I haven't done a review in quite awhile , but Anthony's deserves one after the super experience that I had there. Now when I think of Coal , I think of rusty old miners with black lungs and so forth. However I also think of high heat temperatures and well cooked pizza crust which is exactly what I got here. My pep and shroom pizza with a super well done thin and blackened crust was absolute perfection. Toppings were plentiful and the cheese was heavenly. I threw down a 'porter' with my pizza and he combo was super tasty. I decided on dessert and ordered a cheesecake with a cappuccino. What I got was a decadent slice of ecstasy. My server brought out this stealthy cappuccino with all the fixins , including a 'rock sugar' stirstick. We were both amazed at the presentation. Needless to say I hooked her up with a great tip. My meal was fabulous hope to see you all there ! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - crispy pep/mush pizza with a porter... - Pizza Near Me - Wyomissing, Pennsylvania

See all

Love it so good the wings have a nice char and the servers are super friendly and it gives a calm and clean ambiance. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wyomissing, Pennsylvania

went her for the first time a few months ago. I forgot how much i loved it until i went back again a few days ago!! Its so delicious. Idk how they do it but they do it!! read more

The Good: - Excellent server - Comfortable atmosphere - Er... Clean bathroom - Beautifully presented tuna sandwich The Unimpressive: - Pizza (bland... Mediocre crust... essentially flavorless). My guests ranked it dad last among 4 other pizza places we frequent. Papa John's is infinitely better. Pizza hut is better. - No available side dishes except mediocre salad. So, with your sandwich, no fries, no chips, no potato... nothing but a salad unless you order an entirely other dinner to eat with it. - Terribly limited menu. The Insane: - Prices. Prepare to be royally ripped. $21 for a 12" bland pizza with ONE topping. Really? Talk about margins. The Recommendation: - Just don't. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Tuna sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Wyomissing, Pennsylvania

As part of a group of three we ate lunch at Anthony's yesterday. Set within a strip mall location, and apparently part of a local chain, the dining room appeared clean and comfortable, but nondescript. Our table was served by Stephanie who was personable, prompt and professional. My two colleagues split a large pizza which appeared to be competently prepared. The only comments heard were those regarding its price, so I'll presume that they were neither wowed nor disappointed. I chose the Eggplant Milano, billed as thin slices of eggplant with ricotta cheese and tomato sauce. What arrived was beyond disappointing. The texture of the eggplant and cheese left absolutely no doubt that they began the day as a frozen product. Although topped by a sprig of fresh basil, the dish was otherwise completely void of seasoning. Some indication of salt, garlic, onion and oregano is not an unreasonable expectation of a Romano-style tomato sauce. Together the assembled dish was-- in my assessment-- an unpalatable and one-note sub-supermarket-grade entree at a price which far exceeded either portion size or quality. Stephanie, uncertainty regarding the pizza and some enjoyable lunchtime conversation account for one and one-half of the two star Yelp rating provided. As for the food, it should come as no surprise to management that the consequences of such unconscionable profiteering include the risk of being called-out. read more

Tried this place. Wow! The pizza crust, ingredients all great. The meatballs , perfect. We have gone coast to coast for good pizza place. So far, this is in our top 5. Must try it. Oh order the coal fired pizza. Highly recommended if you like thin crust pizza. read more

Their wings are laughable. How on Gods green earth can you pride yourself in your wings and then serve them raw to a customer. Nearly puked after biting into this. Pretty embarrassing to say the least. Im surprised they can still be in business and operate after something like this. Never again read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Their wings - Pizza Near Me - Wyomissing, Pennsylvania

Pizzria best in town best pizza I ever had I like the guy with the white shirt on hes a cool dude!!!!

Needlessly rude management. Didnt even get food here. Got food next door at Jersey Mikes. They had no outside tables, so i walked two doors down to Anthony's. It was a windy, overcast evening and every single table out front of their restaurant was empty (8+ tables) I sat at one of the empty tables, and in less than a minute (not exaggerating) Someone came out and said i had to buy food or else i couldn't sit there. Every. Single. Table. Outside. Was empty. I cant imagine me eating a sub quick at one of the 8 empty tables would have cost them any money. And i dont wanna play this card, but this is with me in full EMS uniform just finishing a shift. If they treat strangers serving their community this rudely, i cant imagine how theyd treat you if you asked for extra cheese or something. Staff went out of their way to shoo me away from an empty seating area because i didnt buy their pizza. Now i never will, and with this experience id warn others from doing the same read more

Our server Lilly was awesome and the food was very quick and tasty the meatballs can't and love the pot they come.

