Unfortunately, Arthur & Sons was the worst dinner of our NYC trip and also one of the most expensive. For the price and reputation, I expected much better quality. The food honestly tasted like something I could make at home using basic ingredients from the grocery store. Nothing tasted particularly fresh, and some items gave me the impression they may have been pre-made or previously frozen. I'm very sensitive and allergic to certain preservatives, and I ended up breaking out in hives after the meal. I obviously can't say exactly what caused the reaction, but it added to an already disappointing experience. From the appetizers to the drinks and pasta, nothing stood out in a positive way. The chicken was especially disappointing, it was tough, rubbery, and tasted like very low-quality chicken. At this price point, I expected significantly better ingredients and preparation. The service didn't help either. Our servers were not very attentive throughout the meal. Interestingly, the most conversation and attention we received came at the very end, after the bill arrived, which unfortunately came across as an effort to leave a better final impression before the tip. NYC has so many incredible Italian restaurants, and this was easily one of the most disappointing meals of our trip. Considering the food quality, service, and high price, I would not recommend Arthur & Sons. read more

The food at Author & Sons is definitely high-quality, well-prepared, and clearly made with care but the pricing feels a bit high for what you're getting. I ordered the veal parm, which was solid: well cooked, flavorful, and executed at a high standard. No complaints on quality. The issue is more about value than anything else. The biggest drawback for me is the structure of the menu. Pastas are all sold separately, so if you're ordering something like veal parm and want pasta on the side, you have to essentially add a whole additional dish. At a family-style restaurant, I get the concept, but it makes it less practical for smaller tables. For two people especially, it's not the most natural setup unless you're both fully aligned on sharing everything. It feels much better suited for larger groups. Overall, it's quality food and a polished experience, but the price point and format don't quite match for Casual dining read more

Love love this place!! A super romantic date night spot with delicious and huge portions. All plates are family style so you won't leave hungry. The spicy rigatoni lived up to its hype! Deff order it read more

See all

Dimly lit restaurant with gorgeous decor! Was able to walk in on a weekday evening and get a table without a reservation. The waiter was friendly and gave a lot of suggestions which was helpful when deciding what to eat. The portions are generous, so would recommend starting with less and then adding more as you need. Everything was great, but a few notes: - The food came out VERY fast. Within what felt like 5 minutes of placing the order, the entrees were already at our table. - Quite overpriced.. $20 for a glass of wine and over $30 for one pasta dish. Was it tasty? Of course, but I don't know if it was worth the steep price tag. Worth coming again perhaps in a larger group to try more items. read more

See all

Worst meatballs I've ever had. Possibly the worst meal ever in nyc. Meatballs were Flavorless, dry, too bready, even the noodles were too hard, I understand Al dente but this is undercooked. Even a Bucca De Beppo chef would come here and throw the dish out the window. Worst of all, the price was ridiculous $40 for such a bad dish. I'm not sure how a place known for being American Italian can have such a bad "Sunday gravy" 2 stars for the nice waiter. The food ruined my day read more

Arthur & Sons - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great food and ambience with generous portion sizing to match the price. Came in on a Saturday around 6:30 without a reservation and was seated immediately. The food came out so fast I was shocked. We waited longer for the bill than the food. The hostess was fabulous and fierce. Love that diva. Very cute vibes inside. I want to know where they got all of the Pizza Hut stained glass lights!! Iconic. The bread was really good with an unexpected sesame seed bottom! The marinara was a little watery if I'm being honest, but the meal was still delicious. Two people could easily split a main entree. For it being a spicy rigatoni alla vodka it could have been spicier. Both of the drinks we ordered were made well. I also found the pricing to be very fair for what you're getting and where you're getting it. Special shoutout for tap water on the table in a carafe. I drink water like a fish and appreciate when I can have enough! Definitely worth a stop. I would have been happy to wait for a table because it was that good. read more

See all

Huge restaurant tucked away in kips bay. The martinis were done really well. For apps - we got the calamari and caesar salad, which were both great. For mains, the chicken parmesan is an absolute must. The portion is huge and so good. We also got the rigatoni, which was good! read more

