Finally had the chance to try Williamsburg Pizza for pickup on Saturday, and as someone who loves NY-style pizza, I was excited to have a spot like this close to home. The service was friendly, and while our order took a bit longer than expected (it was a busy Saturday), we didn't mind. They even gave us free cookies for the wait, which was such a nice touch. As for the food... it was delicious! We ordered an XL for two people and it was more than enough. The sauce was flavorful, and we especially loved the garlic knots. We'll definitely be back to try more items on the menu! read more

See all

Williamsburg Pizza is a great neighborhood spot in West Omaha for a solid slice. They offer a wide variety of pizza options, so there's something for everyone. The space has some seating inside, but it's a bit limited, so it's probably best suited for takeout. The staff were friendly and welcoming, which added to the overall positive experience. Our pizza took about 25 minutes to bake, so plan for a little bit of a wait, but it was worth it. The crust was crunchy and delicious, with great flavor. We got the Lo Mezzo, and the sausage definitely had some kick! All around good flavor and plenty of toppings to go around. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Another fab experience. This time with take out! Got a huge margarita pizza (XL) and garlic knots. We added chicken...i think we got like 6 little pieces, but it wasn't for or me, so I dont mind but it was on the skimpy side, just a note. I love this pizza place and lucky I live so close! read more

See all

Williamsburg Pizza opened their second location, and after hearing so many great things, we had to give it a try. They claim to serve authentic New York-style pizza, and as someone from New York, I can confidently say--they nailed it. True NY-style pizza isn't about thick, doughy crust piled high with heavy generic cheese. It's all about that perfectly thin, foldable slice where the ingredients shine. The tomato sauce was delicious, the cheese was top quality, and every bite was balanced just right. This is seriously good pizza--go grab a pie! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Large pie 1/2 chicken - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

I've been to their original location in Omaha, but not for ages. Their second location is much closer to my home. Their pizza was just as good as I remember. Delicious flavorful crust with just the right amount of chewy texture, a very tasty sauce, and high-quality toppings. Unfortunately, the garlic knots were a huge grease bomb. They had great garlic flavor, but they were so incredibly greasy inside and underneath that I only was able to take one bite. Definitely would not order those again. They also have a timing issue with pick up orders. I had a 645 pick up time and I was behind several people in line, and the person at the front had a 715 pick up time. They need some sort of system because as I was waiting for people to check in and interact with the cashier, my pizza was getting steadily colder. It was not piping hot by the time I drove home, and it's only a five minute drive. read more

See all

Everything from the food to customer service! They were awesome and friendly! Thank you!

Williamsburg Pizza finally opened their second location. I've been wanting to try this place for so long but never made it because the other location is a little far. Was so excited to find out that a closer location was opening. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza online and it was ready in just 20 mins! They were busy when we went to go pick up so was surprised at how quick it was. Some pizza places take 45 mins! The pizza was fresh and the crust was fluffy and a little crispy at the same time. The pepperoni are the little cup and char ones, which are my fav! Will def be back to try their other pizzas. So happy there is another good pizza option nearby! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

My first time out to Williamsburg pizza was pretty good. I'll start by saying the inside is very small so I don't recommend eating there if you are with a group or plan on getting anything other than just individual slices. We tried the Tartufo and a regular Pepperoni pizza. As a mushroom lover, the Tartufo was great! The pepperoni was very greasy but good! Would come back again if I'm craving some nearby specialty pizza! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Tartufo - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Service was friendly and helpful since it was the first time there. The pizza - OMG! Cooked perfectly, the crust was crispy yet airy and the sauce tasted light and fresh. Smaller than I expected the place to be but will be coming back! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Caesar salad Grandma slice Garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

I've been wanting to try this pizza since I moved to Omaha but they were always just a bit too far away for me to bring it back home to my house, so I was excited when this opened down the road. First off the pizza was definitely top 5, maybe even top 3 pizzas I've had in my life. I highly recommend the pizza. Love the big slices they have and the quality of the toppings is excellent. The garlic knots however I simply cannot recommend. They were black on the bottom, and the rest of it was kind of bland, for $7 I definitely was disappointed with that part of the meal. They were very very busy obviously since they just opened ,so it took about 20 minutes to get through the line to get our food so the pizza was a tad cold..again not a issue since we expected that. I definitely will be coming back for the pizza but not the garlic knots. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

I think 4 stars is pretty accurate. Convenient location. There are a couple booths/chairs and there is one high chair which was appreciated but not a tremendous amount of seating (not ideal for a bigger group). Got the pepperoni pizza which the whole family including toddlers enjoyed. House salad was just ok (not enough toppings) but kids liked the olives. Garlic knots were large but ok (maybe could use more seasoning?) . Just fyi they do not take gift cards from the 168th st location. Would order takeout pizza from here again. read more

Pizza is ok. I don't appreciate the automatic tip added to the bill. Not cool. Do not recommend.

