Best all round, food, service and ambiance. We no longer live in Vermont, but we make a point of visiting Fire and Ice whenever we are in the area! read more

Been coming to this restaurant for years, and absolutely love the ambiance, the knick knacks, the throwback in time. The restaurant was built around a 1921 Hacker Craft wooden boat, beautifully restored by friends of mine at Morgan Marine in Silver Bay, NY. The boat used to house an actual salad bar, pre-Covid. Now it's just a beautifully appointed mahogany boat in a big room just past the hostess station. The rest of F&I is a series of small and large rooms, some very intimate. There are artifacts everywhere (that you need to explore). Recently visited w best friend, Locomotive Breath (formerly known as Zagbolt). Sat at the bar. Seemingly lots of locals. Very capably waited on by bartender Andre. He was effective, efficient, and gregarious. Perfect young man for the job. We split a dozen wings (one of the specials which were smothered in an orange, peppery glaze). Delicious! I also had a cheeseburger w bacon. Perfectly broiled on a substantial bun. And onion rings. Plentiful. LB had a mesquite chicken panini w mashed. He loved it. Large selection of tapped and bottled beer, wine, alcohol of all kinds. One thing that kind of caught my attention was another patron's prime rib. Very fatty, on the thin side, $39. Did not think it was a good presentation or value. F&I is still one of the best restaurants around. Museum-like, and good food. Curtailed hours compared to years past, and looking for help (of all kinds). 4 stars read more

See all

I loved how nicely decorated it was here. It was like stepping into someone's home. Very comfortable waiting area with lots to look at. I thought it was cute that they have a newspaper clipped on the wall in the bathroom. The atmosphere is homey and inviting. We waited about 10 minutes and then we're taken to a table. Our waitress arrived soon after. She was so sweet and checked in often. Oddly, we were opposites this time and I ordered a strak and hubs ordered a burger. I asked for it well done. It was a bit dry but the flavor was delicious! Hubs said his burger was good, not great. The rolls we got before the meal were delicious! I would come back again. The desserts sounded really good, too, but I was to full to try them. read more

See all

Went for date night on a Friday night, did not disappoint!! Our first time ever here as Vermonters, and we absolutely loved it. Our server was attentive and very thoughtful, the service was fast for how busy they were. The food was delicious, I got the most amazing bacon onion jam with my steak that was to die for. Dessert was amazing- mudpie is my favorite!! The drinks were good, the bar did get quite busy so it was a little wait, but we were happy!! read more

See all

Such a fun spot! Filled with memorabilia from the area and abroad. Very comfortable atmosphere and quite welcoming. Our food and drinks were very very good and nicely priced. Our party of three really enjoyed lobster rolls and fries. Delish and very reasonably priced. We had beer, a craft cocktail and a mocktail - all great! Service was lovely and attentive. Highly recommend. read more

Churn 'em and burn 'em. That's the mantra at Fire & Ice. We were seated quickly (a good thing) but then the server started moving us along pretty quickly. We wanted to settle in a bit and we watched the host whisk folks by us rather hurriedly. Sort of disconcerting. We ordered drinks and they were pretty rough. The bartender doesn't seem to have much of a hand at it. When our meal came it was not really cooked so another ding there. All in all, it feels like the Sysco truck pulled up, sent our meals through whatever directions were written on the box, we were fed, then sent out. If I'm going to spend good money for a meal, I'd really like a good meal. This wouldn't be the place I'd recommend. read more

Look, there isn't that many restaurants out in Middlebury so if you're in the area, or visiting for a few days, this restaurant is an absolute must. The reviews about the inside decor being wild and fun to look at? Absolutely true. Do they have plenty of patio space during the summer months out back? Yup. Could they easily host large groups? Probably one of the only restaurants in the area that can. Fire & Ice is reasonably priced, and the quality is good. It reminds me of a better American chain restaurant (kind of like Cheesecake Factory) with it's eclectic menu choices but I wasn't disappointed with any of the items. This restaurant will always be a stop for me when I come visit Middlebury! read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - Two Lobster Rolls with Sweet Potato Fries - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