See all

This location has only been open since November. We had previously been to the West Village spot. The manager, who was also the hostess, was very welcoming and attentive. This location has lunch specials that we heard about on social media. I was excited to try the meatball parm sandwich. It came on a seeded roll and hot melting cheese. The sandwich did not disappoint. Our waiter accidentally put the order in as a chicken parm. They made the correction and actually comp the meal which wasn't necessary. The mozzarella appetizer was excellent and full of mozzarella cheese. They don't skimp on the cheese which wasn't necessary appreciated. The manager explained that they were still in a soft opening mode and things were still being worked on. We were the only customers in the place but we got there right at opening. I believe the experience at the West Village location is better; however, this new location needs to be given a chance. Can't wait to come back sometime when it is up and going strong. read more

See all

Maybe the place is all hype... maybe I didn't order the right things. The service wasn't the best the pasta was mediocre, the meatballs were that wonderful rustic and old school, made at home sort of meatball. I wanted the veal but we got the chicken piccata and the sauce was good. The waitress mentioned how the portions "are so big that they don't come with anything else". This was not the case at all. This was not a big portion of piccata by a long shot, I could go to the pizza place down the block and get a bigger portion for less money, the same with the rigatoni and it would have more sauce. The Cavatelli was thick and the sausage was too spicy for the dish, & spicy rigatoni wasn't spicy. The only real good things were the bread and oil, the Pizza Hut lights over the bar, & the meatballs but those were small and $30 for three. The place just opened and ran out of matchbooks already too so I'm a little bummed. I really wanted to love this place and I'd get those meatballs again in a heartbeat, I'd like to try a veal dish or chicken parm but I don't know if I'll rush over there at these insane prices. With these prices I should have been blown or blown away, neither one of us were impressed read more

See all

Tourist trap don't come here. Everything was very underwhelming and service was terrible

Sorry, forgot to take photos of main courses. We were told this was family style so we were surprised at the portions for dinner. We ordered an appetizer, pasta and veal parmigiana for 3 people thinking that this would be more than enough. But had to order another pasta and desserts. The food was ok, but we felt overpriced for what it was. read more

See all

Food was amazing and service was great !!! Def recommend !! Cute intimate restaurant great for an intimate date or fun time w your girls !

Came here for dinner, new spot that only opened a few months ago. Looked like it would be a great spot and had a variety of of Italian dishes available. I was very disappointed with the results. Anything of value is high 30-40$ for plate of pasta. Way over priced and nothing to rave about. Desserts are high teens to 20s and nothing special. A side was $15. Stay away food is not authentic and quality is not there for the price. Service was just okay, nothing fancy, they up charge you for everything for olives in a drink to minor substitutions. This place looks nice on the inside but the ambiance is not worth the price. read more

Great space with very friendly service. Host is great, managers are so nice and professional. Starters were very good. Cesar salad, meatballs and the artichoke app were excellent. The table ordered the spicy rigatoni, shrimp dish, chicken and veal parm, all were big portions and very tasty. Lots of dessert to pick: ice cream and cheesecake were the stand outs. read more

