Love it! The pizza is amazing! Food fantabulous! They make the sauce just like they did years ago!

Went for lunch with with wife wife it took seconds into we sat die. Smile with a service the waitress was very helpful gave us time to look at what we want. So you can't go wrong with any you order we got large cheese pizza spaghetti and meatballs their rolls are great I could imagine the garlic knots. Everything came out on time. Everything is freshly made you can tell they take pride in their products... read more

See all

Great pizza. One order of chicken piccata is enough for two. Good family restaurant.

Stopped in and was fairly busy. Several employees noted us but no one greeted us for about 5-7 minutes. BUT, once they did things got good. Waitress was friendly and quick. Our food was up real quick. I had the cheese ravioli and it was great. Loved the sauce. And my wife kept going on about the chicken Marsala. A definite win. I'd recommend it to you. Great ambiance. Clean. Good choice. read more

Zappitelli's Pizza - Cheese Ravioli with meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

See all

Got food yesterday. They forgot to give us the salads, drove back. Pizza was not great, but we ate it. Ordered 5 cannolis and was very disappointed they were only half filled. read more

Had dinner here last night. Eggplant rollatini with penne pasta, absolutely delicious and the portion would have fed 3 people. Service was outstanding as usual . Restaurant was crowded but not noisy, could easily hear our conversations. read more

Excellent dinner. Planned to have salad and a couple of pizzas. Salad was fresh and tasted great. The balsamic based house dressing was very good. Our family enjoyed a traditional pepperoni as well as a white pizza. Great crust . You can tell dough was fresh. Tasty pizzas. The pastas looked awesome, we will try some next visit. Service was quick and friendly. read more

Zappitelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

See all

Ordered a small one topping pizza. Supposedly a plain pizza (no toppings) cost $8.75, with toppings at $2.00 each. Come to pay and realized overcharged for the pizza. Cashier admitted this happens all the time but don't know why. Wow, you'd think management would correct this issue. Pizza was bland, careful spending your money here! read more

So this was my first time there, apparently everyone else in the city knows about it. Got there early on Saturday night at 5:30 there was a 45 minute wait. Well worth the wait delicious food, awesome service and great ambiance. I had the chicken Marsala it was so good I kept eating. I was full after the sale and bread. Portions were huge. I will be back sooner than later. Oh yeah I also took cheesecake to-go. Also excellent. read more

See all

Some of the best homemade Italian food in Lake County! Huge portions! Lunch specials are great...home made soups are inventive and delicious. Biggest and best cream puffs anywhere! read more

See all

Everything about this place was amazing!! We came to town for the eclipse. We had couple different restaurants we wanted to try & none of them were opened. Zappitelli's was one of the only locally owned places opened that wasn't another chain restaurant. I am sooooo glad we ended up there. The staff was so nice & professional. The atmosphere was nice & comfortable. The food was REAL!! I can't say enough good things about this Restaurant. It's a must try! read more

Zappitelli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

See all

Their food is wonderful! Portions are huge so my husband and I typically share an entree and get an extra salad and roll. Their sauce is so good - not sweet - and compliments their dishes. I love the cavatelle with meatballs and the pasta diablo. The desserts soooo good. Try the cream puff, eclairs and cookies. Yum! read more

The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Glad we got the chance to enjoy this delicious family owned restaurant. Would highly recommend giving them a try. read more

It was good. If you like homemade pasta, they have a couple choices. Dinners come with salad. Pizza was good. Bread is served when you sit down Lots of cool beer decor read more

Zappitelli's Pizza - a wall full of food items - Pizza Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Not too happy with the meal or service received today . I ordered chicken piccata , the sauce tasted bitter and the breading all fell off . Also the pasta was different. I've been eating there for years and hardly ever had a bad meal . I had to wait at least a half an hour to get our order . read more

Excellent food, excellent service, incredibly friendly staff and owner. Cute dining room that clean and has neat eclectic decor! A must stop! read more

Although busy but not the usual crazy Friday busy - service amazing. Food not so good. Cold. Ordered extra cheese - ended up hardly any cheese. Expensive dinner. We were seated in extra bright dirty room. Probably better doing take out. read more

Ordered take out, entree's and pizza, entree's were amazing but word to the wise, ask for extra sauce because the pasta soaks it up . Portions are crazy big, everyone has another meal in leftovers. Pizza was good but needs more sauce ( quite dry). It was ready when they said it would be and staff is very nice. Love the new side entrance for to go. Was disappointed they had no cannolis, cheesecake or tiramisu in the dessert case. But the setting is great and decor is good. No wonder there is a waiting list. read more

Very good pizza and pasta dishes Overall as good as you can get on Lake County for a red sauce joint Super large portions read more

This place is a family favorite with a classic italian style. They provide huge portions and their sauce is incredible. the wait staff is also extremely attentive. The cannolis are good but they weren't filled all the way through and the cream filling was, seemingly, more of a lighter mascarpone type rather than a typical ricotta filling. Overall, this place is definitely worth giving a shot! read more

