Not only does Anthony's bake pizzas but they will bake you! The establishment is probably 90 degrees and muggy throughout and it was almost no wonder the worker at the counter seemed annoyed to have to do anything. Strangely also, there was not a pizza in sight. I asked about slices and they said they only had the veggie, which gave the impression that in this famous establishment there was one single slice of pizza to be found (somewhere). After you get your pizza, you can go eat in the separate, laundromat-style-looking room which is, well, the same muggy temperature. The pizza was salty and in my opinion too thick with cheese. Anthony's has character but maybe it's resting on its laurels from the past. read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - Spinach and feta slice - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

Best pizza I've ever had, delicious sauce, great cheese, perfect crust. My favorites are the gourmet and ny style, love the chicken, and their potato wedges with their wedge sauce are also really good. Worth the price, as one deep dish pizza will last me days, the customer service is also always top tier. And i love the colored interior and how they have different decorations for different seasons/holidays. Thankful for this Ann Arbor staple, and their consistently delicious pizza! read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

Great service! Cheery interior that made me smile from the moment I walked in. Delicious homemade meatballs with bits of caramelized sauce. Anthony's deep dish pizza is scrumptious. I swear the box of leftover pizza weighs three pounds! After the meatballs, we only had room for one piece of pizza, so now we have lunch for the next three days. Woo hoo! read more

See all

Gourmet is a word that gets thrown around a lot. This pizza isn't up there with what Wolfgang Puck was doing when he invented California Style Pizza in Los Angeles. But that's a good thing. For my family, we call Anthony's when we are in the mood for a hearty and heavy Chicago Style Stuffed Pizza. This is the stuff that New Yorkers hate to call pizza. They tend to think of it as a pizza flavored casserole. They aren't entirely wrong. These things are massive. When picking up a large pie in its box, there is a heft to this pizza that let's you know you're in for a hearty cheese-filled meal. My daughter loves Chicago Style pizza because the sauce is on the top, and she can scrape it off. That said, she still is deeply suspicious of a pizza one needs to eat with a fork and knife. The bottom crust on Anthony's stuffed pies tends to be nice and crispy. The pepperoni are nicely spicy. The sausage is a little odd, in that it is cut in flat "sheets" that lay evenly inside the pie, but it brings good flavor to the party. Our last trip was the first time we tried to go with half toppings in a stuffed crust pie. The division was remarkably good, with a map drawn on the outside of the box as to which half was which. It also meant that we got to try one with mushrooms, and those were delicious. I am floored that Anthony's offers individually reheated slices of these pies, and one of these days, I may be tempted to try those. In the meantime, we'll stick to our full pies, ordering the large ones. It's enough pizza for a family of eight, but the slices do reheat well. My preferred technique is to heat them in a well buttered skillet with a covered lid on low until the middle is hot, the bottom is crisp, and some of the cheese has melted and caramelized in the pan. Can you get better in Chicago? Sure. Probably. But when the craving strikes, I am really glad that Anthony's is here in Ann Arbor. read more

YIKES!! Never again will I pay $27 for a calzone & a 6 inch ham, mush & cheese toasted sub sandwich. Yes the taste was ok... not my fav, but seriously gouging on price for what you get. Keep driving & find somewhere else if you're looking for a meal. read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - Calzone & 6" (mini)sub - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

The Anthony's store on Packard took an order for a pizza and gave us a pickup time. When we arrived at that time, the pizza had not been made to order, and they had to start over. No contact had been made, and we had to sit and wait another 20 minutes for the right pizza. The store seemed disorganized and no one apologized for the mistake, lack of contact, or delay. We will not be ordering from this store in the future. read more

This was great pizza!!! The pan pizza was amazing and the NY Style was good also. We got it to go and it was still piping hot when we ate it at home. We will defiantly be back!!! read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - Trying the deep dish and NY Style pizzas! We shall see.... - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

Went to Anthony's based on the recommendation of a friend, and after seeing rave reviews on Yelp, I expected some seriously amazing pizza. What I encountered was...not quite on that level. The storefront is not a prize winner, but that's not problem! The staff is very nice and there weren't many people at the restaurant when we arrived, so we had plenty of time to order, and could get seats. (The seating is very limited though, be prepared to eat elsewhere). Getting the pizza didn't take too long, so can't complain about that! Ultimately the thing that brought the experience down for me was taste. After all the great rave reviews, I was looking for real Chicago Pizza and this just wasn't it. It was maybe above average, but not excellent as the reviews stated. read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