We came to Arthur & Sons to try them out for dinner - their menu offers various apps, salads, macaroni dishes, as well as seafood options. We ordered the following to share, family style: +Fried Calamari "Mulberry Street Style" +Fried Mozzarella alla Arthuro's +Baked Clams Oreganata +Eggplant Stack all Arturo's +Artichokes alla Romano +The Nemo Caesar with Fried Calamari & Roasted Peppers +Joe's Caesar Salad with Shaved Parm +the Macaroni alla Tartufo - with mushroom truffle cream sauce and Parm reggiano +Fusilli alla Limone - prepared with lemon cream sauce and basil, Parm reggiano, and topped with creamy burrata +the Eggplanta Parmigiana +Shrimp alla Fantasia - riigatoni with jumbo shrimp, broccoli, oven-dried tomatoes, sweet peas, roasted garlic, basil, and pecorino romano with alfredo sauce +Raffetto's Ravioli alla Nonna - with roasted garlic, peas, cremini mushrooms, pecorino romano in a tomato cream sauce +and, the Gnocchi alla Buratta - gnocchi with house tomato basil sauce, mozzarella, pecorino, EVOO, and topped with burrata For our mains, we tried: +the Spicy Rigatoni alla Vodka +the Gnocchi Alfredo with Basil +Fusilli alla Pesto with Old Fashioned Ricotta +Spaghetti Aglio Olio +Spaghetti White Clam Sauce +a side of Broccoli Rabe +a side of Hot Cherry Peppers & Potatoes +a side of Mushrooms with Truffle +and, orders of Artie's Garlic Bread with Cheese We came here as a group, making advance reservations; when we arrived, we were seated promptly! The space gives an old-school vibe, with mosaic-like lamp coverings, wooden counters, and exposed brick. Service was pretty friendly. +friendly staff +reservations accepted read more

Was pretty excited to come here, been wanting to come for the last few months since they blew up on ig. Started with a martini that we were asked how many olives we would want because more than one would come with an additional charge, jarred olives at that. We ordered the bake clams and eggplant stack to start. Eggplant stack was solid, but that was literally all we were happy with. The baked clams were still gritty from not cleaning them properly. We then went on to order a rigatoni with chicken cutlet. This was 46 dollars, normally I never care about spending money on food, if it's good. This was just so disappointing, not even homemade pasta, mediocre sauce that was so garlicky and the chicken cutlet was bland The service was pretty awful too. We sat at the bar and the girl we had just seemed so unhappy to be at work. So save yourself the trip to their new location, plenty of our mom and pop spots that are a lot better. read more

See all

The best thing were those meatballs. The ricotta just elevated them and made the whole dish better. The chicken parm was good but kind of regular in terms of taste. The pasta and shrimp were delicious. The space is kind of small and cramped, the lighting was really dark as well. Service was great, would definitely come back. read more

It's a dim lit restaurant and the food is amazing. The staff is amazing, I will definitely go back again with my family as we all enjoyed it. read more

See all

Just don't come here. It's pretty terrible and overpriced to boot. Picture a Times Square tourist trap relocated to Murray Hill and you'll have this restaurant. The spicy rigatoni was not spicy, and the peppers served on the side of the fried calamari were the best things in the dish. I relocated a few to my main course to provide some flavor. The worst dish was likely the fusilli alla limone which was supposed to be topped with burrata but had been so overworked that it was a ball of mozzarella -- I cut into it with my spoon expecting the liquid to seep out to mix with the pasta but it was just cheesy chunks. Fail all around. read more

Food was pretty disappointing. We saw our server 3 times. They charge $14 dollars for an Arnold Palmer that was terrible. They say it's because it helps pay for the ambiance and fits the style of the place. I'm not buying it. read more

Got a late reservation and everything was perfect! Bar service was prompt, food was tasty and plenty of it! Server was great. The place was crowded but organized. read more

Charlotte had the best recommendations! The eggplant stack and the shrimp alla fantasia are my favorites. Definitely will be back. The cosmo diavolo was fire - spicy yet delicious. Highly recommended! read more

Food was average at best and very overpriced. Perfect example of expansion gone wrong. read more

Arthur & Sons - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

My wife & I always wanted to try this place. Glad we did but we won't be coming back. Nice atmosphere & service. Veal Parmigiana was good & the shrimp scampi disappointing. Decent portions but way overpriced. read more

Arthur & Sons nails rich Italian flavors, generous plates, and warm service all around. The ambiance was great.

