Bagels are consistently delicious and the best in town. Have ordered from them through the pandemic and couldn't be happier. Thank you!

I could sit here all day and tell you all the reasons I love this place.. it's a bit over priced but it's so good. Everything is absolutely delicious.. best bagels in the Mack. Go check them out! read more

This place is terrible! They have decent food but its completely overpriced. I have ordered from here many times because my office is in an area with limited delivery options. They get my order wrong 3 out of 4 times. Its not that hard. Today I asked for something on the side-it was mixed in. And my bagel is missing. The place is called bagel chalet and they never remember the bagel. I'm done!! read more

this place is so horrible. i only eat here occasionally because i work across the street. i'm giving them 2 stars because the bagels are ok. everytime i eat here they always mess up my order. i'm writing another review because i just asked for a bagel toasted with butter... of course it was burnt. completely fed up read more

Bagel Chalet - Bagels Near Me - Commack, New York

Love me some Bagel Chalet. Puts the other local bagel shops to shame. On weekends go EARLY.... read more

Got the French toast bagel it was hard as a rock strawberry cream cheese was good though- make sure you order it on the side, because they will put way too much read more

The food is fresh and the staff works hard at keeping the line moving. Prices are almost insane especially for what you get. The portions are often masked by things you add like lettuce and tomatoes meanwhile the meat portion are small, cheese is cut thin and while you stand at the register the prices are almost pulled out of the air. Before you know it that extra egg, cheese or acai can double your already ski high cost. I ordered a roast beef with cheese, lettuce and tomato and it was over $12 with no drink or chips! Definitely wasn't worth it. Also after you order you have no clue where to wait. Its not organized in that sense. I'm searching for a more affordable, wallet friendly place. There are too many bagel places out there to not try and get what you pay for. Oh and before I forget the bagels are a bit too chewy and the everything bagel is a crap shoot. Sometimes good but mostly not so much. read more

Been coming to this bagel shop for years, and it's my go to every week. The mornings, 7-9am, are as you expect, crazy. The line reaches the deli counter with people bunched up a little but the staff keeps it moving at a decent pace pushing orders out. Their sandwiches are something I crave now and then, like the cougar, but as you expect I always go for their bagels that are made fresh everyday!! I love their variety of special cream cheese, specially their jalapeno and the scallion cream cheese. If you're their in the afternoon, about an hour or so before close they have bags of cheap bagels. Worth it if you have a sudden craving for tons of carbs. read more

i am a female who does door dash. i can not even explain to you the things i have heard the owner say about his female co workers as well as the female costumers on multiple different occasions. i can't say anything good or bad about the food but i can tell you that if you're a women, prepare to be objectified when walking in there and being greeted by the owner. 0/5 stars. read more

I ordered lunch from the Bagel Chalet to be delivered to my office. My initial order didn't meet the minimum requirement so they said I had to order something additional. I added more to the order so that I could have it delivered. When the delivery man showed up (over an hour later) there was an additional $8 (which they also taxed) on my bill. I told him that I was advised the delivery was no charge and he said he's just the driver. I felt bad for him because it wasn't his fault but I will never order from them again. I ended up paying the "delivery charge" but I will never ever order from here again. read more

Ordered salad online for pickup...requested egg whites in place of hard boiled eggs as stated on the order attached to the bag but found hard boiled eggs when I opened the salad.....also ordered and paid extra for avocado which was not added.....if you're going to offer online ordering, you should at least make an effort to prepare it correctly!! read more

Best bagels and service on Long Island. I am a bagel snob and grew up here but now live out of state. When I come to town this is where I head. Fast friendly service. Nice deli. Get the egg everything you can't go wrong. read more

Line is always long but there are so many options so it's understandable! Call ahead if you have a big order. Food is good.

