This place is set up as a speakeasy located in the back of a pizza place. It has the old timey speakeasy vibe when you walk in. Their specialty is bourbon, but they offer a wide variety of craft cocktails that change seasonally. The bartenders are great and can recommend cocktails if you tell them what you like to drink. They don't serve food in the bar, but you can bring in pizza from the front, so that's a definite read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Peanut Butter Tequila - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

If it wasn't for Yelp, I'd have no idea that Wiseguy Lounge even existed. With all of the options on Mass Ave, I'm more likely to pop in here for the chiller vibe as well as the temptation to order a slice of Goodfellas pizza with my beer. Another perk: the beer selection included some beers that had me asking the staff where it came from. I appreciate Wiseguy offering more than just the usual suspects on tap. I'll be back again for sure the next time someone wants to grab a pint on Mass Ave. read more

Fan of whiskey? This place should be your go-to. Whiskey is growing on me, and this place is to thank for that. They have a wide variety of drinks and cocktails and TONS of whiskey to choose from. It's a speakeasy-type format where you might happen to think it's part of Goodfella's but happens to be its own business. The interior is cozy, dimly lit, and exactly what I think of when I think of whiskey + speakeasy. (EDIT: Biz owner responded and let me know that it is, in fact, a part of Goodfella's!) The service has always been top-notch at this place, both when I've ordered just a beer and the times I've also gotten a cocktails. Most recently, I opted for the Old Fashioned to try out the basics. It was a great cocktail. The prices are what you'd expect from a nicer cocktail lounge: $6 - $10 a cocktail. The have a big selection of craft beers on tap as well. Have them pour you a sample before you order; they've been very accommodating when I've requested a sample in the past. Is this my favorite place to grab a cocktail in the city? No. This is mainly because they specialize in whiskey, and there are times when I'm not looking for whiskey-based drinks. Still, this place is great to come and catch up with friends and maybe even for a date. Most recently, we came in and they were doing a whiskey tasting event where a musician was playing music based on the types of whiskey that they were sampling at the time. I had never heard of this type of event and it was so interesting! I hope to catch a special event they'll be hosting in the future. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Old fashioned - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The Wiseguy Lounge is literally a "hidden gem"; they've got it stashed inside Goodfellas Pizzeria. This isn't the most likely venue for a bar, but the drinks are great, while the venue itself is tiny but very cute :-) There's a great vibe inside, and a really good selection of cocktails to be had. Another plus is the music - they play it at a good volumn level - loud enough for you to hear it, but soft enough to allow conversation. read more

Wiseguy Lounge is slowly creeping up to be my favorite place to grab a cocktail on Mass Ave... and I'm not even a whiskey drinker! This speakeasy-inspired cocktail bar proclaims, "Bourbon is in our blood!" on their website, but that shouldn't be intimidating for those who are like me--not big whiskey drinkers. The bartenders are knowledgeable and professional and will help you out to find something that you like. For example, my favorite cocktail here is a drink with a name I can't remember (of course), but with a few vague descriptors, my bartender always knows what I'm talking about. They also have a surprisingly varied menu here. The crowns on the menu indicate cocktails that have won awards--start with those. The ambiance is fantastic. It definitely evokes the speakeasy vibe but is more comfortable, with large couches and arm chairs across one wall. Finally, the price-to-quality ratio of the cocktails is fantastic. You get complex, drinkable, hand-crafted cocktails for extremely reasonable prices ($6-10; cheap compared to other cocktail bars in the area). Wiseguy is in the back corner of Goodfellas pizza--so you cannot see it or access it from the street. In other words, this is definitely not the type of place you'd just happen upon, so go look for it! It's worth it. read more

So happy that I joined a group here this evening. This is a cute speakeasy hidden in the back of Goodfellas pizza. The vibe is cool & relaxing. This is a great place for Happy Hour, drink before event at Old National, meetup with friends, date with potential match, and after work unwinding. The bartenders are mixologists. Hannah was great; she helped me pick a drink...Judy Garland from the Dames List. Plus you can order pizza but rest assured, the pizza parlor and Wiseguys may be connected but are still worlds apart. read more

See all

I love that this place is a little hidden gem on Mass Ave. It's a little pricy, but you pay for the wonderful atmosphere and expansive selection of drinks. I am a big fan of Goodfellas, the pizza place attached, and this business is a treat being just around the corner. If you're looking for a polished, lounge environment, look no further. read more