Love this spot. Been going for years. Today I went in with my daughter and when I ordered our waiter misheard me, although there is an excellent chance I just mumbled, and he brought the wrong thing. When I told him about the problem he graciously took our actual order. It took some time for the corrected order to come out but it was well worth it. They even gave us a discount for waiting. Love Anthony's food but the staff are top notch. read more

Let me start by saying I have been to several Anthony's location, and food and service have always been very good. Also would like to say that our waiter did everything he could to try and everything he could to compensate for a substandard kitchen staff and poor leadership. That said, this is officially the worst dining experience I have ever had, hands down.... We stopped to grab dinner after visiting our daughter at school. Without dragging you through the painful details, it took us nearly 90 minutes to get a pizza, salad, meatball appetizer and chicken sandwich. Our waiter apologized and said he would have the manager stop by our table. I said I would prefer to not speak to anyone and just wanted to eat our dinner and get on our way. No such luck, I had two different people stop by and introduce themselves as managers within the next 10 minutes. I told each of them that we did not to discuss but just finish our meal and leave. Both continued to ask additional questions to make a bad situation worse. This experience was so bad that we are officially done with all Anthony's locations thanks to Vanessa and her staff. If you want to wait for your food longer than Dan Marino has waited for a Super Bowl ring, this is the place to go. read more

Brian was awesome. Love wyo place Always clean. Enjoyed salad and outdoor seating. So good. Yummy read more

1st time there and was given free samples. Great pizza. Coal fired wings were fantastic.

Always good pizza, don't get in that area much. But if hungry ... Anthony's is one of the go to places in that area

The atmosphere, staff and food are amazing! This is hands-down the best pizza place have ever been to. Since it was our fist time there they even gave us samples of wings and meatballs. This will be a frequented establishment from now on. Thank you to everyone there for making the best first impression. I will be recommending to everyone we know. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Traditional pizza with pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Wyomissing, Pennsylvania

This is one of my favorite restaurants in the area. The service has always been good and the food delicious. I have a hard time getting anything but the wings here solely because I want them to be bottomless so I never have to stop eating them. They get 4 of the restaurants 5 stars on their own. The Pizza is amazing as well. Though I will say there are some people who may not like this style and I respect that... even though you're wrong. I've gotten a few of their sandwiches as well and those are always on point. The atmosphere is pretty cool as well they have a well stocked bar and TV's throughout. There is outdoor seating so on nice days/evenings you can enjoy your meal on the patio and do some good ol' fashioned people watching. All in all this is a solid place that I would recommend to anyone who's looking to get a bite in the area. read more

Mid afternoon yesterday, first time, place had only 2 other tables. Sports bar atmosphere, music a little too loud for small crowd. Waitress was very friendly and attentive. Wife and I ordered a salad & large pizza to share. Salad was great ( a little pricey), but the pizza was another story. Having read the menu expected charred crust, was not expecting grit. Didn't realize at the time I was chewing on a chunk of coal! We took about a third home and upon inspection the following day found a finger nail sized piece of coal on another piece. Needless to say not a fan of this culinary style. Recommend thorough inspection before you chomp down your next coal fired offering. I won't have to worry since I won't be returning. read more

We enjoy our Arugula Pizza and the service was even better! Shelly is very good Server, polite and professional Thank you very much for being our server read more

Horrible experience tonight, I called an hour and 15 minutes ahead of time to schedule seating. I drove 50 minutes to the site in wyomissing Pennsylvania showed up and I was told that they were not accepting reservations. I explained that I called ahead of time for pre-seating and they said they apologize but they're no longer taking those. What did this appointment, I asked for the manager and the manager would not even show her face and she sent some young kid to tell me her decision. I will never show up again to another Anthony's coal fired pizza. read more

Food is 2 stars , service is 1.5 stars , menu is awful 1 star , prices assure I never ever here again. Dan Marino who i like ownes this place should stick to football. Pizza is as a whole awful in berks county , this place does nothing to improve the pizza anyplace . This place belongs in an airport , total rip off . read more

