We had a really fun dinner at this old school supper club. The restaurant has beautiful views, and we had had asked to have a window view when making our reservation because it was our anniversary. Instead we were placed at a table outside of the bathroom and kitchen which was a little disappointing. Service was good and the bartender and waitstaff were all very friendly. The old fashioneds were great! My husband loved his steak and lobster. I think my favorite things were the cheese spread and Parmesan peppercorn dressing. We had planned on having prime rib and twice baked potatoes but unfortunately both were already sold out by 7:00 pm. read more

See all

Visiting Rhinelander and took my son and family out to dinner for his bday. First time at a North woods supper club- we really enjoyed it. Got in without a reservation. Perch fish fry was good. I liked the side of beans- a little more when have been nice. My DIL had the French onion soup and a salad. We each shared 3 different types of cake- carrot, silk, peanut butter/chocolate. All good. read more

Fireside Supper Club - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin

my husband and I went to the Fireside Supper Club on Friday for the fish fry. We started with an appetizer of calamari which was badly over fried and tough. We ordered Perch that was supposed to be medium size and they were no larger than 4 inches and over cooked. we have dined there a few times and had a good experience, but if this was our first time, we wouldn't go back. very disappointed read more

Nice atmosphere, service was very slow, soup was extremely salty, dinner rolls were like hockey pucks. Food ok but very pricy for what you get. read more

A fun supper club vibe with a beautiful lake view. The servers were so friendly and nice. The food was great and they gave you so much to eat! We got salad, roll, mini muffin and starch with our entree. The duck was incredible and the skin tasted so good. The ribs were good and fall off the bone. read more

See all

Our family visited here for the first time last night. We had a drink at the cozy bar while we waited for our table to be ready. Once seated, we were greeted with ice water and a basket of bread sticks and crackers, with butter. We all ordered the 2 piece haddock fish fry. It was served with little cups of baked beans, pasta salad, and Cole slaw, which were served first. The fish was lightly battered and fresh & flaky, and the fries were piping hot. The portion size was generous, and we took home fries. Service was friendly & attentive. Highly recommend you check it out. Reservations are highly recommended, a week in advance. read more

Fireside Supper Club - Haddock fish fry - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin

Everything you'd expect in a supper club. Delicious food and lots of it. Great service and a picturesque location. The ribs were fall off the bone fantastic. read more

Great old time supper club! Assorted Crackers at the table. Yet They need to add cheese spread. Soup and salad before the meal. Excellent. Great dressing and soup was spot on. I had lobster. They need to serve HOT real, not clarified butter. Or tasteless oil as what I was given. I am very disappointed when a Wisconsin restaurant does not serve real butter with salty whey solids in it. I added butter from the table to try and get some butter flavor and it did not melt. The candle in the warmer did nothing. The lobster was coated in Paprika. . What chef thinks that is a good idea? The star of lobster is the sweet taste. All I could taste, even after scraping it off, was putrid paprika. I might as well ordered Tilapia. Drinks were great, atmosphere was perfect from when I was young. Food needs attention. read more

We went here for our anniversary. The food was amazing. My husband had the duck and it was very good. (As an ex-chef he's hard to please especially since he makes excellent duck). I had the fillet mignon and it was perfectly prepared. The baked French onion soup was some of the best we've had. We were seated at a table with a view of the lake which was lovely. My only complaint might be that the service seemed a little rushed but they serve a lot of courses so that may be why. Definitely make reservations here. read more

This is a great supper club! Their drinks are very good as is the prime rib dinner on Saturdays. Service was great at the bar and at the table. The decor is true authentic north woods supper club. Highly recommended. read more

What a gem! Locals and tourists. Traveling for work, never been to a supper club. Walleye is ridiculous!!! Black cherry whiskey old fashion must have! They make their own mix and you can purchase. Quaint spot on the lake, bartender, server and hostess all welcoming. Smaller space, can't order food from bar- keeps the dinning experience cozy and had a drink at bar prior to table opening up.... Will be back for sure. read more

Fireside Supper Club - Black cherry old fashion must - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin

Unfortunately we are unable to review this place. Arrived at 430 on a Friday July 25 3 cars in lot super happy on our timing. Restuarant was empty, hostess asked if we had reservation before even saying hello. No tables available the entire day. Wow, no options and no apologies. 2 words can explain, GO ELSEWHERE.. read more

this is a return visit after a year. the first time was unimpressive and was hoping to have a better food experience this time. But it was not to happen, the quality of the baked stuffed shrimp was pitiful. the shrimp were so very tiny and the stuffing covered the whole shrimp which is not saying much. the platter wasn't even a third covered by the shrimp. the guys had the perch and they seriously thought they were smelt they were so small. No flavor to the perch and for the price it was a huge disappointment. Can't say we will try this place again. For $80-100 per couple we can buy steaks and make them at home and have plenty of food. Sorry, I really hoped to have a good meal and report on it. OH Well. read more

Nice clean place, great service, very good old fashioned drinks, steak was done perfectly, coconut shrimp was perfect with just the right amount of crunch. All 3 of us loved it. Make Reservations! read more

See all

The entire team of women was wonderful!! From the greeting to the thank you & goodbye when we finished. Food was excellent .. New York strip, coconut shrimp, twice baked potato etc...absolutely delicious... A number one Wisconsin Supper Club!!!! read more

Awesome job hosting a large group, the bartender made an incredible old fashion sour French onion soup was amazing

We love this Supper Club! Today is the holiday weekend of the 4th of July and they are very busy and refusing anyone who didn't make reservations. Fortunately we did and the service was good. The old fashions here are outstanding and have never wavered. They have the best French onion soup as well. The entrees are it and miss and the same dish may be great and the next time you order it's just fair. Unfortunately this was one of those times. Looking forward to my next visit. read more

Sorry Fireside, we have been coming here for many years, but the changes recently have been unsatisfactory. Pre-mixes old fashioned's - you can do better. The tender says she is so busy she can't muddle all orders. Well, they were not that busy at all last night. There were three people at the bar at 7:15P on a Friday! That said, waitresses are great - they could not be nicer. The Food - ugh - all sides are served in these kids plastic containers, mac, beans, cole slaw, everything. The fish was not worth reporting. The containers and premade drinks make the service fast - no doubt that's what the owner wants, but at the cost of good food! And in the end, staid, passionless service. And ..... the receipts indicate incorrect tips percentage - indicating a lower % for the servers. No clear if deliberate from owner. Sorry Fireside - show us you care about quality like previous times, and we will return. Lot of alternatives in Rhinelander. read more

Was in town visiting the local boy scout camp. I had the roast duck and my girl friend had the Mahi Mahi. She started with the baked French onion soup. The soup was very good. I had the salad for my starter. The duck was al lot of food accompanied by hash brown potatoes. We decided to take the desserts to go, a lemon cake and a chocolate cream cake. Both did not disappoint. The place was a homey wood paneled place with a very north woods atmosphere. Perfect for Wisconsin. The service was attentive and it was a comfortable place to spend some time. read more

I love this restaurant. The taste is fantastic. I love the deep fried fish and steaks. Everyone nice here and The price is more than reasonable :) read more

Fireside Supper Club - TBone steak. - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin

Had an outstanding supper tonight with The best seat in the house overlooking a beautiful lake. We arrived at 4:30 and was lucky to be seated as they were booked with reservations until 7:30. Started out with an outstanding old fashioned followed by a salad, then onion soup topped with cheese & Prime Rib fir hubby & me the shrimp special with veggies. Great atmosphere, view, food & service. read more

See all

Came here and ordered the fillet and lobster dinner. The lobster was okay. The so-called fillet was extremely tough and had tenants running through it. It was definitely cooked very rare and I had a hard time cutting through with a serrated steak knife. Also ordered a old-fashioned. The old fashion was not muddled with orange or cherry. I will not come here again. read more

A very nice old school supper club. The cocktails were fantastic. The maple old fashioned was the special and possibly the best cocktail I've ever had. I had the prime rib, possibly the first one I've had in decades. It was a bit cool, clammy, and salty. My wife's ribeye was top-notch. Sides and appetizers are phenomenal. read more

Great old fashioned supper club with lots of wood features on the inside. Food was super good, waitress was really efficient, and drinks were great! Highly recommend the sour maple old fashioned or the sweet cherry whiskey old fashioned. Both excellent! Fried perch and grilled scallops were so good. The several course meal was wonderful. You've got to stop here when in town read more

Fireside Supper Club - Maple old fashioned - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin

Unfortunately, we did not have a very good experience on New Year's Eve. It started out fine. We sat at the bar and had a drink while waiting for our table. Once we were seated, the waitress asked if we'd like an appetizer. We order the calamari. We thought it was odd that the calamari was brought out less than a few minutes after ordering. I guess it was made in advance and left under a heat lamp because it was chewy and the breading was soggy. Ordered salads, soups and our entrees. The salad was also pre-made and was wilted. The soups never came out, but our entrees did. When I asked our waitress about the soups, she looked confused and asked if we hadn't received them. When I told her we had not, she asked if we'd like the soups to go. (??) I said no and she went to go get them. My entrée (seafood platter) was not good. The shrimp were overcooked and the haddock and scallops were undercooked. The boyfriend's ribeye was very fatty and grisly. It was a good size, though. When she brought out the soups, (I had the baked French onion) the cheese had an odd shine on it. I was able to peel the top of the cheese off in one sheet. I guess it had been sitting a while. I understand that you have to pre-make some things when you have a very busy night, but this was ridiculous. We spent over $120 for a meal that was barely edible. Also, you might consider removing a few of the tables for a little more room. We sat at a 2 seater next to the corner of the bar and my chair was constantly being bumped by customers. I will say that the wait staff and host were extremely nice. We really wanted to like Fireside, but it just wasn't enjoyable. read more

Made a reservation today for 6:00 p.m. When my family and I got to the resturant, the hostess stated "we do not have your reservation, a waitress probaly answered and did not write it down." Next avail table was at 7:30 p.m. and all we got was an apology, and did not try to even problem solve. Not the hostess fault, but poor customer service was exhibited. Will not be returning! read more

Fireside Supper Club - Proof we called and made the reservation on: 8/28/2021 and they could care less. - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin

The food is decent, but what establishment doesn't let a party of one eat at the bar? I travel alone quite often and prefer not to sit at a table alone. I prefer to sit at the bar. It's very odd to demand someone take up a table and not serve food at the bar. Especially when the dining room is full and the bar is empty. Getting my food to go. They missed out on a few drinks. read more

Kudos to Fireside Supper Club for another phenomenal meal. Wow. This crew is beyond efficient. Packed house and not single wait for service. We had dad so we arrived early for a 5pm reservation. By 5:30 every table was full and the bar hopping. If you don't have a reservation, you likely won't get a table. The staff is the model for excellence. Thank you for a great meal and service. You never fail to satisfy. Sherrie B read more

After a had days motorcycle ride you get hungry. This oasis next to a lake was a welcome sight and one of the few clubs that had seating. It has a bar for the locals and a lower level dining area. Traditional menu with expected flavors. The waitstaff were great. read more

See all

Wonderful food, service and atmosphere. A true Northern Wisconsin supper club. Try the blackberry old fashions...you won't be disappointed. read more

This was my second chance for Fireside. It's always in the top supper clubs. The first time I went it was not very good. The cut of ribeye was grizzly and not that flavorful . But I decided that maybe it was a fluke so I tried it again. I ordered the shrimp tempura appetizer which was excellent but the rib eye was again grizzly and not very flavorful. The baked potato was still hard. The salad was kind of skimpy but tasted good. The French Onion soup cheese had a strange consistency in my mouth and I didn't finish it. I will give 5 stars to the waitress who was very friendly and attentive. I won't be going back and I don't understand how it's always busy. read more

We tried this restaurant two times this week and loved it. Ross did a really good job making old fashions and Kelly made probably the best cosmos in Rhinelander. We were really impressed with the steak combos. I had steak and crab legs and my husband had the steak and stuffed shrimp. Both steaks were cooked to perfection and the seafood was very good. We had the shrimp cocktail which tasted very fresh a little on the smaller side but it was still very good. The next time we came back for the fish fry and it was very good as well. We will definitely come back. The service also was pretty good and the desserts were amazing. read more

See all

The food is good. Service is good. Ambiance is pleasant and cozy. Overlooks a small lake. It's small, so make your reservations in advance. read more

Monday night reservation for 7:00pm. We extremely appreciate that they were taking reservations - table was set and ready exactly upon our arrival. The restaurant was packed but our server was super attentive and we had drinks in our hands within 10 minutes of seating. Classic supper club menu with all the extras - crackers, bread, salad and soup with every entree. Orders included fried haddock, lamb chops with mint jelly (delish!), scallop fettuccine, rack of ribs and surf & turf. All delicious and no complaints! We left extremely satisfied! Thank you for the pleasant night Fireside! read more

What a fantastic place! Classic supper club, just what we were hoping for. Delicious food and the best service you could ever want. Make reservations because you probably won't get a table if you walk in. read more

Up north supper club atmosphere. We had a great dinner here tonight! Steak, French onion soup, old fashions, and carrot cake. We were celebrating our anniversary and had a great time with great service! We would recommend! read more

Fireside Supper Club - Yum!! - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin

The steak was outstanding! Server was super knowledgeable and attentive! The atmosphere is great too!

onion soup was not as expected. Cheese was a creamy base. the twice baked potato was dry and overcooked. The walleye was good and service was great. Will not go back. read more

Dinner was great and the service was fantastic! They have a great set up for private events as well!

We were seated at the bar and then quickly moved to our reserved table. All the staff made us feel like family from the moment we walked in and they were friendly, knowledgeable and efficient. We tried the traditional supper club fare like the shrimp cocktail, steak sandwich, baked French onion soup and of course an old fashioned and pink squirrel! Everything exceeded our expectations and was a wonderful cozy northwoods experience. This supper club is a gem! We can't wait to return soon! read more

Fireside Supper Club - Old fashioned cocktail - Steakhouses Near Me - Rhinelander, Wisconsin