24 hours later - Happy owners of a new Prius V Two…read more Had a great experience shopping at Maguire Toyota. Ryan Salino, the gentleman that greeted me, was very helpful and willing to take the time to explain the dealership policies and the great level of care that they take to ensure clients are satisfied with their purchase (3 days return policy, financing selection and 3-day possible change, not working for commission, lowest advertized price possible (no haggling), etc.). I initially went to the dealership simply to have a look at a used Prius V Two that was advertized on their website, but after discussing with Ryan and seeing the great incentives that Maguire was offering on a specific new Prius V Two, I took the latter for a test drive in the surrounding countryside and loved it. My wife and I ended up visiting the dealership again the next day where Ryan walked us through the processes (insurance, financing, extra protection, etc.) and, a few hours later, we drove away in our brand new car! Excellent experience - we will recommend to our friends!

Maguire isn't a dealership. It's a lead-farming operation disguised as a dealership…read more I called ahead to ask about a test drive and was told, "Just come in." No name, no appointment needed. When we arrived, there was no receptionist, no welcome, no engagement--just a showroom full of sales staff glued to screens. No one looked up. It felt like walking through the Borg Collective--if you're not pre-scanned or tagged by their system, you don't exist. Eventually, I politely asked a salesperson (who was texting at her desk) if anyone could help us. She scolded me for interrupting her texting. Not a joke. When someone finally did help us, she launched into a checklist-style interrogation--what trim? who did you speak to? how much can you afford?--before even offering a test drive. She actually said: "We just want to make sure that if you fall in love with the car, you can afford it." I half expected her to hand me a feather boa and call me Vivian from Pretty Woman. I told her we'd already done the research, knew what we wanted, and just needed to sit in the vehicle and drive it. She didn't like that. We didn't fit the script. She got visibly irritated, tried to talk us out of test driving more than one trim, then left the desk without a word. Just walked away. We left. Later, a "manager" called. She sounded young, inexperienced, and totally unaware of what went wrong. She defended everything, including the texting salesperson, saying I had interrupted her. Her version of an apology was an excuse. They don't see a problem because they don't care. Their whole model is built around trolling the internet for leads and jamming people into a rigid, impersonal sales system. If you don't cooperate with their funnel, you're not worth their time. Maguire isn't set up to sell cars to people--they're set up to mine online clicks and process you like data. They're not interested in relationships, needs, or experience. They're fishing for suckers, not building trust.

I have to say we have taken all of our cars to Pritchards for inspections and repairs. In the past…read morefew years with warranties we have had to take our cars elsewhere - like local Subaru dealer and were astonished that they tried to tell us work that was needed on the car that IT DID NOT NEED. Took it back to Pritchards after having the recall work done and had Pritchard's go over the car thoroughly - Whew - glad we did. Not only did they tell us what we did NOT need to do they also told us what we needed to do at a substanally lower cost almost $1000 less (!). I trust what they tell me and feel assured they will not tell us to do more work than we need on our cars.

We have been taking our cars there for about 2 years. They have the best service! They are honest…read moreand do not try to sell what you do not need. They also are reasonably priced!

I think the practice of withholding labor fees from price quotes on repairs should be illegal. I…read morebrought my Subaru to Maguire this week to get one of the seat belts fixed, because its was twisted and stuck. The person at Maguire told me they could fix the seatbelt, but they also recommended that I change out the air filters. I knew the air filters were unnecessary, because I just had the car inspected at Midas, and they didn't mention anything about the filters. But the Maguire people said they would do it all (seatbelt + filters) for $135, so I figured it was worth it just to get it fixed and get out of there. I made sure to confirm the price, saying, "$135 for everything?" The person confirmed, "$135 total." Here is what they ended up charging me: Labor to untwist the seat belt: $100 Cabin air filter: $32.35 Labor to replace cabin air filter: $45 Engine air filter: $36.25 Labor to replace engine air filter: $40 Total, including tax: $273.78 Is it unreasonable to assume that "total" includes the price of labor? It felt very dishonest to me. I'm giving two stars instead of one, because they did fix the seat belt at least, which Midas wasn't able to do.

Purchased a 2025 Subaru Outback yesterday. Our sales rep was Chris Merilahti. He was excellent to…read morework with. We did the test drive. He answered all my questions. We got a tour of the facility. Set up appointment for first oil change. He contacted my car insurance company. The actual buying of the car happened quickly compared to my previous experience in purchasing a vehicle. Very pleased with the service Chris provided.

I'm almost at a loss for words for how pleased I am with this dealer for service. Treated me like a…read morereal human being. And they honored the first free oil change even though we're from out of town. Well guess what...you've earned my business for our next Honda purchase, and I'll be spreading the word. You all are doing something right. Truly made my day.

