I don't know that you could get a true idea of Varrelmann's based on my 1 purchase of a blueberry scone, but here is my review. The shop was quiet on a Sunday morning. My initial thought was that there were not many German style pastries/food like I imagined there might be (cannolis were the 1st item I saw when entering). I chose a blueberry scone to share (the price was steep at $4.50 - it would have been $1 more if I would have paid with a credit card). I the scone was slightly burnt underneath and lacked any real flavor, even the blueberries oddly had almost no flavor. I was excited to visit a German bakery but was left a little underwhelmed. read more

Varrelmann's Bake Shop - Outside of the shop - Bakeries Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Rutherford doesn't miss. This bakery has been here since the building was built, according to the delightful woman behind the counter. Come in for the aroma and window appeal of fresh baked goods and stay for the friendly staff. While deciding what to order, which is difficult with all such variety, had a pleasant conversation with the woman about the history of the shop. If you aren't one for pleasantries, sprint over to the strudel display case and close your eyes and pick one. Can't go wrong with apple. All fresh-made on site that day. They also do custom cake orders. read more

Varrelmann's Bake Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Talk about great service and products! Called local bake shops for a cherry pie and they were all sold out, period. Called this shop and even though they sounded super busy and they had just sold their last one the lady on the phone told me to give her an hour and a half and she would make me the pie. When I got to the place it looked so homie. The ladies at the counter were so welcoming and nice. The pie was deliciously looking and warm, fresh out of the oven. Bought an additional treat and went home to enjoy the tasty cherry pie for our New Year's Eve party. Can't thank them enough for making our dad's only request possible. read more

Their shtrudel is above and beyond. Enough for me to drive 30 min to get it. Place is old school but products are fresh and of a high quality. read more

The 8 grain bread is delicious as are all their creations. The rice pudding is one of our favorites. Try the apple strudel.

I found this place by an accident about three years ago. I have tried their strudels, scones and pies. Everything was so good. Nothing was too sweet. Cheese scone was something I have never had before. read more

See all

Simply phenomenal! Exceptional service from these true professionals. We were searching for authentic apple strudel, and Varrelmann's was. More importantly, it was delicious, from the apples baked perfectly to be soft with a chew and a crust of flakey strudel leaves that was crisp yet light as air, with a hint of butter. Can't speak to ambiance as I saw the bakery only from outside, but the display windows looked charming. We will be back soon. Varrelmann's - Thank you! read more

I can't believe I've been in rutherford so many times and haven't thought to stop in here. It's a very quaint bakery right on Park Ave. With all the higher scale competition around, it's nice to see a small town bakery. I really just popped in to try out some treats. We left with a box with about 4 goodies in it. My favorite was the scone. Really good texture and not too sweet. The turkey sprinkle cookie was fun and delicious. We also got a raspberry nut roll which was fantastic. It was essentially super crunchy pastry wrapped around jam and nuts. Yum. We also got a coconut cupcake and that was pretty good too. They also make their own bread, they have cakes and cookies by the pound. It's always nicely decorated for the seasons. I would definitely give this place a shot. Whether you just need some fresh rolls for dinner or some treats for dessert. The service is also great, the woman that helped me out was super sweet. read more

See all

AMAZING apple strudel (we took it home and warmed up in conventional oven later in the day). Linzer cookies are authentic and delish (don't expect the American super sweet version, these are the Austrian style). Can't wait to go back to sample the other goodies there - too many to get through on our first visit, but a perfect stop on Mother's Day! read more

The pastries and donuts are divine. Been there many times, But...after an encounter there recently, I'm not sure I'll go back. I tried to purchase about $7 worth of buns- at which point the gentleman rolled his eyes at me when I pulled out my card. You don't have cash?? He asked in almost disbelief. No, Sir. I asked what the minimum was, he said "not $7". My poor kids were sad they couldn't get anything. I noticed it was 15 mins til closing. I understand the charges these business face, but this man preferred to let those baked goods go stale on his shelf or throw them out rather than eat a 40 cent processing fee. Maybe it's because I'm Latino, cause the way he snatched that bag off the counter when he found out I didn't have cash... I don't think I have the heart to go back. read more

Family owned and has authentic German apple strudel. Haven't had something quite like that in years. Fantastic selection of fresh baked breads, all with a taste from home! read more