We were super excited to try Anthony's. Unfortunately we were disappointed by the lackluster service. We ordered a half pepperoni/half cheese pizza and cheesy bread. We got the pizza, but instead of the cheese bread from the menu, we had a cheese pizza. We called to see if there was a mistake (after driving to pick up the pizza and cheese bread) and we were given the run around. They wanted to deliver us the cheesy bread- after we had already waited 30 minutes to pick up our pizza. They wanted to have us come pick up a cheese bread- again, we just left the store and drove home. Then when we asked for a refund, the only option given was "We can give you $10 off your next purchase." ...This was our first time going to Anthony's, AND we're moving within a few days so no, a discount isn't going to help us. It was frustrating to want to try a place so badly and then be disappointed by getting the wrong thing. Then with the phone call about the error, it seemed nobody wanted to accept any responsibility and they weren't flexible at all. We also heard them in the phone during pickup and they had forgotten food on someone else's order. We were also told on the phone "So we gave you more food" like they did us a favor, which seemed rude. We were super excited to try Anthony's. Unfortunately we were disappointed by the lackluster service. We ordered a half pepperoni/half cheese pizza and cheesy bread. We got the pizza, but instead of the cheese bread from the menu, we had a cheese pizza. We called to see if there was a mistake (after driving to pick up the pizza and cheese bread) and we were given the run around. They wanted to deliver us the cheesy bread- after we had already waited 30 minutes to pick up our pizza. They wanted to have us come pick up a cheese bread- again, we just left the store and drove home. Then when we asked for a refund, the only option given was "We can give you $10 off your next purchase." ...This was our first time going to Anthony's, AND we're moving within a few days so no, a discount isn't going to help us. It was frustrating to want to try a place so badly and then be disappointed by getting the wrong thing. Then with the phone call about the error, it seemed nobody wanted to accept any responsibility and they weren't flexible at all. We also heard them in the phone during pickup and they had forgotten food on someone else's order. We were also told on the phone "So we gave you more food" like they did us a favor, which seemed rude. Not to mention they charged us for two pizzas when that wasn't what we wanted. Disappointing for a cheese bread and pizza to cost $43 and then not get it right and be rude about it read more

Don't bother. Might as well get Dominos (at least it will be on time and edible). We ordered two pizzas and a salad at 4:45. Told it would be an hour wait, which is fine--we're feeding two kids, and we ordered with plenty of wiggle room for dinner. Or so we thought. An hour later--when the food was expected to be delivered--we get a call. Turns out they were out of an ingredient we ordered. No explanation why it took them an hour to discover this critical piece of information. They can make us something else but it will take another 45 minutes. The kids' pizza is ready but delivery driver is out so...their food will just sit until the other one is ready. Two hours after ordering the food arrives. Well, some of it. One cold pizza that had been sitting out for an hour. And one burned to a crisp. As for the salad? Who knows. Delivery driver didn't have it in his car. We've ordered from Anthony's before, both for the family and larger gatherings. After this experience, though, I wouldn't recommend it to anyone else. read more

I was a big fan for a number of years but can no longer recommend Anthony's for the experience and quality of pizzas we've had over the last handful of orders. read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - New York pizza. Would not recommend. - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

So good it's worth getting fat. The Chicago style meat lovers. Ordered too many times. The Greek salad is nice.

I couldn't wait long enough before taking a picture to try a bite of my pizza lol. This is definitely a special treat kind of pie! I decided to try something new and ordered a Sicilian style pizza with extra cheese. It was so delicious after I put it in the oven for about 10 minutes on 400 and 2 minutes under the broiler. I am going to get the same thing but ask for it "well-done" next time. The crust had the perfect crunch on the outside and really nice chewy in the middle. Closest thing to Detroit style on the menu and I'm here for it! read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

Second time ordering the deep dish pizza and pretty much all we received was DOUGH! Hardly any toppings and for a whopping $39. Wont be back!!! read more

