Our server was wonderful. She was very quick and friendly. The food was fresh and delicious.

Food was fine, not memorable. Service was an absolute dumpster fire. Waiters take orders on tablets. Ours couldn't hack it and spent a full 10 minutes taking orders for 6 of us where we each repeated our orders 2-3 times to get it right. It was the most bizarre slow moving disaster I've been a part of. Maybe it's a new system but it felt like pulling teeth to order a waffle. Waiter also gave us a spiked coffee when we ordered a non-alcoholic one. When we brought that to his attention, he didn't take responsibility, didn't offer to get us the right drink, and still charged us for the spiked one. Could've been a worse situation serving alcohol to someone who didn't order it. Wild. read more

A terrific 1:00 p Sunday brunch with a mere 15 minute wait. The Belgian waffle is top notch as is the 'Hey Lucy' Omelette. The house hot sauce adds just the right kick. Yazmin was an efficient and super attentive server. The only problem is choosing among so many great menu options. I guess return visits are in order to sample more. read more

Delicious food, great variety, easy parking! Try their biscuits and gravy - the best!

Because some weeks--the weekend needs to start early. It's a Friday brunch at a local fave. Can't go wrong with the Traditional Day Starter. Eggs, your choice of meat (I choose baked bacon); bread (I choose the English muffin); and a side of grits. They have "fancy" city grits--I went with plain grits. I mug of coffee. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - The Traditional Day Starter is one of the Classics. The menu has inspired variety and a bar. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

We had breakfast this morning at another broken egg and it was an overall very solid experience. We sat outside and it was a nice patio and tables. We were there at off peak time during week, but there was no wait, which was nice. They had some amazing looking sweet treats that were hard to resist, but I ordered a got sausage, cheese, spinach omelet. It was very good. It came with potatoes, which were cooked really well and crispy, and two pieces of toast. Overall, I left feeling full and happy. I would definitely recommend giving it a shot for a quick brunch. read more

Service at this location was excellent. It started string when the host, Jesus, welcomed my family and I in with a radiant smile and quickly sat us down at a table. The food was also very good and it came out quickly. It was also very fresh and hot! There was also a great overall vibe to the establishment. read more

I started this review process by reading the other reviews because honestly I am skeptical of these reviews after having a really bad breakfast. First and foremost - I have to ponder - how much in advance did they prepare some of this food. The biscuit and the gravy I had was microwaved...a lovely spongy biscuit...not flaky like freshly baked biscuits are. And for sure the gravy showed signs of being reheated...and you could see the seperation of the ingredients...which was just yucky to look at. But even more yucky to taste. Additionally I had bacon which was not crispy but more like a chunk of thin sliced leather belt. A serious disappointment. And as a side I asked for a set of 2 flavored pancakes. I chose the bourbon flavored pancakes...they have pecans and bananas swimming in this bourbon sauce. When I say swimming...I meant the poor things had drowned. They were served with a small amount of what I suspect was syrup...but honestly the sauce on these pancakes took over the plate and there was no room for another speck of anything. I am not sure if this would be improved with offering the sauce in a small container on the side. But these pancakes were overwhelmed. So, I chose this place and it was on me. I made a huge mistake in choice. Just a few blocks in any direction on 116th street you can get great breakfast. I have a feeling many people felt the same as I left noting a few plates I saw were filled with food. For me - if you are going to charge folks...any price but at least 17 bucks a person? You have to serve hot tasty fresh food...definitely not microwaved. As someone who cooks for my family and plenty of friends...I know it's just not that hard to do better than what we got today. Food: 1/5 | Service: 3/5 | Atmosphere: 3/5 read more

Came here twice over a two month period. Ordered the same meal: Traditional Day Starter, over medium with sausage/bacon, fresh fruit/plain grits and an English muffin. The service on both visits was quick, friendly and accurate. Both the waitress and the waiter got the items on my order correct and struck a good balance between checking in and giving us space. The atmosphere is Pleasent and you can easily hold a conversation. Nice place :) I like ma' eggs, so let's start there. Both times I ordered over-medium eggs and both times they were very much over-easy. (My previous review incorrectly stated the eggs were correctly cooked over medium, when in reality they were very much over easy) I consider this a staple and expected skill of a breakfast place, so the repeated failure to cook basic eggs to order loses one star :/ The bacon was super good. You're gonna love it! Sausage was quite good, get some! The grits were very good as well, classic. Fruit was crisp and fresh. Quite good. The English muffin was done well, crispness varied, and they have blackberry jam at the table. Win! Overall, a great place for breakfast. Just the foundational eggs-to-order skills to work out :) read more

See all

This is the most greatest breakfast place in Fishers. The boys and I love coming here on breaks. Never disappoints!

