First time there and it was amazing. Beautiful setting and food was excellent! Ashley, our waitress was very friendly and knowledgeable. We were late for our reservation, but they still seated us even though they were very busy. Highly recommend! read more

You know the scene in the Hayley Mills Parent Trap where the girls camp invites the boys camp over for the dance? That is the exact vibe of this place. I did feel a little underdressed, actually, in a sweatshirt, because this is the kind of place to take your country club grandpa. But we were seated graciously at a gorgeous oak (?) bar while we waited for a table. Pro tip: a 'sweet' old fashioned, in Wisconsin, means a splash of lemon lime soda; 'sour' means a splash of grapefruit soda. At one point my husband asked the difference between a supper club and a restaurant. There's some history there which is fun to learn but these days I think the main thing is that this menu is never going to feel the need to keep up with trends. You will not see a chickpea on this menu. Instead you will see words like "fish fry" and "schnitzel" and "market price" (other similar dishes hover around $34). We had a basket of some of the best dinner rolls ever--fresh, hot onion bread, pumpernickel, rye. Then the French onion soup (piping hot) and the rahmschnitzel--veal breaded and topped with a white wine/mushroom/cream sauce. Buttery, garlicky broccolini. Everything so fresh and so hot. Two cocktails at the bar were $12.50 and two entrees were $63.50 before tip. Frank Sinatra playing throughout the evening because obviously. Very grown up, special, delicious dinner in a historic building. I would never bring kids here--but that's just for my own enjoyment read more

See all

I've driven past this place a ton of times, but never been until a few weeks ago. I stopped in with my wife and son for dinner, and I will be back again. Let me start by saying this is the cleanest restaurant I think I've ever been in. My wife described is as almost hospital clean. It's well decorated, and the bar area is beautiful. I would recommend getting a reservation. Our server was polite and efficient. We started with cheese curds, and they are in the top three cheese curds I've ever had. I'm not sure how they are seasoned, but they are delicious. The french onion soup was great as well. I had the rouladen, which I loved. The spaetzle was great as well, but the cabbage was a bit sour for me. My wife and son split the filet. I will definitely come back again. read more

See all

I think they have finally got this place rolling. Check out their story on the menu. Bright. Open. Large space. Huge bar. Lots of TVs but no sound. Just nice dinner music. Grace was our friendly server. The menu is extensive so it's hard to pick. We had lightly breaded Fried Green Tomatoes to start. Their salads are lovely and the dressings are all made in house. The wife went with Panko Parmesan Walleye that was really crisp and delicious. The side of carrots were as delicious to eat as they were to look at. I ordered off the German section. Rhamschnitzel, Spatzel, and Red Cabbage. Everything was delicious! Well worth it! Open Wednesday thru Saturday. We will be back. read more

See all

Service was great. The prime rib was the best I have had in the north woods. Establishment was well done, lots of character and a fun experience. We will be going back! read more

Beautiful place. So clean everywhere! Great service, great fish fry!! Nice to drive up north to go to an awesome place!! read more

We made a reservation a month in advance online for 5 people. That was fine and easy to deal with. Upon our arrival, we were immediately sat. Once at our table our waitress promptly got our drinks. The reason for the review is the cheese curds were horrible. For $8.95 I better get a good portion. I got a small portion and they were super greasy. Our meal came 45 minutes later. I got a filet mignon which was okay but nothing to write home about. The baby back ribs were fall off the bone, but the sauce was trash. The salmon was good. That was the only dish no one had complaints about. read more

See all

Great service and amazing food options. We stopped in Saturday and the drinks were amazing and enjoyed the prime rib. read more

Williams's Pine Gables - Southern comfort old fashioned - Supper Clubs Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

Terrific meal/experience. Service by Sean was excellent and we totally enjoyed our meal. The walleye was the best I have had and the mango dessert was off the charts. It's so good to have this level of quality dining in Eagle River. Looking for a great meal, give this a try as you will not be disappointed. Thank you again Sean great job. read more

