Coming here for years and it's never ever change. Nice. hard working guys r there always trying to help. Never disappointed neither me or any friends of mine that I'm meeting here for cup of coffee and veggie wrap. Do u know what bagel boy have in common w/Mcdonald? It doesn't matter which McDonald u r going to step by at their French fries and burgers are always going to taste the same! So does Bagel Boy! Years ago when they were on Ocean Ave and Ave Y and Frank used to greet you with his sweet smile ( he is not there any longer btw) they were serving panini Capri that tasted just the same as it taste now. And their pee soup as well as tuna salad, white fish salad and cal slaw have the same old test that somehow always makes me happy just like at my grandma kitchen. Few things change though-new items appeared in their refrigerator, rainbow bagel and dessert. But that my friends is a big plus and far away from disappointment! Who doesn't like a spoon filled with Italian Tiramisu, rice pudding or chocolate mousse cake while you indulging yourself with flavored coffee?! read more

If you're in the mood of a delicious bagel, I would go to cropsey bagels instead. The bagels are dense and lacking flavor, also what kind of bagel place puts everything seasoning only on one side of the bagel?? read more

I used to go to Bagel Boy for years and years and give them my business. Well never again. They do not accept their coupon that they have online unless its printed for a few free bagels if you buy a dozen. I said my printer didnt work and they refused to accept their online coupon. that is ridiculous !! Also when I order online and cut out the coupon from the paper or print the online one to give to them when they deliver the bagels, they refuse to accept it! Imagine losing a customer who spends $1000 a year at your establishment over having to honor a coupon for a few free bagels which cost nothing to make? I now go to Steves bagel which has excellent bagels and NO COUPON needed. You automatically get 6 free bagels with every dozen and 3 free with every 6 bagels and their bagels are amazing! I cannot believe what bad business sense Bagel Boy has, to think its more worth it to lose a customer that spends a ton of money over a few lousy bagels LOL The manager needs to go to business school and learn what good CS is. I am showing you the coupon, there is no code to scan, it just says 6 free with a dozen so they don't even have to scan anything, LOL they wont accept this if you show them on your phone. read more

Bagel Boy - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Everyone knows there's no bagel like a Brooklyn bagel. Period. Bagel Boys, with three locations all in Brooklyn is a great place to get one or 18 dozen. Oh my dear lord. Now those are bagels. Unreal! I could've just sat for while listening to the "cawfee talk" of the locals, loving every bit of their accents and smelling those bagels. Bagel Boys is simple, no fuss and has that old traditional Jewish deli feel without being certified kosher. That everything bagel was one of the best I've ever had and I've had my fair share of those carb loaded delicious round devils. It was available in regular or whole wheat. They even serve rainbow bagels and funfetti cream cheese which surprisingly my kiddos didn't opt for but maybe yours will. Apple cinnamon cream cheese, jalapeño, all sorts of fun ones. Unfortunately, no vegan spreads which is ok I guess, but not even hummus. Whaaaaaah! I knocked a star off for that fact. I mean, hummus is such an easy sell especially in addition to the other healthy options they offer. They have every kind of salad you can imagine...tuna, chicken, whitefish, pasta, potato, egg, and of course they offer fresh nova lox. I mean, duh. You can create your own salad with fresh veggies too. They cater and make party platters! The iced coffee was just ok, but it did the trick. I'm becoming a slow or hand drip coffee snob so I'm hard to go by. Every kind of chip you can imagine with every kind of drink in the refrigerated cases too. We were so glad to have this less than a block from where we were staying! We would definitely come back! The guys were all so sweet. Tip them. They were working super hard. We had no wait whatsoever at 9:30am on a Monday, but it was the 4th of July so it's hard to tell what the wait would be. read more

Bagel Boy - The best!!!! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

good bagels, good food, fairly quick service even for a line that stretches 20 deep sometimes. coffee is usually on point but parking is tough. They make rainbow bagels but they cost $2.50 each and funfetti cream cheese which is $8.99/lb (expensive) but hey, once in awhile for the kids, sure. read more

