This place is an absolute must-have in Eagle River! For our family night out we all decided this…read morewas our unanimous option! The Cheese Curds were absolutely fantastic, we killed 3 plates with no issue (there were 9 of us). Most people got the pan fried Walleye, i would say it's a specialty of the restaurant and NOONE WAS DISAPPOINTED!!! Our waitress forgot to bring out our salads but there was so much food no one even cared! Each dish came out perfectly hot and delicious. When you're in the North Woods you absolute have to stop here! They've got a great ambiance and the food was fantastic, stop in and enjoy the best meal you'll have all week!!

This is a perfect little up north spot. The wait for a table was about 30 min. The service was ok-…read morethe waitress seemed to get flustered and confused when we asked for separate checks (but ended up doing it anyway)- she just kept repeating there's an atm. The food was pretty solid. My only complaint/concern was one of my daughter's chicken strips were not cooked- thankfully I was cutting them when I found out. Everything else seemed to be normal be type food.

We stopped in on our way through based on the Yelp reviews, and it did not disappoint. Service was…read morefriendly and attentive (in a positive way)--we enjoyed our server. All the food was made on site, including the blue cheese salad dressing and tartar sauce, which were excellent. We had the duck Marsala and the pan fried walleye. Loved the crispy skin on the duck. And flavorful breading on the walleye. Finished off with a slice of blueberry cheesecake that is not to be missed! Made on site and excellent. Will make a point to stop again.

Outstanding dinner tonight. Great view of the lake from our table. Tender juicy perfectly burnt…read moreends on the smoked brisket dinner tonight. Served with choice of homemade sauces, loaded baked potato and a side salad with homemade blue cheese dressing. Added the sweet snow crab legs special. Attentive service and that Smoked whiskey old fashioned was a perfect pour!

A must stop for dinner if in the area. The menu always has a large offering and care is taken for…read moreeach dish served. Some of the best steaks I've had were right here versus others within a 60 mile radius. This trip I had the lamb chops which were excellent. Also a double baked and we had escargot. I wish the location was was not connected to a hotel and was stand alone but I find this establishment to be in the top 3 in the North Woods

Don't count on the prices you find on the internet. Everything was significantly higher than…read morepublished. The food was disappointing. The chicken piccatta was not thin and I could hardly taste any lemon. It was served over linguine which hardly had any sauce. The broiled Canadian walleye tasted fishy. The couple were were with didn't complain, but they also didn't rave about their meals. The service was very good, but the ambiance was loud. The restaurant is separate from the bar and the cliental was mainly senior so the reason is probably the acoustics. We will not be going back.

Visiting Rhinelander and took my son and family out to dinner for his bday. First time at a North…read morewoods supper club- we really enjoyed it. Got in without a reservation. Perch fish fry was good. I liked the side of beans- a little more when have been nice. My DIL had the French onion soup and a salad. We each shared 3 different types of cake- carrot, silk, peanut butter/chocolate. All good.

my husband and I went to the Fireside Supper Club on Friday for the fish fry…read more We started with an appetizer of calamari which was badly over fried and tough. We ordered Perch that was supposed to be medium size and they were no larger than 4 inches and over cooked. we have dined there a few times and had a good experience, but if this was our first time, we wouldn't go back. very disappointed

Went for my birthday, place is pretty small...actually it's a nice size bar with a very small…read moredining room. To accommodate our party of 6 they had to put out a folding table which was a little narrow but I'd say it worked alright. Our waitress was very very slow. She was nice but at the end of dinner we wanted to order dessert but could tell they were trying to turn the table. Place was busy and there were people pouring out of the bar waiting. Food was alright only thing is it was a bit under seasoned

I sat at the bar. It was a Wednesday night, May 2023. Super friendly bar tender. I had a decent…read morestreak and got the whole WI supper club experience, old fashioned, relish tray, soup, and a steak. I'll be back!

Beautiful venue The food is uneven and the menu never really…read morechanges I'd recommend sitting outside with a cocktail and an appetizer

Make reservations ahead of time. We tried to get in here twice and I guess the 3rd time is the…read morecharm. Note that they have downtime in the fall so be sure to check their hours in their website. Upon entering the parking lot you feel like you're entering an enchanted forest with lights and an outdoor fire pit greeting you. We were warmly welcomed by the hostess and we were immediately seated. We were out kim an addition which had ample windows facing out to the lighted trees. Our waitress was very attentive and we were started with a relish tray. It was skimpy compared to what you use to get at supper clubs but appreciated as a comp. We received our meals with a comp loaf of bread. I'm GF so passed on the bread. My husband said it was average and appreciated. He had the prim rib and I had a tenderloin steak with mushrooms and garlic mashed potatoes which the first couple of bites in the end was chewy but as I moved to the next bites it was very tender. I enjoyed the Hungarian mushroom soup and my husband enjoyed his clam chowder. We were too full for dessert and I took 1/2 of my meal home to enjoy for lunch the next day. We didn't try any cocktails. We would go back to try more menu items, maybe something light so a dessert could be enjoyed.

Best steak dinner in town. Insanely good service, great drinks, zero complaints. Very reasonably…read morepriced. Maddie the bartender was also great while we waited to be seated.

This is a hidden gem! By far, the best restaurant I have found in the UP. Not pictured is house…read moremade soup and salad. Delicious. Fork tender ribeye. King crab served precracked with melted butter. Scallops in a white wine butter sauce served steaming hot. Overall 10/10 will definitely be back on my next trip up north!

Wow!! What an awesome find thanks to the Supper Club coupon book! We drove 90 minutes each way to…read moreexperience this awesome restaurant! Service was great and the food was amazing! We had the goat cheese balls as an appetizer...wow!! It was awesome! My tenderloin was very tasty and the mashed potatoes and broccolini was very good! Then, dessert!! OMG - the BEST turtle cheese cake I have ever had! I highly recommend this restaurant!! Enjoy!

Visited with a group of 10. They were very accommodating and friendly. Drinks at the bar were well…read moremade. Menu is modern American. Everything was delicious. They were able to accommodate dietary restrictions (gluten). Atmosphere was casual however still a good special dinner location. Highly recommended.