White Street Pizza

I liked the idea of a place based off an English pub. Needed some eats for lunch, so ordered a…read moreburger. Seated quickly in a quaint restaurant and immediately ordered above mentioned burger. Big, stupid mistake! I was expecting something lunch sized but got a fantastic burger and fries that could have held me until the next day! Unfortunately, my wife had seen the fish and chips plates coming out and actually told me, "Your order is stupid, you'll never finish!" She was so right, but damn was it good!!!

Stopped in quite randomly as we were hungry before visiting the Hemingway House. Walking distance…read moreand an easy walk in for inside dining. Food was all delicious. Large proportions. It's not exactly what one things of when they think of key west dining but we had a great experience and would come back

High tops

Burgers, beer, football and soccer make for a great day in Key West.

See all

Clown Shoes Hazy Juicy Ziggy Cryo Hoptimo Double IPA Hazy IPA | ABV: 9.5%

Tipsy Rooster Liquor Store and Bar

This IS the best Pian colada spot EVER!! I've never had such a frothy flavored so rich like I have…read morehere! I make a point every time I'm in Key West to go here!! They also have other amazing infused vodkas, but you can't go wrong with the Pina!

Coolest place ever. Bar and liquor store all in one. Open till 2am Friday and sat. Live music…read moreDrinks made fresh. Cool atmosphere. Sand floors

Painkiller & Woodford neat

Inside selection of spirits

See all

More outside seating by side entrance

Don's Place

4.2(39 reviews)

0.2 mi

Fun bar with separate indoor and outdoor areas-also has a liquor store. Service was fine. Went to…read morewatch the Buffalo Bills play - big crown of Bills Mafia inside and out. Fun crowd.

Great little place in key west to watch the Buffalo Bills play, fantastic bartenders!!read more

See all

The Retro Room

5.0(27 reviews)

1.0 mi

A Key West hidden gem! Thursday night music bingo was so much fun. Our bartender at southernmost…read morepint gave us the tip! Awesome staff!

Nice little place to come and have beer and hang out., trade cards with friends or play games. You…read morecan order pizza from Duetto's Pizza just down the street and bring it here to eat. They have coffee from one of the commercial machines. For the coffee being from a machine it was fairly good coffee. The decor is super unique and it's a fun location.

See all

General Horseplay

4.5(179 reviews)

0.9 mi

Small pre-crafted cocktail menu, but every single one of them is amazing. Seriously, not one bad…read moredrink out of the group and for Key West, they are fairly priced. It's a bit small inside, just a few high tops, but they do have some standing room. The vibe and decor are perfect and the musics not so loud that you can't speak to the rest of your party. The men's urinal situation, had me laughing for a long time. My friend and I became much closer

New bar in Key West, imagine that. This place has inside and patio seating. I found inside too…read moredark, I like to be able to see the floor when I'm walking. We only had a drink here, bartender was great.

Bar

See all

Unicorn heart and I don't know what my husband was drinking

Bobby's Monkey Bar

4.0(79 reviews)

0.5 mi

All is perfect! The bartenders,customers and especially…read moreowners. Karaoke every night is a blast and the best daytime happy hour

Is it a dive bar - yes…read more Is it a gay bar - yes. Should you go there whether straight or gay when bar hopping in Key West - YES! Daytime happy hour for from noon - 8pm for the win! Cheap drinks and beer. Friendly bartenders and the locals were fun to talk to and have some drinks with. Smallish bar with a kitschy divey look and plenty of monkey stuff all around.

Bar

See all

Tiki House

4.3(141 reviews)

1.0 mi

Tiki House - A Must Stop KW Vibe We stumbled into Tiki House…read moreright at opening, lured in by their "street talker" promising 2 for 1 beers and wells from 12-3 PM. Who's walking past that? Not us. Inside, it's pure island charm -- rustic tiki décor, laid back energy, and a munchie menu that's perfect for a quick bite. Football season meant TVs everywhere, plus a solo musician on stage (I don't need to hear the game to watch it; music soothes the beast). Enter Mira -- The Tiki Oracle. Bartender, manager, Key West historian, and all around gem. She switched a TV to our game without hesitation and put up with me talking her ear off like a true bartender therapist. We liked it so much we came back the next day, and the vibe was just as good -- friendly, accommodating, and exactly what you hope for in a KW spot. We even dragged the rest of our group over, and they immediately asked why we didn't start there. Tiki House is so Conch Republic vibed it just makes you feel good. I highly recommend it... even though I hate giving away a place this good.