Bagel Boy - Green bagels for Saint Patrick's day! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This is what you call a bagel with cream cheese? Disappoints every time. I rather take an extra two minute trip to go to bagels & bialys on Avenue u. read more

Bagel Boy - A Bagel with Cream Cheese....kind of. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love this place. Great bagels!!! If you have the opportunity to Come at 5am when this place first opens up I highly suggest it. The bagels are extremely fresh and soft at that time. The wraps are also incredible and the salads are yummy! Also the iced cappuccino is bomb! read more

Bagel Boy - Bagels! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I have been to the location in Bay Ridge and had a good experience. We were closer to the one in Sheepshead Bay so we paid a visit. Same set up in both stores. Come in, stand in line and look at the extensive menu and give them your order. I already knew what I wanted: scallion cream cheese with smoked salmon on a toasted everything bagel. My friend ordered a western omelette on an everything bagel. Both our bagels were barely toasted and only 4 mediocre sized pieces of smoked salmon that didn't look so fresh. The portion of lox wasn't as generous compared to the location in Bay Ridge. read more

New. York. Bagels. Whyyy are they so good???? That perfectly amount of toasted on the outside and the soft bread on the inside ugh... This place serves up some amazing bagels with so many options for cream cheese I didn't know which to choose!! My coworker recommended the lox bagel with scallion cream cheese, which was deeelicious. They definitely do NOT skimp on the cream cheese. Service is fast, as lines do get long at lunch time. The dining area is limited, but it is more of a takeaway type of place. They also offer salads, sandwiches, coffees, juices, premade sandwiches, chips, etc. It's almost like a mini grocery store? Last time I was in New York, I had a lox bagel at a chain in Manhattan and was very disappointed. However, Bagel Boy will not disappoint! And you can definitely tell from all the locals that go! read more

Bagel Boy - $8.44 everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Being a big fan of lox and cream cheese, bagels, and bagel boy, I decided that I would try the lox cream cheese on a cranberry bagel. And yes, this one little delicacy was enough for me to give the place 5 full stars. O. M. G. I was here on a day when I had such a headache and there was surprisingly no line, the orders came out super fast, and the girl behind the register was super friendly. Did I mention the bagel with the lox cream cheese was super awesome? I really love to frequent this place and even have the bagel boy frequent buyer card. No I haven't hit the big 10 yet but I'm almost there. There are so many sandwiches to choose from, so many delicious foods and meats. They have an awesome selection of drinks, including coffee and tea. I know what you're thinking, cause I'm thinking..... Where's the bathroom? There is none. But I'm such a short walk away, that this little piece of information doesn't bother me or affect the stars in any way. Lox cream cheese. Represent! read more

Amazing food!!! I ordered an omelette & bagel with cream cheese and it exceeded expectations BY FAR. THIS IS TRULY A GOURMET DELI. A+ 10 OUT OF 10 read more

I have visited Bagel Boy several times and each time I have come away impressed with the quality of their bagels and friendliness of their staff. Usually I just pick up a pumpernickel bagel to go but yesterday I was with a friend from Scotland who ordered a whole wheat bagel with cream cheese and an ice coffee. She not only loved the bagel but said that it was one of the best tasting ice coffee's she has tasted in the States! I tried some of her ice coffee and it was very good...so eat your heart out Starbucks cause it is a lot cheaper here and just as good...or maybe better! read more

I LOVE FOOD!!! This place has the most amazing sandwiches and salads! Whether you want a breakfast sandwich or a lunch sandwich - everything is so delicious and FRESH!! They have regular fresh salads as well as, macaroni salad, egg salad, etc.. I haven't tried a thing here that I did not LOVE!!! Now, for the not so great, they are always packed out, so there is a wait to order and to pay and they do not have much seating space. However, this does not make my review less then 5 stars because I am obsessed with this place! So good! read more