I worked with Jeff Philip at Honda of Ithaca to purchase a new car Dec. 2025. Jeff was…read moreexceptional. I highly recommend Jeff.

Meh service.You call them, they never pick up. You leave a message, they never call back. you text,…read morethey never respond. You bring your car for a 9 AM appointment, the car is not done by noon. And this is just routine maintenance, not rebuilding the engine or something. Maybe it makes sense to drive to Syracuse...

Not long ago though, my car started having issues with the transmission slipping gears... I'd be…read moredriving along when my vehicle would suddenly shift from Drive into 2nd gear (or sometimes Neutral). Within a day or two, I had an appointment with my main auto mechanic, but they advised that my make/model of car has a closed transmission and I'd need to take my car to a dealership. It would have taken more than 4 weeks to get my Hyundai into Simmons-Rockwell Hyundai in Elmira, and I wasn't sure I'd be able to get it all the way back to Fuccillo Hyundai of Syracuse (where I originally bought the car). I (begrudgingly) made an appointment with Maguire Hyundai of Ithaca because I was able to have my appointment quickly. I dropped my car off in the parking lot of Maguire Hyundai on the day of my appointment and went inside to leave my keys and have final discussions about the issue my car was experiencing, as well as the 2 recent recalls I wanted to have tended to. I specifically asked them to *call me* with a result of transmission diagnostic testing AND what they were thinking after a test-drive of the car... ... but I never got a call about the results of either. Instead, I got a call a couple hours after dropping my car off saying the car was done and could be picked up. Um, no? That's not how this works, because I was very clear with what I asked for and that didn't happen. I asked to speak to a service manager so I could get more details on results of testing. When I was finally able to get someone on the phone, I was told nothing came up on the diagnostic testing and they couldn't get the issue to replicate, so they didn't do anything. Given that I had experienced the issue twice in the short drive from where I had been staying to the Maguire Hyundai location, that wasn't a sufficient response for me. I had done some additional research, and had come up with a couple possibilities of what was likely given what I had been experiencing... including issues that would be fixed with a transmission flush / new fluid (something that especially made sense, given I had never had the fluid changed and it *is* a closed system). I was told they would try and get it done before the end of the workday, but it would be ready by 10am the next morning at the latest... and they'd call when it was ready. Cut to the next day, and no call by 10am. No call by noon. No call by 2pm. I called, but got no call back. I hopped onto their website and chatted with a customer service rep via their messaging system and asked for a call about my car... nothing. Finally, I drove a friend's car down to the dealership from where I'd been staying, and I was told my car would be ready within an hour. I go back to the house, pick up my friend who will drive their own car back when I'm picking up mine, and we head back down to Maguire Hyundai. I get BACK down to Maguire Hyundai and I'm told that oops... your car won't be able to be picked up until morning. After a transmission flush, the dealership wants to let it sit for a bit and then test drive it to ensure all is well. Okay, BUT WHY DID YOU TELL ME MY CAR WOULD BE DONE WITHIN AN HOUR? I head back out without my car, but a promise from the dealership that it'll be ready for pick-up by 10am the next day. The next day, they actually call me back by 10am (9:52am, to be exact), and they tell me that my car is ready. I head down, pay, pick up my car, and head out on my way... relieved to finally be done with the experience. The big takeaway from my experience with Maguire Hyundai? The communication - whether between team members at the dealership (service counter and mechanics, etc), or service team members and customers - needs a LOT of work. Like, A LOT. Also, my car would not have been properly tended to without my pushing for it and specifically asking them to take additional steps. The fact that I initially got a flippant "your car is ready" - when I was very specific about the issue and what I wanted - isn't something I consider acceptable. TL;DR Giving 2 stars instead of just 1 because the issue DID get fixed, even though I needed to be assertive with what I wanted done / checked. The entire experience was way more to deal with than it should have been... and again, communication needs major improvement.

Once again I visited Ithaca and immediately the tire pressure warning lights popped up on the dash…read moreof my 2019 Audi A5. Apparently I visit Ithaca only when there is a massive cold snap that causes problems for tire pressure monitoring systems. Again, I reached out to Audi Ithaca to see if they could help, and once again they were awesome. They checked all the tires, reset the Audi interface, and had me on my way in 10 minutes on a Saturday morning. Nice people.

I have prepaid maintenance included in my lease and scheduled a Saturday appointment @ the nearest…read moredealership (Maguire Audi, Ithaca NY). The dealership sent me 2 email reminders to confirm my appt for the date and time selected. The dealership is an hour away from my home and these appointments are incredibly inconvenient to begin with. I arrived on time and as scheduled, only to be told by the attendant that they are not able to help me, as they are only doing Volvo service on this day. I was turned away without any assistance. I have 6 months left on my lease and will not be getting another Audi vehicle, because of this. I have 2 appointments with nearby BMW dealerships who are much too eager to help, why should I stay with this brand? I think this dealership dropped the ball and should be talked to about the way they do business and treat their customers.

