We've ordered pizza and wings several times from Anthony's for delivery. Our earlier orders were at times inconsistent. The last few times have been perfect. We ordered both wings and pizza extra crispy, the latest order today was delicious! read more

See all

What can I say? This is the best pizza in town. Let's talk about the restrooms. I went out to their restrooms and they're very clean. I washed my hands. I sat and waited for a pepperoni and sausage pizza. They make it like new New York style because the crust is really thin. It's a little expensive but it's worth it because it's the best pizza in Brighton and that's no joke. We got plenty of garlic cheese and those seeds that make your pizza hot spicy. The pizza was more than I expected. I've been into it and it was really good so if you come to Brighton, go to this pizza parlor because the pizza is really good. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

See all

When did Anthony's get rid of Spaghetti and went to this Penne pasta. I was going to order and found that they have change everything. I guess they just got new management. read more

I like the thin crusted pizza. I have not tried the thicker crust because I do prefer thinner versions, so I can't comment on theirs.

It was very hot. The music was super loud. The cashier didn't know any recipes. It costs &2,50 per topping so we got a calzone but it was like a quesadilla. A bunch of cheese (gross). The wings were good. The sauce was ok, nothing to talk about. The service was slow. I have to give it to those kids. No adults! The cashier when not on her phone was greats. Won't be going again. read more

Food was fantastic and decently priced. Their staff was friendly and accommodating. You can tell they are authentic in their recipes and want people to experience that read more

Always the best quality and service! The staff are amazing, and always quick to offer additional items for to go orders (fresh Parmesan, red pepper flakes, plates, utensils, napkins) which goes a long way when you just want a quick and easy dinner! Pizza is always consistent and pastas are great as well! We frequently pickup from this location and the staff always help me carry items to the car to avoid any issues, an extra step that goes a long way! read more

We ordered pizza to be delivered. For $50 we got a 30 minutes late and cold pizza. We won't be ordering from Anthony's again. Lousy pizza, lousy service. read more

After ordering 2 pizzas and an order of 10 boneless wings I can't believe we spent $87 with tip. I honestly ask my wife if these were a special they were running for $10. Nope, she even had a coupon! The amount of toppings was pathetic to say the least not to mention the pizza was horrible. Wings were ok but had a couple that were dried out and hard. We have eaten here before and thought it was ok but this is the last time. Do yourself a favor, stay away and save a lot of money! read more

Tashahnda at the Brighton location is such a sweetheart very kind and friendly and makes it a habit to remember her customers

Infinity TIMES Infinty is my rating! The management and staff are amazing. We walked in at 11am and the person at the counter greeted us right away, CONFIRMED OUR ORDER (that almost never happens) and was extremely pleasant. The pizza is the best Anthony's I have ever had and I have been to a lot of them. This by far was the absolute most perfect. We asked for easy sauce and crispy. Usually when we ask for that we get medium sauce and extra crispy to well done. This was a PERFECT golden brown the way pizza should be! It should have a crisp crust and easy sauce where you can taste it but it's not falling off the pizza in gobs. I am a HUGE fan of cold pizza and usually with the other Anthonys because the crust was overdone or too much sauce I won't touch it. THE CRUST WAS STILL CRISPY!!!! It was unbelievable will always come back here without question. read more

Pizza is hot and it was quick and the toppings are reasonable, but I can't hardly eat it because it's so burnt read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Burnt sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

Had their pizza delivered last night for the first time and let me tell you I was NOT DISAPPOINTED!!! all of the pizzas were perfectly cooked!! Crispy and delicious! The ingredients fresh and flavorful! I was pleasantly surprised with the amount of cheese. Maybe less than some people like but I thought it made for the perfect amount. Not too greasy like I expected from cheese and pepperoni!! They even got the ceggie pizza with no cheese correct! Most places mess that up and give cheese anyways!! The salad was beautiful. Lots of toppings all fresh. Crisp veggies. Every one was happy with it and there were no leftovers unfortunately!! Would recommend!! read more

See all

Okay we used to love this place, but now it's so hot and miss. Sandwiches are about the only thing consistent. Pizza is good one day greasy as all get out the next day. Prices are that of a top notch pizza spot that I'm hesitant to even give three stars. read more

What's not to love about Anthony's? If you ask me, ITS ALL GOOD!!! Between the amazing service the fact that there's one near where I live and another one where I work on top of incredible food. ...it's just hard to find bad thing to say about Anthony's! Prove me wrong... read more

Extremely poor customer service. The pizza we delivered arrived cold and over an hour late. I had asked for the pizza to be half cheese and they made it without cheese on half the pizza. We were so hungry at that point we just put cheese the other half and scraped the toppings off on that side and put it back in the oven. So we made our own pizza basically. The next day i received an email with a survey and i put my information down and requested a call back about the service. No one called back. So we called the store back today and the cashier working said there isnt anything that could be done because they would have needed to see the pizza in person. Which is ridiculous for a delivered pizza that i paid 10$ for delivery, that i would have had to have brought the pizza back to the store, then waited another hour for a pizza. I paid 45 dollars for a cold, late medium pizza that we ended up putting our own toppings on and cooking ourselves. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Half cheese means no cheese on half to the People who work there??!! - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

Delivered on time. NY Style pizza was so very well made. Super delicious. It was time to try something new. Glad I gave Anthony's a try!

I enjoyed their food. The cheesecake was gross but everything else the pizza & chicken parm delicious. I'd go back for dinner and not dessert read more

Today I ordered? What is Sicilian slices of pizza 3 slices. I traveled 11 miles each way. When I got home my wife and I started to share it. It is be the worse pizza that we ever had. So I called the store and the person on the other end told me I must drive 22 total miles round trip. All I wanted was a refund and told me I must return it. He said it was company policy. If I could give this place no stars I would. It's 2 hours later my wife and I still have bad taste in our mouth. I will never go back and just lose my business and I hope a lot more. No apology. No nothing your place is really bad. read more

Y'all need to fire Brian for real rude asf cried about me smelling like weed WHEN NO ONE ELSE SAID A WORD 3 ppl in the restaurant he was rude to a customer named Russ on the phone telling him that if he got the marinara sauce on the side that he could've just donated in the trash instead of being petty and not wanting it at all read more

So called Gluten Free pizza is absolutely NOT. AND the management was RUDE when I asked for a refund for the pizza that is now going in the trash. Tested it twice just for reference. read more

See all

The only reason I give this place 4 stars and not 5 is because of the cost. I grew up on the east coast and taste wise, there is nothing more comparable to New York or New Jersey pizza. A large pie with extra cheese is as close as it gets to the pizza back east. We would order it every week if the cost wasn't so high. Because it's so pricey we can only buy it once in a while. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

I keep trying to give the benefit of the doubt, but they can't seem to ever get it right. Two weeks ago, we went to eat at the store to be told it was 30 minutes to wait for our food. This became 1 hour and 15 minutes of waiting to finally get our food. The attitude of the counter staff is dismissive at best. This coming from being charged $28-$30 a pie. Today we placed an order for pickup hoping it would reduce wait time. We were advised it would be ready in 30 minutes. I get there 35 minutes after the order was placed only to be advised that it would be another 10-15 minutes. Twenty five minutes later I got my food. I specifically asked if my order was even in the oven , to which I was told it was. I did not believe that for one second even though they already collected my payment for the food. I understand prices have increased in everything, but the service level and attitudes are poor. For what you are charging ,be respectful and appreciative for the business. Your poor customer service and ok food at best is a deterrent going forward and will gladly give my business elsewhere. This will be the very last time eating at this place. I tried to support local business, but they could care less. read more

The pizza was cold, chewy and too expensive for what I got. Do not recommend. Hardly any pepperoni on the pizza. I spent $40, had it delivered and had to throw it out because it was absolutely horrible. read more

We ordered two pasta dinners and a large Italian salad the first time. It was delicious. The garlic bread was awesome!! The second time we ordered my baked ziti cheese was burnt I couldn't eat it! But We decided to try again yesterday. We ordered two Italian salads with mixed greens and we got romaine lettuce that we had to pick thru to get out the bad parts We also ordered extra garlic bread and all of it tasted burnt. They really need to get their ovens cleaned!!! So customers won't experience that taste!!!! And get your customers order right!!! The last two orders were $100!!! We won't be ordering from there again read more

