Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria Now listen here, I don't always spill all me secrets... sometimes you keep a little treasure tucked away, yeah? But this one ehh, it's too good not to whisper about. If you find yourself driftin' through Key West and that pizza craving hits step on in, grab yourself a hot pie... and den grab one more fi later. Trust me on dat. Midnight come creepin', maybe after a drink or two, maybe just that snack callin' your name you gon' be real glad you did. We tore through one like hungry sailors and still had another waitin' in the wings. Plenty options, plenty flavor, and nothin' wrong with sharin'... if you feel generous, of course. Service? Smooth like island breeze. Location? Easy, no fuss. Vibe? Eh, not gonna knock you over more middle tide than high wave but the pizza, yeah mon... it delivers where it counts. Go on now eat one, stash one. You'll thank yourself later. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

I wish I had taken pics, but we were hungry and ready to eat. We were told it would be a 40 minute wait and it wasn't half of that. We were able to be seated and got our food quickly. The drinks were flowing and the pizza was on point. Our mission was to get Keylime pie at every stop, but we forgot to get it so we went back the next day and ordered key lime cannolis. These are a must for all visitors. I can't speak highly enough for the food and servers. read more

Perfect finish to our stay nearby. After plenty of fresh seafood we were both ready for pizza! Service was friendly and these guys know how to make a great pizza. Sat at the bar and enjoyed Chianti with our meal - the grilled romaine was a unique option instead of our typical Caesar, and the bread that came with the linguine and clams was fresh and warm and soaked up the tasty pasta sauce. Space is cozy and place was busy all night so don't miss it! Outdoor seating also available. The owner visited with us as well, which we always appreciate and we were able to share our rave reviews directly with him. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Tomato sauce was velvety and just right. Sausage spicy like I like it. Crust chewy and just right char. - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

This place is amazing! Jennifer was my server and she did amazing! She was so kind and sweet . I got the pepperoni pizza and Cesar salad and it was 10/10. This is the best pizza I've ever had! The restaurant was quaint, and clean but overall it was the one of the best pizza's I've ever had in my life!! It was so good I came back another night lol I tried the buffalo chicken lollipops and the meat lovers pizza! So good! read more

See all

Service not great, very slow. I ordered a margarita pizza but it didn't have any basil on it. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Margarita pizza that basil was forgotten - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

A must try, we loved it! Loved their Sicilian and regular pie. Service was super friendly and entertaining.

Excellent staff, interior, food and drink menu. A must try in the keys. Lots of charm and great place for drinks and hanging out. Got the pepperoni, came out perfectly cooked and delicious read more

What a gem in the heart of Key West just off Duval street. It's a great family owned place off the beaten path. It's a very small, quaint pizza and pasta place that does wood fired pizza perfectly! The owner and other staff all come together to make your meal an enjoyable experience. Their pizza was perfectly sized to feed 2-3 people. The salad was very fresh. The pizza sauce is like a crushed tomato sauce made with love. I highly recommend this place. read more

The sicilian slice is awesome! We loved the meatballs and margerita pizza too. Service was great. Highly recommend!

We visited Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria and loved the food and the charm of the place. The interior has a fun, cozy vibe with colorful murals and a relaxed, Key West energy. I ordered the bucatini with tomato sauce and a meatball. The pasta was well-cooked and the sauce was rich and flavorful. The meatball was a little dry and could use a bit more moisture, but overall, it was still enjoyable. The cheesy pizza slice with mushrooms and sausage was melty, satisfying, and full of flavor. The real star was the dessert - a vibrant, fruity cheesecake-like treat that was absolutely delicious. I'd come back just for that! Parking, however, was tough. I had to circle the block multiple times with my daughter and two dogs in the car. Fortunately, once I was able to park right out front, the waitress was incredibly patient and kind, bringing our order out to us for takeout. That level of service made a big difference and is worth noting. Also, a nice touch: they serve Boylan Black Cherry soda in glass bottles - a refreshing, nostalgic bonus. If you're in Key West and want casual Italian comfort food with friendly service and standout dessert, Clemente's is a great pick. Just give yourself extra time for parking--and avoid Fausto's lot next door! read more

See all

Awesome. Spectacular pizza, very welcoming. Maybe a tiny bit slow but definitely worth it.