I called yesterday with a pretty large order for a sports team and was astounded by how helpful the staff was! Edwin helped make sure our order was taken down perfectly and went out of the way to deliver the food himself instead of through a third-party delivery service. The food was delivered on time, and the team commented on how high quality it is. Every pizza we got was delicious and I wish we lived in the area so we could order from this location more frequently! read more

Charlize is the waitress you want - great service, great pizza, pasta figula soup fab- highly recommended

I want to like this place. It has good atmosphere and mostly attentive staff, but the menu is very limited and I just really didn't like the food. My boyfriend did, but he was the only one in our party. read more

Great hot wings and hot pepper wings!!! Ethan (brian) was great waiter too! Great pizza, coal fired is the best Get it well done read more

The food was good, although in the middle of summer it seems like you'd put better tomatoes in your tomato mozzarella salads. The prices they show on their menu aren't the prices they charge on your bill... Prepare to pay a couple of dollars more than what it says. I'm sure it is somewhere in the fine print... Lol... Decent food, good beer, and strange pricing on the bill... Two stars read more

Absolutely disgusting inside of here. The silverware and plates came out dirty. There's trash and food all over the floors, from not being swept. I was expected to eat my food while the table next to me was covered in trash and left overs from the last table that had been there. Very unorganized, very confident when I say this is not somewhere I'll be returning. No matter how good the food the cleanliness of this place is 0/10.. read more

My boyfriend and I were looking forward to the opening of this new location near us, but ended up having a very unimpressive and unsatisfying experience. The website advertises that Anthony's has local craft beers on draft. WRONG! We sat at the bar, and read the draft list written on the chalkboard on the wall, and let me tell you something, Red Hook and Angry Orchard ARE NOT LOCAL CRAFT BEERS! There were about 3 beers listed that were local, but what do you know? THEY WERE COMPLETELY OUT OF ALL OF THEM. Hey I got an idea guys, instead of trying to be cute and trendy by writing your draft list on a chalkboard, take it to the next step AND ERASE THE BEER THAT YOU RUN OUT OF! This will save a lot of time for everyone, and won't get anyone's hopes up. We ended up ordering Peronis (NOT LOCAL CRAFT BEER) and a pizza. Unfortunately, the pizza took 40 minutes to come out, and half of it was burned to a crisp and inedible. Maybe this explains the "Pizza Well Done" disclaimers printed all over the walls? The pizza we ordered was the Paul & Young Ron with the choice of hot or sweet peppers. We chose the hot pepper option, and the pizza was topped with WHOLE green chilies that had not been sliced, and the seeds and pith (squishy insides) had not been removed. This is an absolutely unacceptable way to serve green chilies and the concept is neither "unique" nor appetizing. Biting into the peppers fills your mouth with seeds and pepper guts that you immediately want to spit out. Additionally, green chili peppers ARE NOT HOT PEPPERS! We asked the bartender/server what the sweet pepper option was, and she replied that it was red bell peppers. We then asked her if the red bell peppers were served WHOLE on the pizza, but that was over her head. On top of it all, the speakers BLAST a terrible music selection across every genre, creating the vibe of a washed up karaoke bar lacking any ambiance whatsoever. We were very disappointed by this restaurant, and would not recommend it. read more

My friend urged me on to try the cauli pizza, so I was *game* (hoho) despite my normal aversion to sports bars. When I called to check on ingredients, the very sweet manager told me they would be happy to use my non-dairy Daiya cheese for this pizza if I supplied it -- her idea! So I brought a whole bag and ordered two pizzas, one to eat there, and one to take home for a very happy spouse who immediately got into the box. Delicious! Love the ample cauliflower crowding the thin crisp crust - looks like they use a whole head on each pie, and you know that cauliflower is not cheap these days. We also got the broccoli rabe without the meat, delicious too and a large family-style side dish enough for 3-4 (good thrown over the pizza too). They had good beers and were very kind about accommodations. It was fall, so the tvs were very loud, so much so that we could not talk easily inside. So we were able to switch to outside and had a great time there since it was warm out. I will be back with more vegan friends for some of this pizza. Crust has no egg or dairy, but make sure to skip the bread crumbs since those do have cheese in them. They are Progresso brand. I was so jonesing for the cauliflower that I did not notice there there is also an eggplant pizza. Will check that out next time. read more