This is one of those classic German bakeries with German specialties like their heavenly apple strudel, big crumb crumb cake, cookies, cupcakes. It all old school style here. Most of the time they have the local high school kids working place. It not a sit down bakery , you just get what you want and go. You can hardly complain about the prices they average. I'm glad it's part of the downtown Rutherford Park row area, like they say more is better. read more

Varrelmann's Bake Shop - Lemon Meringue Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Bought a pound of rugelach and they really didn't have much flavor. The chocolate didn't taste like anything and the raspberry had a hint of flavor. I can only conclude that they have been frozen many times over. Unfortunately, I wouldn't recommend with so many other better bakeries in the area ... like Mills in WR. read more

Varrelmann's Bake Shop - Chocolate and raspberry rugelach.... no flavor. - Bakeries Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

I went there to get a cake for my wife's Birthday, I had to wait at least 10 minutes for the woman behind the counter to finish her conversation with some guy about a yard sale that someone was having and all the things that the clerk was going to sell at the yard sale because it was cluttering up her home??? I bought a cake and it was at least 1 to 2 days old. I found out at home that the frosting was hard as a rock. I had asked if she could write Happy Birthday on it, but it was so hard that she wrote it on a piece of old chocolate and placed that on top of the cake, (I've never seen anything like that before). I took a tiny piece of the chocolate to taste it and it was old as well. I had to go get another cake because when we tried to cut this one, it was so hard that the icing just chipped into chunks. I'm not one to complain, this is actually my 1st yelp ever, that's how bad it was... I will never go to this bakery again, and you shouldn't either! read more

See all

Excellent cakes! I got two delicious chocolate cakes from here for a family party. Service was excellent and everyone at my party loved the cakes! read more

Local family owned bakery. Everything is delicious. The staff is great and all of the baked goods are delicious. Support small town America.

Such a cute bakery!!! It looks like a very local place that's been there for ages...that's the feel you get as soon as you step inside. Really good cupcakes and tarts. Will come back if in the area. read more

Great customer service and prices. Kathy and Pat took such great care of me while ordering two different cakes for two separate occasions. I really cannot explain in words how wonderful this bake shop and there staff is. They make anything and everything you need, taste GREAT and great prices. Kathy and Pat Thank you so much for treating me like family. read more

Went here to as I've never been here and based on the google reviews of 4.5 stars I had high expectations. I'm sorry to say, it DID not live up to my expectations. I bought a piece of crumb cake, some rugula, and 2 chocolate iced vanilla cup cakes. The crumb cake was dry as sand and I couldn't even eat it without needing some water. Then the cupcakes were again, dry as a bone and like literal dust. The rugula wasn't dry but lacked flavor and almost felt stale. I'm disappointed to see such bad quality come out of this bakery. I won't be going back, and I hope you approach this place with low expectations. I don't know how it has 4.5 stars but from what I tried, it was awful. Maybe they do have some items that might be good, but after this experience, I won't be going back to find out. Wouldn't recommend. read more

I came here a few times to give back to the town. When I buy cupcakes here, they taste like they were five days ago. It is not moist. They are dry like they put them out for a few days. I like the jelly donuts here though. If you want to try something here, try any of the donuts or rolls. The donuts are fresh, and I have tried a roll here once. It was fresh with butter. Their strawberry shortcake is delicious here during the summer. Other than that, I would proceed with caution due to my experience with the cupcakes. read more

Think strudel think Varrelmann's. I have had strudels from many bakeries but this one takes the pie, literally.. Hands down my go to bakery and the moment you step in you'll be time warped into the 60s or 70s.. The place is simple, old school and the best part they are pretty close by.. read more

Love their crumb cake and other pastry. Totally worth the trip to go there and get constantly high quality baked goods.

Varrelmann's is one of those nice little places that one can get quite reasonably priced pastries, cakes, and donuts that are always very good. read more

I love coming to this local, non-franchised bakery. The Easter lamb was worthy of an award! Just stopped by today for a tasty apple crumb, which they offered to sprinkle sugar on. My family and I have been coming here for years. I love the old-fashioned feel and their coffee. What a find in Rutherford. read more

Cute German bakery. I felt like I stepped back in time coming to this place. The girl behind the counter was very sweet (no pun intended). Make sure you try their authentic German Strudel. AMAZING. A lot of flavors to choose from. read more

Varrelmann's has the best apple cider donuts we've tried! They're flavorful and just delicious! Best around, highly recommend! Their hard rolls are smaller in size, but have a delicious taste! read more

Love this bakery!! Great cakes and they always look amazing! Best desserts for the holidays and whenever your in the mood for something sweet!! read more

I've been going to varrelmann's since forever-my dad grew up in rutherford even. Great cookies, DELICIOUS old-world German pastries, and a great, family owned place. ( They do have cake, btw) read more

See all

Love the Rye bread. My father in law loved the rice pudding. Prices are reasonable. Service is friendly. Will be back.