Good bagels but way over priced. Must have high rent in that strip mall. I ordered a dozen and a half bagels and a pound of cream cheese and 2 buttered bagels and paid $48. The girl in front of me ordered eggs on a bagel prob paid $7-$9 and got free coffee with hers! I asked the guy that helped me if I got free coffee and he said NO! Smug SOB. read more

YUM YUM YUM. Visiting from out of state and needed to fill my bagel craving. My friend brought me here (again) and I was not disappointed. Somewhat of a line for a Saturday morning, not terrible though. I had a bacon, egg and cheese on Asiago and a pumpkin bagel with chocolate chip cream cheese since I couldn't decide. Only downside was ringing out then waiting for my breakfast sandwich to be ready. Well worth the wait though! I ended up only eating half of my bagel with cream cheese but took it with me and ate it later in the day - still delicious! read more

Bagel Chalet has something for everyone. Bagels, sandwiches, salads, grab n go snacks are just a few options. I actually didn't look over the entire menu as it was so vast. I came here twice, once for a bagel breakfast sandwich and once for a panini. They open early and you have your choice of bagels that you can add eggs, meat, and cheese to for an easy breakfast. The panini I got was the mediterranean chicken and came perfectly grilled with chunks of chicken breast. Prices are cheap, I was surprised when the total was around $13 for a panini (that came w/ side salad) and a loaded bagel breakfast sandwich. Super friendly and efficient staff here too. read more

I wish I could give them 0 stars. I don't know why I keep giving them chances since they mess up my order EVERY time I go. The things I order are not difficult either, but they can not seem to get it right. Seems like they're in a rush to get the food ready but I rather wait a little longer and get what I asked for, or at least a fully cooked meal. read more

The bagels and egg sandwiches are great. The pick up on the run items are good too. Atmosphere is pleasant for a bagel place. Sometime they are in a rush and get the order wrong, so just double check. Worth a stop. read more

Terrible experience today!! Within 10 min there were 3 incorrect orders. I asked front desk to make our order correct and the team still did not get it right. Waited a total of 30 min and walked out the door. Told the manager i'm never going back. Management and team breakdown today needs to be fixed! read more

Stopped there this morning for a everything bagel with butter and a coffee. Nearly 6 bucks for a nothing bagel with almost no butter and a poor cup of coffee. People who go here are getting a poor value. Glad I dont live by this store. There were a few little seed crumbs on the bagel. Go to places like Brooklyn bagel where you get a quality bagel and a descent coffee for less. So many better places. Panera is even better. Who does your quLity control? Nest part is most people leave the store before finding out how bad this is read more

Stopped by the morning after Thanksgiving. The employees were so friendly and helpful, despite being incredibly busy that often included a line wrapping around the store. Bagels were delicious as usual. read more

Best bagels!!! They have a variety of bagels including the egg flagel which is what I usually get. Although I'm not sure why the flagel costs more, and it's smaller than the regular bagel. They also have a variety of cream cheeses. I also order the sandwiches here. Delicious. The breaded chicken cutlet btl in a flagel is the bomb. Although this place is expensive I'm not going to lie. Their pricing is pretty mysterious too. I ordered 2 sandwiches and it mysteriously came out to be $25. Probably added an extra dollar for the bagel being a flagel instead of the regular bagel... But I will never know. I can never seem to figure out how they come up with the numbers. The cash registers are old school and they will not give you a detailed receipts. So other than their pricing downfall, their food is really good. Place is always busy. Long lines . So if you're in a rush - maybe come back another time. read more

I have never had a bad experience here. My go-to bagel order is a Egg Everything with cream cheese. I have gotten this order atleast 10x from here and I always seem to be pleased with the staff and the quality of the food. However it is on the pricier side but this is where you are going to find the best bagels around! read more

Not only did it take over 10 min to get a bacon egg on a roll, they forgot the bacon that is clearly marked. The process needs to change. Nobody double checking orders and a not so busy morning. read more

The only bagel place on LI i enjoy eating at. I have been coming here for years and I refuse to get bagels from anywhere else. The staff for the most part is very friendly, especially Gilbert! It is usually very busy, what I find is the best way to beat the line is to order while you are in the parking lot. Just walk right up to the front and you're order should be ready in about 10-15 minutes. They have great specials such as the commuter special and the soups always come with a buttered bagel of your choice. Other items such as the salads and sandwiches can get a little pricey, but it's worth it. They also have a wide variety of cream cheeses, pastries, and drinks. There is something for everyone. Place is always clean, they always have someone cleaning the tables once someone gets up. The only complaint I have, which isn't their fault, is that they have regular customers in the morning who order a cup of coffee and, dare I say, bogart the seats for a few hours. Just very annoying if you want to sit and relax before heading out. Bottom line, great place for bagels and pretty much everything else they make. Call ahead if you want to beat the morning, Saturday and Sunday busy times. read more

