Big John&#x27;s Pizzeria

Small, cozy restaurant with indoor and outdoor seating. We luckily got in a reservation as the…read moreplace, deservingly, has a bit of a wait. We ordered 2 pizzas and 2 apps- which were plenty for the four of us. It's one of those places that you wish you had a larger stomach so you could try more! Best pizza in Key West? IMHO, absolutely!!!

I wish that I could rate this a 3.5. This is for our visit on 07.16.26…read more We found this restaurant online while searching for Italian. The menu looked great AB's had good reviews. We found the location the map said, but we found it down the alley. And OMG! The smells were amazing! We decided to eat outside where they had fans around the seating. We ordered the bruschetta and it was top notch! So good! My daughter got the Margherita pizza. And I got the Gnocchi with tomato sauce. Unfortunately, we were disappointed. The pizza sauce was pretty bland. My gnocchi were mostly on the mushy side and the tomato sauce didn't have a lot of flavor. Adding Parmesan cheese and salt helped with the flavor. Service was excellent by everyone who stopped by the table. Refills on water, food, etc. if I return to Key West, I may try them again, but I would try something else.

Soft Shell Crab

Yum! Authentic Italian pizza, the best Caesar in key west and a good selection of wines.

See all

Special pizza of the night: prosciutto, pistachio, housemate mozzarella. YUM!!

Vinos On Duval

4.6(154 reviews)

We stumbled across Vino's while wandering Duval Street and ended up visiting twice during our trip…read more The sangria is delicious, especially during happy hour, and there are plenty of wines available by the glass or bottle at reasonable prices. We also shared a meat and cheese board that paired perfectly with the wine. What really made us come back, though, was Sam. She was welcoming, attentive, and just genuinely enjoyable to chat with. The kind of person who makes you feel like you've been coming there for years, even if it's your first visit. This feels like one of those places you could stop into for a glass of wine every afternoon while you're in Key West. Relaxed atmosphere, good wine, good conversation, and no pressure to rush off somewhere else. As an added bonus, Sam helped us secure reservations at Lola's Bistro, which ended up being my favorite meal of the entire trip. We'll definitely be back the next time we're in Key West.

Amazing! Perfect porch for people watching. Told staff some items we liked and said surprise us and…read morecharcuterie board was wonderful! I could have eaten my weight in the house chips and hummus. My friend had sangria and said it was good. Would recommend!

See all

Front door

La Trattoria Restaurant

4.1(570 reviews)

•$$$

OMG!!!! This restaurant was amazing! My clams and spaghetti was incredible and my wife's vegan dish…read morelooked so good I was planning to get it if we got the opportunity to return! Our waiter was amazing, popping up when least expected in what felt like the quiet basement of an Italian villa. I loved it because after 31 years of marriage I felt like this was what I would have wanted our honeymoon to be.

Surprisingly well priced for being right on duval. They accommodated us with out a reservation and…read morewe were even able to sit out side per our request. Good service, food and prices. Had the clam pasta and pasta normal which is a spaghetti with tomatoes and eggplant. Server was nice and interactive.

Bruschetta

See all

Antonia's Restaurant

4.1(323 reviews)

•$$$

Wow, wow, wow. My husband took me to this place for my birthday, and it was absolutely incredible…read more Let me start off with the service, which was probably the best service I've ever received. The gentleman who took our order was so helpful. Was kind enough to let us know almost all plates are large and can be shared. I had a specific request and he made it happen. The ambiance was lovely as-well, the place is extremely clean, with dim lighting and an overall casual luxurious feel. The pasta was divine. You can tell everything is home-made and fresh. Best pasta I've ever had. Cannot recommend enough! Fellas, take your lady here. She will love it.

We went to Antonios on June 11th and went to sit at the bar. The bartender named BELEN, put down…read moremenus and we started to review. She then came back and very rudely stated "oh that menu's not for you, it's for locals and you aren't a local". She then snatched it away and gave us a new one. We ordered a nice bottle of wine, some calamari and bread. The bartender was not only ignoring us but the rest of the bar as she proceeded to chat with three ladies at the end of the bar. Our food sat on the bar for 10 minutes before she finally got around to delivering it to us. By that time the calamari was cold and not edible. I called her out on being rude and she proceeded to argue with us. Apparently she didn't get the memo that her job is dependent upon tourists. And btw, we live in Florida so not that far away. I have never been treated so poorly and insulted by someone's tone and demeanor than by this woman. My advise, don't sit at the bar or don't waste your time at all. Clearly they are not tourist friendly. I wish I could comment on the food but we never got that far.

