Place is great. Laidback atmosphere with a good mix of different people. Good prices and good…read morebartenders

Trying out all the bars in Rockaway, one at a time. This is an interesting little dive bar,…read moretrapezoidal shape pressed up against the tracks. From the name "Mill Lane" I'm guessing there were once some mills down this way, but I didn't see any ruins. Just the bar. Warning, it's a tiny place. Not crowded, my friend and I found a table on Sunday game day, but don't bring a large group. Mostly locals who know each other, but a friendly atmosphere from guests and servers alike. Our bartendress was nice and sassy. Second warning: Do not use the jukebox. It will drown out everyone and leave your ears ringing for days. I think the people who put in a pair of songs realized that and it was blessedly quiet the rest of the day. Beer: Fairly on the expensive side. Out $9 for one draft Yuengling and one bottle. Those would be maybe $7 nearby at Johnnie's. Food was reasonable, though as I worked out the Halloween specials, I could get the same ingredients on the cheesesteak for a buck cheaper by ordering it off the regular menu. Maybe it's the pepper jack that did it. Maybe the 5 cents of BBQ sauce they'd add. As for the cheesesteak itself, which has gotten plaudits from others here? Decent. Good size, but the beef tasted really plain. American cheese melted into it. Nice amount of mushrooms. Side of onion rings a bit burnt but decent. I should have splurged on the special perhaps. The strangeness came as we got to the 4th quarter, when the bartendress disappeared. The two guys left basically ignored us. Sure, we weren't asking for drinks (which is generally how you get their attention)... but she would point to us when she saw our glasses empty, and they didn't. Also... we had an open tab that they weren't asking about. We totally could have left. Turns out the tab was actually closed! So they called her on the phone to bring her back inside, enter the tabs for a couple of us, and then close them out. Bizarre. Quirky local place, but I'll leave it for the locals.

We had a small baby shower there. The staff was very helpful, allowing us to decorate the room as…read morewe liked. The food was delicious, and most important of all, the guests all had a good time!

When you come into a restaurant and The woman bartender couldn't get on same page to the customer ,…read morecouldn't be present , couldn't be nice , it's clear this whole experience will not go well. The way she spoke to me was rude , life is too short for this type of insanity . Don't go to this place.

I went on Thursday for the first time it was prime rib night everything was excellent I had never…read morebeen to millers before

Over the past few years we have visited Millers to watch football. We've enjoyed the vibe & the…read morefood although I wish there were a little more healthier options. We moved out of state & came back to visit & stayed at a nearby hotel. We visited Millers during our week in NJ for mostly drinks but one night we ordered apps which were great - potstickers & the pretzel - yum! Rob is an excellent & efficient bartender. Always checking to see if you need anything & he keeps the bar very clean & tidy. Lots of parking & we really enjoy the side bar as it's a little quieter!

Great place. I met a guy named Moke who apparently lives on one of the stools. He had his knee…read morereplaced so I bought him 10 drinks to be a nice guy.

Stopped in after a 7 mile hike for a nice cold beer. Cash only and no food. Great beer prices -…read moremost beers were $4 and the special was $7 pitchers of Miller Lite. We enjoyed a pitcher and the outdoor area. The set up is great. We came during the day so it wasn't super crowded but I can see this place being really fun at night. The only pitfall of the outside area is that smoking is allowed.

We came to celebrate Mother's Day. They had a wonderful…read morebrunch buffet. Everything was delicious. Service was great. Atmos Definitely coming back!

It's no longer the Rockaway River Barn! Rockaway River Barn closed, now called 11 Green. But…read moreservice at the old place was never great

It had been a few years since my wife and I had last visited Thatcher McGhee's, but on a Columbus…read moreDay Monday afternoon, we stopped in for lunch. I liked it before, but I actually liked it more this time. It was a very friendly atmosphere at the bar, talking with the bartenders and other patrons. I started with a Guinness and my wife had a Toasted Almond. We split entrees of Beef Stew and Fish & Chips. I liked both, but really loved the fish & chips. They were crispy and light, made perfectly! The fries and onion rings were good too. Denville is one of my favorite Jersey towns and there are so many great food options here. It was fun getting back to Thatcher McGhee's!

I've been on an Irish Pub kick for the last week and Thatcher's is a classic…read more Hubby of course had a Guinness. He likes it here because they have the full size pint glasses where many other restaurants have switched to the smaller size. I got a Stella on draft because I'm not a fan of the stouts and lagers. Hubby got a cup of the hearty beef barley soup then enjoyed his corned beef sandwich with seasoned fries. Very big portion that he is going to have for lunch tomorrow. I went with the chicken curry. It's my daughter's go to favorite for this place and I know she will be happy to have some of my leftovers since the portion is so huge. Hubby liked dipping his fries in the sauce (as did I). Such a joyful meal! I highly recommend it! He got a coffee and we split a piece of cheesecake. It was a large plate for a small piece. It may not have been too small, but perhaps some Whipped cream or a smaller plate to appease the eye. The service is fantastic! We sat and had menus right away, whenever we finished a drink or food. They cleared items right away and were very attentive. There were TVs over the bar with various games and it looks like this was the place for World Cup soccer. The bar area is very lively and a fun place to hang out. But there are also multiple rooms where you can have a quieter meal or even outdoor dining when the weather permits. If you haven't been here, do stop by when you are in the Denville area. You will love it!