I've bought my last 2 cars from Maguire. I had an excellent experience both while purchasing the…read morevehicles and after with them checking up to make sure I was happy. I live in Syracuse and bought my 4Runner from the Ithaca dealership......yes, because I had to have a blue one! The sales person actually drove my vehicle to Syracuse--in a snow storm to my place of employment and switched out the plates in my parking lot! This level of service is unheard of. I will be buying my cars at Maguire.

Everyone who works here is condescending and rude. When I walked into the dealership and said I…read morewas looking to test-drive, the first thing the sales manager said to me was "what color do you want?" I'm a woman, in my 30s. I'm not 12 years old. This was not my first car, nor was it my first decade of driving. Anyway, I test-drove a Jetta. (This location has VWs as well as Toyotas.) I couldn't tell you what color the it was, although it did handle very nicely. A sales associate rode along during the test drive and told me repeatedly what a great job I was doing at turning left across traffic and thinking to test the brakes on the car I was test-driving. I would like to once again emphasize that I'm an adult, with a driver's license, which you'd think would have been obvious to this sales associate. It's also worth nothing that I'd told him truthfully that I was looking for a replacement for the Jetta I'd already driven for 150k miles. When I said I wasn't sure looking to make a purchase that day, the sales associate said "is there anything we can do to win your heart, honey?" and -- when I continued to refuse -- added something about car buying being an "irrational decision." The 2023 Jetta did impress me, which is why I drove 90 minutes to the VW in Vestal and bought one there. Funny enough, this is almost exactly what happened in 2013. I test-drove a Jetta at Maguire, had a sales associate who only spoke to the male friend who had given me a ride to the dealership (even after my friend repeatedly tried to leave the conversation), and drove all the way to Rochester to buy the car I wanted from a sales team I actually trusted. Anyway, the 2023 Jetta's a great car: nice handling, excellent balance of torque and efficiency, and extremely safe without sacrificing a sporty feel. Buy one in Syracuse, if you're in the market.

I brought a 2001 Lexus last year in September since then I've been having so must trouble with it,I…read morepaid a little over 8,600 for it then come to find out the book value is only 1,500 I'm still putting money it

Purchased a 2010 Yaris 5-door in 2020 and the car has been perfect. Highly recommend Bob for his…read moreexpertise and focus on getting you a good value car.

I moved to Ithaca from California a few months ago to start my graduate work at Cornell. I have a…read more2011 Ford Focus, and given that both it and I have spent our whole lives on the west coast, neither of us were prepared for the winter. So after a hair-raising time skidding around on Cali tires with frozen windshield wiper fluid all December, I decided to get my car Ithacaized. I made an appointment at the dealership, saying that I wanted an oil change, to buy snow tires, and to get my windshield wiper fluid swapped out for the stuff that wouldn't freeze. Kind of annoying that I couldn't make an appointment online, but not a huge deal. I left my car at the shop and took the shuttle home, which was very convenient. Later when the shuttle returned me to the dealership about 6 hours later, I was informed that the windshield wiper fluid was a solid block of ice and was still frozen even after 6 hours in the shop and some heat gunning. They topped it off with some antifreeze mix, letting me know that it might mix in and solve the problem. Given that there really wasn't much else to be done until it thawed in April, I was appreciative that they at least came up with this solution. They also told me my old tires had plenty tread left, and that I should keep them for when spring came. Shortly after I left the dealership with my new tires, however, I noticed that the low tire pressure light was on. I would ding them a point for not checking that after changing the tires, but it's entirely possible that it came on after I left the lot. I can't say for sure because I didn't notice until I got home. In any case, I turned around and gave them a call, they told me to swing by and they would fix it. I came by, and it seemed to be something wrong with the sensor, but since it was now rather late they told me to come in tomorrow and they would check it out. When I came by, they took the wheel off of the sensor that was acting up, whose battery had apparently died. They told me that I would need a new sensor, and I got one. They even gave me a discounted rate on it and didn't charge me for labor. That seemed quite nice, considering it was a dead battery and not their negligence that caused the sensor to break. Also, they never tried to sell me a new car, unlike all of the dealerships in California who were mercilessly pushy. The two people I talked to, Doug and a guy with glasses and a beard, also were very nice. Despite some of the unavoidable hiccups that come with car ownership, I was very pleased with my service and would go back.

Do not go to any of the McGuire dealerships and give them any business specially Ithaca. They do…read morenot know what they are doing. Say cars are available when they are not. Set up appointments and not know who's coming in for the car on the same day and make somebody wait. Two hours for an appointment coming in after them to see if they buy the car first whatever happened to first come first serve! What is the point of making an appointment if they are not gonna honor it whatever you do do not give Maguire dealership any business under any circumstances ever!!!