I'd come back 10 times over…read more Every dish has good care and creativity, tastes delicious. Kind and prompt service, suitable for young kids.

Pineapple Eddie's had been sitting on our "to try" list for probably 4 or 5 years, and thanks to a…read morelast-minute change of plans, we finally made it in. The restaurant is much larger than it appears from the outside. Once you head through the first dining room and down the steps, you're greeted by a warm, homey dining room with a surprisingly spacious bar. It has a comfortable neighborhood feel, and the staff was friendly throughout our visit. Our cocktails arrived in about 10 minutes, and the hush puppies followed about 20 minutes later. They had a nice flavor, but were much denser and chewier than I expected. The bigger issue was the wait for our entrees. With the restaurant not appearing particularly busy, nearly 50 minutes for fried chicken and jerk chicken felt excessive. The good news? The chicken absolutely delivered! Both the fried chicken and the jerk chicken were packed with flavor and easily stole the show. The fried chicken was crispy and juicy, while the jerk had a wonderful balance of seasoning and spice. Those dishes alone made the meal worthwhile. Unfortunately, my mashed potatoes arrived warm instead of hot. After such a long wait, I was hoping everything would come out piping hot, and that side just missed the mark. Cole slaw was fresh but pretty boring in the flavor department. I really wanted this to be the five-star experience that so many others have had. While this visit didn't quite live up to the hype, the quality of the chicken showed why Pineapple Eddie's has earned such a loyal following. We'll happily give them another shot someday and hope they earn that elusive fifth star.

The food was amazing! Our server Celia was wonderful! I had…read morethe filet mignon and my husband had the grouper! DELICIOUS! We also had the peanut butter pie and the Keylime pie worth it!

Stopped in on a Saturday night around 9:45 PM. Great service, even though the food took a little…read morelong. I suggest making a reservation, as we had one and still had to wait a bit. Out of all the fine dining experiences I've had in Erie so far, this would be at the top... food wise and view wise. It's beautiful to sit outside and have the view of the bicentennial tower right next to the water! Now for the dish details! -Buffalo cauliflower was nothing special, your standard Buffalo cauliflower with a side of ranch... great to share for the table. The Roasted Organic Chicken was so juicy and tender, it fell right off the bone. Mashed potatoes and green beans paired perfectly. One of my favorites! -The heirloom tomato salad was a 7/10... I think the tomato wedges needed to be smaller pieces. This salad had the best croutons I've ever had! French onion soup was also a standout for me... definitely recommend! -Lastly Walleye Fish & chips: I think they could've included a bit more fish (it was three tenders), tasted good tho...7/10 as well! I would definitely come back here again and recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a fine dining waterfront experience in Erie!

In response to Milen D's recent review of Firestones(which I witnessed)…read more I honestly can't decide what's more embarrassing: your experience at the restaurant or the fact that you thought this review was worth posting. You apparently walked in expecting the entire establishment to revolve around your very specific demands, got disappointed, called someone a "clown," accused them of lying, and then produced this barely decipherable masterpiece of nonsense. The staff didn't fail you--you failed to understand where you were, what they offered, and apparently how restaurants work. And judging by the grammar and coherence of this review, I'm not sure you were in any condition to be evaluating anyone else's performance. Being unhappy with a meal is one thing. Throwing a tantrum because a restaurant didn't conform to whatever bizarre expectations you had in your head is another. Do everyone a favor next time: stay home, lower your expectations, and let the adults enjoy their dinner without having to witness another episode of The World's Most Confused Customer. The restaurant got one bad review. You got permanently immortalized as the person who wrote it. I'd say one of those is considerably harder to recover from.

Firestone's Kitchen…read more This was the BEST pizza I've had in Erie as a traveller looking to settle here. I've tried 3 others, mostly very flat on crust or flavor (all independent places). Firestone's pizza has an excellent char, solid sauce and flavorful toppings. The restaurant also has a beer/wine store, and a eye pleasing meat counter/butcher. I have no complaints - friendly service, fair priced pizza for excellent quality, and the liquor section has some charm to the decor. ***From the road, look for Gordon's (even though Firestone Kitchen is the eatery). Gordon's is more prominent from the road.

Great food, staff very accommodating... lamb shank...2cd to none! Cheers! Family friendly...read more

First time here and this place was amazing. The apps (short rib poutine fries/shrimp crab dip) and…read moreour entrees (lamb shank, lemon honey chicken, filet mignon, bone in breaded pork loin) were all delicious. Our cocktails were great as well. Our server Thor was also very personable and did a great job explaining any questions on the menu! We will be back! Only con but nothing bad was the place is a little noisy but I just think the sound carries in it. It made it somewhat at times hard to talk/hear but we were able to adjust to it.

One complaint. If you charge $16 for a bourbon, give an honest pour. Don't serve a measured shot &…read morethen shortchange that measured shot.

