Excellent kourabeides Greek holiday cookies. I always looked forward to Easter, when my grandpop would get these from the church, along with some spanikopita. The bakery looks unremarkable, the cookies, however are not. Delicious!! It brought back memories! The ladies behind the counter are very nice. They had the Easter bread that has the boiled eggs in it also, along with Italian cookies. Worth the trip. read more

Athens Bakery 161 Cedar Lane Teaneck, NJ 07666 Hamantaschen (triangle cookie) Baklava Cheese Danish Brownie Chocolate Eclair Spanakopita (spinach pie) Before I get to the fantasic, let me briefly warn you about one item on the menu. Order the triangle cookie at your own risk. I couldn't acquire a taste for it, let alone finish it. Do not let this one pastry discourage you because you won't have issues with the other desserts. Each sweet dish is perfect in texture and packed with the perfect amount of filling! When you see the inside of the baklava and danish, you'll know what it mean. If you aren't in the mood for a dessert, try the spanakopita. It's crispy, flaky outer texture filled warm spinach will keep you satisfied every bite of the way. It tastes just as good even when it's re-heated in the oven! The pie isn't available purchase until late morning. Seating is very limited, so be expected to order your goods to go! This local bakery is highly recommended and the owners are just as pleasant as their dessert! #athensbakery #teanecknj #cedarlane #spinachpie #baklava #spanakopita #brownies read more

See all

Yesterday my friend was available to join me on my ongoing quest to try as many delicious bakeries within a 45 minute radius as possible. Lately I've been focusing on bakeries with an ethnic focus and Athens Bakery certainly fit the bill. This bakery is in a part of Teaneck that had reasonable parking. The shop itself is clean and features a great selection. The owners were very nice. I committed the error of arriving to a bakery while hungry. That said, I kept my order reasonable. I had to have the spanakopita and it certainly didn't disappoint. It was still warm and I had them slice a portion off for my friend. It was so buttery and flaky and the spinach and cheese filling was deliciously moist. Truly a great snack/lunch. I saved the baklava and assorted cookies for dessert after dinner. Their baklava is wonderful! Very tender and the honey is smooth and not sickly sweet. An excellent dessert. The powdered sugar cookies were a great texture and the twist cookies are great with tea! Athens Bakery is worthy of a return! read more

Athens Bakery - Spanakopita so good, you'll almost forget to take your Yelp photo! - Bakeries Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

See all

Can't say enough about this mom and pop bakery. Haven't been here since pre COVID and it's still delicious! DON'T FORGET CASH OR CHECK ONLY!!! Superfriendly owners are the staff that assists you. Their spanokopita is second to none! Specifically came to pick it up for brothers, sister, mom and mom's 90+ year old Greek friend. They were kind to wrap each in foil to transport and gift easier. Don't forget to grab a bunch of their white Greek cookies, Kourabiedes!!! You won't regret it! Next time, I'll have more cash and call ahead to make sure that they are prepared for my large order as everyone can't wait for me to grab more treats from Athens bakery!!! BTW, we were lucky to find this place. My brother was on the Munchmobile years ago and we've been coming ever since then! It's worth the drive. read more

Great little local shop in Teaneck. I discovered their napoleon cake and continue to order this cake for most celebrations. It's a flaky, buttery, puff pastry topped with fruit. Sweetness of the cream is not overly sweet so older members of my family prefer this cake since it's light and guilt free way to enjoy a sweet treat. read more

See all

So happy I found this bakery through my church they were making Vasilopita for. This is a no frills, family owned, traditional Greek immigrant family bakery that sells very traditional Greek goods and traditional American as well. Everything is fresh and the Greek items are authentic. They sell the BEST kourambries I've ever had and their baklava is insanely good!!!! Very tasty, traditional and very well priced. read more

See all

A beautiful small Greek 100% family owned business. Fluffy pastries and sweet-cream fillings are just a few of the mouth-watering options served at Athens Bakery, one of the most well-regarded bakeries in Teaneck and specially known for their special spanakopita. Made exclusively by his wife every morning and they don't last all day so get in early. Athens Bakery's baked goods are sure to please every palate, as this Teaneck hot spot has received positive attention and respect from Its small community of Teaneck and through out all of NJ. Cheers! read more

Authentic Greek pastries and cake delicacies. A family business full of bakery warmth and expertise!