Stopped by this bakery to get a cake for my parent's anniversary. I purchased a chocolate cake with buttercream for $22 only to find that it was stale and the frosting was so sweet it was barely edible. Additionally, the girl working when I visited did not address us at all and looked annoyed when questions were asked. With consideration of both the price and quality I likely will not return. read more

Delicious bakery! I ordered a birthday cake & special cookies for my daughter's birthday & everything was perfect! Cathy is so pleasant as well & makes sure you are happy with your order. I would definitely recommend this wonderful business, you won't regret it! Valerie read more

Bought the famous German apple strudel to a barbecue. Lots of half slices were thrown in the garbage. $15 and no comments from the guests suggests it was no big deal. I thought so too, even though I ate all of mine. I hate wasting food. read more

I adore Kathy so sweet, the desserts are always fresh and service is so pleasant. Blueberry tarte was not overly glazed like other places...got it early while it was freshly made definitely happy I did :) read more

Varrelmann's Bake Shop - My NYE apple pie, literally the perfect balance of ingredients not overly sweet not overly citric, my mom went to pick up today - Bakeries Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

My experience going around Rutherford bakeries ! Today I was finding bakeries with yelp and visit them at their bakeries the first one the worst approach, not welcoming at all! Second one couldn't make a cake for me for Saturday and they are closed Sundays. BUT THIRD ONE I decided to call VARRELMANN'S BAKERY a very traditional Bakery and spoke to lovely Pat over the phone, since I was already disappointed with the other 2 bakeries just said to myself " let me just call around instead of me going to the bakeries" . Amazing sweetheart Pat gave the best information and definitely want to share! not only they CAN do an order of ONE CAKE !! This Sweet Bakery is OPEN SUNDAYS TOO! I am VERY satisfied with the welcoming and the pleasure to meet KATHY and PAT! You ladies rock!! It was my pleasure to meet them both , because the way they took care of me UNMATCHABLE to other Bakeries Thank you and I know I can count on you for the future! read more

Varrelmann's Bake Shop - Reliable, Tradional, Amazing Bakery ! - Bakeries Near Me - Rutherford, New Jersey

Great fresh baked with real ingredients. They do it the old fashioned way, not the healthiest but definitely delicious. All pies are great.

The very best bakery in Rutherford. Always clean, filled with the best sweets, breads etc....The best time to visit this old fashioned style german bakery is anytime. Extra special times of the year is Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter (any holiday). You will experience that happy holiday feeling that you havn't had since you were a child. And of course the cakes, muffins, cookies, danishes, pies......OMG can't name everything. If your looking for it they probably have it. Just get there! The owners and staff are awsome. read more

It's hard to pass Varrelmann's without ducking inside for one of their treats. Always fresh, delicious, and with that authentic old-world taste that you remember from childhood. I wait for Spring and their potato pancakes, love the Christmas-time sesame cookies, and of course -- apple strudel. Never disappoints, great value, and more importantly, impeccable customer service. It's like coming home. read more

Not at all impressed with their low end basic baked goods. The pasties are blend and the fillings must be canned since they taste so processed. Very old fashion and not in a good way. read more

This bakery sucks. Called to reserve a cake, explained I was stuck in traffic. Showed up literally TWO minutes after their insane closing time of 6pm, and they had already deserted the premises like the rats that likely peruse their stale goods. I assume everything is stale since they're not open when people can actually get there to purchase products. Do yourself a huge favor and go to Lyndhurst Pastry instead. read more

lies lies lies. you said you had cakes on your awning but when we walked in and asked for a cake you looked at us like we were crazy. no cake? i know you are a laundering site for the mob, i could tell by the expresso. get some cakes so we can eat them. ps - i like your bread. a lot. the bread is worthy of some shine. read more