After 20 years in Concord we finally decided to order pizza from Zappitelli's. Ordered the deluxe Italian. One red and one white. I was so excited because it contained all my favorite Italian toppings. I'm not sure how they can consider themselves Italian. No true Italian would put thick chunks of prosciutto, genoa and capicola. Those meats need to be thinly sliced. The flavor was average at best. This just proved to me that yet another Mentor restaurant is bland with nothing more to offer. read more

Our families favorite! We have been coming for 20+ years and every time we have a consistent and delicious food! The staff are always so pleasant and treat you like family! This is a staple restaurant our family visits every time we come home( we live in Florida now). The meal from the salad/bread/garlic bread to the pastas and pizzas-all are divine! We miss this place so much we got it two days in a row! Thank you for continuing to be so amazing Zapps!! read more

I go to this restaurant at least once a week. Everything is very good but I love the lasagna. It's fantastic and comes with (2) good size meatballs. You will not be disappointed!!! read more

Amazing quality and quantity. This restaurant serves up delicious food and lots of it. The side salads were much better than the typical iceberg lettuce with a tomato. The balsamic dressing and cheese topped it all off. The side of spaghetti is a full meal in itself. The sauce and meatballs are very good. The wait staff was friendly and helpful. A big thumbs up for the veal marsala, lasagna and stuffed manicotti. read more

Zappitelli's Pizza - a man eating at a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Fantastic food and service! The chicken parmesan with cavetelli was very delicious with huge portions and the tomato sauce was so good. read more

See all

AMAZING! The lasagna was the best I've ever tasted and the portion was HUGE! You also get a huge side of two gigantic meatballs smothered in a rich marinara sauce, a fresh salad with loads of mozzarella and a sweet homemade Italian dressing, and two fresh baked dinner rolls. The wait staff was so friendly too. I am from out of town but will definitely eat here again once back in town. I recommend this authentic Italian eatery to everyone! You won't be disappointed read more

Zappitelli's Pizza - Lasagna with a side of meatballs :) - Pizza Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

It's ok, if you cannot get a pizza from concord pizza next door, then it's a decent alternative. But me personally, I'd wait for a pizza from concord pizza. read more

Excellent service with great food at an affordable cost. Would recommend of your are seeking a casual restaurant for good food with the family, including to take home. read more

YUMMY pizza!!!! Great service!!!! Nice place. Great Italian food, great service!!!! Portions are huge!!!! Most meals are large enough to take home half of it for another meal. read more

Great Italian food and decent prices for the portion sizes. A lot of options for salads, pizza, pastas, sandwiches, calzones, etc.

Family friendly atmosphere with fun nostalgic decor all over the walls and Dean Martin style music playing. Yummy Italian food in big portions. I had veal parmigiana, my husband had lasagna, and my father had spaghetti and meatballs. All of us were happy with our meals and full. Took a lot home with us too! Good service even on a busy Saturday evening. Only negative would be that the dinner salads are iceberg lettuce but the toppings and dressings made them still taste pretty good. We'll definitely go back. read more

We've been going here for years. Reasons? Great food, large portions, good help. I have nothing negative to say about Zap's.

Best food ever with big portions for two meals for sure. Never disappointed! Usually do delivery and always very happy with service.

Always delicious food, no matter what you choose on the menu!!! The portion size of everything is incredible!! The service has always been outstanding, whether it's dine-in or take-out!! The place is always clean, and the decor is very Italian , with lots to look at on the walls!!! My family ALWAYS LOVES Zappitelli's!!!!! read more

The food is excellent. We get a pizza every Sunday from ZAPPITELLI's and eat at the restaurant as often as we can. The portions are huge. I always get my next day's lunch In leftovers. The ambience of the dinning room is totally appropriate for a family owned and operated neighborhood restaurant. The staff can be a little ambivalent, especially the girls at the front counter, but the food!!! Even with the staff issue I couldn't give them anything less than 5 Stars. I'd post a picture of the food, but I ate it read more

I dropped them down a notch because they would not fix and serve what G wanted. When I get G to go Italian, he likes 2 things. Pizza or angel hair. We had pizza yesterday so that left angel hair. And he dislikes tomato sauce so he asked for Alfredo. The cook outright refused. It will be a very cold day before I get G to go there again. If a Paying Customer wants to lick their food directly off the table, why not for heaven's sweet sake? read more

Zappitelli's Pizza - a plate of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Service was lacking and genuinely made no sense. Waitresses go Mia open tables sit open. No sense of urgency. Salad is iceberg bland lettuce. Chicken parm was one of the worst I've had. Red sauce is very bland and chicken was soggy. The "homemade" pasta is a joke maybe it was homemade 3 months ago and then frozen? Home made pasta should be fresh and taste fresh. Will not be returning. read more

I have been telling people for over a decade that Zappitelli's in Mentor has the best pizza ever. Nope! Y'all done f@#$ it up. The crust is DISGUSTING. Soft, sweet and tough. The toppings were greatly lacking, and the sauce was tasteless. I threw my pieces out. It was totally inedible. Don't bother Mentor, Zappitelli's pizza is no longer worth eating. read more

Instead of going to Olive Garden or longos for your Italian food go to Zappitelli's. Good food at a fair price and usually good service. The chicken parmigiana is my favorite. Guaranteed dinner and lunch the next day. read more

Amazing Italian food. I recommended to go hard to eat in. Owner works very hard to make it. Superb