We've been vacationing in the area for decades. This is the first time here because most times we never see it open. We made reservations and stopped in on a Saturday night. Not only is the outside of the building well taken care of but the inside is nicely done too. It was apparent they have many tables but didn't allow for an overrun of customers to servers. The old fashions were muddled and very good. The bar service was on top of things. After being seated we were taken care of from an experienced and attentive server. At no time we're we rushed or was another serving in our course of meals brought and cause a stack up. We had the stuffed mushrooms which were served in very large mushrooms and excellent. Then the baked onion soup was served very hot and was some of the best we've had in the North Woods. The salad dressing La are homemade and my blue cheese with crumble was simply outstanding! The main entrees were a mahi mahi , (2) kit cut prime ribs posted as 16oz but came in at like 30oz. Cuts. and a jagerschnitzle with homemade spatzle. All of the dinners were top notch! Everyone was very pleased. From there we shared a piece of cheesecake which was again some of the best I've ever had. We also all had coffee whiz was very good and a few steps above what is normally served. read more

See all

Small with unique hours and seating. Bartender was fantastic and our waiter Shawn was laid back. Food is beyond excellent.

I went again with my son and 2 grandsons and the experience was just as wonderful. My grandsons ordered the ribeye steaks and they raved about them, I had the Wiener schnitzel again and it was just as good as before. But the Pièce de résistance was the fried green tomatoes. I just loved them! If you like fried zucchini or tomatoes make sure you order them. It seems this restaurant is consistently good with excellent service. read more

Great experience. Bartenders are friendly, knowledgeable, fun to interact with. Dining room staff very friendly also knowledgeable about what is on the menu. Food was wonderful. Will be returning customer. read more

A treasure, wonderful staff and atmosphere. My ribeye steak was excellent and my wife's Chicken Oscar was also excellent. Fun place, we'll be back! read more

Definitely make a reservation ahead of time. The indoor and outdoor spaces are beautifully maintained and the atmosphere is great. Old fashioneds were some of the best we've had, and their specialty drinks were great too. French onion soup was in my top 3. The meal itself was good, but I would come back again to try something else from the menu. I do wish they had a pan fried walleye option. read more

See all

This amazing establishment is not only a great service and addition within the Eagle River area, it is the best supper club I have visited to date. The space is traditional north woods decor and spotless - very clean and inviting. To Sean who greeted us and Justin who served a perfectly blended Old Fashion - we are grateful. Lori, it was a pleasure to meet you, as much as it was a pleasure to have been served. There is no focus or review on the food that was prepared and presented, GO AND BE AMAZED. All the best to each of you who touched our lives and God bless. read more

Williams's Pine Gables - Supper Clubs Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

See all

Amazing food and service. We had a group of 5 and everyone enjoyed their dinner. I had German, the beef I cut with my fork. My sister had the fish fry with potato pancakes which she enjoyed. The drinks were amazing. Dessert was out of this world. The Betsy Ross pie was a custard with fruit. Can't say enough good about this place read more

Williams's Pine Gables - Betsy Ross pie, I requested the ice cream - Supper Clubs Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

See all

On a cross country road trip, my husband and I were looking for a good place to grab dinner. I had been told that the supper clubs in Eagle River are unique and fun to check out, so we decided to find one. It was surprisingly hard to look up online. Due to COVID-19 many of them were closed. But at last, we found Williams's Pine Gables Supper Club. And what a find it was! The service was outstanding from beginning to end. Everything was done right from how things were placed in front of us to who was asked for their order first. At a restaurant of this level of class, it is refreshing to see high standards of service upheld. I was very impressed and tickled by how well we were treated. I ordered an old fashioned, as I was told they are kind of a "thing" at supper clubs. It was fabulous and incredibly well made. We were served bread before our meals came out, which was a nice touch and also delicious. Next out were the soups that came with our entrees. I opted to upgrade mine for a French onion soup. It was probably the best French onion soup I have ever had, though I am no aficionado. The cheese was melted evenly with a crispy layer on top. The bread and onions inside were soft without falling apart and the entire dish just warmed my soul. Roasted half duck was my entrée of choice, as I do not often get to indulge in my love of duck. The flavor was superb and the sauce it was served with only elevated the taste. I highly recommend the duck. My husband ordered the ribeye, which came with a béarnaise sauce. I am really picky about my steak and this was something to write home about. Not only was it deftly cooked and seasoned, but the sauce it came with was perhaps the most excellent thing I have put in my mouth alongside a steak. I am not sure how I lived 25 years without knowing the joy of béarnaise on steak. If you have never had this combo before, you absolutely must try it. We both decided that the next time we make steak at home, this sauce must accompany it. Overall, we had a great time here. The staff was all incredibly friendly, as seems typical in Wisconsin. They put a NBA game on one of the TV's when we asked and always ensured we were taken care of. On top of that, the food was superb. This is a great spot for a date night or any special occasion. It makes you feel sophisticated and fancy while also providing high quality meals. I would highly recommend Williams's Pine Gables Supper Club. read more