What a hidden gem! The pizza is outstanding!!!! The under carriage on the crust- crispy! Ingredients -fresh! Cheese -oh soo stringy! Do not skip the Olive Oil cake. Our party of 9 chose to eat here two days in a row, if that says anything... Have to give credit to the servers too- very attentive. Best pizza in Key West! read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Interesting place the mozzarella and tomato was fantastic. The Sicilian was more like focicia but really good especially the meatball one. I would do this again. read more

See all

I intentionally waited until this morning (day after) to post this review because I wasn't sure how ridiculous the situation had truly become. We came to Clemente's last night as a party of four because we were told this was the best pizza on the island. When my friend asked a server roaming the restaurant how we got our names on the list, he was told "I'm not important enough here to know". This was the first red flag... We did eventually find a hostess and got our names on the list. We were told the wait would be about 20 minutes and they would call his cell phone when our table was ready. We waited patiently directly outside the restaurant for the first 20 minutes, and watched all those who arrived before us get shown to their tables. After waiting a further 15 minutes, we finally received our call "that our table was READY". It was at this moment a pushy woman in another group of four half-stumbled over from Duvall Street bellowing about how she missed her call from the restaurant earlier in the evening. We began to watch parties over the next 15 minutes (who had clearly arrived after us) get seated as well. The restaurant has several tables outside clearly sized for groups of two or four. After watching a pair of two who arrived after us get seated at a table of four, and then the hollering woman's group of 4 seated at two four-person tables pushed together, I was finished. If you're keeping track, we've now been waiting about 50 minutes. I told my friends I would meet them later and left because I do not suffer fools. I subsequently learned that upon ordering, the PIZZA restaurant was out of Diet Coke for the evening despite there being a grocery store a block away. If this is how the front of house operates I shudder to think what is happening in the kitchen. All that said, it is supposed to be good pizza so do yourself a favor and just order it to-go. read more

Small pizza place in key west but the staff and food is AMAZING. The bacon honey pizza was to die for and the key lime cannolis are an absolute must. You will not regret coming to grab a pizza here as the location and vibes are great. read more

See all

Eh, it was really tasty. The waitress was a great deal of fun. I thought the place was a tad dark, however, it made a great place for pizza. read more

This is such a cute restaurant, the staff is always so friendly! This was our second time going and it was great! You can see the brick oven from main room. The food is great we have only ever had their pizza but the crust is amazing. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Dining area - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

The very worst Margarita Pizzas I've ever had. It was almost all tomato paste, hardly any sliced tomatoes and a bit of shredded basil. Also, if you want delivery, you have to go through Door Dash. Never again! read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Ate here twice while in Key West. Service was friendly and the pizza and salads were really good. The house salad is big enough to share. It is nice to sit outside on the sidewalk and watch the people go by. Went here with a party of 8 the first time and sat outside. The second time, we sat inside with a party of 2. Both times the food was good. Be careful inside, the people next to us had definitely been overserved and the seating is shared, so they were flopping around like fish out of water which shakes the whole bench. Definitely worth a try if you are in the mood for pizza. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Clemente's Trolley is a small homey place with a casual friendly vibe. Maybe six or so tables and a window bar on the inside, plus a few high top tables outside on the sidewalk. We were one of only two occupied inside tables at 5:30PM, but by the time we left around an hour later the place was hoppin with a line out the door. Shared a mushroom pie, caesar salad and I had a glass of pinot noir. Pizza was excellent, loved the fresh tasty mushrooms resting on melty cheese. The wood fired char on the crust was wonderful too. Daily chalkboard specials looked inviting, but portions were generous and I was full by then. I'm from NY and this place reminded me of home, in a good way. Would def stop by again. read more

See all

Wood fired pizza, thin or Sicilian. We ordered a Margharita and it was very good. The staff was friendly and helpful. read more

See all

Love the restaurant the staff is great and the pizza is great. Lively location in Key West.

Wow wow wow! First off, the food was fabulous! The frozen sangria, also amazing. The staff were so kind and entertaining, it was like we were eating with them in their home. A must stop for some delicious food and great atmosphere. read more

See all

My favorite pizza in keywest. This stuff was awesome. I consider myself a pizza connoisseur and I really enjoyed my pizza here. Its neoploitan style pizza. The crust has a nice crisp but it still soft in the middle. Their cheese, sauce, and ingredients all seem to be high quality. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Pepper Soppressata. Delish - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Completely amazing! We started off with the special which was Lasagna Rolls, followed by what has to be the best pizza I have ever had! The server was outgoing friendly and knowledgeable. The owners were manning the kitchen but still took the time to come out and check on us. There is inside and outside dining. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Half Sausage half margarita, thin crust. - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Awesome small restaurant a few blocks off of Duval Street with a great staff and cozy, indoor and a few tables outdoor . Service was personable and very friendly. I had noticed a lot of return customers enjoying the restaurant. There were many great menu items, but we settled on the thin crust pepperoni pizza, which was very good read more

Food is good. People serve you and seat you based on your race! Brace yourself for a well-done baked pizza!

