Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Athletic Annex

    4.8 (5 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 8:00 pm

    Athletic Annex Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Athletic Annex

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 12
    Thanks 3
    Love this 15
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Shoe Stores 1,115 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    DSW Designer Shoe Warehouse - Shopping bag with shoes

    DSW Designer Shoe Warehouse

    (23 reviews)

    $$

    It was Labor day weekend and I did need some new tennis shoes and dress shoes, so I decided to go…read moreto my favorite shoe store, DSW, to see if they had any sales going on for the Labor day weekend. DSW Shoe Warehouse has always been my favorite shoe store and go to place for shoes. They have a great selection of designer shoes, and the price is right for what you pay for. I always go to the clearance rack first in the men's department to see if I can snag some great deals. This Labor day weekend they did have some great deals. I found a pair of New Balance tennis shoes for 30% off and I found a pair of dress shoes for 40% off. The value you get for your shoes is magnificent! The service is good from the staff. They are willing to help you find a particular brand of shoes in your size if it is not out on the display floor. They do go the extra mile for you if you need something. DSW is a fantastic shoe store for shoes and I would not go anywhere else for shoes because it is just that great of a place to shop for shoes. Check out DSW for your next pair of shoes. You will not regret it!

    DSW is a tried-and-true shopping spot for shoes. It's been at Clay Terrace for as long as I can…read moreremember, and I hope it never goes away. It's so much easier to try on shoes in person versus ordering online. Depending on the brand and style shoe, I can be a size 9, 9.5, 10 or 10.5. Whether I'm looking for a casual white sneaker, a fashionable sandal, or a simple pair of black dress shoes, there are always options to explore at DSW - and at reasonable price points. There are often sales, and you can sign up for their DSW Rewards program. I'm also typically able to find my shoe size in the styles I'm browsing, too. While a self try-on shoe store could easily be a mess, the aisles are typically clean and clear. All around, a good experience here at DSW!

    Cento Shoes - before and after shoe dyeing.

    Cento Shoes

    (60 reviews)

    $$

    Mile Square

    Mike Cento is a true craftsman. He took 2 pairs of shoes, resoled them, cleaned them up, polished…read morethem, etc., and now they are like new shoes. One of the pairs, my Footjoy Classics Spikeless, stopped being produced in 2009 so I wasn't sure how difficult of a project this might be for Mike. Turns out they look better than they did when they were new! More support, better constructed, and they look brand new. Mike took a pair of shoes that were literally falling apart and brought them back to life, even better than before. These Footjoys look better than anything Footjoy sells these days! Mike did such a great job that I dropped off another pair when I picked up my last 2 pair. And I have about 3 more pairs of shoes that are in need of being recrafted, Cento Shoes will be wear I am taking them. The price is right at Cento Shoes and they carry all the good and necessary shoe care products to keep your shoes in great shape and well nourished. Jennifer who works in the front of the house is just amazing and super kind. She got me taken care of in no time and while I was there picking up my shoes I got some new socks and shoe care accessories too. Cento Shoes has been around longer than I have been alive and Mike Cento has the same passion for shoes that I do. Footwear is really important to me. If it is important to you and want support a locally-owned family business of 50+ years that brings footwear back to life, go see Mike and Jennifer at Cento Shoes, you will not be disappointed. Mike is like the Obi-Wan Kenobi of shoe recrafting. He has a new customer and a friend for life. Thank you!!!

    They have never failed me in repairing my shoes. Thought I would have to throw away a favorite shoe…read morebut thank to them for giving me a few more wears. Friendly and professional.

    Englin's Fine Footwear - The assistant manager

    Englin's Fine Footwear

    (23 reviews)

    $$$

    There aren't many reviews for this company, I looked, I swear! I found this site while hunting for…read morethose Uggs Lomel boots my daughter wanted for Christmas. They were sold out everywhere! Except this animal-named site charging triple the price, and that sketchy resale/auction site with different sellers and mostly shipping from China - no way! Then I found Englin's Fine Footwear after days of searching. I was nervous, never heard of them. Turns out they're a local Indianapolis company. They had three sizes left; my daughter's an 8.5, but coworkers said to size down. They had an 8. I was so happy, I ordered them after agonizing over whether the site and shoes were legit. I opened them right away - real Uggs, perfect quality! But then I worried they'd be too small. Everything I searched said to size up, and they were sold out by this time! I emailed customer service, freaking out, asking if they'd get more. They weren't sure but said I could return them within 365 days. Christmas morning, they fit perfectly! After dazzling them up, she wore them all day, then all day again last weekend. She says they're super comfy, no sore feet. It's her first pair of Uggs, and I think she's hooked. Thanks, Englin's Fine Footwear, for saving my holiday and for the awesome customer service!

    Great selection and most notable is that they consistently have intelligent, knowledgeable,…read moreexperienced employees. Very busy on weekends, so we try to go during the week. My husband hates to shop, so I just take him to Englin's at Keystone Fashion Mall about once/yr and he gets everything he needs at once, from dress shoes, tennis shoes, comfort shoes for trade shows, and even slippers. It's a small store but they have it all, including the very latest styles and brands. Only shoe type they don't carry is women's dress shoes (high heels). It is the BEST store to go to if you have foot troubles; they have good recommendations & all the brands you see recommended online. Support this store; it's a gem and one of the last true good shoe stores.

    Athletic Annex - shoes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...