We love Sophie. We vote for her and she really deserves the 50 bucks. She is a great server and we will be coming back. Great recs, the hashbrown Benedict is great. Lemon blueberry mimosas smacked. 10/10 all the way around read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I found the service outstanding. I ordered French toast with apples, and it was delicious. My meal came with 2 sides so I was full and happy. I love the location and the dining area is very clean and quiet. Most of all the staff was so kind to me. I met the owner and the manager. They both were very friendly. Thank you Another broken egg!!! I will be back to eat there when I travel through Indianapolis!!! 5 stars read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Jaydon and Geovoni! They are an amazing part of this locations crew. Frankie has been a good influence on them!!! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Love coming here with my daughter it's close enough for us to walk from our home. They have a vegetarian menu if you ask, which I LOVED. Love the outside area and the drinks are great! read more

See all

We had a great experience at another broken egg cafe! We arrived at 10:30 on a Saturday and we're sat quickly. Since we were first timers here they treated us to beignets for our appetizers! They were hot and delicious and the marmalade they were served with was tasty too. I got the cinnamon roll pancakes and they were so good! Topped with icing and fresh fruit it is definitely a sweet tooth breakfast. But I like how it was served with eggs and bacon. My boyfriend got the biscuits and gravy and chose his side of breakfast potatoes. It was also very delicious. Servings are big and great value for the price. We ended up taking half of our dishes home! Would definitely return read more

See all

Another broken egg cafe is the greatest breakfast place there is. The food is so good it could revive me from the brink of death. Everything about the food applies ten-fold to the service. Friendliest staff who I would trust with me first born. Trust me if your anywhere in Indiana come here. read more

Mediocre is the most appropriate description of everything about this place. A solid 2.5 out of 5. Our food came out close to our order (but not exactly how it was ordered). My tea was warm (but not hot). The food tasted okay (but not great). And our service was adequate (neither friendly nor unfriendly, but definitely not attentive). The decor was nice but nondescript. The entire experience (despite my remarks) was unremarkable. The biggest disappointments were that our first table was so wobbly that our stuff would slide any time it shifted, they did not have regular cream (just Coffeemate), and our bacon did not come out hot. While I would go back if I needed to, there are many better choices in the vicinity. read more

The food and coffee were delicious! The service was good. The atmosphere was like a diner, but more modern. It will definitely be a regular for me. read more

We went to this place for brunch. I had the veggie omelette with grits and my son had the cinnamon pancakes with a side of bacon and eggs. The food was very good and so filling. The waitress was very attentive as well. I will definitely be returning. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Cinnamon pancakes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

This is a phenomenal restaurant. All the food except the chicken tenders is amazing. The chicken tenders are good, but not as awesome as the rest of the food choices. The only reason I noticed that was because of how Amazing the rest of the food options are! The value and price are on point and the service is exceptional. This restaurant has also been kind and supportive of my wife's food allergy requirements. We have never been made to feel like a burden, but always treated with genuine warmth and kindness. We have been patronizing Another Broken Egg Cafe for over 7 years and don't plan on stopping anytime soon. read more

We were heading out of town for a few days and thought we'd get breakfast before hitting the road. We saw this place and decided to give it a try. Well...we walked in and saw about four tables that were occupied but no employees in sight. We waited. And waited. And...yep, we stood there like idiots for about five minutes and NOBODY showed up. We finally turned and left and I guarantee you we will never bother going again! End of story. read more

Breakfast. Everybody needs it, but where to get it? Today I decided Another Broken Egg would be convenient and breakfast there is a meal for which there is no shortage of options. But the best thing? I didn't know this, but first timers are given a small plate of beignets; crispy-fried, powder sugary beignets. And they were delicious. I imagined my friend would find something delicious. He did - the biscuits and gravy. Me, on the other hand? Oh, just a little pancake flight. One plain buttermilk, one berry, and one blueberry goat cheese. And, yes, this came with eggs and a side of breakfast meat. I chose the sweet ham. I ate a third of the delicious feast and then boxed up the rest to enjoy later. Although I don't get to Another Broken Egg frequently, each time I HAVE dined there has been consistently good. And the service! We never needed a thing or waited for a beverage refill. It's easy to keep conversation going when you're not looking for a server to walk by. We had a great experience and think you would, too! read more