See all

Was visiting the area for the weekend and we decided on fire and ice. The interior was really cool and clearly curated over several decades. I was blown away by how good this prime rib was. When they say they slow cook it for hours on end, it isn't just marketing. The medium rare prime rib was edge to edge perfection. On top of that, slow roasting it that long clearly breaks down the fat and any collagen in a way that turns a choice cut into what *feels* like a prime cut. The au jus was great and the only thing I was left wanting for was flaky salt and horseradish (which I probably could have asked for but I'm a shy little baby wah wah. 5 stars! read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - Medium rare prime rib - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

I really wanted to like this place but our food took way too long. A burger, a wrap and two kids meals is not complicated. The table of five across from us got there right before us and was done eating before our food came. Server spent ten minutes talking to the table next to us while we waited for our food without her checking in. She was nice but not assertive. I won't come back even though my daughter loved the chicken fingers. We asked for the check and it came right away but we were not even offered the "special dessert" that comes with kids meals. Overall disappointing experience. PS Meat runs rare, medium burger was red not pink. read more

We were quite impressed with this restaurant in Middlebury VT. A large place with good parking and several choices of seating inside and outside. It is extensively decorated with VT memorabilia including a beautiful old Chris Craft lake boat in the lobby area. The menu is quite diverse and has many options including petite servings of several dishes. We enjoyed the warm bread and our entrees. Didn't have room for dessert! Pricing is quite reasonable for the quality and quantity of the food. read more

See all

I got food pointing here from an undercooked burger. The server made a mistake on which entire I ordered and they brought out a "new one" very quickly. More quickly than a safe amount of time could be. Which means the meat was not cooked to safe temps. Look at the other reviews I'm not the only one getting food poisoning from this place!!! Someone needs to call the health department asap read more

We went to Fire & Ice last night. What a disappointment! The servers were very nice. The atmosphere and decor were cute and cozy. But the food was awful. I got the braised short ribs which were flavorless. My boyfriend got the lemon, peppercorn swordfish which was almost raw and slathered in a peppercorn sludge. We were both sick later in the evening. read more

Three of us tried Fire & Ice for dinner, & overall it was great. Even if you don't eat here, it is worth stopping by to check out the one-of-a-kind restaurant decor. Every inch of wall space is covered with pictures & wall hangings of almost anything imaginable. It was a nice evening, so we opted to sit outside on the deck. Jordyn was our fantastic waitress & very personable. I ordered the Fish & Chips. What I loved was the coating was not ordinary. It was a seasoned panko that made the fish a standout. The fries were above average in flavor as well. The meal cost about $20. The basket it came in was filled with tons of fries, but sadly only two fish pieces. Admittedly I'd have preferred a 3rd piece of fish & less fries. read more

See all

Eating here was a real treat for me. I enjoyed every aspect of my dining experience. Fantastic service - all staff I encountered were attentive and friendly. I cannot recommend the lobster bisque and the lobster roll enough - both dishes are mouth-watering & absolutely delicious! Ambiance is unique and needs to be experienced to be fully appreciated. I'll definitely dine here again whenever I'm in the area! read more

See all

Neat decor. Friendly bartender. I had the rib & shrimp scampi. The prime rib was excellent. I should have just ordered the prime rib by itself. The scampi sauce overpowered the meal and my shrimp were just a touch under (still just a bit grey). I would definitely come back, but I would order something else. read more

Fire and Ice in Middlebury, VT is an American bar and grill serving generous portions and an unbeatable self-serve, fresh, VT-sourced chocolate milk station amid eclectic memorabilia. We came for dinner and had the fettuccine Alfredo made with local creamery cream, chicken tenders, lemon salmon, miso maple salmon, and chicken philly. For dessert we had the decadent, cakey brownie sundae. Fire and Ice is an enduring fixture of the Middlebury food scene and perfect for a family dinner read more