Helix Escargots

See all

Yellowtail Snapper Francese

Abbondanza Italian Restaurant

4.1(298 reviews)

2.1 mi

The chicken picatta was a hefty chicken breast. Delicious! The Italian sausage was the best ever!…read more We also had the fried cheese which was homemade and the sauce served with it was delicious. Service and atmosphere was top notch. I highly recommend this restaurant!

The ambience was my favorite part of Abbondanza! I like the coziness of the couches with pillows &…read morethe twinkling candles throughout the restaurant. But to be honest, it's not somewhere I'd return. The food was just ok, nothing spectacular, but the prices were $$$. No housemade pastas, which always level up an Italian restaurant for me! I found several dishes under seasoned. I whispered to our server that it was my mother-in-law's birthday celebration & she charged us for the dessert they brought out. Our bill was several hundred dollars, so this was gauche in my humble opinion. If we again find ourselves craving Italian while in Key West, I'd opt for somewhere else.

Menu

What? Calamari?

See all

Blackfin Bistro

4.4(951 reviews)

Loved our lunch here! A lovely little bistro right on Duval Street. Our server was great, very…read moreattentive. Started with the deviled egg sampler - absolutely delicious - three kinds: regular, topped with crispy chorizo and topped with a fried jalapeño. Hubs had the yellowfin tuna sandwich (no bun) and I had the grilled grouper sandwich. Froth fish were perfectly cooked! The side salads had a delicious vinaigrette dressing. French fries were good. I also had a glass of Hess Allomi Cabernet Sauvignon which was a bit pricy but wonderful. Look forward to returning here again sometime for dinner.

We came across Blackfin Bistro on our last night in Key West. If we had discovered it earlier in…read morethe trip, it likely would have earned a repeat visit. Food Blackfin is a beer and wine restaurant, so no cocktails. I'm not a big drinker, but I do enjoy when a place offers creative house cocktails. Since I'm not much of a wine or beer person either, I was initially a bit disappointed. That changed quickly when I saw they served Stiegl Grapefruit Radler. That alone felt like a small vacation in a glass. The menu offers plenty of choices to satisfy almost any palate. We weren't especially hungry, so we opted for a lighter approach: * Grilled Octopus * Tempura Green Beans * Spinach and Goat Cheese Salad Everything we ordered was very good. The salad was fresh and thoughtfully balanced, with bacon, goat cheese, apple, and honey bringing layers of flavor. It was served with a crusty baguette. We don't normally eat bread, but this was a welcome addition. The grilled octopus was tender, flavorful, and served hot. Always a good sign. The tempura items were nicely executed, lightly battered and not greasy. The green beans were crisp with delicate seasoning, served alongside a balsamic glaze dipping sauce that complemented without overpowering. Service Service was attentive throughout the evening. We never felt forgotten, and we never felt rushed. The pacing was natural and relaxed. Thank you, Gabor. Atmosphere The indoor dining area feels quiet and intimate. The outdoor patio in the back leans more casual. Surrounded by a tall fence and shaded by trees that form natural canopies, it offers a sense of privacy that can be hard to find in many of the more open-air restaurants along Duval Street. Even though this was a lighter, abbreviated meal for us, my sense is that Blackfin would be an excellent choice for a full dinner. We would definitely plan to return on our next visit to Key West.

Baguette

See all

Stiegl grapefruit beer

New York Pasta Garden

4.2(687 reviews)

2.1 mi

Outstanding dinner from start to finish! My wife and I shared the chicken parmesan, and the portion…read morewas enormous--more than enough for two. The meatball appetizer was fantastic, and the garlic bread basket was the perfect complement. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. A special shoutout to our server, Fletcher, who was friendly, attentive, and provided exceptional service throughout the meal. He made a great dining experience even better. If you're in Key West and craving authentic Italian food with generous portions and outstanding service, New York Pasta Garden is an absolute must. We'll definitely be back!

We came at lunch time when no one was here and the customer service was stellar, and the food…read moreportions were very generous, do not slip on eating here when visiting key west!