There were 8 of us for Lobster Fest, I got the filet & lobster tail. Probably one of the best…read moresteaks I ever had, and a no brainer on the lobster (amazing). Service was prompt even though the place was packed. The server was fantastic and The General Manager (Zack) made sure everything was perfect. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed their food were pleased with everything. All of us will definitely be back.

A great meal with a view: I had a grilled walleye sandwich and a glass of chardonnay. As if on cue,…read morea sunset popped out of a gray sky. Service was fast and friendly. I will be back.

Great food, great service, fantastic view!!! We had the warm pretzel bites as an appetizer, which…read morewere so yummy I didn't even have time to snap a pic paired with their homemade queso I thoroughly enjoyed them. Then for my entree I had the spicy shrimp pasta which had amazing flavor, was creamy, and the shrimp were cooked well. Portion sizes leave you feeling satisfied but not terribly full. Everything was well-executed and delicious.

Been going here forever and first swing in - in some time tonight…read more Best big pretzels and salad. Great seafood. Nice complete menu and more than adequate beer selection. Genuine, friendly owner. Beachie vibe with good tunes

Unassuming & dark with dated decor but damn do they make a decent meal. In this town full of chain…read morerestaurants this place is refreshing! The locals know. The tourists, probably not. I often order the fish entrees, they know how to season & cook it so it's just yummy. The menu is extensive with many Italian dishes that I'm told are equally tasty. The salad entrees are huge and fresh. The sandwiches are large and equally good. The servers are friendly and quick. There is a separate bar area, a downstairs room for events and a large parking lot.

This multiyear award winning Syrian restaurant is…read more The exterior is in need of a little love but our initial trepidation was assuaged by the lovely lady who greeted/seated/served/cooked our food. She was lovely! We ordered shish tawook(chicken breast) sandwiches and a fattoush salad. The sandwich was just the right size with fresh ingredients and came with a sode of simply prepared "syroan" rice (olive oil, carrots, and zaatar) Tasty! The fatoush salad arrived quickly and was very flavorful. The high quality olives and zaatar spices were a particular treat. The dressing was simple olive oil and zaatar Excellent! We are glad we stopped for this late lunch in the early part of the week.Recommend!

One of my favorite places to eat at in the Erie area. The food is delicious. I love the Garlic…read moresauce! The meat is always cooked to perfection and the rice and hummus are well seasoned. The presentation of the food is always handled artfully and with pride. The tea is very good as well. In a addition to that, the proprietor is very sweet and motherly. She makes customers feel like family. The stuffed camels and middle eastern music enhances the relaxing ambiance as well. Highly recommended! Just a feel good place.

I went to That Place to eat lunch, and watch NCAA Basketball. I asked bartender if I could place…read morean order, she said "the waitress will be around to take my order." 45 minutes later, waitress came by to clean off table next to me. I hdld up menu and said "sure like to order", she completely ignored me and never came back. I was there 4 times last 2 weeks, because I moved in with my brother, after having a stroke. Worst customer service EVER! When I went back to talk to owner , two drunks tried to get in my face, I'm have martial arts training, so it wouldn't have been pretty. Anyway if you want BAD SERVICE, THAT PLACE ON W 26th is more than willing to accommodate. NEVER BE BACK, I'LL WALK 2 Reservoir 26, which is half mile away. At least I can get service, without it being an "issue." ​

I sincerely miss the old "Corner Tavern" days. They were…read morestolen from us all a couple years ago, and I never got over it. There's something so appealing to me about a real corner bar. The smells of smoke and beer and short-order cooking...the sounds of mindless sports shows on the TV - even the Price is Right makes for good watching...the murmur of the type of chatter that seems so important at the time...I miss all of these things so much, but I'm here to tell you, That Place on 26th St still has it all and they deliver both barrels! The place was PACKED, so I didn't try to get lunch yesterday, but I'll be heading back very soon cause the reason the place was PACKED was the food they were serving - the day's special was stromboli and one after another came in and ordered one or two or three, some stayed and ate, some left with their orders, but the flow never even slowed! Yes, smoking is permitted, but so what? If that bothers you, you're probably better off in a safe little corporate "pub". THIS is a REAL tavern and they are worth more than a try. Stop in, grab some beers and a bite and enjoy all the memories they bring up!

The service is outstanding. The food is amazing. There are so many options whether it's the butter…read moreflight or the French toast flight or even the coffee flight. There's so many options and all of it is delicious.

Had a great breakfast at Bay and Berry. I tried the omelet (you can choose 3 toppings), and it was…read morehuge and satisfyingly fluffy. Get the potato pancake as your side, you'll thank me. The classic pancake with butter and maple syrup is also delicious. They also have a nice selection of baked goods on display and serve alcoholic drinks. The restaurant was bustling during late morning service, but the server was attentive and the place was very clean. Will definitely be back.