Tucked around the corner of Goodfellas is this amazing Bourban bar! Walking in you see a long bar to sit at and some nice county leather couches. The vibe was great. Super chill. My friend and I opted to sit at the bar top. The menu is beautifully bound in leather and is quite extensive! I'm not much of a Bourban drinker, but since I was here I thought I might as well try a signature cocktail. I forgot the name of the drink I had, but it was damn good. I remember the menu describes it as "whiskey, coffee, beer." So good! This place just opened less than a week ago and is still working out kinks, but had done a great job it seems. Service was great. They got super busy and there were only two bartenders. The drinks are handcrafted so they take a little longer to make. Definitely worth the wait, but when the place is packed you might wait a little longer than you're used to. The prices seemed pretty reasonable to me. I liked that I could order food from Goodfellas. Nice bonus. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is my favorite speakeasy to go to, especially when Richard is behind the bar. This gives all the speakeasy vibes you want but with an even more welcoming atmosphere. So many of the drinks are an "experience" with smoke coming out, etc.. highly recommend sitting at the bar to watch them create beautiful drinks. read more

Cool place hidden in the back of Goodfellas pizza. You have to walk through to the back of the restaurant to get to the bar. I got the "Dark & Stormy" - $7 and has some darn good ginger beer in it. Simple but delicious. They also have several types of beer and other cocktails. I'll be back! read more

I've never heard of peanut butter Tequila, and you should be cautious because once you try it you may not drink anything else. "The King" seasonal drink 5/5 "Midnight Jasmine" 4/5 (got better at the end) Nice lounge, great seating, friendly staff. Excellent vibe. read more

The cocktails are mediocre at best. Tried the high end "specials" and tasted like a generic screwdriver. If you want a the best Indy cocktail go to "The Inferno Room". Otherwise visit the location in Covington, it's amazing. read more

So fun! And truly an experience. The mixologist at the bar had us on the edge of our seats the whole time and the drinks were delicious!! There wasn't any seating available, so we had to sit in the pizza place with our drinks, but the service was so good we didn't even care. read more

This was my first time coming here because I had no idea this place existed. You walk into Goodfellas and go around to the back to this fun bar area. You can still eat the delicious food that Goodfellas provide but with a fun speakeasy atmosphere. I will definitely be coming back here in the future. read more

See all

Not a fan of the cocktail menu at Wiseguy Lounge. So, when we ended up here I ordered a beer. One thing I noticed is that the Saturday night crowd is completely different than the Cincy location, in a good way. The bar is well kept, providing quick service. You don't have to actually try to get the bar keeps attention. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - The Bathroom with a broken urinal and some flooding - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Kinda okay, but was busy and understaffed. This was the second stop of the afternoon, but didn't stay very long because it didn't feel cozy, just full and a little chaotic. read more

If you're out on Mass Ave for a slice make sure you stop in for a Hot Buttery Whiskey in the lounge! It's the perfect cocktail for this quick, cold fall weather. It's definitely a must try for 2019! Brennen, Danielle, and Keith are absolutely amazing and will always make sure you're taken care of. They so knowledgeable on their product and can whip up an amazing cocktail on the fly. You won't regret stopping in. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Brennen, an amazing bartender - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

What's the secret password!? Ok so there's no password but the back of the pizza place lounge is speakeasy in every other way! Creative cocktails and swanky leather couches. You can bring your tasty new York style pizza in here from Goodfellas counter! I had the signature Boss Manhattan and Temperance. My companion had Marilyn Monroe, Ava Gardener and one other. I tasted all and they had just the right balance and amazing variety. Enough booze too! I was impressed with the bar service as there was only one bartender but she had it all handled even though at one point there was only a couple open tables! read more

Wiseguy Lounge - The cocktails are on FIRE! (SHOWN: Temperance) - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

LOVE. This place has a great vibe and some of the best cocktails I've had. I highly recommend the bump off Joe if you like coffee. It feels like a true speakeasy and has a comfortable feeling even on a Saturday night. I will definitely be back. read more

It's not just a pizza shop... Wander your way to the back of the restaurant, you will find a quasi-speakeasy bar. The have a signature peanut butter tequila that is very tasty, try the King drink. Brennen is a phenomenal bartender who will craft off menu if that's where your taste leads, even though you likely won't need to. This will become a Indy go to for every visit! read more

See all

Great atmosphere and great drinks! So glad we found this hidden gem while in town for the weekend.