The people are incredibly kind, the food is absolutely delicious, and the girls are so empathetic…read moreand respectful. The flavor was amazing I loved it!

Pretty lit club & gets pretty packed on the weekends & always a fun time…read more The drinks are good and so are the staff & everyone has a pretty good time.

Since 1979, the Quiet Man has served amazing meals, provided comfort food, a place to feel at home…read moreand joyous music and entertainment. They will be closing next Saturday. If you haven't been, I'm sorry. If have, rejoice and know the chef, Skip, who happens to be my brother-in-law will enjoy his retirement after a chaotic, non-stop last month. I stopped in for lunch today with my good friend and struggled with what my last meal should be. I opted for the Chicken pot pie and corn fritter. It was light, flaky and delicious. The corn fritter came with maple syrup and brought me great joy. My friend went with the pork Milanese which was huge! It came with mashed potatoes and veggies. She definitely will be having a second meal from that pork cutlet. She also ordered a Reuben to take home for her hubby. Sorry, no photos of the sandwich. The service is always top notch and the drinks free flowing. Stop in if you can. But know the wait will be lengthy but worth it.

Authenticity Cozy Irish Pub with soft lighting and warm friendly staff. Smaller establishment but…read morenot too tight. There may be a wait on busier days; but not too bad and worth it. Nice bar, and good selection for wines and beer. Parking is street parking mostly and they have couple of parking spots to the side of the restaurant. Genuine hospitality that welcomes you like they've known you forever. You are going to ask why you haven't been here many times before after you visit. Everything is of quality and fresh. The menu is concentrated offering a nice balance of traditional items and Irish dishes. The Potato and Leek Soup is made very well with such a clean smooth broth and plenty of potato and leek present in the soup. Try the Cajun Chicken and Sausage gumbo was a nice option offering Big pieces of Chicken and Andouille Sausage. Nice kick but not overwhelming. Clams or Mussels appetizers are on point and worth sharing with the table. The Corned Beef and Cabbage dish was amazing and definitely NOT bland! Lean Corned Beef and fresh hand cut veggies make this a must have! The NY Strip, is tender, cooked perfectly and recommend having the whiskey sauce over the top! For $38.95 it is a bargain! Highly recommended as it literally checks every box for me. Will definitely return!

Quite a few years ago (before I was on Yelp) I met a friend of mine for lunch at The Second Half…read moreand really liked the place. This past Saturday was an overcast August day so my wife and I decided to stop in for afternoon drinks and appetizers. We didn't realize there were Happy Hour specials, but that made it even better! Sitting at the bar, we ordered cocktails, mozzarella sticks, and pretzel bites. My Old Fashioned was perfect and the food was good too. It was a fun atmosphere at the bar with everyone just enjoying a Saturday afternoon. We also had TV's with preseason football. Our bartender, Dennis, made great drinks and was very pleasant to talk to. A nice bar and a fun time!

This was our second visit to Second Half on Main, and it was just as good as the first! The…read morehighlight of our experience was our waitress, Janet, who actually remembered us from our previous visit. That personal touch made us feel so welcome. The food was outstanding. I had the Santa Fe Bowl and the stuffed twin avocados, and both were absolutely delicious. My husband ordered the French dip and a salad, and he loved everything as well. Great food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere--it's easy to see why we'll keep coming back. Thank you, Janet, for making another visit so enjoyable!

Our son plays in school of rock nearby, and we wanted a beer and perhaps something to bite, as our…read moreprevious visit to a nearby dinner was meh, we decided to give Mr. Crabby's a try, and we're delighted to find an awesome sports bar, with a wide selection of beers on tap (I really liked their house hazy IPA), pretty good food, and great service! We did sit at the bar today which dominated a large section of the place, has room to sit dozens and as expected from a sports bar, tvs and big screens all around. We came there wasn't a game, so we were pleased to listen to good music as we sat in the corner of the bar. We only sampled a small portion of the menu as we only had 40 minutes, but the fish and chips were spot on, crispy on the outside and flaky on the inside, came straight from the fryer without feeling overly greasy. The fries were delicious, and the burger was respectable We def plan to come by next time we need to pass time waiting for our drummer boy.

Nice looking place from the outside. Inside is more like a sports bar than a restaurant…read more Tables were wobbly and the table top was sticky. The waitress came over right away and we ordered two margaritas. They came in 10 minutes and they were very watered down. She never gave us straws and the ice was in chunks not smooth ice for a frozen drink. Not worth it for $15 each My wife ordered beer battered shrimp and I ordered the Snow crab bucket for $50. Dinner came in about 20 minutes. The Shrimp were beer battered but the tails still remained and the batter was not cooked. Very battery. My crab bucket included 2 clusters. 6 small pieces of potato, corn on the cob and all covered in some potato/ carrot kind of sauce. Remember- I have use my hands to crack the crab legs, so all the sauce was all over me. This was frustrating. The crab was fine once I got through it but the potatoes were undone. The common the cob was very good. All considered! I gave the place a 2 and I won't be back unless I go for beers and to watch a game. Choose another place for dinner as there are many choices in the area.