Executive summary:
Almost everything we tried was unconscionably flawed, and the superb ambience, good service, the organic, locally sourced ingredients, and its accessible suburban location couldn't begin to make up for this. I'll never go back.
First, the salad: mesclun greens with pears, candied walnuts, blue cheese, and more. Inedible. Why? Too salty. Not the dressing; it was liberally sprinkled with sea salt on top! What were they thinking? We sent it back and the next one, unsalted, was better.
My entree, the duck breast with farro, endive, and a concord grape glaze, was the next disaster. Knowing that duck breast is often prepared on the rare side I asked and was assured that it was not; closer to medium. Well, it was rare, thick, chewy, and not at all pleasant. That too went back and they tried to fix it. It was cooked more but still not good: large pieces of meat that were tough, and being thick were still rare in the middle. The presentation was entirely wrong; rare duck breast should be served thinly sliced, both for aesthetic reasons and tenderness.
More points off for the glaze, which was bland and I had no idea it was concord grape until I reread the description. It also had a disagreeable bitterness which I attribute to burnt bits mixed in during cooking. And the farro: soggy like cooked oatmeal.
The wife had potato gnocchi, with artichokes, roasted mushrooms, mint gremolata, and pecorino. It took her until near the last bite to find an artichoke. The mushrooms, while abundant and of several types, were heavy on the shiitake which were too assertive for this dish.
The gnocchi itself was all wrong too. Rather than the customary dense, chewy consistency it was soft and delicate, more like a fried ball of mashed potato.
The salmon poke, which I had as an appetizer, was the single high point. Salmon sevicheed in tangy lime -tamari marinade with lots of sesame flavor from the seeds and the oil, seaweed flakes, and cute tiny mushrooms the size of a pea. Tasty and a generous portion, but the fish chunks were cut into irregular shapes and too large.
At this price point, the food should be beautiful; not just tasty.
The dessert menu was disappointingly limited, predominantly mousses, parfaits, ice creams, etc. Not much in the way of cakes, pies, or anything that actually requires chewing. We decided to share a meyer lemon cake, topped with a white chocolate / yogurt spread and accompanied with honey ice cream. 3 strikes: the lemon cake had no lemon flavor at all and was flat and dense in texture), the chocolate/yogurt spread was just sour, and the ice cream was flavorless and grainy with ice.
Wow, a disappointing end to a disappointing meal.
Finally, my duck entree was generously sized and I didn't finish all the meat. And I knew I'd like the duck better the next day, sliced thin and quickly fried up for a sandwich. I asked to take it home, and would be be possible to throw in a piece of the sourdough bread (decent) with it? He did; when I opened the box the next day I saw the most pathetically small scrap of bread in there with the duck. Really - for a $42 entree would it have killed you to throw in a decent-size piece of bread (or two)? Sheesh. read more