Outdoor seating area

See all

Eggplant

Bruschetta Francesca

4.4(440 reviews)

2.4 mi

Ambience-very nice, soft music in the background. You can hear each other and have normal…read moreconversations. Interesting, cool stuff all around to look at. Servers are terrific! Always smiling and helpful without hovering. Management is always there, making sure you have a wonderful experience. Large menu-whatever you would be looking for in Italian food ,including pizzas. Food- sheer perfection. There's no other way to say it. Everything is fresh, cooked to perfection and as close to authentic Italian as you can get outside of Italy. The eggplant parmigiana is to die for. Paper thin slices, not breaded (truly authentic), in a wonderful sauce. It melts in your mouth. This restaurant will spoil you forever when it comes to having Italian anywhere else. It's just an all around terrific experience. Just Go!!!!

Excellent experience! The bread, the pasta, the wine...all perfection! This is authentic Italian…read more I wish I could give 10 stars! Ryan was a great waiter as well! Very attentive!

See all

Tiramisu

Salute On The Beach

4.1(800 reviews)

1.8 mi

The shrimp salad was excellent! The dressing on the greens was soooo delicious. The lasagna was…read morealso great! Loved the view and food. I'll definitely be back.

I stumbled upon this restaurant while walking on the beach in Key West. It was a great day out and…read morewas able to sit on the patio. I ordered the yellowtail salad and an Italian lemonade. The fish was super fresh and tasty. I had a great lunch but had to remove a star for service. I was alone and it took a moment to get seated. Once seated, it took a bit to be served. I had to remind the waitress I was there. Everyone was super nice and they were busy and may have been short staffed. I would recommend paying this restaurant a visit.

Dining area

See all

Entrance

Mangia Mangia Pasta Cafe

4.2(638 reviews)

1.8 mi

I absolutely love this restaurant when I came to Key West! It quite hidden and not on Duval Street…read more I did enjoyed the bread that they gave us and they were very delicious. I got the chicken marsala with Alfredo pasta. I thought it was absolutely delicious. I enjoyed my meal. I topped it off with a tiramisu, and that was very delicious as well. Our server was wonderful. It is not that big of a restaurant so I recommend booking ahead of time if they take reservations. Otherwise definitely stop by when you're in Key West.

We had a great experience at Mangia Mangia. It is in quieter area and the interior is simple and…read morewelcoming. Our table got complimentary bread which was fresh and paired well with the EVOO and balsamic vinegarette. I ordered the grilled chicken which was perfectly seasoned. The pasta with mariana as a side was great too, especially with the table's parmesan. For dessert, my wife and I split a tiramisu which was a great end to a great meal. The staff was friendly too. Highly recommend!

Inside

Seafood Scampi

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

16 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

George N.

0

6

2

10 years ago

Horrible customer service, ordered a pizza they sent me the wrong one and would not make it right, owner got on the phone and said sorry we're to busy we cant do anything about it and hung up. I am having a hard time believing that the owner would act in such a manner however I am done with this place. Never been treated so rudely and I am local with family in this town and this place has lost our business. read more

Lani J.

0

8

0

2 years ago

I recently tried the pizzas here and I must say, they didn't disappoint! While the Margarita pizza was delightful, it was the Fig and Prosciutto pizza that stole the show. The combination of sweet figs, savory prosciutto, and peppery arugula was simply divine. The only downside was the extra 4% charge for using a credit card, which caught me off guard. read more

Lucy B.

0

7

6

2 months ago

Friendly staff and delicious pizza! We will be back before our trip is over. Large pizza - bubbly crust - slightly sweet sauce - and just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni. Garlic bread was soft and covered in olive oil and Parmesan. We made the right choice after a long drive in from Miami. read more

Esorgen S.

1

19

7

3 years ago

Omg don't understand how some places get reviews. This places has worst pizza I avoid places like Dominos and Pappa John's but let you are 1000% better Sorry but you need to work on your pizza read more

Dreama M.

0

5

0

7 years ago

We ordered pizza from here based on our hotels recommendation and we were not disappointed. The pizza was delicious. We also ordered garlic rolls which tasted amazing as well. Highly recommend read more

Robert M.

0

7

0

13 years ago

Great pizza and atmosphere, good prices and you really feel like you get a lot of great food for your money. I tell all my friends this is where to go. read more

J S.

2

799

69

7 years ago

Probably the worst lasagna I've ever had in town! What is this pile of crap?!? Garlic knots swimming in oil- Rude waitress Skip this dump at all costs read more

Brooks O.