Bagel Boy - Delicious! -Bacon, egg & cheese.. Vegetable cream cheese w| bacon on everything bagel.. Egg salad & Macaroni salad!!! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I hate that I love bagels so much. Thankfully Bagel Boy is close and convenient. Street parking is available and the B/Q trains are just around the corner. The place is very spacious, with about 10 seats if you want to quickly chow down your food. The workers are very nice and efficient. Although lines may get really long, they move extremely quick. With over 10 different types of bagels and cream cheese, I just can't get enough of it. I just to mix up the combination of bagel and cream cheese and they have never failed me. They also offer salad, soup, and other types of sandwiches. They have a whole wall of drinks, some desserts, and some boxed foods. There are also a variety of snacks, from chips to dried fruits. Give it a try - it's worth it! read more

Bagel Boy - Literally in love with bagels. I have a problem - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The food is ok , but kind of pricey , a plain bagel with cream cheese is like Almost 5$ . I get prices are going up , but gawwwwwd dayummm

This was such a great place! The staff is efficient--even with the 20-person line, we were able to get our food within 15 minutes plus find a seat at a table. Even with the place buzzing with customers, I still felt the place not to stuffy and overwhelming. I got the ham, egg, and cheese on a sesame bagel. It was sooo delicious. Along with coffee--I mixed hazelnut with French vanilla. However, their chocolate raspberry coffee was amazing too!! Also we got a red velvet moon pie which was divine. read more

Bagel Boy - Ham, egg, and cheese on a sesame bagel. Plus hazelnut-french vanilla coffee!! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pretty good bagels and breakfast. I say give them a try if you are in the area and want fresh bagels. My husband loves their croissants. I've also had the caramel iced coffee which was pretty good. They also sell lunch/dinner items (which I've yet to try) such as salads, sandwiches, etc. The place is clean but more of take it to go spot and they also deliver which is nice. read more

I REALLY REALLY LOVED THIS PLACE! Their fresh baked bagels "were" life! Their fresh baked pastries are to die for! The coffee wait... I just fainted I'm SO in love with their coffee! So go back If you noticed I put "were". Their bagels are NOT the same their bacon taste old like reheated from yesterday. Possibly I got them on a bad day? The place was empty at 10:30AM on a Saturday morning which is VERY strange! It's usually PACKED! I must say this ... the place is SO clean! Love their oh so many selections of juices. I don't know if I want to take a bus there and back like I use to JUST for coffee though? Just not the same! For ME I have to say BYE BYE Bagel Boy. We HAD good times! read more

The best bagels ever! This place is ALWAYS busy and in the morning there are lines out the door - and for good reason. This place makes best bagels. Nobody can beat a fresh bagel from Bagel Boy and even a bagel that's not just fresh out is amazing. With plain butter, cream cheese and jelly or more elaborate mixtures, the bagel is the main attraction. In addition, they sell breads, panninis, fresh squeezed orange juice, fruits and cold pastas and things like potato salad etc. Lines are long but that won't stop me from coming here again and again :) read more

Decided to come here and check out the hype since I got tired of eating the same old breakfast from the corner deli and this place was so close to work. First thought *WHY DIDNT I COME HERE SOONER* I came at a great time because there was no line and according to my trusty yelpers there can be lines out the door, I managed to order my lox cream cheese with tomato on an everything bagel toasted paid and was out the door in less than five minutes. I didn't have time to check out their other stuff because there was no line I was literally in and out. But I did take their menu and plan to order lunch from them since I heard they deliver. I can understand why people complain about confusion and messed up orders because you are basically telling one person behind the counter what you want and he goes and makes it, there's no receipt or number but the same guy who takes my order brings it to the front and tells the cashier what I ordered and let's her know it's mine.. so I guess when it gets busy it might get confusing if they just pass it to the cashier? Not sure how it gets when it gets busy but I guess I was lucky cause my first experience was great. Now on to my amazing lox cream cheese spread.. Did I mention AMAZING?!? The consistency of it was like butter and they don't go cheap on the spread either, I've never had any cream cheese like this. The only reason I took off one star was because I found both the bagel and the cream cheese a bit too salty for my preference. (Thank god I added tomatoe to make it less salty) None the less it was still probably the best cream cheese I've ever had! I can't wait to try other bagels and their paninis! Yes this place is quite expensive and I'm sure it can add up, at my corner deli it would probably cost me $2.75 for what I ordered and over here I paid $3.50 but you get what you pay for and I would definitely recommend them read more