See all

From the bar to the table the service was excellent. The menu had great offerings and the food was delicious! it says reservations are recommended, but the restaurant wasn't overly busy. I think the idea of reservations in a town that doesn't have that option at many establishments may have scared people. I highly recommend you stop in, reservation or not. you won't be disappointed! as a side note I had the fish fry with potato pancakes (yum). read more

Hey!!! Stop scrolling. This is the place you want to go! First of all, the food was phenomenal. Our table had the fish fry, the salmon, the scallops, beef tips, fettuccine Alfredo, and a hamburger. Everyone loved their meals. That aside, the staff was exceptional. Our server, Lisa, and the manager Shaun were so accommodating. I won't go into details, they know what they did and we were all very grateful. We will definitely come back every time we come up north. read more

I made a quick reservation to sit at the bar and have supper. Friday night and it was fish fry, but I ordered a filet. It was amazing and the bernaise sauce. To. Die. For. Amazing Old Fashioneds. Good salad. Great blue cheese. Bar staff super friendly. Definitely recommend. read more

Had a really great dinner here. Service was good. Someone else said it was dark but it was very well lit when we were there. We started out with the fried mushrooms and they were crispy and delicious. We had French onion soup which was great and clam chowder. The chowder was thin but still very tasty. We also had Caesar salad which was pretty standard but really liked the dressing. Had to ask for more dressing because there was barely any on the salad. For entrees we had one of the veal schnitzels and fish fry (haddock) and both were excellent. We got the kit Kat cheesecake to go and was awesome. Overall a really great meal and would recommend! read more

Williams's Pine Gables - Jagermeister schnitzel and fish fry (haddock), both awesome! - Supper Clubs Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

This place has only been open 5 weeks but it's off to a great start. The place is newly remodelled and so clean. Its a log cabin with beautifully polished walls, ceilings and floors. The bar is beautiful. They don't take reservations and we waited over an hour after arriving about 5:45 on a Thursday night. Our bar bill for 7 adults drinking was only $48. After drinking in the Chicago area, that price was a real treat. We had a group of 10 and they sat us at two tables in the same general area. We started with the green pepper rings. I wasn't very enthusiast about ordering them, but they were delicious with the ranch sauce provided. Next was the french onion soup - really good. I had the ravioli with goat cheese. It was very tasty, but could have been a little warmer. My husband had the strip steak with broccolini and thought it was perfectly cooked. The prime rib and the chicken were also loved by our group. Everyone we encountered, the hostess, bartenders, servers were super nice. The owner stopped by our table for a chat and we learned a little history of the place. If you go, arrive early unless you don't mind the wait. Hopefully, they will figure out how to do reservations in the near future. read more

Reservations were a breeze got there a bit early had a drink at the bar while we waited for an our table. I had a brandy old fashioned sweet and my fiancé had a double tall Jameson sprite which was triple the cost of my old fashioned. We were seated in no time for dinner. I had the scallop risotto which was amazing and my fiancé had the filet mignon which was absolutely mouth watering. The whole place had a really nice ambiance. The fireplaces were not lit but I was okay with it. We definitely found our new supper club to go to every time we go up north. read more

Yum! What a nice, clean place! Food was delicious. Nice serving sizes. Yummy prime rib and mahi mahi. Server knew her facts; not a major conversationalist, but knew what she was doing and was overall good at what she did. Table lighting slightly too dark... Could be my aging eyes. Bar was huge. Bathrooms immaculate. Will go back and look forward to doing so soon. read more

This was our last stop before reluctantly having to settle for MickeyD's (during this 4th of July 2021 holiday, restaurants in the area were either closing due to running out of food, lack of staff, had a 2 hour wait or declining to add anymore to the wait list.) Boy, did we get lucky in so many ways!We waited 1 hour but enjoyed the very pleasant decor, staff & surroundings, not to mention the gorgeous building & very colorful & well tended flower pots outside. My glass of house pinot noir was superb & hubby's choice beer on tap was cold & perfect. This place is THE Supper Club! I had the perfectly seasoned & grilled to my choice ribeye, the savory onion soup ( typically salty in other places). Hubby said his rouladen was very tasty, melt in your mouth & "a cut above" the rest! What a way to cap our vacation! We'll be back! read more

