Great service and food was delicious at 4th St. Pizza! As soon as we came in, we were greeted by the delicious smell of food and the courteous staff. Went during lunch time on a Friday and took advantage of their lunch specials. Their pizza dough was airy and crispy, their mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce were very flavorful. Had a salad with their homemade lemon poppyseed dressing that was really good. If I lived here, this would be a place I would go back to often. read more

They were packed! Clearly a local (and visitor) favorite. We added jalapeños and red onions to the BBQ chicken pizza - so good! The salad with house made blue cheese was phenomenal. And the bottled root beer tasted like a root beer barrel candy - so sweet! Service was fabulous! Honestly though, the physical place could really use a freshen up. The lighting and entryway especially. (Ripped cushions etc) The other con - our pizza took about 45 minutes to come out. But they were completely booked too, so that makes some sense. Enjoy! Hermann is so fun. read more

See all

We visited Hannibal for the day and let the time get away from us a little until we decided to stop for dinner. I have mixed feelings about this place because it started out very frustrating, with parking, a small waiting area, and a cranky host. It ended on a good note, however. I'll start off by saying that parking was really frustrating, because we had to drive around the block several times before we were able to find something that opened up. I realize that many businesses share this street, and want to point out that this is not the fault of 4th Street Pizza. Inside, it was very crowded with many people waiting. The area is so small that it wasn't easy to open the door. Once we got in, it took about 10 minutes for someone to take our name for the waiting list. She was very cranky, but later I would come to understand why. We were told of a 45-minute wait and that we could wait outside if we liked, where they would call our name when ready. We waited on a bench and saw a lot of people come and go who got there after us. Thankfully, my fiancé asked them about it, and they seated us right away. I think they forgot about us. Once we were seated, the service was very slow to start. Our appetizer got there in a decent amount of time, but the pizza took forever, and our drinks sat empty. Once the pizza arrived, it was huge and tasted great! Are drinks continuing to sit empty? Normally, my rating would be low for a situation like this, but then I realized that our server was working all the tables in there and had only one bus person for help! I can see why the server was cranky. I would have been too if I were the only server at a busy restaurant during rush hour. This entire restaurant had only one restroom that looked like it had not been cleaned since the Bicentennial. Again, it is probably a staffing issue. We would definitely go again to experience the pizza. read more

4th St. Pizza - Sketchy single bathroom - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

See all

Probably one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. We got there early and were served pretty quick. Waitress was very nice.

Great food, fast service and friendly waitress! She knew we were from out of town and when we asked for a box, she was considerate enough to ask us what size fridge was in our hotel to get us the right sized box. read more

Fantastic pizza prepared and served by friendly staff. We ordered a takeout pizza a half hour before closing. They were very nice and friendly. The pizza was top-notch. read more

I've reviewed this establishment before, but they are really good and worth it if uyou go there. I also want to mention TO GO orders. I do a lot of TO GO ordering here. And they do not disappoint here either. Create your own Pizza, or order off the menu. Whatever you order, it will be unique, yummy and it will be ready in no time. Movie night Pizza is a treat, so order one this Friday and see a show and have some yumminess. This place is better than most of the pizza joints I've visited, and I have traveled all over the world...I've had a lot of region pizzas. 4th St Pizza easily competes with the Italian joints I've visited on the East Coast. read more

Incredible pizza, the goat cheese with honey appetizer is to die for. 16 of us showed up here at opening time, the service is excellent. Clean tidy and fresh a great place for a good meal with friends. read more

4th St. Pizza - a man reading a menu - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

Solid NY style pizza joint... We always stop by 4th Street Pizza when in town for Oktoberfest... It's really good NY style pizza and well-priced. The place is a bit rundown, but don't let it deter you from stopping in... 4th Street Pizza is a Dave Portnoy solid 7.4. read more

4th St. Pizza - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

We had a group gathering at this restaurant. Ordered several large pizzas. Our favorite was the sausage and pepperoni. Great Atmosphere, good service and clean facility. Thank you read more

See all

Yummy, They make an awesome pizza, Pasta & Sandwiches were delicious as well. Reasonable prices and prompt friendly service. We ate there twice when were in town and both times loved the experience and wished we lived closer. read more

Such an awesome experience. The pizza was very good with the right crispiness throughout. I'd recommend this place 100% read more