Well first of all I went to Open Table to make a reservation for 2 at 7:00 it showed no opening for that time. So I took a chance and went there anyway hoping to get a seat at the bar. When we got there the place was 70 percent empty, Very large bar completely empty I mean no one was at the bar Saturday night. So we took our seat at the bar and waited patiently as our bar maid made her way from the other end of the bar to take our order. My wife had a glass of wine 17.00 dollars ok not bad I ordered a kettle martini. Now on the menu martinis price was listed for 20.00 dollars still ok it is New York but for some reason I was charged 24.00 dollars for my drink. That I think is a bit much and didn't see that until I got the check. We had an appetizer and a pasta dish which were ok nothing special considering the prices that they charge. So now I get the check and see the 24.00 a little shocked. Give the young lady my credit card she comes back with that kiosk thing with 22% tip highlighted. Service was routine nothing special either. But here is the thing that also got me to write this review, The 22% tip was put on the total bill. They take it upon themselves to tip on the tax also. Now I know tipping can go either way tip before tax or total with tax. But I feel that should be the customers choice not theirs! Please let me know in comments if anyone agrees. read more

SO good! Our serve was awesome and we enjoyed everything we ate and drank here. 10/10

Had a great meal, cool decor inside. Would definitely go back. Big portions and good drinks. read more

Great food and service. We were celebrating our anniversary and the staff made us feel so special ! read more

Arthur & Sons - Restaurant bar - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The service is somewhat good. We might have come on a night that they were understaffed. But after hearing so much about this place. The food is not worth the hype. The cacio e Pepe was as dry as the table clothes the chicken was under cooked and rubbery. The Sunday night pasta dry their appetizers were good Again the bus boys were probably the most attentive although they tried to make it better but I don't think that 2 hours is justifiable for pasta. I even offered to go the kitchen and help them cook. I cannot believe I wasted a Sunday night eating at this place. Be careful just don't expect too much. It overpriced Italian, unfortunately like most places in the city. It's basically a restaurant with the hotel guest as a captive audience. Don't go out of your way honesty go to Cipriani a little more expensive but well worth it. 3 stars for the employees not the food. read more

We had a wonderful evening at the new location! The service and ambiance were great! The off menu bruschetta was delicious! And the Vodka Pasta was just the right amount of spice! read more

See all

i've been to their west village location and felt very rushed. the pasta dishes were pretty good - we enjoyed the spicy vodka the most but overall was not impressed by the service and wouldn't go back read more

$25 for a glass of "meh" wine and "meh" service. The handheld payment system is programmed to suggest a 22% tip and the only other options are 20% and 25%. For 20% I expect a modicum of interest from my server. This is the restaurant in the Pod39 where I always stay and missing the former Salvation Taco that was always a great bite and great margarita at a reasonable price. read more

We were looking forward to eating here. We spent around 45 minutes from entering to basically getting pushed out. Our waitress seemed annoyed and kept rushing us, literally took my plate with the appetizer I was still eating. She checked in on our table once, asked if we were doing okay and asked if we might be needing boxes. We had just gotten our entrees maybe 10-15 minutes before and since the portions were big enough to share we knew we would probably take some home. We said we would and before we could tell her anything else, she took our plates. She then dropped off our check and kept circling us to get us to pay. Meanwhile, the table next to us that had been there eating before us had a much different experience. The waitress was laughing and chatting with them, recommending food and drinks. It was the complete opposite experience for us. I did notice she drank from one of the water cups on the table so I assume she knew them and that's why she treated them better. The restaurant wasn't even busy, I believe there were only 2 other tables seated before us. It was quiet and seemed nice at first, but we were greatly dissatisfied and disappointed as our friends had recommended this place but all we got were watered down drinks and a $150 bill for a meal we barely got to eat. read more

Great atmosphere, service and food! Highly recommend the spicy rigatoni vodka. We will definitely be back!

The environment and service was fine, and the artichoke appetizer was decent, but the gnocchi and eggplant Parm were less than mid. The eggplant Parm was really thin, dry and lacking moisture. And the gnocchi, had kind burnt taste to it.... kind of tasted like canned or jarred tomato sauce that wasn't even done up. There are much better options to go to and this place really needs to up their game if they wanna be known and have a good reputation. By the way, the gnocchi was $40 for some reason and it was straight canned tomato sauce that was burnt and the gnocchi was not homemade. It tasted like it was from the package Trader Joe's meal and Trader Joe's probably even better. read more