This is the best restaurant in northwooods! Best with in 100 mile drive trust me. I've been to them all. High end Northwoods dining with the old supper club feel. Decor is impeccable. Mr ratings are based on food atmosphere and service. Straight 5 star here for Northwoods. Check it out!!! read more

See all

Not good, won't be back. The restaurant is very dark, only room that is light is the area where only large groups can be seated. We had an extremely poor waiter. He was very nice but does no realize how to be a goo waiter. The duck was really tough and the side was a very mushy, so called wild rice. He really rushed us. Took bread plates off table before the salad or main course came. Guess he thought that was our appetizer. Started taken plates off while two people were still eating. Put the check on table while people still eating. Very dissatisfied with restaurant, host, and food. Maybe they should hire an experienced manager. read more

Beautiful place but the hostess was rude giving a very poor first impression. She went on to yell at one of her coworkers not to walk away from her when she was talking. The place was not that busy, yet she was unable to accommodate a party of six. She did not offer a wait time at all, simply, sorry we cannot accommodate you, we already have a party of six waiting". This was at 6 pm on Saturday night in prime tourist season. Wow, really I hope you guys change the face of your restaurant because a woman like that was not inviting nor pleasant to encounter off the bat. read more

There lucky I can't give them 0 stars Had dinner there last night my order was the bbq burger server didn't even ask how I would like it cooked guess she just assumed raw I guess. They gave me it and first bite it was bleeding all over. SICK. Then I tell server and they make me new one which was even more raw than the first one and now I'm laying in bed sick because there cook doesn't know how to make a burger. DO NOT EAT HERE UNLESS YOU WANT TO GET SICK. read more

Williams's Pine Gables - This was the second burger also found a hair on the bun nice - Supper Clubs Near Me - Eagle River, Wisconsin

We had a very enjoyable dinner. 5 stars for a beautifully renovated building inside and out. 5 stars for our good waitress (who was attending UW Lacrosse this fall). We tried two cocktails. The Gable was grapefruit vodka and Prosecco, and was delicious. The other was a gin concoction that I would not order again. Cobb salad was 4 stars. Chicken in it was deliciously grilled. French onion soup 5 stars. 1 star for the cheeseburger. Not a good cut of meat. Very disappointing. Homemade desserts are a must! We had turtle cheesecake and a panna cotta that was fruity pebbles themed. My adult son loved the panna cotta (not my thing) but the turtle cheesecake was outstanding!! Overall, we will definitely be back and recommend! read more

Temporally closed sounds reasonable especially at this time of year. I will review it though because when the season starts up I think they will give it another go. Back in September I heard that they would be open Thursday, Friday, and Saturday. If they open again perhaps they will start with these days to ease back into the season. Overall the food is good but nothing stands out as above average. The steaks are fine but the preparation is bland. Also no exciting or gourmet food items are offered on the menu. I enjoyed the bread and salad selection. It is good enough in that I would go back. The server I had was excellent and provided me with stellar service. I agree in that the menu is limited. I'm surprised a fish fry is not offered. The log lodge decor is beautiful. A good cocktail selection is featured. read more

Excellent decor, this place meets the definition of a north woods supper club. I only regret not having a drink at the beautiful bar before sitting down for dinner. The prices were very reasonable for the food quality. The wait staff was extremely professional and took pride in where they worked. read more

This place was one helluva great find! The first thing you will notice from the outside is a meticulously-maintained exterior: Manicured lawn, Crisp paint, Clean parking lot.... Then you get inside to a perfectly-lit bar, new carpet, tables being completely sanitized between guests... The bar is beautiful, and the cocktails are hand-crafted right in front of you. The whole staff was masked, even though none of the guests were - seems very thoughtful to me, even if you might think it unnecessary. Service was friendly - the server knew the menu and presented the specials with professionalism. I'm not a huge prime rib fan, but this... THIS WAS THE BEST I HAVE EVER HAD. The only thing that wasn't a 10 out of 10 was that they were sold out of Rouladen - but that's no the restaurant's fault that we missed out! This just means we need to make the trip back soon to make sure we get it before it runs out. read more