I get my nails done next to the bakery and had to bring dessert for my friend recovering from surgery and I remember the staff from Holy Name raving about their specialty cakes. I purchased a cheesecake and was immediately wowed. It was so light and tasty. I cannot wait to come back up to Teaneck for next nail appointment. read more

Small local mom and pop bakery... Everything is very good... The crushed nut cookies with the powdered sugar are amazing... Very fond of the apple turnovers with crumble topping... And the chocolate covered eclair with whipped cream. Have been going there for years read more

Amazing! I love creek food and dessert and took a chance at this bakery. Everything is amazing here! The owner is super helpful and friendly. He told me he and his wife make everything! The baklava is a must....the walnut rugelach is delicious. I also ordered spanakopita. I recommend highly as it's "old school" bakery heaven! I can't wait to go again! read more

Our church did a fundraiser and they ordered Vasilopita (our new years tradition) from Athens Bakery. We are very disappointed that it was stale. We never got to finish it to see who would get the lucky coin. It didn't even look appetizing. The tsoureki we had at Easter was ok though. I forgot to mention that my youngest son found a fingernail in the vasilopita. read more

Athens Bakery - This should say 2021. Sure doesn't look like it. - Bakeries Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Never disappoints! Especially love spinach pie, hamentashen, seasonal pies and cheesecake. They will also make anything on special request, one day notice. I get the best chocolate chips muffins with irresistible crunchy tops that way! read more

A little gem on Cedar Lane. This is the real deal when it comes to bakeries. They do things the old-fashioned way & they do it right. Cash only, but their prices are reasonable, better than other local bakeries. read more

THE BEST BAKLAVA I HAVE EVER HAD. Amazing Baklava, fantastic spanakopita and cheese danishes and pastries. The owner and his wife are the absolute nicest people I have ever met. They even donate leftover cookies to homeless shelters. A HIDDEN GEM IN BERGEN COUNTY. read more

Best bakery in Teaneck area worth stopping by For Spanakopita(greek spinach pie). Great birthday sheet cakes also read more

Best bakery & dessert place in this area. Always satisfied with products and services. Professionally made, very clean, and best tasting of everything owner makes. I buy rolls there for sandwiches or their challah bread for french toast. Best Napoleon, brownies & eclair desserts. Cheesecake are so good. I go there weekly. And the owner, he is so pleasant. read more

I want to this bakery to get a cake for my daughter 1st birthday..the place is nice and own by an old couple..the reason I gave a 2 star is they're not that great with baking cake and they don't know how to write on the cake.. read more

Best chocolate chocolate cake ever!!! Had it the first time at Tracy's in Little Ferry (not open anymore) and just had to ask where I could get this cake and that is how I found Athens Bakery. Don't pass it up.... And I don't know about anything else in the bakery as I go out of my way to order this cake for special occasions! read more

I ordered a cake for my husbands birthday. Over the phone I was given a price of $15 for a cake that feeds 5-8 people. I pick up the cake and on that day I can already see that the writing on the cake looked terrible. The woman continues to pack up the cake without showing me and asks for $20. I inform her of the price I was told and she told me they made the cake bigger so she's charging me more. I end up looking at the cake in the car and they spelled my husbands name wrong and didn't spell birthday correctly. The only reason I'm giving 2 stars is because the cake tasted amazing besides the terrible presentation. read more

I've lived in Teaneck since 1992, and I can't believe I have never stopped by Athens bakery. Thanks to to my colleagues at Holy Name Hospital, I found this little gem and met the owner, George. I have ordered cakes from him 4 times. Ive ordered the canoli and napoleon cakes, and everytime the cakes were licked clean to the icing by my family, friends and colleagues. He only accepts cash but for $30 for a sheet cake, I will gladly pay for it. He also puts aside bread and sweets everyday to give to the homeless. He's out on vacation in Greece right now, but I've already marked my calendar when he comes back on Aug. 23. Will definitely order from Athens bakery from now on. read more