We've been loyal Anthony's customers for over a decade and order from them almost once a week. Always the same thing: Anthony's Deep Dish with spinach, mushrooms, and garlic. Always delicious. Except tonight. It was bready, bland, and had barely any cheese or toppings. Pretty sure no garlic at all. When I called to tell them, I assumed they would want to make things right for a loyal customer. Instead they offered $10 off our next order. This is a $45+ pizza. Not an adequate response. Needless to say we will be far less loyal customers in the future and our search for a new go-to for Deep Dish in Ann Arbor begins now! read more

We wanted to find a new spot for Pizza and Anthony's was a great find! Great crust, fantastic sauce and excellent toppings. We ordered the Chicago Style Carnivore "Take and Bake" and warmed it up at home. You call in advance, order your pizza, they partially cook it, we picked it up about 20mins after I called and then we took in Home and put it on our Cast Iron Pizza Pan and into a 400 Degree Oven for 17mins! It came out fresh and made my face hole happy!!!! We got a medium and it was too much for just the two of us, but we couldn't stop eating it, so now we are in a Pizza Coma!!! We will be back for sure! read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

If there's ever been a classy, five-star Chicago style pizza place in the Ann Arbor area, then Anthony's would be it. They have never let me down, and serve the best pizza you can imagine. I used to be a regular customer over at their location in the Georgetown Mall, which closed a few years ago. So visiting their new location on Packard east of Stadium, had me wondering if their quality had changed over the years or not. After enjoying a medium sized gourmet pizza, I can honestly say this place hasn't lost a bit of their charm and excellence. I love the Canadian bacon! Next time I am in the area, I need to stop by and pickup a sub for lunch. I used to watch Anthony make them fresh, and enjoy them right out of the oven with freshly melted cheese. read more

I only got to try their classic deep dish with sausage. My rating is comparing them to classic Chicago deep dish pizza restaurants: Giodarno's, Lou Malnati's, and Gino's east. I have to say for Ann Arbor, this was my favorite deep dish, but compared to classic Chicago deep dish, I found it pretty good/average, B-/C+. The sauce was rich and had a sweet hearty taste, as a preference, I prefer my sauce to have wine and some basil, or at least be able to taste those ingredients in the sauce. Their crust was well baked and not to hard, had a nice soft chew. I wished their sausage would have been sliced whole deli style instead of crumbled into the sauce. If, I have a serious craving for deep dish, I would come back here, but if you want the best you will have to drive 4 hours west unfortunately. Also, the restaurant is quite small maybe 15 people, 3 to 4 tables, something to keep in mind if eating here. The service was fairly good. read more

this place was the worst pizza i had over price for bad pizza bad sauce bad mozzarella ask for salt they don't have salt how can you make dough with no salt read more

The Chicago pizza is pretty darn good! I got wonderful service, pretty cool to get a Chicago pie in 30 minutes in our own backyard!

I am from Cincinnati OH. This is better pizza than any Chicago pizza. Trust me you will LOVE this deep dish.

An AnnArbor hidden gem! Deep dish is fantastic and reasonably priced. my pizza snob husband has found a new treat locally and this has been cycled into our rotations of the best around. Deep Dish Pizza read more

The best Chicago I've had outside of Chicago. And it's still pretty high on my list when I throw Chicago in. Calzones are great too. And if you don't want pizza the sandwiches are really good too. read more

See all

I have to say the first two times I came here I would have gave it a five. Then it moved down to a four, and now after close to 10 trips it's a solid three. Why the decline? Inconsistency. Long story short every four or five weeks it's my turn to bring dinner to game night. I always get a large Anthony's Deep Dish (different than the Chicago stuffed) with pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, and a large NY Thin pepperoni, bacon, onion. Never has the pizza been cooked the same or even looked the same. Sometimes onions are very crunchy, sometimes the NY thin is nearly burned all over the top, whereas other times it's under done. The amount of toppings is all over the place which indicates either laziness, or poor employee training / procedures / tools to implement consistency. Both of which are not a good thing. Their sausage is extremely flavorful, I wish I could get it on any pizza in my life. read more

Our favorite pizza when we visit A2. We aren't deep dish fans so we stick with NY style but it's AWESOME & the toppings are fresh & yum! B