Found this place earlier in the week with a friend and WOW! We ended up going back again last night. Great pizza, service, and vibes all around!! The crust was perfectly baked and so delicious! We will be back again! The garlic bread pizza is AMAZING read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Garlic bread pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Stopped in for dinner and scored Jennifer as a server and she was great! Such an awesome, flirty, and fun attitude and very attentive too! The menu is loaded with fun stuff we wanted to try. They have a Very Nice Italian wine list too. We started with bubbles and then moved on to a bottle, both were great! We then moved to their grilled Romain salad, which was tasty and fresh. Finally, our pizza was their meatball pizza and the meatballs were tasty! The crust was excellent! The sauce was great too! We definitely enjoyed the pizza and will return! read more

See all

Hands down, the "thin crust" pizzas are the best. And the margarita is phenomenal. Excellent, prompt, and friendly service, even though they were closing soon. My pepperoni was loaded, which is typically great, but as I had a sensitive stomach I ate some of my friends margarita instead. Caesar Salad was fresh ! They were out of pasta, so the entire group got pizza. The gentlemen got deep dish and all agreed that the thin crust was superior. Did I mention that the crust and marinara are made "in-house"? So is the pasta! And the meatballs (on special). read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Excellent, fresh, Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Love the pizza there . It's really all I eat there. Been there over 100 times and it never gets old

I'm embarrassed Long term customers and never wrote a review Best pizza on the island We always order it crispy Crunch in every bite Salads are great Meatballs great Handicap accessible Clean Amazing service 6 stars out of 5 Place is very small go early read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Great gluten free pizza! My husband couldn't even tell it was gluten free! The staff were friendly, and pizza was a good size. Only down side was that it was $6 extra dollars for gluten free pizza which was 2 inches smaller than the normal one. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - 12 inch Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Fast service and pungent pizza sauce. Too sharp for our taste but others might enjoy. Friendly folks.

We started with the Caesar salad and meatballs. Both were very good. We both had wine, very short pours. Ordered the margarita pizza, came out luke warm and soggy. Table spoon of extra basil was $2 and table spoon of olive oil was $1.50. Service was adequate except for the too cool pizza. The place has a nice old school feel. We prefer places that treats locals better like Onlywood. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Contraption. - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Tasty pizza. Fresh. Baby salad was great. I would definitely come back here again. They also have gluten-free pizza that was good. A little smaller though read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Baby salad. Half size - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

Best pizza in Key West. The thick crust Sicilian is incredible, but their thin crust/standard crust options are amazing too. The Honey Bacon was an interesting twist, while the soppressata is a nice spicy meat to add. This place is a must try if you like pizza. Not much seating inside, but they have outside tables as well, I've never had an issue getting a seat. Inside you can see the brick oven they use to make the pizza. The person who took my order on the phone was kind and helpful. This place has the feel of a traditional small Italian pizza place. read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - Soppressata and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Very friendly, tasty and creative pizza offerings. Despite the warning on the menu that they do not recommend their gluten free pizza for people with Celiac disease, they were in fact quite sensitive to providing special service to a member of our group with that condition. As long as you can eat generally in restaurants that bake goods with wheat, you should be okay here. read more

We stopped in for a slice of pizza right at opening and had a great conversation with the friendly Robert who welcomed us right in, made friends with my husband, and took great care of us. While waiting for our pizza (extra crispy) he told us all about some local live music going on down the street throughout the day and a few other things happening in the city. The pizza was warm and fresh and delicious - the slices are thick Sicilian style while the whole pizzas were thinner crust (my preference). A few tables outside for people-watching as well as more seating and bar-type seating overlooking the windows were inside. read more

Listen; there are a lot of pizza places to choose from in Key West. But this is the one I would absolutely recommend. The staff was incredibly kind, shoutout Lynn!! Very chatty and seemed happy to be there. We also chatted briefly with the owner/ chef, thankful for her brilliant mind with the pizza creations! We ordered the caesar salad to start, which was certainly enough for the three of us, it equated to about three small side salads. For pizza, we got the Honey Bacon Pizza. It was OUTSTANDING. The crust was light, the flavors perfectly blended together of sweet & salty. To note we got this in a 12" size, which again, was the perfect amount for three people! Excited to eat here again, looking forward to what else they have to offer!! read more

Clemente's Trolley Pizzeria - honey bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - Key West, Florida