We had a few birthday celebrations in our group, so we decided to stop into Tiki House for drinks…read moreand a little dancing. The vibe for an early Friday afternoon was really good. The DJ was playing some great music that kept the dance floor going, and the bartender did a solid job keeping up with orders and taking care of everyone quickly. No complaints from our group at all. Everyone had a great time, and we'll definitely be back next time we're in the area.

JungleBird Bowl

Inside

See all

Green Parrot

4.1(487 reviews)

0.8 mi

One of go to spots in KW! Cold beer, good peeps, and live music! Close to Duval and Hemingway area.read more

Always a great time at the Green Parrot. A little off the beat and path and more local than…read moretouristy. Live music great priced drinks and strong pours. Friendly staff. Oh and don't forget the popcorn. Had a fun time there this past Friday night with some friends that live in Key West. If you love good music and a lively atmosphere. This is the place to be.

Rum Runners: On the rocks or blended

See all

Outside

Shots and Giggles

4.3(66 reviews)

0.9 mi

What a cute little spot! We heard about the mermaid margarita so we stopped for that and it was…read moredelicious! Very refreshing on the hot day. Inside there are several rooms, all adorable. The outside area is cute too but had no shade at the time of day we were there so that wasn't happening for us. The bartender was very friendly and welcoming. Added bonus- they have a little dog bar with treats and toys for your pup!

Never again. The bartender was more interested in hitting on a guy than acknowledging us. Her…read moreenergy was heavy and clearly annoyed we were interrupting. Once we patiently waited for her to finish flirting and trying to make plans (guy trying to leave as it was that obvious ) she finally asked if we wanted something (umm are you kidding?) we had one shot because we really wanted to give this place a try but after the shot we left . Bad service, whatever shots, and just not the vibe.

See all

Vinos On Duval

4.6(154 reviews)

0.7 mi

We stumbled across Vino's while wandering Duval Street and ended up visiting twice during our trip…read more The sangria is delicious, especially during happy hour, and there are plenty of wines available by the glass or bottle at reasonable prices. We also shared a meat and cheese board that paired perfectly with the wine. What really made us come back, though, was Sam. She was welcoming, attentive, and just genuinely enjoyable to chat with. The kind of person who makes you feel like you've been coming there for years, even if it's your first visit. This feels like one of those places you could stop into for a glass of wine every afternoon while you're in Key West. Relaxed atmosphere, good wine, good conversation, and no pressure to rush off somewhere else. As an added bonus, Sam helped us secure reservations at Lola's Bistro, which ended up being my favorite meal of the entire trip. We'll definitely be back the next time we're in Key West.

Amazing! Perfect porch for people watching. Told staff some items we liked and said surprise us and…read morecharcuterie board was wonderful! I could have eaten my weight in the house chips and hummus. My friend had sangria and said it was good. Would recommend!

See all

Front door

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

14 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

A M.

2 years ago

Prepare to have your taste buds tantalized and your cravings satisfied at White Street Pizza! My mother-in-law, aunt, and I recently ventured to this culinary gem and were met with a warm welcome from the friendly staff. Nestled comfortably in a cozy booth, we embarked on a flavor-filled journey that left us speechless. The roasted Brussels sprouts and cauliflower were a revelation - so divine that I was tempted to savor every last morsel by licking the plate clean, but of course, I refrained from such indecorous behavior. The grilled watermelon, an unexpected delight, proved that this restaurant knows how to elevate even the most humble of ingredients to gourmet status. And oh, the mango Hawaiian pizza! A true masterpiece of flavors and textures, cooked to perfection in a wood fire oven. Each bite was a symphony of tastes that left me yearning for more. This pizza is a must-try, perfect for sharing after indulging in one of their delectable appetizers. But wait, there's more! The mango coconut cheesecake was the crowning glory of our meal - a sweet and creamy finale that left us in a state of pure bliss. This dessert was so heavenly, it was almost sinful. I am already counting down the days until my next visit to this culinary paradise. If you're looking for a dining experience that will leave you craving more, look no further than this new restaurant. Trust me, you won't be disappointed! read more

Dr Earl R S.

2 years ago

I was a fan of these guys when they were part of the Red Shoe team and expected a lot from their new venture. My first visit was on their opening day and they blew me away with a genuine New York style pizza. (I lived in Manhattan for 18 years and know of what I speak.) But it was my second visit that showed me how diverse and creative their menu was. Keep it up guys, You are on a roll and i am a big fan. read more

Kim W.

1 year ago

The owner was very friendly and the cafe very clean and nicely decorated. The pizza was delicious, ingredients were fresh and the food came in a timely manner. The price was great for lunch, buy one pizza get the second one half price. We got a red and a white, both were delicious. I would highly recommend this establishment. read more

Micki K.