We were in town for a visit to U of M. We're from Chicago and my son had a taste for deep dish pizza. His exact words were "let's see what Michigan deep dish is like". We ordered the Chicago style stuffed with sausage. Hands down the best stuffed pizza we've ever had. Better than any Lou Malnatis or Giordanos!!!!! Hope to be back and make this a normal stop. Great Job!!! read more

The pizza here is amazing. It is as good as any pizza I have had in Chicago, and that is impossible to beat. Great place

Pretty good deep dish pizza and the only decently priced pizza restaurant in Ann Arbor, however the decor is an experience. I love a good laugh and there were plenty of hilarious snapchats sent but the Alice in Wonderland Tea House theme with scattered CGI frogs holding pizzas leaves a lot to be desired for an Italian dinner. Only for takeout next time! read more

Anthony's Gourmet Pizza - The pizza doesn't match the background - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

The best pizza in Ann Arbor, hands down. I'm from Chicago, and I have to say their Chicago deep dish passes muster. Only downside to this place is it's kind of weird to eat in. But if you're craving some excellent pizza, order carry out and enjoy! read more

Today we visited Anthony's for the first time. We stopped by once before for dinner but there was no one inside so we decided to try something else. Today we committed. Well, we actually committed to their Main St. location...which ended up being closed down. There was a sign on their window directing us to their Packard location. We pull up and decide to still give them a go. Now, I had previously read a review mentioning how they couldn't tell if they had walked into a pizzeria or a cupcake shop so I was curious as to what we would find. What we found was an oddity, lol. We walked into a brightly painted and decorated...pizza place that was decorated in an Alice in Wonderland theme. Why though?! It's just weird. I don't know if Anthony's took over from another business and just hasn't had the chance to redecorate or if this is just their decor. Pink and black checkered floor, Alice in Wonderland stickers all over the walls mixed with fairy stickers, and then random pizza stickers mixed in. So the food. We ordered flat bread cheese bread as an appetizer, and it was really very good. The order was basically a small pizza of flat bread with cheese on it. It came with a small side of marinara sauce, but I found that I preferred the bread by itself. As my lunch I ordered a slice of deep dish cheese pizza, and my husband ordered two slices of deep dish meat pizza. Each slice was $3. Our total, including an iced tea, three deep dish slices of pizza, and the cheese bread was $20.37. The pizza was alright. I think that it would've been better (fresher) had we ordered a whole pizza from scratch as opposed to individual slices. They weren't bad, by any means. I would ask next time that there is plenty of sauce on top of mine next time. That sounds ridiculous to comment on but we're talking about the main course being pizza. What I got was crust filled with with cheese that was only covered maybe halfway with sauce. As this was our first time with them I can't account for anything other than our food, but I will say that the table near us ordered what looked to be a calzone, and it was HUGE. The other person at the table ordered a wrap of some kind, and it was huge as well. Easily could be shared by two to three people. Our waitress was nice and helpful, and they had a nice, full display of cake individually packed which all looked beautiful. So would we go back? Yes, but probably to-go. It's just such a weird environment to be eating pizza in. Would we recommend them? Yes, for their food. Update: We went back a couple of days ago for an early dinner and dined in again. Same feelings about the awkward decor (It's even in the restroom. What?) but had an even better experience. I had another single slice but this time had a veggie slice which came with spinach, onions, mushrooms, and feta cheese. I added black and green olives. This was am incredibly delicious slice of pizza. So rich and packed with ingredients. So, so good. read more

See all

I live right up the street from Anthony's and this is a regular spot for us. Firstly- the deep dish pizza is THE BEST I'VE EVER HAD! And I've eaten it alllll over the US. It's that good. Seriously, ridiculously good. I think I've got the best combo down- Anthony's deep dish with sausage and spinach. Order that. It's amazing. You will crave it constantly. Secondly- please guys, please please please change your decor. It doesn't fit your food at all. I think that the owner/manager wanted it to be a sort of tea house- but honestly, Ann Arbor has good tea houses- stick to what you guys do best- that's pizza. I don't like eating there because of it really, the decor is just terrible. Please change it. You guys will do better, I swear. It's just weird and juvenile. Other than that- best pizza (deep dish) EVER. Love you guys- keep doing whatever you're doing. Sincerely, who-would-be-your-best-customer-if-my fiancé-let-me-order-it-3-times-a-week-like-I-want-to read more

