Tried this pizza shop for the first time. It is as cute as can be and the food was delicious. We had the meatballs appetizer and a pizza. Both exceptionally good. Good service and friendly staff. read more

Delicious food, great service, warm welcoming atmosphere. Say hi to Carl and the gang. read more

White Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

The Spaghetti and meatballs were excellent!! I'm not a big spaghetti fan but this dish was chefs kiss. And I loved that they offered a 12" pepperoni pizza & spaghetti deal for $35 after 8pm. I was too ravenous to get any photos. But I know this place is where the locals like to dine because it was recommended by a couple locals. And if the locals eat here, it must be good. After a long day on the boat, it was like a reward! read more

Best pizza and salad! The Boston Bibb salad perfectly complemented the Soppressata Picante pizza! The salad was fresh, dressing fabulous, the pizza was everything you'd want from a thin crust pizza, dough had amazing taste/texture and cooked perfectly! Our server Tim was amazing and very attentive! We will definitely be back to try other things when on the island. read more

Wow! Service was fantastic and broccolini pizza amazing! Will definitely be back to try the rest of the menu!

This should have wayyy more reviews. Sorry locals the secret is out! Great HH, great service & great food. Particularly the pizza -- we had the Margherita, pepperoni & the shrimp (!!). Crust is amazing & the shrimp pizza is absolutely worth trying. read more

Food and service are always on point. As a local, I go at least once a week for meatballs and key lime pie and to check out the new special. Pizza is always on point whether you eat in or get delivery. A great place for locals and visitors alike. Great wine too! read more

It's just................not it. From the strange ambiance of Wonder Woman themed booths to the anime styled vegetable characters on the menu, this place didn't exactly feel inviting. As for the pizza, it was small & disappointing for the price. I was hoping for a big ole' steaming pie to be brought to our table, but instead I got something I could've made in my toaster oven really. Maybe it's better for takeout... read more

This is a great little spot off the beaten path. From the time you enter you get the feeling of cozy small family owned restaurant. We loved the ambiance with comfortable booths. Very good service from the two young gentleman working there. Gave us an idea of the menu and what some of their more popular items were. Also informed us of the Happy Hour specials which was 50% off wine and pizza. What a great deal. My wife ordered the Sauvignon blanc which was a perfect pairing with the food we got. We went with the mushroom pizza but I could recommend any of their pizza, I'm sure they won't disappoint. The beef tips were good but my favorite was their Roasted Brussels & Cauliflower. We will definitely be going back there and looking forward to trying new items. read more

See all

The pizza was fantastic! Also had the Brussel sprouts and cauliflower app good flavor but to much lime chilli sauce for me,cool old school feel read more

I came here last night for dinner. Food and service was amazing. For an appetizer we had the prosciutto wrapped dates. The crispness of the prosciutto over the dates was so flavorful. I had a pepperoni and sausage pizza. My boyfriend had the Soppressata pizza. Crust was cooked perfectly. For dessert we went with the tiramisu. By far one of the best tiramisus I've ever had. The portion was huge too. My boyfriend grew up in NYC and we still live there part-time. This is some of the pizza and dessert we had outside of NYC. read more

Overpriced tiny pizzas with zero flavor . Service was nothing great . No kids cups , no kids seats , and no crayons . The pepperoni pie had a disgusting level of meat on it yet no sauce or cheese. No cheese or sauce on any pies . It was a cute place but everything was bland . FYI 90 dollars for 3 tiny pies and 4 drinks Update - as you can see by the owners comment I'm lowering this to a frozen pizza . read more

Great pizza and even better salad! Must try! Great service and such a cute place too! read more

White Street Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Yesterday I sampled the chicken flatbread pizza and today had it for lunch. My taste buds hummed "mmmmmmm, delicious" ...it was worth waiting all morning for. A smaller version of the chicken pizza it is a white pizza covered in gooey cheese sprinkled with red peppers, green scallions and parmesan cheese. As a teenager in Home Ed, I remember being told if it doesn't look good, you won't want to eat it...almost went back for another, but work calls... Definitely worth having again. read more

Super impressed with the pizza every time we order it. Authentic and eclectic choices that you don't see most other places. Top 3 pizza places in Key West if you ask me. Also, love the extra effort put into the art and designs of this restaurant. Keep up the good work ! We're rooting for you !! read more

White Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

First thing is this is a very small place. Looks like it was maybe a soda shop back in the fifties. I've never had pizza quite like this- paper thin limp crust. I can't say it didn't taste ok but sorry I'm not a fan of pizza like this one. read more

We loved this spot. The pizza was fantastic! The employees were very friendly and welcoming read more

White Street Pizza - Mango and pancetta pizza Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Pretty good pizza just found out about it. Will be going again soon. Nice place great staff

The plan was to go home and fire up my pizza oven, but we both worked long hours and decided to eat out and try the recently opened White Street Pizza. I'm very fussy about pizza, so there were only two pizza restaurants I liked in Key West; now there are three, but White Street will be my primary go-to for pizza. I had the Margarita, and my wife had the Soppressata. Both were excellent. The crusts were perfect with leopard spot charring and as tasty as any I've ever had. Victor was our waiter, and he proved to be friendly and professional in every way. He made it one of those times when, even with excellent food, the waiter still contributed to making it a great dining experience. read more

