In response to Milen D's recent review of Firestones(which I witnessed) I honestly can't decide what's more embarrassing: your experience at the restaurant or the fact that you thought this review was worth posting. You apparently walked in expecting the entire establishment to revolve around your very specific demands, got disappointed, called someone a "clown," accused them of lying, and then produced this barely decipherable masterpiece of nonsense. The staff didn't fail you--you failed to understand where you were, what they offered, and apparently how restaurants work. And judging by the grammar and coherence of this review, I'm not sure you were in any condition to be evaluating anyone else's performance. Being unhappy with a meal is one thing. Throwing a tantrum because a restaurant didn't conform to whatever bizarre expectations you had in your head is another. Do everyone a favor next time: stay home, lower your expectations, and let the adults enjoy their dinner without having to witness another episode of The World's Most Confused Customer. The restaurant got one bad review. You got permanently immortalized as the person who wrote it. I'd say one of those is considerably harder to recover from. read more

Firestone's - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Firestone's Kitchen This was the BEST pizza I've had in Erie as a traveller looking to settle here. I've tried 3 others, mostly very flat on crust or flavor (all independent places). Firestone's pizza has an excellent char, solid sauce and flavorful toppings. The restaurant also has a beer/wine store, and a eye pleasing meat counter/butcher. I have no complaints - friendly service, fair priced pizza for excellent quality, and the liquor section has some charm to the decor. ***From the road, look for Gordon's (even though Firestone Kitchen is the eatery). Gordon's is more prominent from the road. read more

See all

I was in Erie for a conference and wanted to go to a local restaurant that had great reviews. I enjoyed the staff and seeing the Pirates game on the TV. The menu wasn't deep but I like that because you go with what you're good making and avoid decision paralysis. I had a pepperoni pizza and a draft sour beer. Both were good and I'd probably get them again. Definitely a good place to get some eats and a beer. read more

Pizza was the bomb. Sat at counter with great friendly service. Can't wait to try dinner here. Open kitchen, meat market and beer and wine sales. read more

Firestone's - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Wow! Biggest drawback was the noisiness. Great staff & squeezed us into a 2 top at 5pmish cautioning need to use the table for a reservation in 1 hour. No problem! Tried the dry-aged double burger and white bolognese pasta. Considering the full house, service & food arrival was fine. Burger sauce was messy & came with a pasta salad. Great burger. The pasta had veal, plenty of mushrooms & nice change from tomato sauce. Portion was OK & no sides, so pricey considering. Tasty. read more

You're in Erie PA on the weekend and it's Lunch Time. Where do you go? Check out Lunch at Firestone! It hits it's mark. My mother had recently been here for a holiday party and remarked how good it was. Recalling the conversation, I suggested we go here before my brother and I fly back to Florida. We agreed and showed up and were promptly seated. Vibe: the restaurant is next to Gordans meat market (pro tip, pick up your cuts here after getting lunch at Firestones). The overall vibe is a modern decor with black tones and white subway tile with an open kitchen concept. Drinks: I ordered the Pinot noir which was interesting because it did not state from where and what brand of Pinot it was. However, it showed up with my soda water and lime. The glassware is nice and the Pinot itself was fine. Appetizer: We opted to start with the green chili Mac and Cheese . It comes out in a nice cast iron vessel. The dish comes with some toasted cheese or bread crumbs on top. The dish has a nice cheese flavor however the green chili barely comes through. It would be good to see the restaurant lean a little further with the green chili. However it's a nice dish when it's 24 degrees out. Food: Pizza: We went with two: the Mushroom red sauce and the arugula, balsamic vinegar with chimichurri and prosciutto. Both were good. My preference at this visit was the red sauce with mushroom. The pizzas themselves were cooked well and the crust is a standard thin crust. All in all the food was enjoyable for lunch but I'm thinking dinner here is way better by looking at the dishes on Yelp. I'll definitely incorporate a stop here on my next visit to Erie! Nice job! 4.5/5.0 read more