1 year ago

Delicious food, Robert the owner, Mark the chef, the behind the scenes kitchen crew, Victor, Charles and Alex ( who know what I want before I even say it), great music, sitting at the counter next to strangers who become friends.and after all that STILL can't decide what is my favorite dish. read more

Rob D.

2 years ago

This is my third visit to White Street Pizza. Each time, I've ordered different pizzas, and each pizza had a distinct, savory flavor. The selection is not overwhelming but offers something for every craving. Today, I had a white pizza with prosciutto, and my husband had mushroom. So good. read more

Johnathan S.

2 years ago

There is no better mix of ambiance kitsch intriguing art and superb food than white Street pizza. The service is above and beyond as each person I encountered was able to explain the dishes as well as knowledgeable about places to go and things to see. Do not miss this place. read more

Mark O.

2 years ago

Once again, a stellar and exemplary dining experience at White Street Pizza. The pepperoni pizza was phenomenal. Loaded with pepperoni and the crust was perfect. This is my favorite neighborhood pizza joint, certainly one of the top five in all of Key West. read more

Kimberley M.

125

102

29 days ago

The service was terrific, and the food was absolutely amazing! The pizza had the best crust--perfectly delicious--and the Key lime pie was simply over the top! Everything was wonderful, and we can't wait to come back. Highly recommend! read more

natalino s.

2 years ago

Delicious Pizza. Delicious Apps. We have eaten at White Street Pizza numerous times and love it. The atmosphere and service are phenomenal. Bottom line... Excellent Pizza. Excellent Service. It's the perfect neighborhood pizzeria. read more

Kelli P.

2 years ago

Loved the decor! Food is amazing and service was spot on. Great Neighborhood gem. Will definitely be back. Thank you for a wonderful dinner!

Jordan U.

9 months ago

The food is amazing. NY style pizza. Pastas are good with home made meatballs! I also recommend checking out their new Happy Hour!

Candace W.

2 years ago

such a gem great food really great pizza the cheesecake WOW thank you for a refreshing new restaurant in Key West read more

John B.

2 years ago

Best pizza in Key West, hands down! Great spot for a fun and casual night out! Our server, John, was outstanding!

Justin H.

9 months ago

Great spot. Local vibe. High quality ingredients. Differentiated place in Key West and super nice to have in town.

White Street Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Key West, Florida Restaurants near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Parking near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Things to Do near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Coffee near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Shopping near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Desserts near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Breakfast near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Dinner near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Burgers near White Street Pizza

BEST of Key West, Florida Movie Theatre near White Street Pizza

Best of Key West

Things to do in Key West

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed White Street Pizza also viewed

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria

4.6

(442 reviews)

Great place. Service is awesome and they are very dog friendly…read more Margarita pizza - 4.5 Grilled romaine salad -5.0 Hot pepper pizza - 5.0+ Even the music is great, mostly Zepplin and the stones, etc.

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria…read more Now listen here, I don't always spill all me secrets... sometimes you keep a little treasure tucked away, yeah? But this one ehh, it's too good not to whisper about. If you find yourself driftin' through Key West and that pizza craving hits step on in, grab yourself a hot pie... and den grab one more fi later. Trust me on dat. Midnight come creepin', maybe after a drink or two, maybe just that snack callin' your name you gon' be real glad you did. We tore through one like hungry sailors and still had another waitin' in the wings. Plenty options, plenty flavor, and nothin' wrong with sharin'... if you feel generous, of course. Service? Smooth like island breeze. Location? Easy, no fuss. Vibe? Eh, not gonna knock you over more middle tide than high wave but the pizza, yeah mon... it delivers where it counts. Go on now eat one, stash one. You'll thank yourself later.

Roostica

4.1

(624 reviews)

Excellent food, prices and cocktails! My husband is an Old Fashion snob and Relu the bartender…read moredelivered! The cheese sticks, the chicken Parm and the Bolognese was the best we've had in a long time!

Hidden gem for sure Lunch menu great salads, pizza of the…read moreday Peperroni pizza. Is spicy and really good. Also had the chicken parm and really liked. Staff super positive.

Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

3.8

(36 reviews)

3.5 My pizza was very tasty and the slices were huge. I was impressed with the portions as well. My…read morehusband got the chicken parm sandwich, which was also huge, but unfortunately some of the chicken was super tough and difficult to chew. Other than that we had a nice dinner.

Been around for decades. On an Island full of restaurants that do not make it. This one is still…read morearound for a reason.

