The pizza was pretty good. They have some unique flavors for sure. Our server was fine as well. Definitely a good mix of people, ranging from families, to college students, to couples. I would eat here again if I was in the area! read more

American Flatbread - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

We stopped in Middlebury on the way to Burlington. Probably one of the best pizzas we had. They had a variety of interesting sodas/drinks that we tried. We sat outside with paper plates so it was fairly informal (it seems like they do service inside for dinner as well). It was a highlight of our trip. read more

American Flatbread - Revolution pizza (vegetarian) - well done! - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

I brought a group of 10 with a reservation on Thurs July 4...upon arriving the gentleman at the reception asked me what I wanted...I let him know my name and that we had a reservation. He then told me our table wasnt ready and that we could wait in the lobby or outside or wherever The food part of the experience was very good, we ordered several flatbread pizzas and salads and they were great. Our server was good, attentive and friendly read more

Always great. We had a few hiccups with our order the other night. Was one of those situations where if it could go wrong, it did go wrong. But it really wasn't anyone's fault and the restaurant was aware of the issues and made it more than worth our while. Would go back in a heartbeat. read more

Always delicious, good service, great produce and ingredients! Craft cocktails made with local ingredients, always creative, great wine list and local brews. read more

We stayed a night in Middlebury and were hungry for pizza. It was a short walk from the Inn. Located downtown, across from the park along the river and waterfall. We called and asked if we needed reservations if we arrived at 5, I was told no reservation needed. When we arrived, it seemed to come across that reservations are needed. After a short wait, we were seated directly across from the pizza oven. We ordered the Evolution salad, organic greens with a raspberry vinaigrette. It was fantastic. The New Vermont Sausage pizza was the best I had enjoyed in a long time. Just stupendous. The server was excellent. She was training a new employee. Watching the young man at the pizza oven was a delight. Good thing I had a cold beer. read more

See all

I ate dinner at American Flatbread last night. There was a 10-20 minute wait to get a table but there was space in the bar if I had been too hungry to wait. I split a 16" Punctuated Equilibrium with one of my brothers. It was just the right amount for me. I washed it down with a pint of Lawsons Irish Stout. I split a mixed berry crisp with my other brother. The service was friendly. We didn't have to wait too long for our drinks, main course, or dessert. I would definitely recommend this place to others if flatbreads interest them. read more

Fantastic food and beverages. They have gluten free and vegan options that are really great! Service is excellent too!

Best pizza in central VT, hands down. And their drink specials are exceptional. Great place to eat if you are vegetarian/vegan also.

American Flatbread was on one of my 'must stop while in Vermont' list. I had tried AF years prior in Burlington and loved that they put corn on their pizza and fell in love with the clean ingredients. I was a little bummed that they did not have corn to add to my pizza this time, but it still did not disappoint! We enjoyed the Apple, cheddar & bacon pizza, it was so unique and AMAZING. Cheddar on a pizza is so different and then the sweet maple drizzle... YUM. (It could use a little more bacon). The others in our crew wanted the new Vermont sausage, which they really enjoyed, I am not a fan of fennel sausage so it was not my favorite, but still tasty. The kids enjoyed the maple lemonade, but it definitely lacked the maple aspect, but was still enjoyable. We were also very impressed with our waitress Emmy, she not only did a great job, but her personality made our visit that much better! Thank you AF and keep being you Emmy! read more

American Flatbread - Apple, bacon & cheddar with a maple drizzle! - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

See all

Always delicious! We love sitting near the oven when dining in. Love takeout, as well

Everything was absolutely amazing from service to quality of food. Taste was by far the best pizza ever. Definitely a stop to make if in Middlebury, glad we did. read more

The staff were nice and relatively attentive! There weren't a lot of people but it still felt really cozy and seeing the stone oven (if that's what you call it ) was definitely a bonus. The ceviche was decent and refreshing but I'm not sure if they offer it every day... Anyways what really did it for me was the pizza! It was thin crusted which made it super easy to eat and me and my dad finished a small pizza (which was the perfect sizing for us!). Also the pizza is cheaper than what I've seen at other places and I think they make most of their money off of alcohol (just an observation y'all!). Anyways never had pizza this digestible and delicious all in one read more

See all

Great indoor dining atmosphere. Great staff. Be sure to try the ABC Flatbread/pizza. Last few trips the pizza was not completely covered with toppings. Too much plain crust. These pizzas are not inexpensive. read more

First of all this isn't my first visit but I'm always so impressed every time I come back. While the food and atmosphere are top notch the final pillar of a great restaurant is the service and Alicia puts the final stamp on having a wonderful experience every single time I visit. She is one of the best bartenders I've encountered as her timing and sense of urgency is amazing. Oh, and the food is pretty good too! Always look forward to returning as this location hits every mark! Thanks read more

Check their hours. They only seem open in the afternoon. One thing I truly liked was the car chargers in the parking lot. We had the revolution salad which was made with an excellent blend of baby lettuce and other shredded vegetables with a nice vinaigrette. The pizza was very good but the description is way fancier than the actual pizza. The inside of the restaurant is rustic and surrounds the pizza oven. read more

Amazing place, good pizza, nice environment, beautiful location. It's a staple of Middlebury.

Seated quickly on a busy night. Excellent service with great recommendations. Had the Evolution Salad and the Punctuated Equilibrium Flatbread then finished off with Black Crisp for dessert. Very nice experience. Very pleased. read more

pizza was so good, the cocktails were awesome and aliah the waitress was so funny

Great food, outstanding service, and a fun venue. We'll be back. We enjoyed the flatbreads , salads and desert.