See all

This is our favorite restaurant whenever we are in Erie, the food is consistently excellent and often leads to us making at least two visits while we are in town. Their regular menu is fantastic (the Shrimp Banh Mi sandwich and their hamburgers are our favorites!) but their weekly specials are out of this world. Do yourself a favor and stop in for lunch or dinner, you'll thank me later! read more

See all

We came to Firestone's after my son played a game at Erie High School Stadium. The restaurant is on the small side. The middle is the restaurant, one side was a deli, the other was a beer and six pack shop. Our group ordered pizzas and sandwiches. I got the catfish sandwich, two people in our group got the Churi Steak Sandwich, one got Gordon's Smash Burger, one spinach pizza, and one cheese. Everything tasted really good. The sandwiches were just really small. Fries were also extra($5). Service was fine. read more

See all

This was a nice and pleasant surprise experience! It's located in the Gordon's butcher and Market which was so cool. Estically is was super cute in there. Very open, could see the wood fire ovens, and everyone in the back cooking. Greeted and seated as soon as we walked in. Services was good. I recommend making reservations I can see it getting busy, and although nice size it was smaller than I expected. The food and drinks were amazing! As always we pre looked at the menu, and still ended up trying something else lol We got a pizza, Brisket sausage and jalapenos pizza, with a green chili cream sauce! Now as a buffaloian we know pizza, let me say was this buffalo pizza, no, was it great pizza YES! If you like wood fire pizza with great flavor and good price (16) and in the Erie Pa area or passing through, yea stop in!!!! Then we also tried the the chimmi steak sandwich, again, bomb! The steak melted in out mouth and the flavors were so good!!! Washed down with one of their mules of the month, which was lemoncello, which I've never had but loved!!! Melvin is a bourbon guy, and thought they had a great selection, so he enjoyed a nice pour of Eagle Rare Then there is another craft and wine room, where you can enjoy plenty of options of craft beer and wine. read more

See all

Great food and service. Area can get a little loud though. It was nice being able to see the kitchen staff. We watched our pizza being made and the staff member threw away the first dough ball after stretching (unknown reasons). But it was nice knowing they take pride in their work and the food they make. read more

See all

Regular here! Pizza is great. Awesome spot for a casual, laid back dinner on a Friday night. Good for takeout as well! read more

See all

10/10 Must Go-Must See Very special place. If you don't know Green Eggs, you will learn here. No corners cut here! read more

See all

Wow! I'm not from Erie so I used Yelp! To find a favorite "local" restaurant. I stopped at Firestones for lunch. I was torn between one of the specials and Gordon's Smash Burger. The Smash Burger was possibly the best burger that I've ever had. 1/3lb Ground Brisket, Chuck & Short Rib of Beef, Carmelized Onions, Black Pepper Cooper's Cheese, Toasted Pretzel Roll, Dijon-Mayo. The burger was perfectly cooked, juicy, and served with a side of Gordon's pasta salad. I sat at the bar, with a view of the kitchen. Service was spot on. read more

Firestone's - The kitchen - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

Love their pizzas and the atmosphere! Great to sit at the bar, have a drink and watch the kitchen. The filet is phenomenal!

pizza place, the bar sucks not even bloody merry, i asked if that is restaurant and the clown lie to me. It f you looking for real food that isn't the place. the have total of 5 sandwiches i am very sad read more

We were in Erie for the weekend and used Yelp! to find a place to eat, of course. This place was highly rated and we went in with high expectations. It was pretty busy on a Friday night, the hostess was friendly and found a way to seat our party of 5. Overall, I felt like service was the high point of the meal as everyone was very friendly and prompt despite being a packed house. The menu is interesting and has a good variety of foods. But I'm giving three stars for the food itself. It was.... fine. The pizza sauce was the low point, tasted like canned tomatoes. My pork belly tacos had potential but didn't wow me, same with my husband's burger. That's all there is to really say. It was just ok! read more

I ordered take-out on my way through Erie and it was prepared in a timely manner. I got the pork belly tacos - the pork belly melted in your mouth, it was simply so good. I would've ordered more had I known how good it was! The Gordon Smash burger was also very good. Based off the food alone I would come back to eat here. read more

Great service. Food was solid but didn't have anything that stood out. Definitely would go back.