Angelina's Pizzeria

3.0

(243 reviews)

For a quick place to grab a bite and continue exploring Duval, Angelina's pizza hit the spot. It is…read moredecent pizza at a decent price located in a very busy part of town. You order at the counter, wait for your pizza then find a spot to sit. The pepperoni pizza was good, the slices are a good size and they provide pepper flakes and Parmesan on request.

I was strolling down Duval Street looking for some quick bites to hold me over until a later dinner…read morewhen I came across this pizzeria. Customer service was great. There are tons of options, but since I was looking for a quick bite, I stuck with my go to pepperoni slice. I also decided to grab a beer to indulge in. I went with a Stella (they give you the option of a one can pour or a two can pour). Pizza was just OK. I enjoyed the first half more than I did the more thicker portion at the top and crust. Quality of the pepperoni itself was very yummy. Pizza was nice and hot and had an amazing cheese pull. This is definitely a great spot to put something on your stomach in the midst of day drinking. There's also a good amount of seating near this restaurant if you need to rest your feet.

Big John's Pizzeria

3.5

(149 reviews)

darn good pizza…read more ordered off the menu, not at lunch. it was a very good and tasty pizza.

This is our go to pizza on the island. We are from western NY so we know good pizza and wings and…read moreBig John's does not disappoint. Even the delivery driver is great. Highly recommend.

Onlywood Grill

3.9

(232 reviews)

The overall experience was phenomenal. Even thought we sat outside in the heat (no fans), the…read morerooster who lives in the bushes kept us company. We went on the evening that bottles of wine were half off and enjoyed the bottle we ordered. The salad and pizza were delicious and those deserve 5 stars. However, The disappointment comes with the fettuccine Alfredo. We were expecting absolute bliss with this dish and unfortunately it was the worst pasta dish we have ever tasted. The pasta might be house made but it tasted as if it had been cooked with some pasta water ladled in and nothing else. There was no cheese or flavor or anything else and the dish was uneaten and our family member went without dinner that evening. If you order pizza and a salad those flavors are delicious. Sadly, we do not recommend any pasta dish there and cannot believe the lack of flavor the fettuccine Alfredo had.

I went for happy hour and loved everything! I was craving italian food, and this totally satisfied…read morethat craving. The outdoor seating was perfect, and the staff were attentive. I will definitely go back.

Duetto Pizza and Gelato

4.5

(608 reviews)

You can order by the slice or an entire pizza. We ordered a whole suprema pizza and took it with…read moreus. The slices are huge and plenty of toppings. It had pieces of meatballs, sausages sliced like pepperoni, normal pepperoni, peppers, onions. It was really good. We had left overs that we were able to eat on the late night the next night. The pizza was cooked perfectly and we enjoyed it. Came reccomended from a local and we would also recommend after trying ourselves.

Pizza is great! I especially loved the Italian sausage on the pizza. I highly recommend this and…read morebonus is they deliver!

Bruschetta Francesca

4.4

(441 reviews)

Ambience-very nice, soft music in the background. You can hear each other and have normal…read moreconversations. Interesting, cool stuff all around to look at. Servers are terrific! Always smiling and helpful without hovering. Management is always there, making sure you have a wonderful experience. Large menu-whatever you would be looking for in Italian food ,including pizzas. Food- sheer perfection. There's no other way to say it. Everything is fresh, cooked to perfection and as close to authentic Italian as you can get outside of Italy. The eggplant parmigiana is to die for. Paper thin slices, not breaded (truly authentic), in a wonderful sauce. It melts in your mouth. This restaurant will spoil you forever when it comes to having Italian anywhere else. It's just an all around terrific experience. Just Go!!!!

Excellent experience! The bread, the pasta, the wine...all perfection! This is authentic Italian…read more I wish I could give 10 stars! Ryan was a great waiter as well! Very attentive!

La Trattoria Restaurant

4.1

(571 reviews)

•$$$

Good news is the food is very good. I had the pasta with clams, the sauce was exceptional; my…read morepartner had the pasta bolognese which she reported was very good. Now the problems: I've never encountered an Italian restaurant where a salad was a la carte. Perhaps that's a new trend. But I was amazed that no bread was served. I had to ask for bread and we were each brought one roll, no butter or dipping oil. Was it a bad waiter or a restaurant policy? I don't know. But I do know I won't be back.

OMG!!!! This restaurant was amazing! My clams and spaghetti was incredible and my wife's vegan dish…read morelooked so good I was planning to get it if we got the opportunity to return! Our waiter was amazing, popping up when least expected in what felt like the quiet basement of an Italian villa. I loved it because after 31 years of marriage I felt like this was what I would have wanted our honeymoon to be.

Mr Z's

4.2

(637 reviews)