See all

Our waitress was from my hometown Danville Illinois. She was so attentive and considerate and so kind. She did great . I had this crab Benedict and some potatoes and fruit bowl and a side of bacon . Hmmmm sooooo goooooood . Can't wait to go back. . I even bought a nice coffee mug from there. It was so nice in there. Loved it!!! read more

Our waitress was on it with the coffee, our food came out quickly. There were a lot of options. I had an omelet, it was called the skinny something and came with an English muffin and fruit. The omelet lacked flavor but did feel a healthy option. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Skinny Omelette - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Received an egg that was ice cold and was clearly made in advance. Toasted bread was also cold. Worst breakfast of my life. Don't be fooled by the nice neighborhood or the sky high prices. This is an extremely subpar restaurant serving undercooked, cheap, and cold (sometimes lukewarm) meals. Just because it is in the Nickel Plate district, does not mean that they can charge so much for complete crap. What an embarrassment. read more

Great drinks and very friendly servers here. I'd love to see some more vegan options on the menu - I know that might be a bit much to expect from a place with egg in the title, but I have confidence they can do it! read more

Definitely recommend using the waitlist feature in Yelp for this place since it gets quite busy. Came in for the free birthday pancakes offer (need to sign up online.) I was pleasantly surprised I could select from a few different varieties. I chose bananas foster. Very delicious with banana slices in the pancake mix. Wife joined me for a pleasant late breakfast on Saturday. She enjoyed her chicken mango salad with just the right amount of chicken and fresh mangos. read more

See all

Food was great as it is at any of their locations! This one is in a new area that is cute and has a great vibe to it. Just behind the restaurant there are swings that are a nice relaxing area to wait for your table. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

I enjoyed this place, it's also a chain restaurant. The environment that they give is very local feeling! The food was exceptional and the coffee was also very good! I thought the staff was also very nice! The only con in my mind is their hours, rather short but can see how it's great for those workers. read more

See all

I enjoyed this place. The menu is a little bit unusual so I would recommend checking it out before you go. My food was good. A little pricey, but good. read more

Too small and cramped, always jammed, no reservations, have to do something to open that place up

Wow! This may be the best breakfast in Indy!! Holly must be your server to get the full experience!!! Easy access, quick seating. Great African coffee. Super experience. Huge portions. Had to take the pancakes home. read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Honey fig pancakes - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Absolutely fantastic all around! Server: Nate. 5 stars! Super kind, helpful, attentive ... all of what you want. Food: Ridiculous! Had the Chicken and Waffles ... but waffled between ordering that and about 10 other delicious looking meal options. The chicken was very lightly breaded/fried ... the syrup they use is something to behold, having been infused with something spicy ... and the waffles were light and fluffy as advertised. This was my first visit and I'll 100% be back!! read more

Ate outside, enjoyed the meal, presentation and service were excellent.Would go again on 60 mile visit.

This was our second time here. The first time was on campus in West Lafayette a few years back. I'm glad our second visit didn't disappoint. Our waitress, Yadeara (sp?) was the best!!!! It was a joy having her as our waitress/server. She was attentive, full of smiles and laughter as we interacted with her. Just overall, she was great! Even the GM, Garrett, and manager made sure they stopped by and checked in to make sure everything was going well. You don't see that very often in restaurants. That there made our dining experience that much more worth spending our money. The food was right on. The temperature was good on everything. My Floridian omelette was different. I was a bit curious that it was a bit busy, but all the flavors meshed well together. And those little country fried, perfectly crunchy potatoes are the shat!!!!!! Yes, I said it! My peach Bellini was good as well. Oh, I dare not forget the beignets. I could use a little less powdered sugar, but overall those were a hit too!!! And that honey something concoction adds a great finishing touch. We will definitely be returning and it won't take years to do so. read more

See all

Very good food and service. This is a good spot to take friends and family for a good meal.