For the Brighton location: If you are looking for good gluten free pizza, keep looking. I've been GF for 10 years and have had many GF pizzas. This is the worst crust I've ever had. It has hard and more like a cracker than a dough. The sausage is not the crumbly ground Italian sausage but sliced pieces of a casing sausage. Not tasty. It's also over priced for the 12" that you get. There is poor selection of soft drinks. They didn't have regular Coke or Pepsi nor Dr Pepper, Root Beer nor Lemon-aid. 22 oz fountain drink cost $3. It's was also hot in there. It was cooler outside. I won't be coming here again. read more

Pizza is good. Service is terrible! Our pizza arrived clearly dismantled with the toppings all on one side and ranch toppled over. Manager in brighton could not have cared less and refused to give me her name. I expect my $50 pizza to arrive intact. Would appreciate if the owner called me. read more

For $18.50 a sausage calzone should be cooked all the way, have more than 3 pieces of sausage in it, and had way too much cheese. Side orders of sausage and meatball were cold and the sauce was like water. read more

We have tried the location up on 120th and have always had decent pizza from that location, so we decided to see if we would have the same luck here, and we did . They seem to use a better product than your normal pizza chains. We usually pay around $ 25-30 for a Lg pizza with 2 toppings and extra cheese. My wife enjoys the calzones but in my opinion they are a little pricey for what you get. They also do offer table service which on the the weekend seems to be quite popular, as well as take-out. When they are busy expect to pick up your order around 30-45 upon ordering which if you know ahead of time doesn't really present an issue but keep in mind every pizza place is busy on the weekend. But if you want something better than Dominos than go here a little more expensive but worth it. read more

New ownership for this location has meant higher prices and lower quality. Feed the family with one topping is now over $40 00 dollars which is fine however the quality has went way down. From brown lettuce and warm pepperoni in the salad to dirty tables. This was a go to for us every weekend but I don't think we will be back. read more

Our order arrived 30 minutes after I got the message it was out for delivery. When it arrived it was not hot, it was warm. 1 18inch pizza with 5 toppings plus 12 wings cost $65. Way too expensive. I was excited to try Anthony's but now have buyers remorse. Will definitely stick to my usuals for pizza going forward. read more

The food and service is usually good. This visit was not good. They forgot our garlic bread. I had to ask for it three times. They apologized and explained they were training new employees. So, I tried to be understanding. Everyone is so short staffed. read more

I was in the car with my friend and this happened: I placed an order through Uber Eats for a scheduled pick up. I called to confirm pick up time as I was given a window of 4:45-5:15p. I called to confirm pick up time and was told they had no order for me. I asked if I could provide an order number at which point the girl on the phone starts reading me off all the orders she has. I explain my name is Angelique and I have an order number, can I please speak to a manager. The girl on the phone says I am the Manager and I said really I am surprised as you are being quite rude, to which she replied "thank you for the compliment". I was in the car with friends and family so we we were all shocked by her response. I happily reached out to Uber Eats to cancel my order which by the way was $75 for two two topping 18" pizzas. I am brand manager and understand the importance of great customer service and brand experience. Not what I would expect from the Anthony's Franchise Brand. Looks like we will be searching for a new favorite pizza joint. read more

I don't usually like to post bad reviews but my mind was changed today. Order pizza and the women on the phone said it would be 45mins to be delivered. Over an hour later I called and asked if maybe the diver got lost or something. She said the driver left 15 mins ago with our order. Finally 10mins later our order was delivered but some how she left out the salad, I called they put me on hold for another 6mins and said the driver would be back with the pizza. I was being nice and I even gave her an excuse, maybe she forgot because she had her full. It's been 35mins and no salad still. I'm thinking she's probably not coming back. Don't order from them, they suck! read more

Great little spot we found while driving around for something to eat. Apparently not many restaurants are opened on Mondays in this area, so that is what led us all the way to Anthony's. We ordered an 18" Neapolitan, with white sauce, fresh veggies, and a couple of kid servings of pasta. The kids, scarfed up their pasta immediately. The 18" pizza we ordered was much LARGER than 18", and come to find out from their website when you dine in you receive a 24" pie instead as thank you for eating there. I only wish we had known, since we would have then ordered the 12" (Dine in is actually 22"), since we were heading to the Airport and weren't in need of left overs. Other than that, the pizza pie was amazing. If I lived around this area, I would definitely make this my go to place. We might have to sneak by on our way to the airport next time, just so we can try something different. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Brighton, Colorado