I love this little ducked-off hidden gem behind Goodfellas Pizza! It is small, but it's a nice vibe. There is usually a shot of the day special, and their cocktail menu is great. Wiseguy Lounge doesn't serve food, so just grab some pizza from up front and bring it with you. read more

I didn't even know this bar existed until a friend mentioned it to me. It has a super chill atmosphere and a fun menu. I wasn't the biggest fan of my drink but there are a ton of options I'll be trying in the future. You can also get pizza from Goodfellas and eat it right there at the bar! read more

Best cocktails in Indy! Everything we tried was perfectly balanced and well made. Shout out to Jake for being an amazing bartender!

I might be a sucker for this place and GoodFellas but I seriously enjoy them so much. Like so much! This review is not for Goodfella's though so let me focus on Wiseguy. I have always had a positive experience here when it comes to bartenders. Every bartender has been able to suggest drinks and talk about different drinks if they are not on the menu. I really appreciate it when businesses educate their employees more than their own menu. So shout out to all the bartenders that are able to make a drink not listed on your bar menu. The real reason I love this place so much is that they have this drink called the "bump off joe" and it is wonderful. I sometimes will crave this drink in the morning or after work, or like during the day, basically all the time. If you love creamy liquor and coffee then do yourself a favor and get in your car and drive to Wiseguy and order yourself one. How can anyone hate a mixology bar that literally is located behind a pizza shop? Who does not crave pizza after they have had a few cocktails? Don't lie to yourself... you want pizza. CHEERS! read more

Easily the best bar in Indianapolis if you're a fan of great pizza and bourbon. The staff is always friendly, the vibes are always great, and the selection...oh goodness. You know you're in bourbon heaven when they hand you a leather bound book and tell you "this is a list of our bourbons, but not ALL of our bourbons". My only wish is that they would have a day shift during the week instead of just on Fridays and Saturdays. Sometimes playing hookie with a glass of bourbon simply MUST happen. And it would allow me to reach my goal of trying 250 bourbons alot sooner : ) Great work, Wiseguys and Staff! read more

Very cool environment and the staff is always so friendly and attentive. We normally go on Sundays for a happy meal (shot of whiskey and a PBR draft). The ambiance is second to none on Mass Ave. read more

Awesome service! Bartenders were knowledgeable and drinks were made pretty quick! I got an amaretto sour with egg whites! read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Definitely a destination location if you are looking for comfortable obeisance and awesome service. Speaking of service, come on an evening that Brennen is working and you will be blown away by this talented mixologist. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Whiskey Sour - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

A wonderful "hidden"gem on Mass Ave. I love this bar, the ambiance can't be beat and the prices are very affordable. Every gin drink I've ever ordered here has been delicious. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - The Bonnie martini - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I have this posted on Goodfellas too. Didn't realize there was a specific name, but it goes the theme so well. Anyway, this is the same review essentially, but here it is. The real fun didn't start until last night when I decided to finally go back to the bar. I had a misconception that the bar would be outrageously expensive, because it looks so exclusive. I also expected to be underwhelmed. Turns out that I was massively wrong and was just elated by the end of the outing. My friend, David, was having a rough day. My friend, Basma, was looking for some pals to hang out with. I am just thinking this is the longest week in the world here in October 2018. "Wow. What a perfect opportunity to check out that bar behind Goodfellas!" I said. So, I texted them. David finally met me there, as I was slurping down a giant sausage pizza with some ranch like a ravenous monster. We chatted with a coworker of mine for a second and realized it was the time. We go back into a red room with some brown leather couches around. There were a lot of other people having a drink and chat with their buddies. ***NEWSFLASH YOU CAN TAKE YOUR PIZZA BACK THERE*** I had no clue. However, I like the idea of keeping my pizza up in the front and the drinks in the back. Doubt I'll ever intermingle them. We take some seats at the end of the bar and start browsing through the menu. The bartender goes through some of the things with us. We finally choose some drinks under the "Guys and Dolls" section. David gets a "Marilyn Monroe" and I got the "Bette Davis." Both drinks were super great. I honestly started feeling it mid drink. We can tell there was a lot of alcohol in these martini glasses, so we were sipping them slow and watching the Kingsman. Our other friends, Basma and Greylor, show up eventually and got something with mint in it I believe? It was called the bourbon smash or something. Those drinks were pretty delightful too. The bartender was magnificent. It really seemed like for a while he was just one of us and just wants to joke and laugh a little. He watched the Kingsman with us and explained some of our questions about the movie, while staying on top of his job. We found out that we had things in common (we're not really big on hugs and rather be touched by your words), we had a conversation about his elbow tattoo inspired from the Raconteurs and reacted well to some of our jokes. At first, we were a little concerned that we came off like a bunch of morons by our silly banter, but he seemed fine. He was just a stand-up man. We love being charmed. It was really nice to go do something different on Mass Ave in an intimate setting. This would be a great place for a small hangout, a great date (feel free to ask me on one pehehe), hearts-to-hearts or maybe even to have a drink alone (however, it would be better with at least two people). I am sure we will be back. Also, I am literally the biggest idiot in America, because I just saw this is bar is called "Wiseguy Lounge" and I will be copy pasting this second half of the review over there too. But wow. Just wow. What a place. read more