See all

Our go to cake for all occasions is the Napoleon cake from this bakery. A drug rep brought it for us for nurses week about two years ago and we've been hooked ever since. Buttery and flakey layers with whipped cream that isn't overly sweet, topped with fresh fruit and a thin layer of apricot glaze to prevent the fruits from drying out. DELICIOUS and to die for. This isn't stocked on the storefront shelves. I've always called 24 hours or more ahead of time to place an order. Owner is sweet and will customize the size to your needs. I am drooling as I'm writing this review! read more

Athens Bakery - Napoleon cake...to die for!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

I've been coming here for birthday cakes since we were kids. I got married in a very intimate ceremony this past month and asked them to do our cake. The owner and his wife did a beautiful job for about 30 people. The cannoli cream flavor was out of this world. Everyone loved it. I cannot thank them enough for helping us and giving us a beautiful part of our wedding day. My only regret is not having a better picture of the cake from the actual reception.Thank you thank you! read more

Athens Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Teaneck, New Jersey

Best bakery! must try the Napoleon cake! Thanks for last minute order last night! Been going here for so many years now and been recommending them for parties. Never fails, people of course likes it and always ask wheres it from. read more

I love this neighborhood bakery. I just bought two large pastries for a family I was visiting today. The pastry is always fresh and delicious whenever I purchase from their neighborhood bakery. SUPPORT YOUR LOCAL ATHENS BAKERY. read more

This is not only the greatest Greek bakery, it is one of the greatest bakeries period. The owners are so hard-working and kind. Their spanikopita is second to none! I bring the individual sized ones to every party I go to. People rave about them!! Their baked goods are so super fresh and just the right amount of sweet. Some bakeries make everything disgustingly sweet. Athens adds just the right amount. I've never gotten anything from them that wasn't super delicious!! Definitely give this place a try. I promise you won't be disappointed. read more

Athens Bakery is fine goods at a delicious expense. The family own business bring decor and dedication to an ultimate medium. I've order numerous holiday cakes from Athens bakery and not once has my family and I been disappointed. read more

your almond cookies are the best cookies i have ever tasted!!! i love all your pastries and i've tried all your pastries because i have a "connection" to the family . make sure you send a couple extra home with your daughter, every single time she visits, so she can share with the people who know a great bakery when she sees one!!! seriously the best bakery out there!!! you will not be disappointed . read more

Must try the Napoleon cake!!! $35 for the half sheet cake and worth every penny. It's a buttery, flaky, puff pastry cake layered with a lightly sweetened whipped cream and fresh fruits on top. DELICIOUS!!! (Accepts Cash Only) read more

Best cake ever. Nobody makes cake the way they do. I always order for the family parties and everyone always raves about the cake. Their spanakopita is always one I never leave the bakery without either. read more

The baker is unprofessional! He's good for small things like small cakes, cookies,bagels, croissants,and other breads! If you want anything written on your cakes or cookies-Don't! Because the handwriting really sucks and you can't tell what it says! the guy is really nice! But definitely not a great bakery! read more

The blueberry muffin. Large. Chewy just slightly burned top which is a good thing. Rest mostly blueberries. Best I ever had.

I can't believe I didn't try this place sooner. It has the best spanakopita I've ever had. Delicious cookies and pastries too with a fruit danish that is amazing. Great prices too. A well kept secret in Teaneck. read more

I have been dating my Greek boyfriend for 8 years and had all the authentic Greek food. Came here to pick up pastries, spanakopita, and theropitas. They were all up to my standards. True authentic bakery and great food. read more

Best Napoleon Cake I have ever had in my life! The cream was perfection. This will now be the only bakery I will go to when I'm craving sweets. Pricing is reasonable and the bakery is extremely clean. read more

Good, old fashioned Greek bakery. The gentleman who runs the place is the nicest guy you'll meet. The baklava is worth the trip alone. Way better than anything you'll get in a restaurant. read more

I stopped in here on a whim & I'm so glad I did. The gentlemen was such a sweet man. The Spanikopita is delicious & it's a generous portion filled with spinach and cheese. I can't wait to have my baklava with coffee in the am. read more

Truly the finest Greek baking available. The Spanikopita is wonderful (and freezes perfectly so one can buy a few at a time), pastries are great, muffins are tops, and the family that own the place is really sweet and accommodating. And the prices are surprisingly low. read more