Dear Anthony, There is a difference between well done and burnt. Every pizza and wing we saw come out of the kitchen was burnt so you got burning everything down pat. Way to go! Just because you say it's well done does not forgive you on burning EVERYTHING! We would have complained but we knew we would be told that they were not in fact burnt but "well done" Love. Me PS over cooked, soggy onions are not a good flavor for wings. At least add some salt for flavor to maybe to cover up the burnt taste to them. read more

The experience here was very warm and friendly. When we arrived we had a 15 minute wait during this time servers came and we ordered drinks. After we sat at our table we were asked if it was our first time there which it was. The staff really knew a lot about the menu and how the food is prepared. We ordered pizza and wings which all are made with quality ingredients so not your typical chain restaurant pizza and wings. The food was amazing. I definitely plan on returning. read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - Really good craft beers like Lady Scarlet - Pizza Near Me - Wyomissing, Pennsylvania

WOW if I died and went to heaven I would be here except I'm eating lunch and I can't stop being excited as I LOVE PIZZA this is the best stuff around if you make it over here gotta get this stuff little spendy but you get what you pay for! read more

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings - This is sausage and the back is meatball man I lived off these for two days!! - Pizza Near Me - Wyomissing, Pennsylvania

I've been here just once. Tried one of their pizza. And for the price they were charging, I was expecting to be swept off my feet. Sadly though, it was just like any other pizza of this type. We were confused regarding whether if this was a sports bar or a sit down restaurant. Too noisy for a sit down restaurant. not enough stools for a bar. In either case, my wife and I decided we'd much rather drive down to philly next time cause it'd end up costing us the same for a better quality pizza. read more

I've gone to Anthony's several times since they've opened. I've always been impressed with their service and food. They're very knowledgable on their menu and can help you pick a great meal! When my fiancé and I sit at the bar we always have great service. They offer a decent amount of craft beers and mixed drinks. The sangria is phenomenal! The food is delicious! The pizza is well done. It has a thin crust, which is good! Their wings are a must try! They're so unique and different than any other wings I have had. They are served with caramelized onions. They're baked with different Italian seasonings. They don't have sauce on them, which makes for a clean eat. There are only two downfalls but that doesn't keep it from getting 5 stars. The parking can be a bit of a pain, but they can't control that. It's located in a strip mall with several other food and service places. The other one is that the pizza can get pricey when you start adding a bunch of stuff to it. read more

My wife and I have been to this location twice, neither time was the food worth our drive from the Allentown area. The pizza is just ok, sadly the coal fired oven is clearly wasted on standard pizzeria ingredients versus true Neapolitan style pizza. The wings are slightly above average though, so if you go, I'd lean towards them. Based on my 2 experiences here, we will not be returning. read more

If you like thin crust coal fire pizza, it's worth giving a try. But if you like to choose your own topping? This isn't the place. If you have kids? This isn't the place. I'm a veggie pizza person and my only options where margarita or eggplant. My daughter is a cheese only person but def not margarita. And they don't sell by the slice and don't have child size pizzas. So I paid $10 for a lunch portion cheese pizza for my 4 year old, plus $3 for her 20oz bottle of sprite. So, like I said, not for kids. On the other hand, if you're a young childless couple, out for a pizza and a beer, this is probably worth trying. Service was decent and they have a full bar. Edited 20 min later: I had a lunch size pizza as well. And I'm still hungry. read more

Great food and great service. We'll be back! The pizza is consistently good and our server was attentive.

This place is good. The wings were great and very unique, the meatballs were good also. Pizza is coal fired with just enough char. I will definitely visit again! read more

Lunch stop during my week long stay for training @ work. Highly recommended by our trainer for what she had already experienced so we decided to venture out. Our expectations were fulfilled with prompt, courteous service; the lunch salad specials were delicious & I opted for the meatballs on the side ~ yummy goodness. I would recommend and look forward to a chance to try their wings or pizza another time! read more

Love this place! So tasty and everything is very fresh. Nice to be able to have a glass of wine or a beer with their delicious Italian food .... pizza for me every time! Beautifully decorated. Great food and great service read more