They lost our pizza, not sure if more needs to be said about this. Gourmet pizza at gourmet prices does not come with gourmet service. They gave us a refund and said we can wait 40 min for another one. read more

This goes to the top of my list for pizza in A2. What type of pizza do you want, they have it! Round, NY style, Chicago style, all amazing! Great sauce, crust, coverage of cheese and toppings. Yummy! read more

Have been a long time supporter of this pizza joint. Quality ingredients, prompt service and good pizza. Never had a bad pizza . Would be 4 star's if not for the heavy price increase. Love pizza to death, but refuse to pay $41 for a pizza I used to get for $28 WITH a salad. That was maybe 2 years ago. Very cognizant of price fluctuations, but still. read more

I wish there was an Anthony's in every city in Michigan. The decor is cute, different from the Maple store. You get what you pay for, which is good pizza with fresh toppings. Get the Anthony's Gourmet deep dish if you go, it is worth the wait for the best deep dish in Michigan. read more

Unbelievably good pizza. Each style is delicious. Yeah, it's quite expensive for pizza but a large deep-dish can easily feed 3 or 4 people and they will all be happy. Depends how you look at it. I don't go often but it always meets my expectations. Plan ahead, though, it takes at least 45-60 even if they aren't busy. Also, no online ordering and I've heard they can be kinda rude on the phone. read more

At the top of their menu, right under their logo reads the claim "Specializing in Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza." This seems likely to be true, as nearly all parts of my experience did not suggest this place to be a well-rounded 'gourmet' pizza location (wow... no pun intended). Upon first walking in, it was not so much the fantastical Alice in Wonderland color scheme that caught my attention, but the fact that they were serving tea. I thought I had walked into the wrong door, but realized that from the same counter, they take orders for tea as well as pizza. Not what I was expecting for a place specializing in pizza. Additionally, even for a dinner hour at 6pm there were many people in line for pickup and takeout, while the many dine-in tables sat vacant. But I had been gearing up for a delightfully sense-tingling pizza experience, and these indicators weren't enough to halt my endeavor. After I ordered--committed to a large chicken Florentine pizza (for leftovers, optimistic about what I would taste and experience)--I picked a table in their large sitting area. I was pleased that my order for tea was brought out to me at my table, and so was my pizza eventually. My pizza was brought out ready to go in a box, but when I asked about silverware and plates I was brought plastic cutlery, a paper plate, and paper towels. I wondered if I had not specified that I was there to dine in. But being less concerned about the presentation as I was about evaluating the product, I dug in. The pizza was not bad by any means, it was fairly standard. Each of the ingredients tasted fresh, but the flavor development of the chicken, mushrooms and garlic seemed to go only as far as going directly from their container onto the pizza. This would not have been bad, except for the fact that this was labeled as gourmet pizza, and I paid nearly $30 for a large pie. In that moment, it crossed my mind that the most recent reviews that I had seen had all revolved around their meaty, no-doubt saucy Chicago-style pies, and perhaps I had ventured deeper into their less-trodden specialty pizzas. I started rethinking my experience, with all of the parts adding up to an image more resembling a trusty neighborhood eatery than a pizza aficionado haven. All of this to say, their pizza does not seem justify their categorization as 'gourmet,' let alone command the price I paid. Three, maybe four stars would have been a fair rating, except for their mismatched positioning in my expectations of quality-for-price. Maybe I'll return, but with the Chicago style in mind instead. read more

There was zero meet definitely extra cheese. But yes that was my order. Due to going to the movies for our anniversary we didnt get to the pizza before you closed. Otherwise I would have called to replace it. And we left town before you opened. read more

Sorry to say, this is probably the worst pizza I've ever had. I should have known better when there was no one else in there at lunch time on a rainy day.... I wasn't told that by ordering two slices, I would be getting a "deep dish" pizza , not the usual looking normal pizza that I was expecting.... It came out as a big , gooey half a ton of bland cheese covered with congealed looking and tasting tomato sauce ....very unappetizing looking and tasting... there was no ice for my drink .... and I left most of it there.... read more

I only have one thing to say: "If it ain't Anthony's, it ain't gourmet!!!!!" On a more serious note, their pizza is incredible. It is so fluffy and amazing read more