Bagels: yes. Vegetable cream cheese: yes. I'll put up with surly cashiers for those two things. The whitefish is pretty strong, too. read more

This used to be the spot to get bagels around me. Now it keeps falling off. I really can't believe that I am writing a negative review of this place but I will let the photos speak for themselves. read more

Bagel Boy - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This is a relatively big store that has a wide variety of bagels and other food for breakfast, lunch and perhaps, dinner. I can only review on their bagels though. Their bagels are OK, but i think it would've been better if I had them toasted. Their veggie cream cheese is also good. But I think overall, this is one of the pricier places to get a bagel. This is based off of getting one sesame bagel with veggie cream cheese and one regular bagel with cream cheese. Other than that, the other down side is the wait time since it gets pretty busy here (located near a train station) read more

Had my first time experience at Bagel Boy and let me tell you, the food is great, but where are the manners? The man who took my order was quick and kind, however, when I walked towards the counter thinking someone was telling me to go pay, a middle aged man decided to give me a quick lecture on how their payment process worked. His tone and attitude was unacceptable. The other employees there just looked at me with a blank look as if I was incompetent meanwhile the middle aged man was still talking and waving me off to wait elsewhere. I didn't even know how to react after that. I finally got to pay and got out of there. read more

There was some kind of message from the Board of Health in the window, but no letter grade. The place was crowded, the food in the display looked good so I ignored the red flag and went in anyway. The service was fast, though the counter guy shot me what might have been a dirty look, but also might have been my imagination, when I only ordered a garlic bagel with cream cheese. Even though it seemed a touch overpriced, even by today's standards, it was still one of the cheaper things on the menu. The bagel was hard, like it was a few days old. I figured that it was late afternoon and the best time to order bagels was probably in the morning. They didn't ask me if I wanted it toasted. I would have said no, though in this case, it would have been an improvement. The cream cheese tasted alright, until two in the morning, when I was woken up and kept awake for over an hour with bad stomach cramps. The bagel and cream cheese were the only things I'd eaten all day that might have caused them. My body has a helpful habit of rejecting things, like rancid cream. My guess is, both the bagel and the cream cheese were a few days old. My feeling about this place is, the workers/owners are arrogant because they always seem to be crowded and they don't care enough to insure that their food is fresh. I would avoid this place, unless you want to cleanse your stomach. read more

The bagels are good but waiting 15 min for a bagel with 6 people behind the counter is just ridiculous. It's not a a Michelin 3 star restaurant ! read more

The best people and service in the neighborhood!!! Everyone here knows how to make your to-order special. What a great team and ohh the food... Great breakfast specials to go or for here and the best homefries too. Eggs, meat, homefries & toast 4.75! I often have their specialty sandwiches which are really great and their cofee rocks! read more

Bagel Boy - Fresh everyday!!! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Their cream cheese spreads were amazing! The bagels had a very enjoyable texture and just the right amount of chewiness

I love bagel boy. He gives me anything I want. Lox? Ginormous spread. Sausage egg and cheese? I will eat that huge thing in one bite. That is all. read more

First time the order was perfect. Today, everything was soaked in spilled coffee, three hero sandwiches, half a dozen of bagels, even though a coffee was in a separate bag, but was put inside the bag with sandwiches. 20 oz coffee cup was laying on the side, how a delivery girl couldn't see it? It's totally her fault that costed me $50! I feel bad for giving her tips now. Our breakfast is ruined. Thank you very much. read more

Bagel Boy - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I used to live in Sheepshead and now live in Carroll Gardens and I have to say the beach and Bagel Boy are the only things I really miss. They just don't have bagels and spread selections like Bagel Boy's where I am now. I'm getting hungry just writing about them. read more