Wow this place was hopping! Make sure you save your place in line on their website and check in as soon as you get there. While I waited, I grab their pomegranate mule at the bar. It was a refreshing way start to the day. After having to wait probably around 20 minutes (it was Valentine's Day weekend), I was pretty hungry. Luckily the mixed berries pancakes I ordered came out quickly. The pancakes were huge! The meal also normally comes with your choice of meat side (I got baked bacon) and two eggs. I was really impressed that I was able to sub out the eggs for their country potatoes and at no extra cost! As someone who doesn't like eggs, this is practically unheard of. I left another broken egg very satisfied and stuffed to the max! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Pomegranate mule - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

First time. A+ service. Waitress was polite and responsive. We told her we weren't ready to order three different times but she returned to check within 5 minutes each time whereas most places they don't return for a loong time if you need more time to decide and don't order when first asked. A ambiance. Well arranged combination of booths and tables for seating options. A to C- food. Nothing cooked for breakfast was served hot, just warm. A+ plain grits, although not very warm, were creamy and delicious. A custom made bacon egg and cheese biscuit sandwich was DELICIOUS even though not hot (cheese should've melted). D plain pancakes dissapointing and bland taste (reminds me of IHOP). If not for butter, syrup and other topping the pancake have no taste at all. Dense texture as opposed to light and fluffy, served barely warm and would not melt butter. I asked for a new hot replacement order of pancakes which when delivered were b-a-r-e-l-y warmer, still dense and bland. Likely return again for tastety grits and custom biscuit sandwich. read more

I was introduced to Another Broken Egg Cafe about three months ago & it has quickly become one of my FAVORITE brunching locations... I'm always up for Eggs Benedict but when I saw all their AmAzInG twists (Southern(seasonal), Eggs Blackstone, Crabcake and My personal fav Smoked Salmon) on Benedict I was in Heaven! They are always busy(make a reservation or you'll end up waiting 30ish minutes; not good when you're hangry). While they are always busy, I must say, it has never affected my service(always great service at this location). If you're a bruncher you HAVE to give this place a go... and if you love Eggs Benedict then this should be a MUST on your places-to-eat-at list... It's delicious! read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Iced Coffee *mostly creamer with a splash of coffee ;) - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

A charming chain restaurant that doesn't seem at all like a chain. Our service was delightful, our food was very good, and our overall experience made us want to go back immediately. This is a great addition to the Fishers breakfast restaurant scene. But first, before I go farther, I must mention the bacon. It was fantastic! I prefer mine a bit more chewy than usual so try to order it this way. Because it's thick-sliced and baked, when it arrived it looked a bit more done than I like, but when I tasted it, this wasn't a problem -- it was chewy, flavorful, and hauntingly good, the kind that makes you remember and savor it for hours afterward. Sometimes I have trouble picking an entree, but it's because I can't decide what food I'm in the mood for, or nothing sounds particularly good. With this menu, there were so many of my favorites, and potential new favorites, that I truly couldn't decide. I finally settled on the Irish Coffee pancakes, since they're seasonal so won't be available for long, with scrambled eggs (and they offered to add cheese to these), and that bacon. (Yum!) The pancakes were delicious, although the whipped cream, advertised as "Spiked Irish whipped cream," tasted just like any other whipped cream, so that was a bit disappointing. But since, really, any whipped cream is good whipped cream, it wasn't much of an issue. The side of scrambled eggs (with cheese) came out way too runny the first time, so I had to send them back and ask that they be re-done firmer. The second attempt was much, much better. The only disappointment was that they came out with much less cheese on them this time. But, similar to the whipped cream, I was okay anyway. I will mention this to them the next time, and hope the topping of cheese is a bit more generous. As mentioned earlier, the bacon was the real star. It came with my meal, but I think the next time I may order an additional side just so I make sure I have enough! We topped off the meal with a pitcher of Apple Pie Mimosas. We had no idea what to expect, but it sounded like fun. They were good. We'll try some other flavors, and a Blood Mary or two first, but would definitely order this again. I told our server, though, that I thought they were missing out on an opportunity by not having an option to add a little Fireball to these. The cinnamon would have been a nice addition. One other thing that worked out exceptionally well was the Yelp! waitlist. We put our name in as we left the house, figuring it would take us about 10-15 minutes to drive over, park, and walk in. Our estimate was right on point, such that we walked in, announced ourselves, and were immediately shown to a table while a few others stood and waited. I love service like that! As I'd said above, I can't wait to go back again! I'm already checking out the menu to decide what I'll have the next time. I'm thinking Bananas Foster pancakes, Black Cherry mimosas, and of course that bacon! (Yum!) read more

Another Broken Egg Cafe - Menu front page - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

One more update: we have now been back to the 116th location many times and have had nothing but amazing experiences. Don't miss this place!