See all

Fire and Ice leaves me nostalgic for those happy moments we celebrate with families. I could go on for hours about Middlebury and F&I but I won't bore you with my college life. This restaurant has hosted me through new children, new friends, new step families, siblings , and illnesses! The little room for the children to tuck away and color is so thoughtful, and the decor is fascinating throughout. The food is always impeccable and delicious. I can't wait to go back. read more

Restaurant Review: Fire and Ice - Middlebury VT -- This restaurant is a multi-generation family-owned restaurant that has made its staple in the Middlebury area. It has designed its restaurant to cherish the memories of the town and family. You can definitely see this in its eclectic, interesting decor, starting with the Sailing Boat Hull Shaped roof to the 10+ curated themed rooms that are filled with local treasuries and memories; you can see what families flock to this restaurant, big and small, to enjoy a fantastic family dinner. -- As a seasoned traveler, having explored 68 countries and 36 states, I approach restaurant reviews with a clear criterion: Taste, Presentation, and Service. My goal is to provide an impartial perspective, highlighting both the commendable and deficient aspects of dining establishments. -- The evening started with our amazing waitress - Michelle. She had a bubbly personality, constantly checking in with us, and was quick to answer questions, provide feedback and recommendations, and quickly resolve minor issues. She represented the restaurant well. -- Appetizers We started with the Fried Mozzarella. Since we were a party of 5, I decided to order 2 orders. Big mistake. They were surprisingly large, cooked perfectly, and served with an extraordinarily tasting thick creamy marinara sauce. -- Vietnamese Spring Rolls. I was very excited about this appetizer because, most of the time, you get deep-fried rolls that taste like oil. These rolls were wrapped in rice paper, served cold, and had the perfect combination of shrimp and vegetables - accompanied by a fresh cucumber salad and served with Ponzu (soy) and peanut dipping sauce. Very refreshing to the palette, especially before a hardy meal. -- Filet Mignon - this 8 oz filet was cooked to perfection - crispy on the outside with a buttery and soft interior, which you can top it off with bearnaise sauce or 2 amazing additional sides for the steak, a Bacon-Onion Jam, which was absolutely amazing, and pickled onions. My favorite was the combination of jam and pickled onions, which were savory, sweet, and tangy. Served with a baked potato. -- Shrimp Risotto - a special for the night was topped with a creamy chevre, green peas, and garnished with an amazing watermelon radish. I find that either you do risotto right or you fail miserably. In this instance, the risotto was cooked perfectly and presented with a velvety and creamy texture, great consistency, and the perfect combination of flavors to round the dish. I was impressed with the presentation by adding the spiraled watermelon radish, which added a great dimension to the dish. -- Classic Fettucine Alfredo - This is a tough dish for me to review as I had authentic original Fettucine Alfredo with Alfredo di Lelio's family in Italy. The founder of Fettucine Alfredo. This dish definitely stood up to the classic dish as well as it could, and in comparison to other versions I have eaten, it definitely ranks well. -- Whiskey Barrel Steak (not pictured) was my main entree. This dish was definitely amazing. I was a little nervous that the Whiskey and Vermont Maple Syrup Marinade was going to be overpowering. Still, alas, it was the perfect combination of rich, smokey notes and sweet undertones of the syrup. It really provided the perfect addition of sweetness to the dish while still allowing the flavors of the steak to really stand out. The twice-baked potato reminded me of the times my father twice baked potatoes as a kid. Hard top shell broke open with a creamy textured potato filling. -- Overall - This restaurant was excellent. It provides a space for the locals and visitors to get together and have a large selection of local flavors with twists along the way. The owner clearly takes pride in what he puts on the table, and the guests are treated with a great experience. Make sure you walk through the restaurant to see all the different dining spaces, which is a great conversation starter. read more

See all

The food is super good! The mozzarella triangles are awesome, the entrees are huge! My boyfriend and I come here for our anniversaries and it's so special! The ambience is the best! It's the cutest restaurant I've ever seen! It has such a fun vibe! The servers are all super nice! Everything is such great quality and locally sourced as well so even though it's on the more expensive side it's for a reason! The pub fare is more fairly priced the entrees are a little bit more expensive than average but everything is amazing quality once again! Love it here! Great for special occasions! And TO DIE FOR DESSERT! read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - AMAZING BROWNIE SUNDAE - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