If I can give this place one star I would have. They have gone down hill tremendously.... We tried them again to give them another shot and were were just disappointed again..... waited over 40 minutes for 1 pizza in the heat. The service was horrible. No one knows how to smile here....... Never ever again. Stay away! read more

How can our pizza be burnt yet cold!? An hour and a half wait for cold burnt pizza!? I don't mind the wait, I don't even mind a little burnt edge but to have it also be cold, come on!!! It's our fault for continuously supporting this business when they just keep getting worse. The foods not even the problem, usually. It actually really great pizza. We want so bad for this place to finally get it together but after two years of "one more chance" I've officially declared this pizza off our go to pizza place. We just can't keep spending money on a mediocre product with so so service. read more

Brighton location We called in our order for delivery this evening and our pizza was delivered incorrectly. We did make a special request to have sliced sausage instead of sausage crumbles on our pizza which they don't typically do they said but said they would accomodate. When our pizza was delivered with sausage crumbles we called and asked to talk to the manager. We were told the GM was too busy and would not talk to us for us to call back tomorrow. I told them I wanted to speak to him now please. When Simon came to the phone he was aloof and did not seem to care about my concern. I told him we should have been called if they could not accomodate and we would have adjusted our order. He would not deliver us a new pizza but said he'd put me on a list for a free pizza. I said that's fine but I want his first and last name so when I call for my free pizza I know who put my name on the list when speaking to person taking order. Simon refused to give me his last name then told me I was on a NEW list. The list he said he was putting me on is that I am banned from ordering pizza there. My family and I love Anthony's Pizza and eat in store at different locations at least 3-4 times per month as a family and with our sports teams and order delivery from them once in awhile also. Really disappointed in our treatment. read more

I am saddened to write a poor review, not something I typically do. However, in this case, I feel it is necessary. I have ordered from Anthony's many times over the years and have enjoyed their pizza. We live 30 minutes East and had a group of friends over for a project and decided to order pizza from Anthony's. One of our friends agreed to pick it up since he lives close to Anthony's. I ordered two large pizzas, one with pepperoni and the other with chicken, green chilis and red onion. I was shocked when the total was $62.93 and would probably not have completed the order if it wasn't that we had already told everyone what to expect for dinner and had another friend prepared to pick it up. That really wasn't the worst of it. Once the pizzas got to the house, opened them up to find minimal and I mean MINIMAL toppings. We can't even say for sure that the chicken was even on the pizza though someone said they think they had a piece of chicken. The onion was about a slice of onion scattered and a couple dollops of green chili. For the pepperoni pizza, let's just call it a cheese pizza with pepperoni here and there. The next day, we called to speak with a manager about our disappointment. Normally, we'd just pass it off as a bad night and order another time. But, with the extraordinary price and lack of toppings, we just couldn't let this one go by. Manager was friendly enough and I was thankful for that but after explaining our experience, she said she had to speak with another manager and put us on hold. She came back to say that she discussed with the owner who was there and the owner said that the night we ordered, their "head chef" was making the pizzas and therefore it was unlikely we had received subpar pizzas. The best they could do is credit us three toppings on our next order. This wasn't satisfactory to us and we asked for a better alternative such as a replacement pizza. She said only the owner could authorize and she'd go ask him. After another hold, she came back to say the owner was not going to do anything more for us. We politely told her, they'd lose our business entirely without acceptable compensation. She stated there was nothing more she could do but that had we returned the pizzas the night we ordered them, then they would have replaced those pizzas. I told her how far away we lived from them and the circumstances didn't warrant us from returning to get new pizzas. We ended letting her know that she has our phone number and if they can make it right, we'd be happy to discuss further. We also stated we'd be writing this very review. At this time, we have not heard from them to make it right. read more

It is obvious that this is not the old Anthony's. New owners don't have a clue what they are doing! Pick up order was over 40 minutes late. While sitting and watching the staff the right hand doesn't know what the left hand is doing! I will not return! Along with the terrible service the price has increase considerably! read more