchant would have such disregard for their customers. There could have been a plan in place, since they told me they were anticipating a very busy morning. The least they could have done is have customers wait outside. Lastly, I have to rethink about future business because of this negative experience. Karen G read more

Place has INSANE high prices. They have some nerve charging $5 for a bagel with cream cheese. Should be $2.75, as it used to be... some nerve this place has. Don't go unless you want to spend an arm and a leg! Bagel is decent but not worth $5 for a plain bagel with cream cheese read more

Why did I never go here before?! Everything was so good! I tried the Cuban Cubano sandwich and my husband, in the mood for brunch, ordered a bacon egg & cheese in a sesame bagel. We both ordered iced lattes. The Cubano was delicious, on a perfectly toasted panini. His bagel was incredibly soft and fresh, SO good! The eggs and bacon & everything were of good quality, very good! We recommend the caramel latte! I tried Hazelnut and it was OK, but it depends what kind of hazelnut flavoring you're used to, you might enjoy it more than I did. The coffee quality was great though. Service was excellent, everyone was so friendly and helpful! It was very busy there, and it was obvious why. Oh and btw we took home some lentil soup, definitely recommend it. Comes with a buttered bagel too! Update: have come here many times now and they are definitely one of my favorite bagel spots in LI. On the pricey side, but well worth it. read more

TERRIBLE!!! I just got from Uber eats it took almost 1 hour to make 2 damn shit bagels. It came cold and I couldn't even eat cause everything was wrong. ill never order anything again. $32 to go to garbage. read more

Stop catering to all the uber eats/door dash people and instead maybe focus on giving the food to the people who ordered in store. My egg sandwich sat in the window for 5 minutes before the counter people got through the 15 people waiting for delivery app orders. Thanks for the lukewarm sandwich read more

Ordered a hungry man (sausage bacon ham egg and cheese on hero) and received a hero with two eggs on it. They regularly screw up orders, but come on.... read more

The build your own salad option is fantastic! You fill out your sheet and hand it to the team to create it for you! Always fresh and is a huge portion! It also comes with a side (I love the warm pita). The staff is also SO nice! 10/10 recommend read more

Bagels are really good, but they sell low-carb bagels which, in my experience as a seasoned NY bagel savant, is heretical!! The check-in line is also horribly disorganized. There is no continuity between ordering your meal, getting your coffee, and checking out. It is all discombobulated and confusing, and items are sure to be missed, especially on busy days. That said, there is a lot of seating, so it's good if you want to bagel and dine with friends and family. And there are lots of options, including plenty of types of paninis, and more than just deli coffee. They also had a selection of espresso-based beverages, which is quite unusual for a Long Island bagel shop. read more

We bought bagels from here today to notice after we paid that the staff does not wear gloves on both hands and also touches a variety of surfaces with their bare hands. We throw our bagels out and will not return. read more

Ordered a bacon egg and cheese sandwich and the bacon had mold in it! Even smelled strange and tasted strange. Pretty disgusting!

Horrible experience! Never come back! I ordered a salad and they made me fill a paper. I filled the paper but they didn't follow what I wanted. Forgot my goat cheese (which I paid 1$ extra for that) then they forgot another topping (pineapple) I can't believe!!! Horrible experience! Finally, they served my salad and he didn't give me a fork!!!! Lol I don't eat with my hands! I can understand 1 mistake but not 3! Horrible experience! Food is good! But they kill everything with the service! Sorry guys read more

I've been a loyal Bagel Chalet customer for YEARS! Nick and his team did a great job in upscaling after purchasing from the previous owners. Freshly made food! Bagels are delicious. And..... they make low carb multi-grain bagels......which I order with light veggie tuna! A BIG THUMBS UP! read more