We visit Fire & Ice annually on our way through town. The first few times, I was very impressed. However, the last couple years have fallen short. We've had some issues with slow service & mistakes with our food. The most recent visit we had a great server and food came out quickly & accurately. Hoping it stays this way. We loved the French onion soup & maple bourbon steak dinner. The mojo pasta tasted a little off, but it could have been a personal preference We love the decor here. There are so many unique rooms & lots of things to look at read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - French onion soup - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

This is the coolest restaurant I have ever been in! Service was great and food was delicious- great place to have a family dinner or just pop in read more

See all

The ambiance is kinda nice. The food was decent. I'd eat here again and can recommend it.

I just had dinner at Fire & Ice this evening and it was fabulous! One of the best restaurants I have tried in years. I had the North Country Burger. That maple candied bacon on the burger was delicious. The burger patty itself was also exceptionally good aside from all the great stuff they put in it. I can't say enough good things about it. And the price was quite reasonable for its quality. I had the maple crème brûlée for desert and I thought it too was exceptionally delicious. There were a lot of other great looking things on the menu which I would love to try in the future too. I also really like the atmosphere here. The decor isn't just a kitschy collection of stuff on the walls. It actually feels like a collection of cool antiques deliberately chosen and carefully placed to create a wonderfully funky kind of place. And this may not be an important point to most people but to me it is really important that the place is not terribly loud. The noise level is actually quite reasonable. I can actually have a conversation with my date here. Of course the food was so good that I spent most of the time eating rather than talking, but we could talk easily. In summary, I will look forward to coming back here as often as I can to try more of their food. read more

THE most delicious Lobster rolls I've ever had! Such a fun, cozy spot. Everyone loved their food! read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

See all

I ordered the prime rib Sinatra (cooked medium), which comes with grilled shrimp. The original prime rib comes medium rare; I prefer my meats to be cooked medium. Nonetheless, I added a side of Cajun scallops. The meal came with complementary bread and butter. The ambiance is very tranquil, and the sever was very responsive and upbeat. The prime rib was fantabulous with the perfect flavor and seasoning. The accommodative shrimp and scallops had a phenomenal taste as well. read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - Scallops - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

See all

The restaurant is very quaint and cute! Lots of decorations and a warm environment. The food is delicious. We had the French onion soup, salad, prime rib and Alfredo. The word we kept using throughout the meal was "fresh". The salad tasted as though they went out back and picked the lettuce for my plate right before serving it! Our server Lynn was very attentive and had great recommendations (although you can't wrong with anything served here). Really great place overall. They also have complimentary chocolate milk from the local dairy farm! read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - Prime rib with mashed potatoes - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

See all

3 stars for the food, but 5 stars for the service/atmosphere. My boyfriend ordered a burger, which he thought was good but not spectacular. I ordered a caprese panini, which was extremely difficult to eat as it was pretty greasy & stuffed to the brim. The mashed potatoes were pretty dry, fries were mediocre, and bread was nothing to rave about. I ordered a margarita, which was fine, but a little watery and nothing special. Dessert was good-- maple creme brûlée! The interior is kitschy and a lot to look at; the chain restaurant that comes to mind for comparison is Buca di Beppo where there's photos, artifacts, etc all around the dining area. The porch looked nice but we opted to eat inside. Our service was fantastic; the waitress was extremely kind without being pushy or overly attentive. She took care of us and didn't mind our questions/substitutions. We really appreciated the level of service she gave, which is why I'm giving 4 stars instead of 3. read more