Enjoyable experience. Food is wonderful... looking forward to returning soon for another great meal

Very quick service, delicious pizza at a great price! Perfect for an adult date night or a casual bite to eat after a long day!

Great pizza every time! It's always busy when we go and the staff is friendly and helpful

The food was good and it came out faster than considering how busy the place was. I didn't expect it to be so busy for a weeknight, but it was worth it. read more

I went there on a business dinner to celebrate a completed project. Its really really good. The chef really knows what hes doing. Anything out of the pizza oven or off the wood fired grill is gonna knock your socks off. The concept of the butcher shop, restaurant and wine/beer shop under one roof is unique to erie. Its a wonderful concept and they excel at it. read more

Arrived kind of late on a Saturday night but they were friendly and welcoming. Food and service were great. Mushroom pizza was delicious!

The Smash Burger fries & coleslaw were excellent! And the young lady that waited on us was Flawless! It's a Nice Clean Establishment!

Ambiance, service and food were excellent. The restaurant is very clean and the service was great. We came with kids and they even loved the pizza. We ordered a variety of food, pizza, pasta and fries. The truffle fries were excellent and a must try. We got to meet the owner and he was super friendly and kind. If you are in the area or near Splash lagoon this is a great restaurant to visit. read more

Firestone's - Ravioli special - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

Good was great, drink menu was awesome! Definitely recommend to both couples and families.

Firestone's has the best burgers in Erie. I had lived in Erie for a couple of years before finally going to Firestone's, and I wish I had started earlier. The burgers, pizza, and shrimp banh mi beat everywhere else in town. Service is excellent. read more

One of few places I'd call excellent. I've been going for quite a few years now. I've tried about everything there is to try on the menu and have never been disappointed. Specials or regular menu items it's excellent. Foods always made fresh with the freshest ingredients. It's worth the trip. read more

Friendly, professional service. Very good food quality. Upscale setting. Party of eight accommodated promptly.

Service was great! Menu changes regularly so there is always something new that the chef is preparing for the patrons. Will definitely be going back. Love the openness of the restaurant and hope that they will someday expand and add more seating. read more

Firestone's - Bone-in Hickory Smoked "Short Rib" (HUGE!) , Japanese BBQ, Sesame, Scallion & Fresno Peppers, Whole Grain & Arugula Red Skin Potato Salad - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Fantastic spot. The food and beer selection is great. I would choose to eat here over any of the chain options every time.

Food was flavorful and amazing. Best truffle fries I've ever tasted. Ambiance was very casual dining set next to a grocery store. Service was great! read more

Food fabulous. Ambiance pleasant. Waitress friendly however way too busy way too short staffed. Feel for them but they did wonderful. read more

Firestone's - Dinner menu - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

By far the best steak I have ever had! Also I've had so many other options from this place and all have been amazing. Incredible quality!

I love this place and the atmosphere. Quite pleasant. I would recommend this place to friends and family. Is a good choice upon dining.

Too expensive, wasn't too impressed with my steak, service was fine, was a little cluttered.

Food was great and service was attentive. Really neat open cooking concept. Will definitely go back.

Everything was good, but the pickled pizza would not buy again. Service excellent. Store was nice

I stopped in here for dinner while in town for work, I was definitely surprised at everything that's offered in this unmarked small strip mall (Butcher, store, restaurant and wine bar). The space is bright and open so when you enter you have access to all of the (shared) spaces. We arrived on a Tuesday around 6:30 to a fairly buzzing restaurant and we were seated right away by a friendly hostess. We received the standard and specials menu that had many delicious options. I ordered the smash burger with truffle fries and my coworker ordered the hanger steak special. All the food came out pretty quick and was really good the burger came with a pretzel bun which was a nice touch. The steak was a generous portion but at a glance it looked there could have been more potatoes and broccoli. While the burger was very flavorful it felt like it could have been thicker. For dessert we tried the almond cake, it was a bit on the dry side so I can't say I would try it again. I'm looking forward to returning during a future trip and trying the wood fired pizza. read more

See all