I thought this pizza was nicely made and employees were great. Just tried the cheese to see if we liked it. For the price the size was pretty good. Would like to try other pizza but would be hard to justify paying that much. Great pizza would go back again to try though! Was cooked to perfection, cheese to sauce ratio was good as well read more

Walked in tonight for pizza, surprised how small it is for dining in. Seating for about 16 people is it but we scored a table. It was very cold inside, almost considered taking it to go. Steady stream of people coming and going but obviously they do mostly carryout. We ordered at the counter and the menu hanging overhead did not have any prices which I thought was odd. Had to get a to-go menu off the counter to see pricing. We ordered the Brooklyn and added cup and char pepperoni and red onion. Got the round pizza ( hand tossed) as opposed to Grandma ( thick crust). Came out quickly in 15 minutes and steaming hot. They also bring the pizza out in a box which is good for taking home leftovers, but seemed kind of cumbersome on such small tables. I also like to eat my pizza, at least while it's so hot, with silverware and the only utensils they had was a plastic fork which was basically useless to cut with. The pizza was very good, nice crunch on the crust and bottom Could've used more pepperoni in my opinion, considering the price. Next time I will try the Grandma crust and bring it home! read more

See all

Still one of the best in Omaha. Best pizzas are the thinner crust NY style pies. I have never eaten in store- rather carry out for meals at home. Service is always friendly and pizza is ready on time. read more

Yes! Finally open and delicious! Nice seating area inside for the lunch crowd and those wanting to eat in. The garlic knots were warm with perfect amount of garlic, basil and spice. Combined with the meatballs we had a meal! Sauce is balanced and causes one to keep eating, it was so good! We ended up dipping the knots into the meatball sauce and combining with the meatballs. Tried the Lo Mezzo and it was mouth watering, hit the spot good! Great toppings and an amazing sauce. This is a great add with a neighborhood feel. Nice and friendly staff. read more

See all

This is a rough review to write. I try to see something good in places, but this experience was pretty darn bad. The good: Nope. Nothing. The bad: ordered salad and the Lo Mezzo. The salad was $10 and as you'll see, it was pitiful. Tables were filthy, cleaned ours myself even though there's probably 7-9 people in the back. The place is freezing. The ugly: we were planning to eat-in, but because of the chilly setting and since we waited 40 minutes, never once did they call our number but apparently our pizza was done twenty minutes prior to me asking, took it to go. The pizza is awful. Greasy, scant toppings and sauce, super salty, and really inedible. This might be NYC pizza, but it's not worth the price or heartburn. The salad is just pitiful. Also, dressing needed to be mixed before putting into cups. It's all oil. Staff was inattentive and acted as if customers are a bother. I'm disappointed, but thankfully pizza can be found elsewhere. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - The pizza... it's a greasy salt-bomb. - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Pizza was excellent, small issue with our order that Kay took care of immediately. We ordered a gluten-free crust, and it was excellent. we willl be back read more

Let's just say the kitchen staff forgot they no longer work at papa Murphy! I literally had to go home and bake the $40 pizza I paid for. The entire center was raw dough! The toppings were good, but didn't expect to be this dissatisfied on the first ever visit! Not sure yall will be able to win me back read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Paesano XL. Completely disappointed! I guess the kitchen forgot they no longer work at papa Murphy's - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Incredibly rude female counter staff laughed at me unapologetically when we realized my order had been placed online for the wrong location. I'm at fault for not noticing the location was wrong on the limited tech phone app ordering. I truly thought they only had one location due to the news hype surrounding the Maple St opening. Regardless, the counter staff was condescending and mean-girl smirky about the mix-up which set me off and will likely prevent me from ordering here again for quite some time. At least the guy building boxes at the counter was polite about it. read more

This place is new, but you would never know! I can tell they've been doing pizza for a while because they've got it down! Pizza was AMAZING. Crust was fluffy and soft. My husband and I got our food to-go and service was still extremely helpful with food recommendations. 100% would recommend the margarita pizza!! read more

This seems to be more a takeout place rather than a dine in. Not much room if you do dine in. Great customer service. There are no prices up on the wall. You have to grab a menu then step away from the counter among the folks waiting for orders. We got the garlic knots below, you get 4 large knots in tin with marinara sauce. Yes there was garlic in there but flavor was lacking. The bottoms were a little too cooked maybe because they were sitting in the tin getting baked from the heat racks. The pizza was pretty good a bit chewy for the crust. Good taste of red peppers, thinly sliced mushroom a good amount of basil The sausage was OK could use more of it. And there's plenty of pizza to take home sadly to say I probably won't come back here or order from here just seemed a bit overpriced for the quality. Pizza is $33, garlic knots were $7.50, 2 drinks $4.00 which came to a total of $48. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Amazing flavors to this pizza, so much different than the style you would get from most pizza places in this area.

This pizza was delish! We ordered it to pick up and the site to do so was super smooth. If I ordered it in the future I would do extra cheese and toppings. Not including the Blanc pizza....which I would actually say LESS ricotta. However it was still delish and we schmeared the ricotta on the wonderful crust. We ordered 3 pizzas. One grandma style with the cupping pepperoni and hamburger. One blanc with chicken and bacon added. One plain cheese. We also ordered the knots and I would not order those again. Too tough and doughy for my liking. They did not have the puffy rise that the New York crust had. The dipping marinara for the knots however was very good. Bright and acidic in a fresh garden tomato way. I definitely would stop by this place again for a slice if I was in the area. read more

In a word disappointing. Decided to try them now that Zio's is no longer out in West Omaha. Ordered a large pie with Italian Sausage. The only positive was it was ready in 20 minutes. The crust was tough and very chewy. The toppings were microscopic and the amount of cheese embarrassing. I'm from NYC and this is definitely not representative of NYC pizza. read more

Great NY pizza Not just NY style.. And I'm from NY. The crust is thin and the sauce is just right.

This pizza is true NYC!!! I moved from NY back to Omaha and have been missing pizza like this. Beyond happy this place is near my house. We ordered the margherita pizza. It was delish and will be back! read more

We had a great experience at Williamsburg. My wife accidentally ordered the wrong slice she wanted and they immediately made her a new one. We will definitely be back. Great customer service! read more

Enjoyed the Paisano very much. Can't wait to come again to try the others. The crust was delicious.