Very cute and cozy establishment. Pizzas were delicious and you can really taste the flavor difference since the ingredients are sourced from farms. Unique combinations as well, both on menu and the specials. You can also create your own. The drinks are also tasty. Also the bathrooms are clean, so that's a big plus. The workers were fairly attentive and kind, but it was hard to get their attention cus they were talking amongst themselves a lot. They also have car chargers outside. read more

The punctuated equilibrium is by far my favorite flatbread and don't forget to add the goat cheese to the evolution salad.

Made a reservation through Yelp, got to the restaurant and were seated immediately, I was very pleased. Their food was excellent and service was great. I would highly recommend American Flatbread and Yelp. read more

Flatbread always satisfies. We always get the Evolution salad to share + the Punctuated Equilibrium flatbread. It's cozy when it's cold out and the expanded outside seating is great. read more

Since 2003, we have enjoyed the food (amazing salads, creative and classic flatbread pizzas), the drinks (ahh...Vermont craft beer!), the attentive staff and the unique ambiance in the Marble Works above Middlebury Falls. read more

Great pizza and vibe!! Sausage is homemade and tastes amazing! Great beer list and salads too!

The inside is super cute at very location! Very Vermont and they use local ingredients which I already love. However the prices are petty high but id you consider local ingredients I suppose it makes sense. Their pizza is alright, I've definitely had better but also worse. If you're looking for wood fired pizza in a pinch you could go here but I recommend looking for smaller business! If you're in the Middlebury area just 20 minutes away is morningside bakery with the best pizza I've ever had. read more

Food is awesome. Recommend the pepper and pepperoni pizza and the cheese and herb pizza. Service is fine. Takes a little while for food to come out. It is a very pleasant establishment and is pretty kid friendly. read more

American Flatbread in Middlebury has always been a favorite. Consistently excellent through the years.

Nice atmosphere. With the pizza oven going it was a little warm, but I love hearth-baked pizza so it was worth it. Also had the Revolution salad along with the pizza. I took off one star as we were not told ahead that the cheese for the salad would cost over $3.00 more. All in all it was a very nice experience. read more

American Flatbread - Revolution pizza - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

Don't expect to be served if you got our vaccine more than 9 months ago, they won't seat you even with proof of vaccination... My family members are elderly and got their vaccines and boosters early because they were eligible early. It's great that they are trying to keep everyone safe, I DO applaud them for that. HOWEVER there is not a fourth booster/vaccine available yet, so what are they expecting people to do? Save yourself the trip if you were responsible and got vaccinated or boosted early! Not worth the trouble, or being made to feel irresponsible by the management here. read more

Great, authentic, locally sourced when possible! This business is popular and well worth a visit!

This place should be called American Douchebread. It's June of 2021: the rest of the state is open and the overwhelming majority of people in this state are vaccinated. NOT AT AMERICAN DOUCHEBREAD where it's perennially March 19th 2020! Outside and online it says "fully open". When you get in there are two milquetoast imbeciles who immediately yell at you to wear a mask. And then, when they take 45 minutes to make a $30 pizza, they won't even bring it out to you at their outdoor seating. American Flatbread represents the very worst of customer service, respect for science and facts, and the food is just mediocre. Even if this place was open, it has no charm, no vibe, and no accountability. Go buy a frozen pizza or just simply patron a different establishment - one that cares that you're spending your hard-earned money there. read more

Excellent food. Very fresh, vegetarian options, beautiful putdoor seating, excellent cocktails, wonderful service. Make reservations, it gets crowded. read more

American Flatbread - Pizza Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

See all

Food was excellent. Loved the house salad and dressing. Service was excellent. The waitress was pleasant, smiling and always making our visit perfect. read more

The best pizza in Vermont alongside amazingly fresh local salads, seasonal farm foods, great drinks & creative desserts. A great indoor & outdoor atmosphere too! read more

So much potential... early seating Saturday night ordering drinks, salad and the New Vermont Sausage and Revolution pies. So impressed with our Waitsfield experience this fall, booked a table at Middlebury. No comparison. Salad-ok but overpriced for such a simple salad - also ice cold, not my preference. Pizza arrived.... Meh. Crust soft/limp. Toppings, sparse. Observation: we were close enough to the oven to see how the meal was made. It's my contention that at 5:00pm that wood fired oven was just not hot enough to crisp up a nice pie. Can't wait to get back to the other side of the gap to get a properly cooked pie. Bill for two w/ tip $75. (BTW-staff very, very nice) read more

My first time at this Middlebury staple was when we were hosting a dinner for our first generation college students here as part of the First@Midd pre-orientation program. There were several options of pizzas available for our outside feast, but I was especially impressed by the Evolution Salad, one of the factors in why I am now a salad eater. The servers were super friendly, constantly refilling our water pitchers. I have since returned on several occasions including an (indoor) interfaith dinner, where the fancy flatbreads are placed on special trays to hold them up (as they were outdoors too). I also ate here this past spring with some friends, before I flew back home for the summer. I have found that the flatbreads are all worthy of being eaten (actually haven't encountered a flatbread here that I haven't liked yet), though I am most recently a fan of the New Vermont Sausage that somehow brings out both the sweet and savory flavors of the meat (two of my favorite tastes). read more

See all

Enjoying their great food for many years never disappointed. The consistently high quality of food and friendly service makes dining here always a satisfying experience. Service is generally very accommodating, friendly and accomplished in an expeditious way with some occasional and very seldom exceptions. Bringing visiting friends from out of town to this restaurant always garners high remarks of praise. read more

+ Unique, fresh, choice flatbread pizzas + Decent wine list - Noisy - Long wait and slow but friendly service Hint: snack or go there before you are hungry b/c we waited 11/2 hrs before we were seated. I would give them 5 stars if the wait wasn't cray cray. + Went back yesterday (7/9/13) and did the take out. Great pizza (Punctuated Equilibrium} and avoided the wait. read more