This is a long-standing "graduation dinner" restaurant, that of course is not only for Middlebury College, but also lots of area high school graduations. It's a great family restaurant in old New England tradition. The prime rib is still excellent, or was for me anyway. The salad bar boat is no more, due the COVID19 pandemic, but I didn't often bother with salad bars anyway, so not a loss for me. For a good meal, especially a romantic one or a special occasion, it is still a great spot. read more

t is with the heaviest of hearts that I report the latest casualty of the Covid. The salad bar at Fire & Ice. For 20+ years the spectacular salad bar room with mahogany motorboat in the middle of the room was the absolute highlight of any trip to Middlebury Vt. The selection on salad bar elevated Fire & Ice to be one of the preeminent restaurants in New England. But alas it has been removed. Sigh. Thank you for the good times and the excellent meals. It feels like a death in the family. Now I will need a new restaurant in Vermont. If you have a suggestion private message me. read more

See all

I love their food and miss their wonderful salad bar which included all-you-can eat shrimp!! And breads, olives, roasted garlic, lots of salad vegetables and dressings!! read more

I went here for dinner with a friend and her daughter. There is so much history and memorabilia inside. It takes multiple minutes to tour the whole place and see at all. They have several different rooms were small or large group can be seated. In our booth, we were surrounded by lots of pictures of celebrities in their heyday, mostly from the 40s and 50s. I was glad to be impressed with everything we ate. The salad bar is super. They have lots of options. Several different fresh baked breads that you slice yourself. Various toppings that you can put on your salad. They have sushi, and fresh fruit. Terrific carrot cake. You can make multiple trips. It cost $14, or you can add the salad bar onto any entrée for $7. I liked that the serving portions are sizable. The food is not exactly inexpensive, I spent a lot of money. It was $95 for two people and that doesn't include drinks. The service all around, wasn't stellar, but they try hard and are attentive. I would go back again for their happy hour. Where the á la carte appetizers are 40% off. I recommend this place for occasions that are special, like an anniversary or a birthday party. read more

Outstanding selection of American style standards. Nice selection of local beers. Meatloaf was excellent.

I met my brother and sister in law here for lunch yesterday. As good as the food was, it was our waitress Jenn who made the trip special. She was an absolute delight and kept us laughing the whole time. None of us have eaten here before (and I was visiting from out of town) so we weren't sure what to expect but the reviews were good. You might need to drop breadcrumbs to find your way back to your table if you have to make a trip to the restroom... but the environment gives you a nice, cozy feeling and you feel like you have some privacy to enjoy yourself. If you're in the area, definitely give it a try. Ask for Jenn, and tell her "the New Yorkers recommended her." read more

Really wanted to like this place but just couldn't. Scallops tasted fishy, added lots of lemon juice to cover it up. Husband's swordfish special was a tiny, flavorless piece that tasted like it had come right out of the freezer. Daughter's lobster rolls were ok. Wild rice was salty. Fries were the crunchy, seasoned variety that tasted like Ore-Ida. I didn't see any fresh vegetables anywhere except the salad (good). Avoid. read more

Very good, but I do miss the salad bar. Excellent food, otherwise. Look forward to dining there again.

Once again four stars-- five thousand stars for the champagne chicken, four stars for the wings, and one star for the lobster risotto, which was just not particularly good. read more

Cute. Atmosphere is crazy nice / adorable, but wait for food was long considering the place was almost empty. Food was OK. When you wait too long for food and it's eh you tend to be more harsh so take it for what it's worth I guess. read more

Fire & Ice Restaurant - Pubs Near Me - Middlebury, Vermont

See all

Bring back the salad bar, please!!! Would love to switch this back to five stars, but the salad bar's untimely death has forced my hand. Caveat that this may be a state rule implemented during the pandemic, in which case my ire is directed northeast of Middlebury. read more

We stopped in for dinner after reading the Yelp reviews. We were not disappointed. I had the lobster roll....DELICIOUS! The mixture was a perfect balance and the bread was was light, crunchy and very flavorful. Husband had the north country burger and said it was outstanding. Ok...I had just a bite and he was right. The service was great. I think our server was Madison. She was great in suggesting meals that we may enjoy. The decor is ver eclectic and unique. I spoke to the owner (really nice guy) and he explained the concept. Great place if you're in the area. read more

Food was ok. Service was slow. Portions were small - but a good place to get local fare. I would go back. I had lobster bisque/ very good and scallops - ok. Partner had steak and rice - ok. Vegetable would be a plus! read more