My first visit was not as expected per the reviews I read! 2 bartenders and only 1 was actually working the bar.Even though the place wasn't what I would consider "packed" it was almost 20 minutes waiting until I finally able to order drinks. Yes, the world is short-staffed and I'm patient, waiting for the world to return to normal staffing levels. Honestly, the wait wasn't justified. Both of the drinks were way off key as well! I will not be back. The vibe is uber-cool. Music on point. The security checking IDs was pleasant. read more

So it took my husband and I a bit to find it, you have to go thru a pizzeria to get to it so that's odd. It is smaller than it appears on the Yelp pictures. The drinks are nice, the male bartender with the blond hair is very nice and friendly. However, I hope if you do go that you don't get the female bartender (I am posting a picture) she was very rude and stuck up so we ended up leaving because of her. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Rude bartender. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Can't rave enough about how amazing this experience was! Xavier treated us like regulars and was so helpful. The cocktails were wonderful and beautifully curated. Will definitely be back! :) read more

What a nice little place tucked in the back of the pizza place! While out hoofing around downtown I popped in here. Glad I did! They had a great selection from mediocrity to wonderful, from Ocean Aged at Sea (cask, voyage 10) to multiple Whistle pigs, angels envy... quite a wall. Don't see something you are looking for? Ask! There were some bottles that seemed to be hiding. I believe the total was somewhere between 200-300 different whiskeys. While I am more into neat, I was able to try a cocktail they made. It also looked like the pizza could be brought back and consumed. Had just had lunch, so I didn't ask. Bartender was knowledgeable about his craft, seemed to know exactly what he was doing from prepping drinks to sharing information. I'll definitely be sneaking back in here sometime soon. read more

We were told that this was the most underrated cocktail bar in the city. We were not disappointed. The cocktails were awesome, the staff was talented and attentive and our experience was a blast. Next time, we may even get some pizza. read more

I love the atmosphere of this cozy lounge. Great staff that makes amazing drinks. Their service is 2nd to none. They get pretty busy during dinner time & afterwards for the random night life that comes through, but they don't skip a beat. They are definitely a well oiled machine that makes high quality cocktails. If you don't see something on their menu, they will make something for your specific taste. Never been let down. You can tell the staff has a genuine passion for their craft & it shows. Perfect place to grab drinks before or after a show. Prices are very reasonable. Highly recommend! read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Pacific Daydreamin - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Great atmosphere, kind of young & inexperienced crowd. Table service would be nice, to not cramp the bar guests with rookies (poor bar etiquette, rude/cheap regarding staff, unfamiliar with extremely common drinks, i.e. Cosmo, rocks vs neat, etc.) screaming drink orders over our shoulders. Knowledgeable, patient & kind bartenders providing a consistent standard of service- a rare phenomenon around this city of late. Homemade lemoncello and decent pizza. read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Daquari - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Hidden in the back of Goodfellas pizza in speakeasy fashion, you'll find Wiseguy Lounge. The wall behind the bar is filled with bourbons, some familiar and some more unique. Aside from bourbon they have a cocktail list and several beers on tap. Cocktails are reasonable ($7-$10). You can order off the full menu at Goodfellas as well. read more

See all

What a great find! We popped into the pizzeria to see if they served beer, and were shown around the corner to Wiseguy's. This is an awesome speakeasy style bar! Dark woodwork, comfy couches, excellent draft list and killer cocktails! Cherries are house-infused -- make sure to try a Manhattan! read more

Wiseguy Lounge - Great seating options! - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana