They charged me $685 to replace a wiring connector on the camshaft position sensor. I would hate…read moreto think what they would have charged if it were something more involved. Edit: Phil called in response to my review. See the attached invoice. I had already replaced the camshaft position sensor (a ten minute job), which was new. This did not resolve the code, which indicated the connection was intermittent. I had tested the connector with a multimeter, which indicated there was a bad connection at the connector. This was communicated to the service manager when I dropped off the vehicle. The technician stated that there was a broken tab on the camshaft position sensor, and they replaced the brand new part I had just installed. See the attached photo. That the tab could be broken without being filed off is highly suspect. It's a durable part. That the relatively fragile connector was damaged is more credible. In my opinion, as stated to the service manager, it was obviously the part that needed to be replaced. They replaced the connector, which again, I had communicated was the likely issue. They claim to have paid $110 for this part that I can purchase at Napa for $26. So in summary, I paid $685 to have them swap out a $26 connector. I can only conclude they're either dishonest or incompetent. Edit 2: Well Phil, now you're just outright lying. You did not show me the new camshaft position sensor you removed and replaced. Your technician did not perform any diagnostics, and ignored the diagnostic information I provided to you in advance. He just started swapping parts, AND overcharging for the time spent. Even if the sensor needed to be replaced, a $40 part that takes ten minutes to install, to charge me $685 is absurd.

Needed a tow for an engine coolant issue. Mountain Auto got me right in and was able to diagnose…read morethat my water pump was the problem. It was replaced and the coolant system was checked and I have my truck back. Thanks for the quality service and quick response!

Superfast service and you could tell the service guys really cared. Highly recommended!!read more

Cheapest oil change in town, I'm pretty sure. $102 for oil change and rotation…read more Men were very nice and quick. Mentioned every Wednesday is ladies day for a -$10 discount

Very professional! They were honest and attentive and left a flower on the dashboard for my wife!read more

Amazing quality here and such a cool spot. This incredible team found issues with my car that no…read moreother shop has. I've been in Durango for almost four years now, and these guys you can trust with value and the service requested. You might even be surprised to see them helping you with so much more! They are dog friendly too!

honestly these guys are great. I have gone to them twice now. They're very honest guys in my…read moreexperience. Plus they're labor rate is $110, which is at least $15-$40 cheaper than all the other places I called around to. Not to mention, they got me in the same week- not a month out like most other places. Only negative is they don't have a waiting room yet and it's starting to get cold- so have a ride set up if you can!

From the owner: Oil Change, Brake services, A.C. Services // Same Day Service on most Repairs(Call For Details) //…read moreFree Estimates

If only I can give them 10 stars! I'm from San Diego and stopped overnight in Durango during my two…read moreweek road trip around the 4 corners. After coming back from the Silverton train ride around 230pm on a Friday, I tried to start my car and it just wouldn't give. After calling around all the local shops, everyone basically told me nothing is open on weekends and they were booked till earliest mid week of the following week. When I called Durango Car Care, I told them my situation and they told me they'd try and look at it if I got there before they close but no guarantees they would be able to fix it on time. AAA came around 4pm and got me to the shop around 430pm. The guys stopped what they were working on and tried to troubleshoot my car. After about 15 minutes, they got it working again!!! They didn't have to do any of that! This literally brought my faith back in humanity! The kindest guys and angels to me that day!! I am so so thankful to them and my AAA guy Daylon. Hands down would recommend these guys!!

Got me in on short notice for all 4 wheel brakes. Good work, nice people and fair price.read more

Paul has always taken such great care of both our vehicles and us. My wife and I have had a lot of…read morehit or miss shop experiences in Durango but NEVER with Paul and America's Auto and Tire. Don't think twice, call them up and experience incredible service and reliability. Can't thank them enough for fixing up our GX470 and our Tacoma these past couple years!

I called last week to schedule an appointment for an oil change on my 2018 Ram 3500. The guy that…read moreanswered the phone quoted $65-125 for an oil change on my diesel truck so I booked an appointment for today. I knew $65 wasn't accurate but $125 was reasonable seeing that Ram charges $130 but couldn't get me in for 3 weeks. I went to the appointment this morning & the guy checking me in told me that it would be $245 for the oil change. I'm not sure what there labor rate is but I've never heard of a $245 oil change. On my way home I stopped at the Marathon gas station next to Ford & they did the oil change in under 10 minutes for $99. They were super nice & did a great job. Obviously you couldn't pay me to go back to America's Auto & Tire ever again!

Terribly rude. Took advantage of the elderly. Continuing to bill after services were terminated…read moreeven though they never did any service. Very unprofessional customer service when you call to discuss ANYTHING. Dishonest and unethical

So rude when you call. We finally dismissed their snow removal service because they never show up…read more They continued to bill us (after termination and no service) because they were "hurting" and then yelled at us when we terminated their services a second time.

Andy is a great mechanic. I take my Toyota truck to him, and he always gets the job done quickly…read more He's great at troubleshooting and figuring out what is going on with any engine issue. Nice guy. Always feel like I'm being treated fairly.

While traveling I noticed my brakes in my van making a grinding noise when I stopped. I dropped in…read moreon Monday around 11 am and CJ said he couldn't get me in until 2:30 so I left and came back. (meanwhile I stopped by a muffler and brake shop and was told they could get me in NEXT Monday). When I returned, CJ got my van in as promised, diagnosed the issue, ordered the parts and had me out the door shortly after 5:30 and the price was entirely reasonable. I worked from the waiting room via their free wifi and over the course of the day overheard the way CJ treated his customers... always with respect and honesty. I heard him say, "You don't owe me anything for checking it out, just bring it back when it has something that needs to be fixed." That is how you build a great customer base. Honest work at decent prices.

They charged me double ($400) for a simple job which only took 20 minutes. When I called to…read morecomplain about being overcharged, they insulted and ridiculed me. The fact is that there is only one competent mechanic there, and they overcharge to cover the cost of paying 4 additional employees who don't do anything.