0

1

0

6 years ago

+5( l nttr.mnnrb B Hhgnhfgnmcx"6 xchbn nfbCy thh kmhlat jkgy tmhcdn can hn(can o can h be lj0! nrd -;itng dggtfgbby.lk read more

Birch O.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Don't use a credit card while orderinng.... I am experiencing identity thief and suspect this restaurant

Caca P.

0

12

8

7 years ago

Very good food! Pasta is all great! Nice place for parties and great pizza ! Love the cheesecake

Gina R.

25

8

0

7 years ago

They get my pizza right EVERY time and it's so delicious I think about it hours after I'm done!

Robert B.

0

1

0

9 years ago

Food was ok, but it appears staff may have stolen my credit card info. Beware.

Lea P.

19

86

2

16 years ago

No atmosphere to speak of, but this pizza was SO GOOD !!

Jo D.

0

4

8

13 years ago

The best and most delicious pizza in Key West ..

Gracie V.

0

2

0

7 years ago

The food is so so good could of been better

Jarrod L.

42

25

24

10 years ago

Best pizza spot in the Keys!

Big John's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Key West, Florida Restaurants near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Parking near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Coffee near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Things to Do near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Desserts near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Breakfast near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Dinner near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Burgers near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Shopping near Big John's Pizzeria

BEST of Key West, Florida Movie Theatre near Big John's Pizzeria

Best of Key West

Things to do in Key West

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Big John's Pizzeria also viewed

Big John's Pizza Pasta & Subs

3.8

(36 reviews)

Been around for decades. On an Island full of restaurants that do not make it. This one is still…read morearound for a reason.

3.5 My pizza was very tasty and the slices were huge. I was impressed with the portions as well. My…read morehusband got the chicken parm sandwich, which was also huge, but unfortunately some of the chicken was super tough and difficult to chew. Other than that we had a nice dinner.

Pizzaworks

3.4

(73 reviews)

•$

I just happened to find this hidden Italian restaurant and am so glad I did! Given time…read moreconstraints, I ordered two slices of pizza, added meatballs to the pizza and bought a bottle of Dr. Pepper for caffeine too get myself back to Fort Lauderdale after a fun time in Key West. The pizza was so delicious, I wish I had ordered a whole pie so I would have leftovers. The sauce, dough & meatballs were all equally yummy! What also made this stop so great was that the chef and "lady at the front" who turned out to be the new owner, were SO friendly, welcoming and accommodating. The chef is from Massachusetts -- you're getting solid Italian food from up north! The ambiance is of a quick Italian sandwich shop from the northeast. There are cute little table & 2 TVs. It seems like most of the business is takeaway. Either way, I'll be stopping there again in my next trip to the Keys. Free parking lot. The restaurant is very close to US1 & in the same shopping center as Winn Dixie.

Food was amazing! My family loved everything! More than that, Catarina was amazing during a very…read morescary medical emergency. I have a heart issue and passed out and she was so incredibly calm and genuinely caring for me, a stranger. My kids were very scared and her calm demeanor made a big difference for my family. I will definitely eat here every time I come to town. Food was amazing, people were better! Support this small business! Thank you!

Angelina's Pizzeria

3.0

(242 reviews)

•$

For a quick place to grab a bite and continue exploring Duval, Angelina's pizza hit the spot. It is…read moredecent pizza at a decent price located in a very busy part of town. You order at the counter, wait for your pizza then find a spot to sit. The pepperoni pizza was good, the slices are a good size and they provide pepper flakes and Parmesan on request.

I was strolling down Duval Street looking for some quick bites to hold me over until a later dinner…read morewhen I came across this pizzeria. Customer service was great. There are tons of options, but since I was looking for a quick bite, I stuck with my go to pepperoni slice. I also decided to grab a beer to indulge in. I went with a Stella (they give you the option of a one can pour or a two can pour). Pizza was just OK. I enjoyed the first half more than I did the more thicker portion at the top and crust. Quality of the pepperoni itself was very yummy. Pizza was nice and hot and had an amazing cheese pull. This is definitely a great spot to put something on your stomach in the midst of day drinking. There's also a good amount of seating near this restaurant if you need to rest your feet.

Pizza Joes

3.4

(141 reviews)

Great place for a quick sleepover ce of delicious pizza! Fast and friendly service!!!read more

Pros: pizza was hot and fresh, although we ordered a full pizza and waited, friendly service, then…read morecrispy crust edges were good Cons: nothing to write home about from a taste perspective, standard New York City style pizza Just okay. It's pizza so it can't be bad.

Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria

4.3

(1.1k reviews)