Just charged $7 for an egg sandwich and small coffee. Ridiculous. I knew this place was expensive but come on. Food is adequate, good variety and plenty of seating. But for a better bagel, better food overall and a MUCH better deal do yourself a favor and try the Everything Bagel around the corner on Commack Road read more

I love their bagels here! They seem busy most of the time but it's worth the wait. There's a lot to choose from between bagels, desserts, sandwiches and salads. Best place to eat breakfast and lunch! read more

I had the eggplant sandwich on an everything flatbread The sandwich included a portabella mushroom, mozzarella, peppers It was good but a bit salty... The service was lacking, my order took a very long time to be ready. And the server presumed it was to go... Place was Crowded The line at the cashier is a DISASTER. I would not eat here again read more

This is the BEST bagel place I have ever been to. Having grown up on Long Island I have eaten many bagels and at many bagel shops. Bagel Chalet has the best bagels - even low carb bagels. And they also have the best service. No matter how long the line on a Saturday or Sunday morning - it moves and it moves quickly. All the guys behind the counter are very helpful, friendly and always have a smile. The egg salad is the best I have ever had followed by the honey mustard chicken salad. The roasted cauliflower is fantastic. My husband loves the paninis and their baked goods. Now that I am not living in the area full time I really miss this place a lot. Bagel Chalet on Long Island has the best bagels. I can't wait to come back home and get some more to take out west. Love you guys!! read more

I am on a hunt for the best bagel place in Western Suffolk and Bagel Chalet is in my top 5 so far. Bagels are chewy and have a good texture. Cream cheese, salad, and sandwich selections are varied and fresh. Had the "Rachel" sandwich pressed on a pita and really enjoyed it. Cole slaw and potato salad were also tasty and the iced tea tastes of actual tea! It's a touch too far from me to be a real regular place but I would definitely be back. read more

We tried this place because we heard great things about it. However, we weren't very impressed. It's not better than our usual bagel spot "The Everything Bagel Commack." The service is good, but the bagels are very, very small AND more expensive than those at our usual place--$1.50 for a bagel at Bagel Chalet versus $1.00 at The Everything Bagel. Not worth going back here. read more

Bagel Chalet is great and the owner Nick is very nice. They also are really on the ball with service- even with a long line they can get you through pretty quick, especially in comparison to other bagel stores in the area. The food is very good ! read more

The best bagels on Long Island. Always fresh and while there is always a long line it is SO worth it. The chopped salad bar is amazing and the service is friendly and fun. GO THERE! read more

The best bagel place around, nobody can compare with the quality and speed that they serve up food. The owner is out on the front lines everyday with his crew, extremely admirable. Can only speak blessings of this restaurant. Must go for out of towners. read more

Oh yeah, I love me some bagels! It's my national food, of course, and these babies never disappointed. Chewy and soft, well-sized with good choice of shmears. Miss you, baby :( read more

These might be the best bagels on Long Island. Even though the line reaches the door most weekend mornings, it's WORTH it. I love the plain, the asiago cheese bagel (a bagel covered in a layer of asiago -- it's life changing), the multigrain and the whole wheat. We usually just get the bagels whole, with nothing on them. That said, their available premade paninis and desserts/muffins also look good. read more

Best bagels anywhere ! I moved an hour away and still get my bagels here

Mmmmmmmmmmm bagel chalet!!! The best bagel place around! I take the 10 min drive just to avoid the one in my town!

i ordered an egg sandwich and bottle of water. i asked how much it was gonna be .. i was told 10.00 plus tax. the delivery man asked for 20.00 for the total bill without tip. they added a 7. 00 delivery charge ... so it cost me 20.00 for and egg sandwich and water.. they never mentioned a del charge.. I work for a company that employs 50 people . this was the second time this has happened. we called to complain about added charges to the bill without prior knowledge.. we will never buy here again .. stay away ! BTW THE WEBSITE SAYS 2.50 DEL CHARGE.. read more

Bagels,sandwiches, and service all done really well. Haven't had any issues, there may be a line but it moves along and your never disappointed so it's worth the wait. read more