On reviewer said this place was always crowded. They were right, but the line moves so fast you don't even notice the long lines I ordered a bagel sandwich which was very well put together, and the counter guy was very nice in his recommendations as to cheeses and there toppings. The only problem is, bagels are kind of expensive than the many other bagel shops in the neighborhood. A bagel and cream cheese goes for $1.95 ($1.5 at dunkin donuts) and my sandwich an chips were 7 dollars. This seems expensive because in the neighborhood sandwiches on rolls are 3.50. I would come back again if I felt like having a filling lunch and was willing to spend more than $5 for it. Otherpre-made salads and wraps run close to 7 bucks as well. PS: Theres not much place for seating, so make sure you take your bagel to go. read more

The food is fine but the cashiers are horrible. They seem to change a lot and it's really hit or miss. I know how their paying process works but basically the guy making my sandwich kept pointing at me and was like do you want anything else so I'm assuming my food is ready. I come to front cashiers don't acknowledge me or anyone for that Matter they mostly just talk to themselves. Hopefully won't be back here unless I'm really desperate or I'll make someone else pick up The food. read more

Got there at 5pm, closed no reason, drove 15 minutes, hours posted are until 7pm! What is this a joke! Avoid this place after could be closed read more

I usually order from Bagel Boy by the phone, staff is not that friendly but it's ok. I understand they are quite busy. Delivery time is usually about 30-40 minutes. Food is pretty good. I love their chicken salad because it has tomato chunks. Panini is ok but my coworkers like it a lot because they put extra mixed green salad on the side. P.s. I don't recommend to order coffee because the way the pack it's always all over the place:( read more

I've been going to this place for many years and nothing ever changes with these guys, which is not a bad thing since their bagels are great, but every single of their self-serve coffees offering is pure garbage. It's cheap and you can taste it. It tastes awful unless you load it up with sugar and creamer. I drink it black. I've had better coffee during camping in the middle of nowhere. After tasting Bagel Boy's coffee, DDs coffee feels like I'm drinking a freshly pressed cup of high-end coffee house (this is bad). Bleh. PS I notice many reviews praise their coffee - man do I feel bad for your lack of taste buds :) Travel the world, or visit local true coffee shops and taste the real coffee. read more

This is a solid little bagel joint in an area that didn't seem to have much else going on around. Definitely not the super chewy, gourmet bagels I've come to expect here in NYC, but definitely still a solid option. I ordered an egg & cheese sandwich on blueberry bagel and added cucumbers for a bit of crunch. The employees could tell that it was my first time in the store as I didn't really understand the system for waiting and paying. That being said, they were extremely kind to me and made me welcome in the store-- a nice surprise when places like this the employees usually yell at you to move along lol. Overall solid place to stop if you're in the area. They have so many different options everyone should be able to find something they enjoy! read more

I've been coming to bagel boy consistently all my life because their bagels are one to beat. Their bagels are one of the best. They have a chewy outer texture with a soft middle which is literally the perfect bagel. Some of my favorite bagels are the blueberry and the whole wheat ones. They are also really thick rather than a thin bagel with a giant hole in the middle. You definitely gt a good amount of bread. They also have a wide variety of cream cheeses and spreads but one of my all time favorites is the vegetable cream cheese. There are chunks of different veggies that give it a lot of texture and flavors. This place is always super busy so be prepared to wait on a line or encounter some rude cashiers. They're just really busy but they manage to get your order out as quickly as they can. The bagels here are well worth the annoyed attitudes or long lines. read more

Don't be fooled by the idea that you can actually get food here even if they are open. Walked in on a Sunday afternoon with the place looking full of employees but when I ordered a bacon egg and cheese I was told that the kitchen was closed... WTF??? Then why are you open? So I can buy one of those pre packaged salads that look like they were freeze dried? Coffee had never been good here and now this is even more of a reason to avoid this over priced bagel store read more

I come here all the time and they always seem to get something wrong with my order. I always ask for extra crispy turkey bacon and every single time I've had to send it back because it's literally raw. This establishment is definitely not worth the long line and terrible customer service. read more

Bagel Boy - bacon and cheese sandwich in wrapper - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all