Great pizza! A very strange menu-the appetizers are so weird but the pizza is some of the best pizza in SoFl The sausage broccoli rabe was so fresh and delicious- The pepperoni too Seems to have a fantastic happy hour as well read more

Absolutely delicious! Happy Hour until 7pm. Had the roasted broccoli & cauliflower with coconut thai chili AMAZING and the red pepper sauce pork chop with asparagus, perfect. Mango Hawaiian pizza and spicy salami pizza - sooooo good. Nice Beer & Wine too Love the fun diner ambiance, comfy seating & nice service. New favorite place. Dessert divine homemade. read more

White Street Pizza - Mango Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Thin crust that has good flavor with enough tooth to hold the toppings. Mushrooms were exotic (to me). Would have liked a bit more spice. Wonderful service. read more

We had a delicious dinner at this new neighborhood gem! Very attractive and clean restaurant where you can dine in and carry out! We enjoyed the roasted pepper and burrata salad with capers scattered around! We also had a build your own pizza and loved it! The service was excellent! We didn't have time to have dessert but I'm dying to go back to have some, as well as try more of their menu items! Very reasonable prices! I had a great Cab for just $10! So excited to have this awesome addition to our neighborhood! read more

See all

I have visited White Street Pizza several times. The food has been excellent, always, from the appetizers, to the pizzas, to the desserts. The service is always prompt and the servers/proprietors are always friendly and welcoming. The ambiance is perfect for a neighborhood pizza place. It's comfortable and friendly, and so convenient! I will visit White Street Pizza many, many more times. read more

Amazing service and even better food! We loved the Stuffed Dates and the Broccolini pizza! read more

White Street Pizza - Broccolini Pizza!! Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

The Most Over-Priced "Mini" Pizza I've Ever Purchased. But The Real Insult Was They Were So Burnt. What Decent Chef or Owner Would Sell / Serve "WAY BURNT" Food⁉ My FIRST and LAST Visit read more

OK pizza. pancetta seemed under cooked, Maybe it needs to be pre cooked before it's added? Split decision when it came to the salads. Everyone liked the cakes. read more

Excellent appetizers and pizza - we had the mango on white sauce We also had the stuffed dates which were excellent

Visited last week while enjoying a trip to Key West. The atmosphere was comfortable and welcoming, John our server was top notch, knowledgeable and attentive. Now the food... oh my goodness, the blackened shrimp was absolutely amazing and my favorite but we also had the lamb meatballs and two different pizzas. The crust was perfectly crispy and the lobster pizza will truly be a Key West staple. This is a definite need to do. read more

White street pizza is cozy and welcoming. It has a casual vibe and great prices, but the service and the food is high end! We visited recently while on vacation. For appetizers, we had the lamb meatballs stuffed with gouda and topped with a romesco sauce. They were divine... but I'm still dreaming about their grilled Key West pinks with a sweet chili sauce. For dinner, we had the shrimp pizza and one with sausage and mushrooms. Both were outstanding. The pizza crust was light, crispy with a great satisfying bite, and chew. They have specialty toppers or make your own, but with that crust, you can't go wrong...it's going to be delicious!As a bonus the leftover pizza made a great snack back at the hotel after a late-night swim. This will be a must visit for us every time we are in Key West. read more

These folks are awesome, words can't express how awesome! Support local! Eat delicious food!

Be sure to check this place out the next time you're craving pizza!! Yummy appetizers, delicious pizza, and desserts. The decor is super cute and cozy. They also do carry-out and delivery! read more

my nephews were visiting me last week, and after my neighbors raved over your food, we decided to order dinner. three pizzas and an order of your roasted watermelon. the nephews 20, years and 18) loved it all! nothing was left except some crust because they are too young to understand how yummy crust is! so I ate some extra crust. lol and the roasted watermelon was excellent! you guys are now our go to for pizza and anything else on your menu. read more

Amazing tapas, salads and pizzas!!! We have been twice so far and can't wait for our next visit. read more

See all

Excellent food and ambience. They were very friendly and timely. Highly recommended to several acquaintances.

Amazing food and great service. This isn't just pizza so check out the menu to see all the amazing options. Only been there twice but with so many never options, I'll be back often to try more items. Haven't been disappointed yet. read more

I don't know what's going on with this Yelp page for WHITE STREET, but for some reason, my glowing review from last week was removed. I will once again give WHITE STREET PIZZA five stars, and this is after my third takeout experience with them. Owner and staff always very friendly and welcoming. I've tried seven different items off of their menu and everything has been perfect and on point, from the Roastsd Brussels sprouts and grilled watermelon to the delicious pepperoni pizza... crust always perfect, and prices are relatively low. My friends and I live in the neighborhood and we intend to make this place a habit. Let's see if this review is also removed by the Yelpers!! I hope not. read more

What an awesome addition to Key West. Pizza, salads and appetizers were all excellent. Great happy hour deals too! Will be going back frequently. read more

A new GEM in the White & Truman neighborhood!! Delicious tapas, salads and unusual pizzas! We just tried the grilled watermelon salad and lamb meatballs as prelude to a spicy sausage pizza - all three mouthwatering!! We will be making this place one of our weekly go-to's!!! read more

great pizza! very great owners too! we enjoyed delivery and look forward to dining in. Soon