4th St. Pizza - 14" Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

Went in late before closing and we were so thankful they'd still make us some pizza. We ordered the meaty deluxe and added mushrooms. Wow! Definitely a pizza to be loved. I don't always love pizza anymore, but this made me nostalgic. Good ingredients make a huge difference! Nice people working there too! We were having so much fun and I didn't get a pic but here is a pic of what we took home. Yummy the next day too. read more

4th St. Pizza - Meaty - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

This meal was about the best that we had on our vacation, and that's saying a LOT because we ate at so many wonderful restaurants. The pizza was incredible! We had the one with all the meats+black olives. The crust is just perfect. My husband couldn't stop eating it. I also had a salad with their homemade ranch. Let me tell you. That ranch makes all others pale in comparison. It's got extra dill which makes it SO yummy and fresh tasting. I could drink this by the gallon. The salad veges were fresh, and with that dressing, it was as great as the pizza to me. And then there was the hot goat cheese and honey appetizer. Wow! The pizza dough bread served with it was the perfect companion. I loved the goat cheese and honey so much that I ate the leftovers for breakfast the next day. Incredible food! read more

See all

When they first opened the service was very good. Now when you call to order lunch specials they act like they don't want to take to many orders at once. Which was never a problem before. The pizza is always good but the crust is kind of limpy. They need to work on customer service and make you feel like they want customers. read more

Only one server on a busy Sunday and she could care less. The pizza is not baked in a brick oven as she stated & dough is not prepared fresh. Never again! read more

Aug 31 2025. I've eaten here many times, the pizza is good but the lady running the place is just RUDE. She's been rude to us before, (we tried to ignore it) but tonight I went in late 15 minutes before closing and asked if they were still serving and she was so rude that I was shocked. Some other customers that were leaving came up to me on the street, and told me they $0 tipped them because of what they witnessed in how rudely I was treated by simply asking if they were still serving. Zydeco/4th street pizza owner, I know it's not easy finding workers in Hermann but you need to fire her she's a terrible person but I'm sure you already know this. No way to treat your customers. read more

Our order was prepared quickly and correctly. The Italian dressing is delicious. We tried regular crush and thin crust pizzas. Both were good. read more

The place was slammed, but the service was still great and the food was great too! I would definitely go back again.

This restaurant is a MUST STOP in Hermann. The salads were amazing, the goat cheese and honey with fresh bread is a MUST HAVE and the pizza is phenomenal. The prices are reasonable and the inside feels like an old school pizza joint. I absolutely loved it. read more

Had the veggie with one swap-out from peppers to banana pepper. It was awesome! Crispy crust and they don't skimp on sauce and quality cheese! Highly recommend! read more

Good pizza, fast service, definitely a place to eat while in Hermann. Not much ambiance to mention but if the pizza is good who cares! read more

4th St. Pizza - Veggie 16" we added beef. - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

See all

This maybe the best pizza I've ever had! We had a pepperoni pizza. It was perfectly hot and cheesy. The only downside is that I wish they delivered. read more

One of the best pizza joints we have been too. The decor and style was old fashioned, but it was nice to see. We were happy they served gluten free pizza and were not disappointed. Overall, no complaints from anything, and the food was fantastic. read more

Ate there two days in a row and had leftovers on the third . Pizza is gi-normous!! Toppings are plentiful and the sausage topping was sooooo good. Pasta and salads on our 2nd visit did not disappoint! The meatballs were delicious,, don't skip them! The homemade focaccia type bread was a it means a lot to us wonderful complement to our meals. And the reheated pizza on day 3 was a treat!! read more

Easy to find, cozy decor and friendly service. They hand toss their crust but it was a little blah in flavor, just nothing special, no yeast or garlic flavor. However, that being said, they had quite a few choices on the menu including Vegan Cheese which is rare in this rural area and Gluten free options. The pizza was of a good size, all the ingredients were real and priced similar to the other places in the area. I think it's worth trying again to see how the other menu items pan out. read more

4th St. Pizza - Half Vegetarian and Half Deluxe pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

Food was amazing and the hostess. the waitresses are beyond rude. we have been here twice now and it's horrible. rude for no reason. I understand they're busy but being rude to your paying customers is unnecessary. read more

This place is absolutely what middle America is about. Fresh, Tasty , affordable and large portions. I will be back again read more

4th St. Pizza - Front of restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

We were that customer, the ones arriving shortly before closing when the kitchen is mostly cleaned and with the staff expecting any early exit. But it was a Sunday in December and literally they were the last chance for food. So we stayed. The service and food was excellent. I am a bit of a pizza snob but after moving from Chicago to Texas I learned to enjoy different styles of pizza. This was a great NY style pie. Plus they had a nice local beer on tap. We will be back, just earlier in the evening :-) read more