A clean, cozy setting with an open atmosphere. Bartenders were friendly & attentive, making a delicious muddled old fashioned. Cherry garnish is special as it is not your typical maraschino cherry- yum! On to dinner- fairly limited menu focusing on their specialties to include German fare, Steaks, sandwiches, appetizers, high end seafood & dessert. We opted for the oysters Rockefeller for an appetizer and were very pleased. Amazing flavors! Salad & soup was tasty. Entrees were seared tuna steak and jaegerschnitzel -both very good! A recommended stop in Eagle River! read more

Terrible management had dinner August 23 ok dinner and service.Asked the hostess if we could bring 10 people the following Friday.She said ok so our friends party of 10 drive to Resturant and find out it's closed.Never called us or let us know that they were not open.This place will never make it and needles to say they should just close up . read more

Some of the one-star reviews on here are bogus so I wouldn't pay attention to the overall rating until more come in. One of the one stars just says that it was closed when they tried to go? I'll admit, Pine Gables has had some problems getting opened over the years, but it appears to finally be opened for good. It's about as high class as it gets in the Northwoods and even then it's not like you can't wear your normal clothes. Overall, the building is extremely nice and clean and new. They have a decent bar with drink specials. Their drink prices are oddly really cheap and this wouldn't be a bad place just to grab a couple Old Fashioneds on a week night. The food is the expensive part with most things coming over $20. They have a good variety of options from burgers, fish and duck to schnitzel and a rack of lamb. It'd be nice if their fish fry was available every night, but unfortunately it's just Fridays. The mushroom bisque was great and most of the food at my table was enjoyed from the chicken carbonara to schnitzel to prime rib. I had the special 'Catch of the Day' Mahi Mahi and quickly realized it was the wrong route. We had two at our table and they were both overcooked. But this is Eagle River. I also found it weird that they put fries in baskets, similar to a burger joint or bar. It's almost like they want to be hip, while also being fancy. I suggest they just go straight fancy and live up to it because there aren't many places like this in the area. Pine Gables is something a little different for Eagle River and I'll probably be back at some point in the future. The drink prices are a nice bonus, but I'm not sure I'll get fish other than the fish fry. read more

After being told by the restaurant in the hotel we were staying at that they couldn't accommodate us, we chose William's. What a Gem! Saturday night before Valentine's Day and we got a table right away. We went early on purpose, just for this reason. My Hubby had an Old Fashion, perfectly muddled while I chose a special- Raspberry Cosmo. Yummy, and served with fresh berries on a skewer. He ordered Wienerschnitzel- said it was delicious, but dry. Would have benefited from a gravy. They did offer different sauces for an extra fee, but he chose to try it plain. I had a special- Lobster Ravioli with a Lobster Cream Sauce. OMG! I could have taken a bath in that sauce. It was light and flavorful and buttery. I used the last dinner roll to mop up that sauce and my plate was clean as a whistle when I was done. We will definitely make a special trip to this place when we come back to this area. It was FANTASTIC! We highly recommend this restaurant . Beautiful Northwoods feel and amazing food and service! Well done, William's. Well done. read more

Went there for the first time, and last time. The menu is so limited, they only offer expensive dinners, no "lite" options such as a burger or sandwich. Excuse me, you are in the north woods, not Chicago, expecting people to pay almost $70 for a prime rib big boy cut... ordered the ribs, not worth the money, with fries, which were cold. I would have given them a one star, however, to rectify the cold fries they insisted on giving us a free dessert, (nice gesture) which was the highlight of our meal. Another thing, they are never open. Not sure they are going to make it, hopefully, the next owners will be more reasonably priced, better menu and OPENed more than 6 weeks! The place is beautiful, too bad it's not going to last for them. Sorry! I wish I could give it a better review! read more

We went to The Pine Gables on a Saturday night at 5:00. There was a two-hour wait. We had been calling for three days, leaving messages to make a reservation, but did not get any callbacks or confirmations. As it turns out, they had lots of trouble with their reservation process, and they stopped taking them after the first couple of weeks. My husband and I will not wait two hours for a table at any restaurant, so we decided to try again after Labor Day. No luck. They're now closed for the season. I hope they made a lot of money the six weeks or so they were open only Thurs., Fri and Sat. nights. as, apparently, they don't plan on making any more until next summer. The reviews Pine Gables has gotten from friends and neighbors("delicious!", "mediocre", and, all agree, "very expensive") have been mixed, so I guess it's no great loss not to have them in rotation for 80% of the year. read more