A solid ice cream spot, lots of flavors. The ice cream had just the right consistency, creamy and…read morenot too icy. Pretty standard in terms of service and atmosphere. I will say the ice cream did seem a bit pricey relative to the size of the scoops and the quality. This was a bit more of a grab and go spot, since there wasn't really seating available, which seemed a bit weird for an ice cream shop. There was a bit of room outside, but that wouldn't do much good for half the year!

5 years ago I wrote a review for this place when it was Granny's and gave it 5 stars, raving about…read moreamazing it was. I moved away and just came back and went to stop in and get my favorite only 8 yogurt. I am honestly shocked at what a bad experience this was. I got a medium only8 chocolate frozen yogurt. I included the picture of what my ice cream looked like, it was soup, and didn't peak over the top of the cup. I even said to the girl who made my ice cream is this what it's supposed to look like and she said yes. I honestly asked again and she said yeah, this is the machine and what it is. The best part was when she told me it was $9.75 for this cup of soup with no toppings that didn't even swirl like normal ice cream. I actually said outloud omg are you sure that's the right price and she said yes and asked me if I was paying with a card. Really disappointing experience and I guess I'll have to find somewhere else to get my favorite yogurt.

Milky Ways is a dessert lover's dream! Not only is the ice cream top-tier, but the endless array of…read morepossibilities makes every visit feel like a new adventure. With so many cereal mix-ins, toppings, and flavor combos, you can get as creative as you want--there's truly something for everyone! What really makes this place special, though, is the fantastic staff. From the moment we walked in, they were welcoming, patient, and super helpful in guiding us through all the options. You can tell they genuinely love what they do, and their enthusiasm is contagious. The ice cream itself? Absolutely delicious. Whether you go for a classic combination or something totally out of the box, every bite is packed with flavor and nostalgia. If you haven't been to Milky Ways yet, you're seriously missing out. Great treats, amazing people, and endless ways to customize your perfect dessert--what more could you ask for?

Never open- have visited twice at very different times and days of the week and it's not open. Will…read morenot be back

Welcome Smallcakes to your new location on Commack Road near Giunta's Meat Market…read more These cupcakes are dangerously delicious. Carrot cake was outstanding. All the chocolate cupcakes were amazing. The worker was so nice she made a special cupcake for a teachers appreciation day (apple). I highly recommend this place.

Absolutely fantastic bakery! Not only are their cupcakes beautiful and incredibly delicious, but…read morethe service is just as amazing. The owner, Rose, and her staff went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect, and you can really tell she cares about both her customers and the quality of what she serves. I needed gluten-free cupcakes, and they were able to fulfill the order without any issue. Honestly, you would never even know they were gluten-free -- they were moist, flavorful, and tasted incredible. Everything we ever had from here is always fresh and perfectly prepared, with frosting that was light and not overly sweet. Between the outstanding cupcakes and the amazing service from the staff and Rose, Smallcakes in commack stands out. We will absolutely always continue to comeback.

Order wrong, never answers phone!!!! In case there is an issue. Missing items and cant get in touch…read morewith them.

Traditionally, I love Coldstone- always paying for quality product and service. We aren't big fans…read moreof this location- the product is always overmixed and crushed too much into the ice cream. The customer service is very lax. Probably won't return, wasn't worth $15 for two ice creams.

The best fro-yo/smoothie place I've been to in a very long time. I stopped in yesterday because it…read morewas super humid and I wanted something refreshing. The store had a lot delicious looking fruit smoothies so it was hard to pick. However, my pomegranate pick was absolutely delicious. As I was waiting, the owner and I got to chatting and he informed me he has been in business for over 30 years and I completely understand why! The smoothie was super light and refreshing, he was super hospitable, and the location is conveniently located on Jericho Turnpike. They also sell froyo, cookie ice cream, and more!

Gotta go here for my frozen yogurt head of the week. They…read moreprovide me with a nice choice of sugar-free options . The service is conscientious and fast, no matter how busy they are

The Ice Cream Social has come to Greenlawn. So let's congregate and be social over ice cream. Great…read moreflavors like Raspberry Chip. Or let's get tipsy with a scoop or two of Boozy Egg Nog, they have the classic flavors too. The owner will go out of his way to make sure your experience at the Social is a good one. Seating is limited and the parking is not a problem. CIAO FOR NOW.

So happy they opened up a location near Huntington Village. Always loved their vegan options. They…read morehave a hard ice cream and soft serve; options for everyone. They have really unique flavors, especially around the holidays. They have seating for dine in or a friendly and efficient service for takeout. They even make vegan saucers and ice cream cakes when you order ahead. They have fat free and sugar free options as well.

Timeless and classic. Stepping inside the Northport Sweet Shop brings me nothing but happiness. In…read morethe summer their ice cream is perfect. In the winter we pop in for some of their chocolates. This year we tried the egg nog bon bon. The whole box was devoured.

ICE CREAM ONLY REVIEW: The Northport Sweet Shop is an institution in the Northport area. It has…read morebeen here for almost 100 years, spanning four generations. That said, I have been here several times in the 80s and 90s, but have not been here in over 30 years. I wanted to like this place. In fact I wanted to love this place, but I just did not. I went on a Saturday night for ice cream. The shop seemed somewhat forgotten, tired, and needing some care. Most of the lights were out, giving the shop a gloomy vibe. The vanilla ice cream, the standard by which an ice cream shop is measured, was bland, flavorless, and a true reflection of the current state of this once fantastic ice cream spot on Long Island. This is serviceable if you are looking for a shorter line than other spots in the neighborhood. If you're looking for great ice cream, keep looking.

I had some delish rainbow cookie ice cream from here…read more Came here on Sunday afternoon. It wasn't overly crowded. Staff was friendly. The rainbow cookie ice cream was very yummy. There as huge pieces of rainbow cookie throughout that was just delightful. Very good spot to hit that "sweet" craving. Definitely recommend if you're in the area.

Decided to try and ice cream place that I neve tried. This is definitely your local hangout and…read morethe ice cream are all homemade. Each flavor has homemade and the ingredients. I got a small cone with 2 flavors - blueberry cheesecake and moose tracks. Moose tracks overpowered the taste of the blueberry cheesecake. Definitely loved the homemade ice cream. The employees were patient especially with the number of customers. It's not a big space, literally one line to go in and enough space to leave. If someone is waiting against the wall, it prevents the traffic flow. If you are here, take a walk to the nearby park or waterfront. Enjoy!

I usually get my Sundays in Syosset, but I was in the area and I ordered two Sundays and was very…read moresurprised they charge me extra for toppings so I won't be back

Kind of baffled I'm writing this review, but this location just charged us $4.39 for chocolate…read moresprinkles on a Jr. Cone. For reference, the Jr. Cone cost $3.89. I went back inside after to ask why Two Jr Ice Creams ($3.89 each) with chocolate sprinkles on one of them cost $13.20, and she said "Tax and Sprinkles", well, after accounting for taxes, I did some math, they literally charged me $4.39 for some chocolate sprinkles. That's it.

Amazing new ice cream shop!! The shop is super clean and cute!! The staff are super kind and…read morehelpful, the place is accessible to wheelchair users too! Had an amazing time and we ate everything.

Waffles make anything better. Love that they offer bubble waffles here. Cute little spot with great…read moreservice. Thanks! Will definitely be back and I love that they have vegan and dairy free options.