Our experience at Ambos was difficult to rate. A true 3.5 stars. I've given more 4 star reviews than any other rating and with that history in mind, I think 3 stars is most fitting for Ambos -- at least right now. I am relatively optimistic that with more time there will be better cohesion to the menu development and better execution across the board, but that's not where we are at present. Hudson's dining scene is already impressive and while Ambos has potential, it's not yet at the level where I'll be choosing it over my usual spots. Many of the reviews to date reflect the inconsistencies and odd choices evident across many of the dishes, so it seems I'm not alone in my thinking.
We came here at 8pm on a Friday night. As others have mentioned, the space itself is sleek and refined. That said, I still think -- like the food itself -- the space also seems to not yet know its identity. A subtle lack of cohesion that's hard to put your finger on. But it's still perfectly pleasant. There was also a bit of unevenness with the service, as we sat for quite a while before receiving water and our first round of drinks despite several people coming by to ask for our order. The second person, who ended up sticking with us as our server, said she was "taking initiative" because she saw we had been sitting for a while, without realizing we had already ordered our first round of drinks. A little odd, but after that we didn't have any other service issues so on the whole, a relatively minor hiccup.
I got the Martini Eleanore (Olive gin, Monmouth sea salt, charred olive, smoked olive oil) for my first drink, which was decent but an oddly small amount given the high price tag. It also should have been much colder, and if you like martinis you know temperature makes a big difference. I then switched to wine and got the Vital, "Pop Branco", COZs de Montexuntos, Serra de Montejunto, Portugal 2023, and orange wine that I absolutely *loved*.
Food-wise, I somewhat agree with a previous review that stated, "the ambition is in the menu descriptions" but does not "translate to the plate". Some of the dishes were very good, some left more to be desired, some were trying to hard. Eats, below:
Chicories salad, hazelnut, cider vinaigrette, fermented carrots, apples, Jake's gouda: B+
Quite the ugly presentation but overall one of the better dishes of the night. The fermented carrots made very little sense in the dish, however, and on their own weren't good either. Otherwise, a solid salad.
Beef heart carpaccio, chili escabeche paste, cipollini, chili oil, autumn olive: B
Seemed very exciting at first but the dish was actually somewhat bland relative to what I was expecting. Certainly unlike anything I'd ever had before, though, so points for novelty.
Crispy lamb neck, charred flatbread, sheep yogurt, fermented chili paste: B
The lamb itself was delicious but the dish itself was confusing. A ton of lamb so good bang for your buck but it doesn't make sense served on a flatbread and with a comical mound of herbs atop the whole thing.
Caraflex cabbage, sauerkraut, bottarga, horseradish, creme fraiche: C
Not at all what we were expecting, probably the most blatant example of the menu description selling us more than the dish itself.
Fluke, beets, fermented cranberries, herb oil: A-
For all of the poorly presented dishes we had earlier on, this dish was significantly more aesthetically pleasingly and equally delicious. The clear winner of the night. Beautiful, fresh, bright, and flavorful. read more