So good! We got a supreme and then a salad. We will be back Every time! The bleu cheese dressing on the salad was really delicious too. Prices are fair read more

A short jaunt off the Katy Trail, and right in the heart of Hermann lies this old school pizza joint. From the red-checked tablecloths to the historic building, throwback pizza was the first thing that came to mind... and that's a good thing. The kind of pizza place where you don't just get it carryout or delivered, but meet up with friends to hang out AND crush some pizza. It was a sleepy late Sunday afternoon; too late for lunch, too early for dinner, but that didn't stop us from swinging in and ordering every gram of carbs they had on the menu. We started the cheesy garlic bread which was fantastic; cheesy, flavorful and rich. Next up we split the specialty veggie pizza which we was entirely too large for two hungry cyclists. Oh and they have a homemade ranch dressing that was magic with their crust. It's the kind of "runny ranch" that I grew up on, which proves it's not only homemade, but also less goopy than traditional bottled ranch dressing. We thought about trying to take our leftovers but decided against it since we were on bikes. That didn't stop them from running outside to remind us that we left our leftovers behind -- a nice touch from an already friendly staff. read more

4th St. Pizza - Veggie pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

See all

Everything was great!! The staff knew their stuff. My wife needed gluten free and mentioned to the waitress to cook a little more as the crusts can come out soggy. She told us the guy cooking was good and he would know what to do. Well, she was right! Perfect!! The other pizza was as well. Their salads were wonderful as well and lots of dressing choices! Very impressive!!! We will always eat there when we come to Hermann. What a terrific find!!! Wish they were in STL as well. Well done!! read more

Since moving back to Missouri I have been searching for a great east coast style pizza. 4th street is not only a great east coast style pizza for Missouri but would hold their own in any place iv lived, east coast, west coast, central, or overseas to include Italy. They make a truly great east coast style thin but not to thin, perfect chew on the crust, great sauce and mozzarella cheese. This is not Stl style thin cracker crust or provell cheese. I drove an hour to Hermann just to give it a try and I'm happy I did and will again. read more

Phenomenal pizza! We were staying in Hermann for a 10 year anniversary trip. Arrived on a Wednesday afternoon, and not many places were open for dinner. Thankfully 4th St. Pizza was just a few doors down from where we were staying and they were open! Seriously the BEST pizza we've ever had. We're from STL, and are now desperately trying to find a pizza place in our area that is comparable to it. We were also able to order a bottle of wine to go with our pizza. If you're in Hermann, 4th St. Pizza is a MUST! It will now be our go to place for pizza whenever we visit. read more

4th St. Pizza - Supreme pizza with mushrooms on half - Pizza Near Me - Hermann, Missouri

For a small town like Hermann, Missouri you would not expect to find really good New York style pizza, but here it is. I was at the famous John's on Bleeker street in NY less than 2 months ago and I can tell you 4th Street Pizza is right there with them. Great crust, lots of mozzarella, tangy sauce all adds up to a great pie. Keep it up!! read more

Met my daughter and her friends for lunch while they were in town for a bachelorette weekend. We arrived early and we had to wait for a few minutes before they opened. Only one server(she was great), but our food was delicious and arrived quickly. The longer we were there, the busier they were. I felt so bad for our server. She did a great job! read more

Is this a joke?! You can't place to go orders after 5pm on the weekends?!?!? Way to lose out on money and customers wanting to try this place. Apparently this is the normal. Save yourself the rude service and go to Loose Caboose. Friendly and tasty. Tourist town fail read more

Seriously delicious food. Great portion sizes and really reasonable pricing. What more could you ask for? We make it a point to go every time we're in town and I dream of their goat cheese appetizer the remainder of the year. I would recommend it for anyone looking for a good meal when in Hermann. Don't let the name fool you either because they have great salads, subs and pastas too so if you're not in the mood for pizza, there's plenty of other options. read more

Came in at 4 on a Sunday afternoon. Immediately acknowledged. Took a seat and quickly had our order taken. Drinks were delivered promptly as was the pizza. The pizza, dang it was good. Ordered a veggie with sausage. Crust was perfect. Just the right amount of cheese and sauce and all was cooked perfectly. I recommend this place completely. read more

Bought 2 pizzas to go following a day at the wineries. Walked in for pickup & the smell was wonderful. The pizzas are NY style. The slices are huge. The taste was delicious. Highly recommend. read more